Torah · MussarMussar71. Never Pray for Evil on Another JewTzidkat HaTzadikPart 71Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 27, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:21Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkas HaTzadik, ot ayin alef. Very, very important concept that we need to know.0:08He says, Ein levakesh meHashem ra'at adam, afilu rasha. A person should never request from0:14Hashem that he should see that something bad should happen to another person, even if that0:18person is a rasha. You're not supposed to ask that somebody else, another Jew, should0:24have something bad happen to him. Kemo she'amru Chazal, like it says in the pasuk, on0:30Chazal learn it from the pasuk. It says in the pasuk in Tehillim, Yitamu chatta'im min0:35ha'aretz. And the Gemara says over there that one time, Rabbi Meir wanted to pray about certain sinners,0:40that they should be finished, that they should die. And his wife Bruriah corrects him and0:45says, Excuse me, it doesn't say that yitamu hot'im, which are the sinners themselves,0:50ela chatta'im, which means the sins of the sinners. And he corrected his tefillah, and he prayed0:56that they should be chozer b'teshuvah. And over there it's talking about, you know, obviously Rabbi Meir felt1:03justified. These people were real wicked people, that they should die. No, you cannot pray1:09for the evil of other people. He says, however, v'zehu bera laShamayim. That's only1:15the resha'im. What kind of resha'im? There's two types of resha'im. There's a person who's a rasha who1:20is bad to Hashem, doesn't keep Torah and mitzvot, he doesn't keep Shabbat, he eats1:25pig on Yom Kippur, you know, all the terrible things. That's a rasha laShamayim.1:30There's another type of ra, and that is a rasha not to Shamayim, but there's a ra labriyot.1:34He's an evil person to other people. So the chiddush of Reb Tzadok, the first1:41chiddush was, you should never pray for the evil of any other person, even if he's a1:47rasha laShamayim. Don't wish him terrible things. You should pray that the terrible things that1:53he's doing should stop, but not that terrible things should happen to him. That's1:57chidush number one. Then, chidush number two, he says, however, a baal ra,2:02a person who's bad to people,2:08then onsho midah keneged midah, shemutar levakesh shehaKadosh Baruch Hu gam ken. The punishment is a midah keneged midah, that you're allowed to request and2:14you're allowed to pray that he should get also evil, because he's evil to people. So, okay, midah keneged midah, we can be evil to him.2:20We could pray at least that Hashem give him evil.2:24And he's going to bring two examples of this, but please stay tuned and don't, you know, shut off the2:29recording yet. Stay tuned to explain these two examples. So he says, matzinu, first example is2:35Elisha.2:43שקילל הנערים מפני שהם זלזלוו לפי שריפא למים ועשה תועלת לבריות, והם חפצים יותר ברעתם, like it says in the Gemara in Masechet Sotah.2:49So what's the story of Elisha? Let's tell you that Elisha was by Yericho, and he was leaving2:54the city of Yericho on his way out. So it says that there were young men, ne'arim, young3:01lads, I don't even call them teenagers, young men, in their twenties, whatever they were,3:05the age, and they came and they were making fun of him, and they're saying, Get out of3:10here, you bald guy, get out of here. What's going on? Why would they make fun of him?3:16Stay tuned. And then what happens? Look at the reaction of Elisha. Elisha turns around3:23and he curses them. And what happens? Hashem makes a miracle. A forest is created, and from3:28the forest bears came out and killed 42 of them. What's the story? What's going on?3:34So Chazal tell us that what happened is that Yericho had waters that were very, very bad.3:39People were getting sick from it, and in fact dying from it. They were not drinkable.3:45So Elisha came, and he did what he did, and he made the waters drinkable again. And as3:50he was leaving the city, those 42 young men were actually people that were the original3:57owners of Poland Spring. They were the people that were actually making money and4:03profiting over the fact that the people of Yericho didn't have water, that we bring4:08them fresh water, and that's how they made parnassah. But now Elisha came and4:12ruined their business, because now that he made the waters drinkable again, people didn't need4:17them. So they were saying, Get out of here, bald guy. Kereach, kereach, get out of here, get out of our city. You ruined4:22our business. So what do you mean? I just helped the entire city, but they couldn't4:27care less about anybody else. They were so selfish that they only cared about themselves,4:31about their making money. And therefore, Elisha turns and curses them, and like the4:38Gemara says, nes bitoch nes, a double miracle happens. A forest is created from the forest, the bears come out,4:44and they kill 42 of them. It says, why is it that he was permitted to curse them?4:49Then we just say he cannot request any bad thing to happen to another Jew, which4:56includes cursing another person. He says,4:59Lachen hayah rashai lekalelam. That's why he was allowed to curse them, because they were not ra lashamayim only;5:04they were ra laberiyot. Maybe they were also ra lashamayim. The Gemara says,5:08yeah, some opinions are doresh that they were also ra lashamayim, but the main thing is they5:12were bad towards other people. They wanted bad towards other people. So when you're a5:18bad person towards other people, then that person deserves to get midah k'neged midah, bad towards himself.5:25He says over here, v'chein David, example number two is by David HaMelech. We find in Mizmor Tehillim, Mizmor Kuf Tet, shekillelo oyvav. David HaMelech curses5:34his enemies. Right, and he really speaks very harshly in that mizmor against some of his enemies.5:43He explains, you know why? Because they were doing bad things towards him.5:47They were chasing him. And pasuk says,5:53Vayehab Kelalah vatebo'ehu. These people, they loved—the ones who were against David—they loved curses.5:58They loved harming other people, like we saw by Doeg, who killed an entire city of6:02Nov, ir haKohanim, and therefore kelalah should come upon him as well.6:07Again, midah keneged midah, because he loves to see the evil of other people,6:13so he deserves also to get it himself.6:18We find Hashem said the same concept.6:21Hashem tells Abraham6:24Avinu, Pashad lech lecha, umekallelcha a'or. Whoever curses you, I will curse him.6:28Meaning, because they curse you, because they look to see evil happen to you,6:33they will also have evil happen to them. I will curse them.6:40Aval, however, bilvachi ein mekalel la'adam. Otherwise, you cannot curse any other people,6:44even a terrible person, hamechalel Shabbat, a sonei Yisrael, he's also a Jew, don't curse him.6:51Scary thing, no? Because we're used to seeing6:53otherwise, but that's what Chazal are saying.6:56Now, we gave you the two examples, like we said, stay tuned,7:00because he's going to explain the condition of cursing another Jew who is bad to other people.7:05How?7:08But we do find that Elisha got punished for cursing those 42.7:20Gemara אומרת, over there in Masechet Sotah and in Masechet Sanhedrin, to bring the same thing, that Elisha himself got sick,7:22and Chazal tell us he got sick three times.7:24One of the reasons that he got sick is because after what he did to those 42 young men,7:30he seems to be got punished from Shamayim that he got sick.7:33So you see that even though a person may curse, like we see by Yeshab, but you got to be careful.7:42U'levad zeh, now besides this fact that you could get punished for it as well,7:46because remember the curse still stands by the descendants of7:50Avraham Avinu, mekallecha arur. But besides this,7:54gam ken lo l'kol adam mutar. There's no permission for anybody to just come and curse,7:58sheharei amru, zabel l'shav v'yir'em, because Chazal tell us.8:00That even Elisha couldn't curse them unless he saw something about them.8:04And what did he see about them?8:07And Chazal tell us that what he saw was that there was something that they did.8:13That each one had a sin, whatever it is.8:16She'ein, you know, some of them, that there was no descendants are going to come out of them8:21that are going to be good, and the mother got pregnant, whatever.8:26But you see that he had8:28ruach hakodesh, and because he had ruach hakodesh and he saw what he saw, he was able to curse8:36them. U'mi she'eino ba'al ruach hakodesh, efshar sheyagia me'avonto. But if you yourself don't have ruach hakodesh, and if you think you have8:41ruach hakodesh, you know, there's a question over here, but if you yourself are not a person8:46who's ba'al ruach hakodesh, so it could be very possible that your own personal interest over here,8:50you're cursing them not because they deserve to be cursed.8:52Remember the whole idea of cursing, not because what they did to you8:55personally and you took it as a personal thing.8:57How many times do we see fights between people, and they come to the rabbi9:00and they come to a mediator, and the mediator says,9:03Relax, you're taking this too much.9:05It's, you know, you're taking it too personal.9:08The guy didn't mean it personal. We all have that problem.9:12We have it sometimes from our spouses, some of us.9:15Some of us have it from our kids, from our siblings, from our parents.9:18We always feel that they're looking to do, you know, that whatever they say,9:21whatever they do, they're trying to harm us. They're not.9:24We take it personal.9:26So how do we know that when somebody is cursing us, not because he's bad,9:29because we just take it too personal. It doesn't even mean something bad.9:33And therefore he says that's a condition.9:35You can't just curse anybody.9:37If you're ba'al ruach hakodesh, then you know that you're clean,9:39and then you can curse them like we find by Elisha.9:42Also, David HaMelech, also,9:52ויקח דוד את המקל... אמר פסוק בלבי... Pasuk, in that same sefer that he curses his enemies, David HaMelech says,9:55My heart is hollow inside of me.9:57And the Gemara's doresh on that pasuk,10:02sheharago layetzer hara. He killed the yetzer. Why did David HaMelech take this pasuk in the same perek10:06that he's talking about cursing his enemies?10:08And the answer is, don't think that when I'm cursing my enemies,10:11it's a personal insult that bothers me.10:17He was saying, I have nothing to worry that it was done10:19for my own personal reasons10:22or my own selfish things.10:25Ki chavad ein lo10:27yetzer hara. David says, I'm saying this, I have no10:29yetzer hara. I have no yetzer hara whatsoever.10:31But because they desire evil, that's why they deserve evil,10:34and that's why he's cursing them.10:35V'kodem mizmor zeh ne'emar, mizmor shebo pasuk,10:39Lig'orad li10:40me'asher. And right before this10:42mizmor, that mizmor that David curses everybody, is10:44mizmor kuf-tet. In mizmor kuf-chet, David says the words,10:48Lig'orad li10:50me'asher, li'efraim uli'Menasheh. And Chazal learned masechet Sanhedrin,10:53very interesting thing from that pasuk.10:55What do they say?10:57That all the people that were listed in masechet Sanhedrin,11:00the Mishnah, as not having11:03chelek l'olam haba, the Gemara says, Dorshei reshumot amru shekulam11:07yesh lahem chelek l'olam haba. They learn from this pasuk11:09that all those people that were mentioned11:10actually do have a11:14chelek l'olam haba. V'zehu k'ein she'amru Chazal, b'dat Hashem11:17yitbarach shemakdim refuah l'makah. This is what11:18Chazal, similar to what11:20Chazal say, that Hashem usually gives11:22the refuah l'makah, that before Hashem strikes a person,11:25He gives11:25the refuah. So too we find over here,11:27mizmor kuf-tet is where they got the11:29makah, these people that David was cursing them.11:32Achitofel and Doeg were listed in the list11:35in the Mishnah, masechet Sanhedrin,11:36as not having11:38chelek l'olam haba. But the pasuk right beforehand...11:40I mean, excuse me, the perek right11:42before, in perek kuf chet, it talks about a pasuk11:44that Chazal learn from11:45there that they do have11:47chelek in11:50Olam Haba. And that's what he's telling you,11:51it's the training for us.11:53Even those people that you feel evil,11:55that they deserve to be cursed,11:56you have to actually be good to them.11:58You have to look for them.11:59You have to find a way to get12:01them to chelek in Olam Haba. You have to find a way that you should do good to them.12:06And then and only then,12:08if you12:09tried and you tried to do very well12:11and you tried to help them12:12and you tried to look positively at them,12:14and only then you see that,12:16hey, these guys are still evil,12:18then if you curse them,12:19then we could say,12:21aliz, asur. You're doing it for the right reasons12:23and not out of a personal interest.12:25So you see that you should never ever pray12:27for the bad of any other Jew.12:30If Yisrael l'shamayim, for sure,12:32never ever. Even12:34ra labriyot, even if a person is bad towards other people,12:37you have to be careful.12:39You have to make sure that you understood him perhaps.12:42Sometimes, you know, we see people that12:43they look, they seem to be very evil,12:45like really terrible people.12:46And when you speak to them, sometimes you find that,12:49you know, they are terrible12:51perhaps in how they act,12:53but they have certain issues.12:55In any case, to curse them,12:58it's not your—let Hashem take care of it.12:59Don't get involved.13:00Because even those who curse,13:02lo aleinu, comes back.13:04They get punished for it,13:05like even we find by Elisha.13:07So therefore, it's best to stay out of it.13:09You see something wrong by somebody else,13:11you want it to be changed, you want Hashem to13:13get involved, pray to Hashem.13:16The sins should be gone,13:18not the actual sinners.