Torah · MussarMussar78. The Good That Can Come Out From Bad ChildrenTzidkat HaTzadikPart 78Rabbi Uri Nahum · August 2, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0016:31Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat ha-tzadik, ot ayin0:04chet. Pe'amim gam banim resha'im efshar0:08sheyihyeh nitzmach eizeh tovah la'av. Sometimes, even though the children are0:11resha'im, it could actually be something positive to the father.0:15Something good could come out of it, basically, for the father.0:18Where do we find this? Kinyan Abraham.0:21For example, Abraham. He, unfortunately, Abraham had children that were not0:25tzaddikim. He had Yishmael. As we know, Sarah tells Abraham to kick out0:35Yishmael. So, kinyan Abraham sheyatza mimenu Yishmael, uvnei Keturah sheyatza ha-psolet al yadeihem. For example, Abraham had Yishmael, and we know at the end of parashat0:39Chayei Sarah, Abraham marries Keturah, whoever that Keturah is,0:44different opinions in the mefarshim. And what happens? He has a lot of children.0:46In fact, he has much more children besides from Sarah than he has from0:53Sarah. Sarah, he only has one child,0:55Yitzchak. And all those other kids from Keturah, he sends away to the far east.0:59And the ones of Yishmael, from Hagar, he sends them away also.1:06And he says, so what's good over here for Abraham?1:08He says, you know what's good for him?1:13Is that sheyatza ha-psolet al yadeihem. Some sort of psolet, some sort of bad that Abraham had that he had to get rid of it.1:18And what came out good is that the psolet came out,1:21that bad thing came out through those children.1:28But over here there was a zechut for the father.1:32What's the zechut of Abraham Avinu over here?1:34Because it's not so pashut. What does that mean?1:36Nobody wants to have any of his children bad, you know?1:38It's like imagine a guy has ten kids, and they tell him, you know,1:42three went off the derech, three became1:45resha'im. Yeah, but don't worry, that was the psolet of yours that went, these three kids.1:48What do you mean? It's his kids.1:50Who wants any of his kids to be off the1:53derech? So what is the good for the father?1:55The guy is, you know, sometimes,1:57a guy can have fifteen kids, and one kid is off the1:59derech and drives him crazy and it ruins his whole life.2:03So what's the good for the father here?2:05So it tells me Abraham Avinu had eight kids.2:10One of them was a tzaddik, they were all bad.2:12Ah, that was good. What's going on over here?2:13He explains,2:18bezeh tzaddik tziyuyskeh ad shefka Torah zal al yad. Over here, there's a zechut that the father needs.2:21It's not like so pashut.2:23What's2:24the zechut? Is that these kids should not be attributed to the father anymore,2:27and they're not considered his kids.2:31The relationship of father and son is completely severed,2:34not in, you know, emotional,2:37no. In halachic, Hashem says, Don't, these are not your kids anymore.2:39Now, how does that happen to any regular person today?2:43It doesn't.2:45A person is the father of that child forever and ever.2:47And therefore, you know, as a side point,2:49even if there are kids that are struggling in their Jewish ways,2:54a father may never, ever, ever let go,2:57and he has to be able to try to help to bring him back,2:59and always keep praying for him,3:01and try to help him and love him3:03and do whatever he needs.3:04Perhaps it's an emotional need that he has,3:06which, by the way, 95% of the time it's an emotional need.3:09It's not a, you know, intellectual thing that the kid is missing.3:14It's more emotional.3:15And therefore, a person cannot, you know, let go of his children.3:21By Abraham Avinu, there was something different.3:24He explains, Abraham was told by Hashem,3:30kemo she'amar b'Avraham, ki b'Yitzchak yikarei lecha zara. Through Yitzchak will only be considered your children,3:33and that was a zechut of Abraham.3:35Hashem made it that your zera, your kids3:38are only, the real kids that you have is only through3:40Yitzchak, not through anybody else.3:41And therefore, he was zocheh that all the psol they had came out through those children.3:54Kemo she'amru, ba'aset ashe batim, so perek amadei bamot, lo zazu misham ad she'asu umot kegoyim gemurim, like it says, vat aset shebatim lo aleinu, that also until they... They declared them as complete goyim.4:00That means they completely were severed from the Jewish nation.4:08וידוע דברי הרמבן על פסוק שורש פורה ראש. I imagine, known the words of the Ramban on the pasuk4:11in the end of the Torah, Parashat Nitzavim.4:14On the pasuk, it says over there4:16that Hashem says He's giving a warning.4:19All you Jews are responsible for each other,4:22and you're all given—Moshe is giving a warning to all the Jewish people.4:26You're all obligated to keep the Torah,4:27and I'm warning you terrible things could happen to a person if he doesn't keep the Torah.4:31And then he says, and you might say, You know what?4:34Me, Baruch Hashem, I'm doing okay. Life is good.4:37I'm not keeping the Torah anyway,4:39and I don't care.4:41And the words that Moshe Rabbeinu says about such a person,4:43he calls him a shoresh, a person who has a root4:46that's poreh rosh4:49v'la'anah, that sprouts very, very bitter, bitter herbs.4:54A person could have roots deep down that could sprout very, very bitter herbs.4:59Then the Ramban says that a person sometimes deep down5:03he has in his depth some sort of evil inclination or evil pull,5:09or pull towards evil—that's a better way to say5:12it—and a person who is perfect and shalem doesn't have this.5:15So therefore, a person who has these evil roots inside of him,5:19or something deep inside of him that's pull towards roots,5:23lo aleinu, could come out eventually in later generations.5:34So about Chizkiyah, we know that he was bothered.5:41He was bothered in his lifetime.5:43Chizkiyah Melech was one of the greatest Jewish— Tzadikim that lived as a king.5:47He was a king towards the end of Bayit HaRishon,5:52and the Gemara says that he completely changed the whole entire Jewish nation.5:59From Be'er Sheva Ad Dan, from the lowest part of his government until the highest point in6:06Eretz Yisrael, he made sure that every little child knew the most complex halachot of the Torah.6:11Yet he never got married.6:13And he got sick,6:15and when he got sick, Yeshayahu Hanavi came to visit him with a message from Hashem6:18telling him that he's going to die from this sickness6:21and he's not going to even have a6:23chelek l'olam haba. He was surprised, I don't have a chelek l'olam haba, and I'm going to die so soon? Why?6:27He says, because he never got married.6:28So Chizkiyahu responds, he says, How do you want me to get married?6:31What are you talking about?6:31I saw that there's going to be terrible children coming out of me,6:35resha'im. And he was obviously seeing, which eventually happened,6:38Menashe. Menashe was one of the worst people, one of the worst kings, actually,6:43to some point, whatever, but he was one of the worst kings,6:46and the Mishnah lists him as one of the people that6:49ein lo chelek l'olam haba. Now, when he says that to Yeshayahu, Yeshayahu tells him the following words:6:55Behaddei d'kafshei Rachmana, lama lach? Those things that Hashem has concealed, why are you getting involved?7:00Things are hidden beyond us to see. Why are you getting involved in that?7:04You do what you have to do. You get married,7:05you have children, and Hashem do what He has to do.7:08Good?7:08Now, he says over here,7:16Think about it for a second.7:17Chizkiyahu was the descendant of David7:21HaMelech, who eventually will be also the forefather of Mashiach,7:26because Mashiach has to come from the descendants of David7:30HaMelech. And if Chizkiyahu would have not been married...7:33And he would not have had children,7:36he took away that chance of Mashiach coming,7:39right?7:40So what did Chizkiyahu think?7:42Yeah, but I'm gonna have kids that are not gonna be good,7:46and then what's— that's none of your business, Yeshayahu tells him.7:48That's not for you to understand7:50why Hashem, how Hashem does.7:52So you see again this concept7:54that sometimes it could be something great that could come out even from bad, evil people.7:57You may not see it, you may not understand it.8:00Somebody like Chizkiyahu, who so clearly is a minasheh, that says about him that he murdered people like crazy left and right.8:06He did terrible aveirot, the Gemara says.8:10And with the knowledge of all that, you're not allowed to prevent him from coming to this world.8:16And Chizkiyahu, who was trying to prevent Menasheh from coming to this world,8:20he was punished, or he was about to get punished, that he wouldn't even have a8:26chelek l'olam haba. Why? So Rav Tzadok explains, because guess what? Mashiach is going to eventually come from that8:31Menasheh. None of your business. You do what you have to do.8:35So you see, even resha'im sometimes have a positive thing for their parents.8:39Now we saw in one place, like by Yaakov Avinu, which is what—I mean by Avraham Avinu—which is to take out the bad roots.8:46Here's another one. Another thing we find, he says,8:51Umatzinu v'kol ha'am v'yishtachavu b'parashat Bo. When Moshe Rabbeinu comes and he informs the Jewish people of the korban Pesach,8:56that the time has come to be redeemed, it says the nation bowed down.9:00They bent and they bowed down.9:06U'kidei shehashi, samchu al besurat habanim. Rashi says over there that they were excited or happy because of the information.9:09Now you think, why would they be happy? Of course, the time of freedom. No.9:12Rashi explains they were happy on the news that they were given about their children.9:21V'Hashem hu b'shelat mah avodah hazot lachem, shelat min hashamayim, k'dei taam hahaggadah. Now, if you think about it over there, it says the pasuk of mah avodah hazot lachem.9:28As a pause for one second, I have to give you a little bit of background.9:31It's a complicated background, but hopefully we'll clarify it.9:35Later I said that we all know about the four children,9:40right? Keneged arba banim, dibrah Torah—the Torah spoke corresponding to four children:9:48echad chacham, one is a chacham, one is a rasha, one is a tam, one is she'eino yodea lish'ol. The wise child, the wicked child, the simple child, and the one who doesn't even know how to ask.9:55What is going on in the Haggadah? What are we saying?9:58And the answer is that we find the Torah in many places talks about10:02yetziat Mitzrayim, leaving Mitzrayim, the fact that we left Mitzrayim,10:06the mitzvah of korban Pesach. It talks about it in many places.10:09And in a few places, we find that the Torah says about communicating10:16the miracles of Mitzrayim towards our children,10:21or, you know, making sure that they have this tradition of knowledge, that they know that we came out of Mitzrayim.10:27But the Torah changes its language in different places.10:31And from the fact that Torah changes in different places,10:33the author of the Haggadah noticed that there is a difference in all these different places10:40because we're talking about different people.10:43So in one place it says,10:45Ma10:46ha'avodah hazot lachem. So the author of the Haggadah understood, why is it saying, Ma10:52ha'avodah hazot lachem? What is this10:54avodah? In other places it says in the Torah,10:57if your child will ask you,10:59Ma11:00hachukim v'hamishpatim ha'eleh lachem? What are these laws and statutes?11:02Why does it change it?11:05He says, Oh, avodah sounds like hard labor.11:08Chukim are laws.11:09Sounds like there's two different children.11:11There's a child that wants to understand details of the laws of how they are Pesach11:19and the korban Pesach.11:21That's a11:22chacham. That's a child who is wise, who wants to learn.11:25That's why the Torah over there, when it talks about that type of child,11:30says, Ma11:32hachukim v'hamishpatim ha'eleh. And the other place where it says,11:33Ma11:35ha'avodah hazot lachem, there the Torah is talking about who?11:38The Torah is talking about a rasha,11:40because he refers to our mitzvot as11:44avodah, hard labor.11:45That's a child who's not interested.11:48And another place11:49where we read in the,11:51every day those who read the parashat11:53Chodesh, it says...11:54Mazot. Vayigash ... lemor, mazot.11:56What is this?11:57A very simple question.11:59That's the tam.12:00And then another place it says,12:04Vegadta levincha bayom hahu. It seems to be not initiated by a question.12:07You're just going and starting to tell your child.12:10There must be a child that doesn't know how to read.12:12So you see that the four children12:14are mentioned in the Haggadah,12:16the chacham, the rasha, the tam, and12:18she'eino yodea lishol. It's not random that the rabbi said,12:20Oh, there's four types of children.12:21No, it's based on the pesukim in the Torah.12:24We see that the pesukim in the12:26Torah, when they talk about communicating12:28the mitzvot or the miracles of Yetziat Mitzrayim12:31to our children,12:32talks in four different ways.12:33Must be the four different children.12:35On the place where it says12:38that the pasuk of the rasha,12:40which is12:42Mah avodah hazot lachem, there it's found where?12:44It's found when Moshe12:46Rabbeinu talks to Bnei Yisrael for the first time,12:48telling them about the korban Pesach,12:49that we're ready to leave.12:51And there it says,12:53Vayikod ha'am vayishtachavu. They bowed down12:55to the great,12:56and they were extremely happy.12:59They were bowing down out of13:01hakarat hatov, out of thanks13:02to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.13:04And what were they bowing down for?13:06says Rashi, because they were happy13:09about the kids.13:10But one second, what kids are we talking about?13:13The kids over here, it's13:15the avodah hazot lachem. We're talking about the rasha13:18in that parashah. Kedi ita b'Haggadah, as the Haggadah says,13:20Af atah hakheh et shinav. Your response13:21to him is to knock him in his teeth.13:26You still see that13:27that generation was excited and happy13:29about the news13:32that there's going to be at least that child.13:34Even that child they're happy about.13:36You see that?13:38So never, never despair,13:40number one. And any child is always13:42a blessing, and every child13:44has his own good that comes. Even what13:46seems to be very evil or very bad,13:48they have something very good could come out of them.13:57It seems like in the13:58Midrash he says somewhere else, d'lo differently.14:01The Midrash is found14:03in Tanchuma. Let me read it for you14:04for a second. Hold on.14:07The Midrash says over there14:10that14:11Shlomo HaMelech prayed14:12at the opening of the Beit HaMikdash.14:15He says14:16the following.14:18He says, Ki14:19yishme'un et14:24shimcha hagadol... He says,14:28... v'gam el hanochri asher lo me'amcha Yisrael hu, u'ba me'eretz rachokah l'ma'an shimcha... v'tefilah... v'techinat... He's going to14:37hear your great name14:39and your powerful hand...14:43He's going to pray in this house.14:47Atah tishma hashamayim, You, Hashem, listen to him in Shamayim,14:48mechon shivtecha, where Your place...14:50v'asita kechol14:52asher yikra eilecha hanochri. He's to do whatever the goy asks of you,14:57l'ma'an yed'un kol15:01amei ha'aretz et shimcha, l'yir'ah otcha, k'עמך Yisrael, in order that they should know15:02Your great name, to have fear of You15:05like the Jewish people...15:07and they should know that Your name is called on this house.15:11That's what it says about15:12a non-Jewish prayer.15:16However,15:18when a Jew is praying,15:19he changes his words. Shlomo15:21HaMelech, and he says, says the Midrash,15:26we're not—quotes a15:28pasuk—v'natata la'ish kechol derachav asher teda et levavo, and You shall give to that man15:30according to his path,15:32that You know his heart,15:35ki atah yadata levadcha et levav kol bnei ha'adam, because You're the one who knows the hearts of the people.15:38Says the Midrash,15:39Im hu15:41tovei banim, if the Jewish person is asking for children,15:44and You know that these kids are going to anger You,15:48and You know they're going to be bad kids,15:50al15:51titen lo. Don't give him.15:56And it goes on, v'chein im tebanechasim, v'todea she'atid leba'ed bahen, ata lo... If he also is asking for money,15:58and you know that it's going to pull him away.16:00From avodah Hashem, don't give him. You hear that?16:03That's the difference between a Jewish prayer and a non-Jewish prayer,16:05says the16:09Sukkat Tzadik. Sounds like from the drash the opposite of what he said,16:11because he said till now even bad kids, good things could come out of them.16:16But yet we see that, no, if a person is praying and he doesn't deserve bad kids, Hashem will not give him.16:22So he leaves it kind of like with tzarich iyun in the piece.16:25I'm sure there's different ways we could answer.16:27I'll let you guys think of different possibilities.