Torah · MussarMussar77. Defects in Families and Power of TorahTzidkat HaTzadikPart 77Rabbi Uri Nahum · August 1, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:14Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot ayin zayin.0:05So, Rav Tzadok says,0:08the first part of it is0:10what the Gemara says,0:11kind of, or he learns it from the Gemara,0:13although the Gemara doesn't say mefurash.0:16He says, Afilu adam gadol0:18beyoter, even a person who is0:20a great, great person,0:22you see he's a big tzaddik and everything else,0:23im yesh bo pegam b'mishpachto,0:26ein ledabek bo.0:26If there's some sort of blemish0:28in halacha in his family,0:30you should not marry0:32within that family.0:34That's based on the Gemara.0:35He brings in0:38Masechet Yevamot.0:40The Gemara says over there that0:42they were discussing different,0:44you know, categories of Jews.0:46The Gemara in Masechet Kiddushin at the end,0:48in the last perek, lists ten different0:50levels of0:52Jews. We all know there's Yisraelim, there's Kohanim,0:55there's Leviim.0:56Those are three levels,0:57and then there's lower levels than that.1:00There's gerim, there's netinim,1:02these are people that didn't convert properly1:05or converted for the wrong reason,1:06really.1:08There's avadim, so on and so forth. So the Gemara is talking about1:10over there that there were1:13certain questions1:14in halacha regarding certain psulim1:16in the mishpacha,1:18and certain amoraim and perhaps1:20even tanaim were matir1:23those1:25pegamim, those1:26disqualifications, certain families.1:28And the Gemara brings this incident1:30that there one time a person that came.1:33to the same1:34people that were matir,1:36and they asked the question,1:38they asked in the halacha, is this person, is it okay to marry1:40into Jewish people? Because, you know, there's a1:42psul in the mishpacha, there's some sort of blemish in the mishpacha,1:45there's, you know, slaves1:46in the family or whatever it is.1:48You know, again, it's a complicated thing to get into the1:50details. So he says, yeah, he's1:53kosher. So they אמר, okay, fine, if I'm1:54kosher, the person says, give me your daughter to1:56marry. He says, no, chas v'shalom, I'm not giving my daughter to marry.1:59So from there, Rav Tzadok learns2:01that you see that somebody that2:02has a blemish in the mishpacha,2:04there's some sort of halachic blemish in the mishpacha,2:06even though medin they could2:09marry within the Jewish people,2:10still he says you shouldn't2:13attach yourself to2:14such a family. Now you're going to say, what do you mean?2:17But this person himself is2:19an adam gadol. So Rav Tzadok explains,2:22כי הוא מפני גודלו אין מזיקו. He is a great person,2:24and that's why that2:26pesul in his family2:28did not damage him. However,2:30יזיק לזרעו. Not everybody is born great,2:32and not everybody has the2:34ability, or not everybody2:36makes the ability to become great,2:38and if so, it could affect2:40his offspring.2:41And that's why2:44Rav Tzadok says you should not2:46marry within a family that has such a2:48pegam. Again, like we said, this doesn't mean over here2:50when there's somebody that made a choice,2:53like for example some people's families,2:54they're not frum, they're not religious.2:56We're not talking about such a thing.2:58We're talking about a pegam in halacha. There could be, again,3:00if it's mamzer, of course it's a problem,3:02halacha. We're talking about not that it's a problem,3:04100% halacha, it's not a problem in halacha,3:06but there is some sort of blemish,3:08mutar, but it's a little bit of a blemish.3:10Stay away from that. That could actually have an effect.3:16And3:16the Gemara goes further on that story. The Gemara says over there3:17that when this person who had a3:20pegam in the mishpacha... Who was told3:22that by the3:24Tanna, you could marry within the3:26Jewish people. He says, Okay, give me3:28your daughter. The reply was,3:30Even if he was like Yehoshua ben Nun,3:32I would not give him my daughter.3:38אפילו נביא יהושע בן נון לא היבנא ליה ברתא. That's what the Gemara says. Those are the words of3:39the Gemara. Even if he's like Yehoshua ben Nun. What do you see from here?3:42Same concept that Rabbi Tzadok is saying.3:43You can have somebody as great as Yehoshua ben Nun.3:45Would you not want a3:47son-in-law like Yehoshua ben Nun? Of course.3:49But the problem here, he says,3:51it's not that. It's because3:53what's going to be with his children?3:55His children will be affected.3:58Now, why did3:59the Gemara choose an example of Yehoshua ben Nun?4:02You could have said anybody else.4:04You could have4:05said—he wanted to say that even if he's a big tzaddik4:07like Yehoshua ben Nun, there's greater4:09tzaddikim. You could have said even if he was a big tzaddik4:12like Moshe Rabbeinu.4:13So Rabbi Tzadok touches now,4:15the rest of the piece now focuses on that point.4:22And you see4:24that the Gemara,4:25or the rabbi, chose to4:29use Yehoshua ben Nun4:30as an example of somebody4:32that, you know,4:33if he would have had a begam and he was a4:35tzaddik as Yehoshua ben Nun, I still wouldn't give to4:36him. Why did he say even like Moshe Rabbeinu?4:38As a side point, he brings down4:40that some poskim learn from here4:42that you have to be very careful.4:44You're not allowed to say4:47something negative4:48and use Moshe Rabbeinu as an example,4:49even if he was a tzaddik like Moshe Rabbeinu.4:51Some want to learn from that,4:53and however, he learns that there's a reason4:56why he didn't say Moshe Rabbeinu, כי משה רבינו עליו השלום הוא שורש התורה. Because Moshe Rabbeinu5:06is the source of Torah. ומצד כתר תורה אין לחוש למשפחות. And if the person is crowned5:09with the crown of Torah,5:10then even if there's a psul, you don't have to worry5:12that there's a blemish in the family.5:17וכתר תורה מונח לכל. And we find that the crown of Torah...5:21It's open for everybody.5:22Anybody could come along and get the crown of5:24Torah. Even the lowest element5:26in Jewish society, which is5:30mamzer. Mamzer is a child that's born from a forbidden marriage,5:34or, excuse me, a forbidden relation.5:36The relation would be chayav karet. The child that's born from it is considered mamzer. For example, take a married woman that goes with another man that's not her husband, and she gets pregnant from the other man. That child is called a mamzer. Why? Because a married woman to be with another man that's not her husband is punishable by karet, therefore, or worse, it's actually mitat beit din, but it's, you know, karet and above. So there, the child would be a mamzer. Yet even though that child is a mamzer, Chazal tell us, if he's a mamzer that's talmid chacham, if he makes something of himself, he crowns himself with the crown of Torah, he would actually be considered greater than a Kohen Gadol who happens to be an am haaretz. And that's why he says, he didn't say, he didn't say, Oh, there's a pigam in his family life. Even if he would be as great as Moshe Rabbeinu. No, Moshe Rabbeinu, the crown of Torah actually supersedes everything else. And that's why he says, being that Moshe Rabbeinu is the source of the whole Torah, we find that Moshe Rabbeinu kibel ha'erev rav. Moshe Rabbeinu, alav hashalom, was the one who accepted the erev rav. As we know, when we came out of Mitzrayim, there was a lot of converts from the Egyptians that wanted to come along, and Moshe Rabbeinu accepted them, even though Hashem wasn't so excited about it, but Moshe Rabbeinu accepted them. Why? Because the crown of Torah has the ability to even overlook or to push aside even the pigam in the mishpachah. Here there's a pigam. They're Egyptians. They're converts from Egypt, and besar, how many, besaram. But Moshe Rabbeinu felt that through the Torah we could take away all that residue of blemishes that are in their family. It's interesting that we find, I don't think the Steipler is basing it on Rav Tzadok at all, but there's a teshuvah from the Steipler. He was asked about a person who's going on a shidduch, and the boy is in yeshiva, and he's going out with a girl, and, or vice versa, I5:36forgot exactly what it was, and the family is a not religious family. That means the parents of the girl are not a religious family, or parents of the boy are not a religious family. And the question was, so what's the problem? The question was that most probably the child is a ben nidah, which means that the parents never kept taharat hamishpacha when this child was born, and8:00Therefore, he was probably born from relations of nidah, and the ben nidah has some sort of8:05pegam, like it says in the Gemara. And the Steipler says that if a person is osek baTorah, a8:10person who busies and toils in Torah, makes a talmid chacham out of himself, then that8:16you don't have to worry. That pegam will not affect them, similar to what we're saying8:20over here.8:21If there's a pegam, stay away from them. But if they are osek baTorah, then that doesn't8:26have an effect on them.8:27Here he's saying8:28the Torah has the ability to overcome it, to overpower.8:37Vulkach, אילו הוותי משה רבינו עליו השלום, רצה לומר, תלמיד חכם גדול בדור, שזהו כמו משה רבינו עליו השלום. That's why the Gemara didn't use Moshe Rabbeinu, because if we would have said8:40Moshe Rabbeinu, if the person in fact was like Moshe Rabbeinu, meaning he was a big8:45talmid chacham, he was known as a big talmid chacham in the generation, like, how do we know that?8:49Because Chazal use that terminology all the time. When they talk about8:53talmidei chachamim, they call each other Moshe, like it says in Masechet Shabbat, Moshe שפיר קאמרת, right?8:58Then havayah, he would have given him his daughter.9:01It's only, he said if he would have been like Yehoshua bin Nun. Why like9:05Yehoshua? Ratzah lomar tzaddik.9:07He wants to say he's a tzaddik.9:09As we know, Yehoshua bin Nun came from Ephraim, and Ephraim came from Yosef, and9:14Yosef was known, Yosef a tzaddik, that midah of tzidkut, a tzaddik, which means Moshe9:19Rabbeinu at Elokim. He's got yirat Shamayim. He got tremendous yirat Shamayim. But there's a9:25pegam mishpachah, and although a person is a tzaddik himself, but it might carry over to the next generation.9:30But had he been a person of Torah, toiling in Torah, soaked in Torah, a9:39talmid chacham, known for his Torah, it would not have an effect on their children.9:49Teluya lo me'achorav. Chazal tell us that when we appoint leaders over a community, over a group of people,9:56we only do it if they have some sort of history in their family, so this way he doesn't get10:01gaavah. And the pasuk says, yet, Bi melachim yimlochu. In the Torah, the rulers will be able to be zocheh to become kings.10:12Kings will be able to zocheh because of the Torah.10:17So you see that even if, gam in the family, when you have Torah, it doesn't affect the10:25person.10:25The Torah is able to override it.10:28And he says, like we find something similar, Chazal tell us,10:35Hizaharu bivnei aniyim shemehem teitzei Torah. Be careful from the poor, from the kids of the poor, because that's from where the Torah will10:40come out from.10:42The Tzadok says the same idea can be learned from this statement, is that you see that some10:48sort of gam, we know that the kids of the poor, again, although it's not their choice10:51and not in their control, but it is a fact that we see that the poor, usually of lower10:58class in society, and as such, they don't usually do the best things. They don't behave11:02in the best way, in mannerism, in everything else also as well, whatever psychology you11:08want to give to it,11:08but that's the fact that we see.11:10But yet, Chazal tell us from them11:13teitzei Torah. You know why?11:16Ki mekom haTorah davka b'kelim shvurim, because the Torah actually comes from broken vessels, from things that seem to be not good11:22in the physical world. There actually we see great things could actually come from there.11:29Chazal tell us, and we'll finish off with this story. Chazal tell us a story of a certain11:33rabbi that wasn't so good-looking. We won't say his name. Actually, he wasn't11:36good-looking at all. And he once saw the daughter of the Caesar. She said, You're that big, famous rabbi,11:42the big talmid chacham. Such wisdom should be in such ugly-looking vessels? So the first11:49thing he tells her is like, Who are you complaining to? Complain to my God who made11:52me. My Creator is the one who made me. Don't blame me that I look like this.11:56So then he tells her, But because I look like this, that's why I'm able to become so smart12:04and become such a big person in Torah.12:07She tells him, What do you mean? There's a lot of big rabbis that are good-looking. He12:10says, Yep, you're right.12:11And if they were ugly, they would have been even greater rabbis.12:15She tells him, I don't understand. He tells her, Let me ask you a question. You're the12:18daughter of the king. What do you store the wine in? Wine is the most luxurious drink.12:25What do you store wine in?12:27She says, We store them in old clay, clay cheres, how do you call it, basically made12:35out of earthenware, cheap earthenware.12:37He says, You're the king's daughter. You're the royal family. You should store12:42it in expensive glass vases.12:45She says, You're right. Why are we so cheap?12:47She goes and she gives an order: all the wine should be stored in glass vases.12:52And what happens?12:52The Gemara says that all the wine spoils and becomes vinegar.12:57She comes back to the rabbi and says, What did you do to me? You made me ruin all the13:01wine. He says, Well, that's what I'm telling you. Something chashuv, when it's stored in13:06something broken, something ugly, actually, that's where you find its greatness.13:11That's what we're saying also over here. The greatness of Torah can actually be found even in broken13:15kelim, even where there's a gam, even where there's aniyim. That's where we can find the13:21greatness of Torah.13:22And he brings the same idea that we find that Rabbi Akiva... Who is the father of Torah, who13:29is of Torah shebaal peh? Where did Rabbi Akiva come from?13:32Chazal tell us he came from13:35mishpachat gerim. And Rabbi Meir, that all the Mishnayot stam Mishnah are Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Meir also came from13:41descendants of13:42gerim. And Chazal tell us in one more place, we find that from the descendants of Yitro, they were13:51sitting there learning Torah.13:54So again, same concept, that even specifically from gerim we find13:59the concept of Torah, because from broken vessels, from places that people wouldn't expect, but14:04from places that have a blem, Torah doesn't have effect. In fact, the opposite.14:08It can actually bring out greatness within them.