Torah · MussarMussar8. Preparation for קריאת שמע vs. עמידהTzidkat HaTzadikPart 8Rabbi Uri Nahum · May 11, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:16Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat haTzadik, ot chet.0:03The following piece is a little bit more on the complicated side.0:07I hope, with siyata dishmaya, that we're able to clarify as much as we can,0:11and let's see.0:12Uzman0:14hachanah hazu. We earlier said in ot zayin that the Gemara brings many different times for the reading of Shema,0:22and we said that the halacha is like what it says in the Mishnah,0:25which is really setekochavim. The Gemara comes out,0:27and we know that's what's brought down in Shulchan Aruch,0:30but the Gemara uses the terminology like what it said in the Mishnah,0:38bizman shehakohanim nichnasim le'echol bitrumatan. The time of reading Kriat Shema is when the kohanim enter to eat their terumah.0:45And we explained, even though there are many different opinions that perhaps could also mean0:50setekochavim, why the Mishnah selected this terminology is because the preparation of accepting upon0:56himself ol malchut shamayim, which is what the whole idea of Kriat Shema is,0:59is that a person has to mentally prepare himself,1:03and it's a spiritual level, basically, of going into a spiritual level,1:07accepting upon himself1:09ol malchut shamayim, and it needs preparation.1:11It's not something you just go ahead.1:13The least preparation is for a second to think,1:15I am accepting upon myself1:17ol malchut shamayim, and we said that's one of the lowest levels,1:19but it needs also preparation, like the kohanim, that's the highest level.1:23So he says,1:27Uzman hachanah hazu, hakol lefi mah shehu adam. Now, how long does a person need to prepare?1:30He says,1:31Rab Tzadok in ot chet, it all depends on the person.1:36Chasidim hayu shohim sha'ah achat letefillah kedei ita. The chasidim used to wait an entire hour before they stood up to say1:39the Amidah, like it says in the Gemara.1:44Veze ta'am gam ken shericheku bizman shel arvit adam hu shah achar. Now he says, why is it that we find—1:47The Gemara says1:48the time of Kriat Shema in the evening, you have the whole entire evening to say it.1:51Yet the time of Kriat Shema in the morning,1:54you only have up to three hours.1:56Good?1:57So why is that so?1:58Why do we have much more time in the evening than the daytime?2:01Says,2:07you know why? כי בחשכת לילה קשה למצוא בהירות מחוד שמים, פעמים עלות שחר, כולי האי ואולי. Because when it's dark, which is at night,2:09represents the darkness,2:11things are not so clear.2:13Things are not running so smooth in your life.2:15Very hard to really see how it's2:19all מלכות שמים and to really be still 100% committed.2:22You know, we all have this tendency as human nature, really,2:26that to rebel against authority.2:29And we have to kind of control ourselves not to rebel.2:31And when things don't go well,2:33people immediately rebel against Hashem.2:35Everyone on a different level, right?2:38There are people that, you know, get upset.2:39I know a guy who got very upset at something and decided to drive on Shabbat.2:43What is that exactly doing?2:44But it's a form of rebellion.2:46Not everybody is such a hothead,2:47and there's other people that, you know, they'll miss2:50Shacharit. Other people will not be somebody that they're going to certain mitzvah,2:54or will not go to class.2:56Everybody at a different level.2:58That's the tendency. That's human nature.3:00When it's dark and things are not going well,3:02you feel like Hashem is kind of rejecting you.3:04It's very hard for a person's nature to accept3:10עול מלכות שמים בשלמות, completely.3:11So that's when it actually needs more work,3:13and that's why he says3:14the Kriat Shema in the evening has the entire night,3:18because it needs much more preparation.3:20It needs much more time3:22to allow the person to have much more time.3:24And of course,3:25Chazal were gozer, they have to be up to3:26chatzot. Ma'areket ha-din, Torah gave you all the whole evening,3:30and even to be able to really accept it in times of darkness,3:34כולי האי ואולי. Again, this is what represents.3:38מה שאין כן ביום. However, in the daytime.3:40We know the daytime represents when things are all going well.3:43As it says in3:45pasuk, להגיד בבוקר חסדך. And in the morning, says David3:48HaMelech, is when I speak to Hashem and I speak about Hashem's chesed.3:52Why? Because the morning represents3:55בהירות, clarity, light.3:57When things are smooth, and you see4:00ממש השגחת השם. You see how that shidduch worked,4:02and you see how the other shidduchim didn't work4:04and this one worked because, ah, it's all b'yad Hashem.4:07You see the hashgachah of Hashem,4:09how you were able to make your parnassah better,4:12or you're able to get that job,4:14or whatever siyata d'shmaya that you see clearly in your life.4:17That's4:18בבוקר אזכרה. So he says, being that the morning is very clear,4:23להגיד בבוקר, בתוך אור הניכר, the chesed is דווקא in the morning when the light is recognized.4:28And that's why you have only the morning,4:30which the Gemara learns from there also,4:31from the words4:33בבוקר, בבוקר, for those who know4:35Masechet Berachot, that's the time.4:40משאין כן בלילות, רק אמונה בלב. The night represents emunah,4:42and emunah is not when you see things clearly;4:44it's the opposite,4:44when you don't see things.4:46That's what emunah is.4:47And therefore the pasuk says,4:51להגיד בבוקר חסדך. להגיד, to speak about Hashem's chesed,4:54to speak it and to say it,4:56that you could see clearly in the daytime.4:58In the evening,5:01באמונתך בלילות, right?5:01But the emunah, which is only feeling,5:04is at night.5:04You don't see it.5:05You don't see it,5:07and you can't even express it;5:08you just have to believe it.5:11Because Haggadah says,5:13the Rav Tzadok, ולא הגדה. In the evening there's no Haggadah.5:18Why? שהוא הכוח לפעול על העבר. Haggadah is the ability5:21to take what's inside of you5:24and to express it, to bring it out5:26on things that have happened in the past.5:28Think about it:5:28when I speak,5:29it's because there was an idea in my head5:30about something in the past.5:32Even if you can tell me I'm going to talk about5:34tefillah in the future,5:35but I thought about it from beforehand5:36and I'm expressing it,5:38right?5:38That's called5:40lehagid. That's what's represented5:41in the pasuk5:44lehagid. But emunah,5:46right,5:49kivuui la'atid, כאשר אתה בוקר גם בכל הלילה כולה. Emunah is in the heart5:51of hoping that5:53hopefully better times will come ahead.5:55It says,5:57v'lakach tefilat arvit reshut. Now, the Gemara comes out5:58in their days,6:00in the times of6:01Chazal, there was a6:03machloket if there's a chiyuv to pray6:05tefilat arvit or not.6:07Now, the Gemara comes out,6:08the6:08psak halacha is that tefilat arvit is optional.6:11As Tosafot explains,6:12it doesn't—even back then it wasn't optional.6:14It just means if you had another mitzvah,6:16you could just do the other mitzvah6:17and you don't have to pray6:18arvit or make it up6:19if you had to do another mitzvah.6:20But to just miss tefilat arvit for no reason,6:24that's not what it means in the Gemara.6:26In any case,6:27that was what it was.6:28The Rif already brings,6:29the times have changed,6:31and already all the Jewish people6:33accepted tefilat arvit as a6:34chovah, and that's halacha. We all have an6:36obligation to pray arvit in our days.6:40But the Gemara originally started6:41that tefilat arvit is6:43reshut. So what's the depth of that?6:44What's the meaning of that?6:45He says, ki6:47tefilah hu hakarat hanochach, yoter mikriat Shema6:49kemo shekatavti l'eil. He says,6:49he explained already6:50the difference between6:51Kriat Shema and Amidah6:53is that Kriat Shema is6:54I'm speaking in third person.6:56I'm speaking about Hashem.6:58But tefilat Amidah,6:59I'm speaking to Hashem directly.7:01I stand in front of Hashem7:01and I say,7:02Baruch Atah Hashem.7:04And like the halacha says,7:07da lifnei mi atah omed. You have to know7:08who you're standing in front of.7:09You're not talking to Hashem.7:12Therefore, in the7:14nighttime, that recognition of standing7:16directly in front of Hashem,7:19אי אפשר לחייב בלילה. You can't obligate, make that7:20as a chovah in the night.7:22Why?7:22Because night represents,7:24like we said,7:24the night itself7:26represents darkness7:27and things that are not clear.7:29As the pasuk says,7:32Zeh shemi le'olam, and the pasuk,7:33the word7:36le'olam is spelled without a vav,7:37and Chazal tell us7:39that's7:41he'elem, concealed, as we know.7:44Ba'olam hazeh, it's in this world,7:45Hashem says,7:46My name is concealed.7:47This olam hazeh,7:50Hashem's not existence,7:51that Hashem runs the world,7:53is not so clear to everybody.7:54The proof is,7:56majority of the majority of the world7:57is not following Hashem's ways7:58because they don't see it.8:00If you see it, of course8:01he followed. So a lot of people who become baalei teshuva are people who see Hashem's8:06hashgacha. I'm going to go a little bit off of my norm just to give you a short, beautiful story8:11of some person that was chozer b'teshuva, and he was asked, What made you8:16chozer b'teshuva? Why did you do8:18teshuva? He says, Let me tell you an incident.8:20He says one time he went to the beach on Shabbat.8:21This guy is an Israeli guy living in Israel,8:24chiloni, used to be completely secular.8:26So he went to the beach on Shabbat with his family,8:29wife and kids,8:31and a long day at the beach. Anybody knows with kids, any day is long.8:35But he's sitting there in the sun and things, okay, time to go, packing up all the stuff.8:39This is about like maybe 25, 30 years ago.8:41So he's packing up all the stuff,8:43he folded the chair,8:44he had all his bags,8:46and finally getting all the kids to go, putting the garbage away.8:50Finally, they get, they walk all the way to the parking lot,8:53looks at his pockets, he can't find the keys.8:54He turns to his wife, he says, Give me the car keys.8:56He says, I don't have the keys.8:56You have8:57it. You're the last one to come out of the car.8:58You're going to give me anything.8:59So what do you mean? I don't have them.9:01They start looking through all the bags, nothing's there.9:03Where is it?9:04He says, Maybe you left it on the beach.9:05They go back to the area they were sitting, they look all over, there's nothing there.9:08Digging a little bit here, nothing's there.9:10He says, Ah, maybe we dumped it in the garbage. Now9:13he's already tired,9:14kids are cranky, and he's burnt from the sun.9:17And, you know, to add on to that, he's Israeli, hothead, right?9:20So he's like fuming, takes the whole garbage with everything, butt his waist, goes through9:25the garbage,9:26sees nothing,9:27nothing in the garbage.9:28Ah, he's fuming.9:29What do you do when you get angry?9:31So we said earlier, or at least in the other piece, we have the tendency that when we are9:36angry, we go, unfortunately, we rebel against Hashem.9:39So this is really nothing different,9:41even though he's completely secular. He said he's walked into the water, got up to his knees,9:46he turns up to9:48Shamayim. He knows that was Shabbat, you know, and he did this on Shabbat.9:51He says, Elohim,9:55ta'azil li et hamafteachot. Give me back my keys.9:56Said, right as he finished his words, the car keys hit his knee from the water.10:03They were on the beach and then somehow sink down, and he hit his, and the waves just hit it by his knee.10:10He said, when he saw that, whoa, he saw10:13hashgacha. Look at that.10:14I called Hashem and said, right?10:16So right away he decided to become10:19a baal teshuva. And that's how it is.10:19If you think about many people who decided to turn their life around is because they have10:24a hashgacha. Even if you improved your life, things that you knew you should have done and you haven't10:28done yet, it's only when you saw a certain level of10:32hashgacha. That's the boker.10:33But the evening is, Olam Hazeh, Chazal tell us that this night, that this world is represented by night10:40because it's a time of concealment,10:43he'elem. So why is10:49it tefilat Arvit reshut? Rak reshut, lemi she-... Was optional.10:50What does optional represent?10:51It represents the person who could see clarity like he does in the day,10:56therefore he could stand in front of Hashem.10:58However, we know that the halacha changed.11:03Nowadays, tefilat Arvit is chovah. Says the Rav Tzadok, you know why?11:06Because we're living closer to the light.11:09Be'ikveta deMeshicha, we're living, we already went through most of the darkness of Olam Hazeh, which is getting11:14closer to the light of Mashiach, as Chazal tell us in Nevi'im, that Mashiach's time is represented11:19by the concept of light.11:21And that's why our tefilah is chovah, because we could stand up in front of Hashem and we11:26have a better chance of seeing that clarity.11:34U'tefilat Shacharit also. Kriat Shema, deadline is three hours.11:39Amidah of Shacharit, really you're supposed to daven by four hours, but latest time, if11:44you just have to pray the Amidah, you have11:47up until chatzot. Why?11:50Because the stand of an Amidah, you're talking to Hashem, and to understand, to11:55recognize you're talking to Hashem needs more time for preparation,11:57unlike Shema. Like we said, Shema is just accepting upon yourself; it's between you12:01and yourself.12:02But here, talking to Hashem needs more preparation.12:04That's why Chazal extended the time, even if a person is late, all the way up to12:09chatzot if he has to prepare more.12:16That's where we find also another interesting idea.12:19If a person misses any tefillah, any prayer, he can make it up with the next tefillah.12:24That means if he missed Shacharit, he can make it up by praying Mincha and then another Amidah12:29to make up for12:30Shacharit. If he missed Tefillat Mincha, he can make it up by12:33Arvit, and if he missed Arvit, he can make it up by12:35Shacharit. We find that concept.12:37However, we don't find it by the third time.12:39What does that mean?12:40That means if you prayed, if you missed Shacharit, you prayed Mincha, and then you realize that12:45by Arvit you forgot12:48Shacharit, it's too late already.12:49Why is that so?12:53Because already that you forgot it twice, you obviously weren't thinking about it,12:57and already it's too distant from you because you weren't mechaven to it properly.13:00Now, with this, we have chazakah by three times; it's a machloket in the Gemara. Sometimes we pasken that13:06two times is a chazakah, sometimes we pasken three times13:09is a chazakah. In this case, he's saying that this fits with the opinion that paskens two times chazakah.