Torah · MussarMussar70. A Deep Idea About Evil Being GoodTzidkat HaTzadikPart 70Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 27, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0018:45Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat HaTzadik, Ot Ayin. Like we said at the end of Samech Chet, that Samech Tet is missing.0:08So we're going to go straight to Ot Ayin because that's what we have. This piece I found it to be0:14very, very difficult to understand exactly his kavanah. I'm not sure if there's words missing,0:20but it seems like there isn't any words missing because usually the printers would kind of point0:24out there's something missing here or whatever. So we hope to explain it in the proper way and,0:32b'siyata dishmaya, hopefully be mechaven to what the author meant to say. Let's begin.0:41Be'oto davar shebo hesaron shel adam. In the same thing that a person finds that this is something negative about himself,0:50be'oto davar, v'al yedei atzmo hu ma'alah to. Believe it or not, that that same thing which looks like0:53it's the bad part of the person, or the negative part of a person, is actually his greatness.1:01That itself is greatness. And he's going to bring now a few things. For example,1:06k'anyan shene'emar, like it says in the Gemara, Masechet Sanhedrin, al on the pasuk. And we know after the sin of Adam HaRishon,1:13ba'etz hadaat, by eating from that tree, it says that they recognized that they were undressed1:18and they made themselves clothing. What did they make as a clothing? It says in the pasuk,1:25Vayitferu aleh te'enah. They made clothing from the leaves of a fig tree. If you've ever seen the leaves of a fig tree, they're1:31pretty large. And we can assume they, you know, based on the size of different people, maybe,1:37you know, you find larger fig trees and whatever it is. And they made clothing from the leaves of1:43fig trees. Okay, on that, what does the Gemara say? The Gemara says,1:50B'davar shekikelu bo, nitkanu. That's the tree that they actually ate from. As we know, there are different opinions of what was the1:55actual fruit of the Etz HaDaat. Well, according to one opinion, it's the fig tree.2:03Why is the opinion the fig tree? It's because, the Gemara says, because they used it to cover themselves2:09up. So in the same tree that they sinned with, that's the same tree that they used also to fix2:17themselves. So that concept of that, you see that the thing that actually is your problem is actually2:23the way to fix you. The fig tree that actually brought you the problems of sinning is actually2:30the way that it made you realize you're naked, is actually the same tree that used to also to cover2:37you from your nakedness. So that's what Rav Tzadok wants to say also, is that the same hisaron that a2:43person has is actually his way of fixing himself. It's a very deep concept, actually, in that way.2:50And you forgive me if I go off a little bit of a tangent, but there's a sefer, which happens to be2:56I'm in the middle of it, and I'm debating if that should be our next book that we learn. It's a sefer3:01called Daat Tevunot from the Ramchal, Moshe Chaim Luzzatto, who's also the same author3:08as the famous book Mesilat Yesharim. This Daat Tevunot is a very, very deep book, and it's written3:16in a style of a conversation between the mind, the brain, and the soul. And the soul is asking the brain3:23about many, many things in how Hashem runs the world and where is this all leading to, and3:29basically the ultimate plan of Hashem, like what does He want from all humanity, from the whole3:35world, basically, and of course the role of the Jewish people in that. It's an amazing3:40concept. But over there, the main focus of the first part of the book is that there's a concept called3:47Hashem is Echad, Hashem, Yichud Hashem, the oneness of Hashem. And it's such a deep, deep concept. We3:54think we say every day, Hashem Elokeinu, Hashem Echad, Hashem is one, and V'haya bayom hahu Hashem Echad. So4:01just mere words. It's actually a very, very deep concept of what does it mean that Hashem is oneness.4:05But the idea of it is that— Hashem is perfect, then it just makes sense that everything else4:12should be perfect, and yet we see the world is not perfect. We see people, which are the main part of4:17Hashem's creation, are not perfect. So what's going on in the world? Why is it like that?4:22And he explains that that's the idea of Hashem, how He wants to show His perfection,4:26is that when He created the yomim, He created the world and the humans imperfect, and the world will4:33start developing to bring it to the point of perfection, and He's going to use the evil,4:40what looks like evil, or what looks like things are against Hashem's will, as the way to bring4:48out His ultimate will. A small sample of this Rav Chaim Friedlander brings down is from what we see4:57on Purim, right? Who was the—if you would have to credit the person who saved the Jewish people5:05in the whole story of Purim, who would you credit it to? You credit, of course, to none other than Esther.5:12That's right, Megillat Esther. She's the one who risked her life. She's the one who approached5:16the king. She was really the shaker and maker of the whole story. Yes, it was Mordechai who5:21pushed, but basically it was who? It was none other than Esther. How did Esther get to such a power?5:28The answer is because Haman gave the advice to Achashverosh to kill Vashti. So you see that the evil,5:35which eventually we had to save ourselves from, is actually the one that set up the whole story5:42of the salvation of the Jewish people. Deep concept. But that's really what's going on in5:47the world as well. We just don't realize it because we only realize it once it happens,5:51how what looks like the world is getting more and more and more evil is actually leading to the5:56ultimate thing of what the ultimate goal of what the world is supposed to reach. And that's the same6:01idea he's saying over here. The same chesaron that a person has is actually his way of— Becoming great.6:11How and what, each person in his own way. He brings another example. He says,6:16Va'aderet Zekanim, כן, משם הוא. You could also understand the famous Yerushalmi. Yerushalmi says,6:22ביום שנחרב הבית נולד המשיח. The day that the Beit HaMikdash was destroyed is actually the same day that Mashiach was born.6:27So hold there a sha'ah on that. And again, what's going on? What do you mean, it was just destroyed Beit6:32HaMikdash? It seems like the Jewish people are gone. No. Now is actually the time when Mashiach6:38is born. What's the idea? The idea is like what we're saying until now. What looks like a6:43hissaron is actually the ma'alah, is actually the ma'alah. How and what, again, each person may not see it right6:50away, but we do see that the hissaron itself brings the ma'alah. The following piece, I'm not sure what he's6:55trying to say. This is why I said I get stuck a little bit. And he says, the Gemara7:00says in Masechet Sanhedrin a question. It's in the last perek, and it says,7:08Minayin לתחיית המתים מן התורה? Where is the source from the Torah for תחיית המתים? The Gemara questions that, and it7:13brings many, many different sources. Where is the source of תחיית המתים מן התורה? And he wants to say,7:19based on that, that again, the same concept, but I just don't see how. He puts in brackets,7:28רצה לומר שכל דבר בעולם. And he's explaining the question whenever the Gemara asks to see a source in the Torah,7:34it's based on the following point, and that is,7:39כל דבר שבעולם יש לו שורש בתורה. Every single thing in the world, everything, every concept, every person, every event,7:48everything that Hashem does, every character that lived in history, they all have a source in the7:54Torah. רצה לומר דביקות במקור החיים שהוא אמיתות רצון השם יתברך. What it means is that.8:00That's where attaches itself to the ratzon HaKadosh Baruch Hu.8:04Everything, everything has to have that thing that it's connected to the Torah.8:08If it's in the Torah, it means it's really the ratzon of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.8:13Perhaps maybe that's what he means.8:15V'ein letchiyat hameitim min haTorah.8:18How do we know the concept of8:19techiyat hameitim min haTorah? Which means that there's gotta be, if there's a concept called techiyat hameitim, it's gotta be in8:25the Torah. And he's saying it means death, which was really not part of the plan, is actually from the Torah,8:32because if there's a techiyat hameitim, the Torah must be death was also part of the plan.8:36So death, which seems to be destroying the person,8:40then techiyat hameitim is actually the ultimate reward of the person8:45because, you know, that's the ultimate reward.8:47But one second, how did he die in the first place?8:48So you see that the chesaron of the person is actually his8:56ma'alah. To die, you zocheh to techiyat hameitim. I believe that's maybe what he's saying,8:58and I'm not sure,8:59but we'll continue now to the next paragraph in the same9:03ot, and he says,9:06V'zehu para l'taher mitumat met. And we know that one of the things—not one9:09of the things—the thing that is used in order to get taharah from tumat met is the9:16parah adumah. This is the same—he says the same concept,9:18because Chazal tell us, why9:21parah adumah? Why did Hashem choose a cow from all other creatures that He had?9:25Why did He use a cow?9:27True, it's a red cow, but why a cow?9:28Chazal tell us,9:31Let the mother come and clean the tzoah, the waste, that her son did.9:35If a son makes, who would we call to clean up?9:37We call the mother.9:39Same thing.9:40Who's the son of the cow?9:41It's the9:42eigel. The9:43eigel. It's9:45the eigel hazahav. And we know the9:46eigel brought death to the world,9:49because when Chazal tell us that when Bnei Yisrael stood by Har Sinai...9:54Bnei Yisrael got to the level of Adam Harishon before he sinned with the9:59eitz hadaat, and there was no more death in the world.10:02Chazal learn this from the pasuk that says,10:07Ani amarti elohim atem, uvnei Elyon kulchem. I said, you're like Bnei Elohim, you're like the angels.10:10And just like there's no death by angels, there's no death by the Jewish people that stood at Har Sinai.10:15But the pasuk continues, it says,10:18Achen keAdam temutun. However, you will die just like Adam Harishon died.10:23When did that happen? It happened after the10:25eigel. So you see that when Bnei Yisrael stood by Har Sinai,10:29even before receiving the Torah, they got to such a high level of,10:35like the malachim, just like the malachim, and they didn't have death in the world.10:39That's why the Gemara says,10:41charut al haluchot, when it says in the pasuk that the writing of Hashem was engraved on the10:47luchot. The word charut, Chazal make a derashah, could also be read with different nekudot as cheirut, freedom.10:56Freedom from what?10:56It says, cheirut mimalach hamavet, freedom from the angel of death.11:00There was no more death, and that's why we say in the dayenus,11:04one dayenu that everybody asks a question on:11:07Ilu kirbanu lifnei Har Sinai,11:12v'lo natan lanu et haTorah. Hashem would have brought us close to Har Sinai,11:14He didn't give us the Torah, it would be enough.11:16What do you mean? We only care for the Torah.11:17No, because standing by Har Sinai alone got us on the level of being free from the angel of death.11:24There was no more death in the world.11:25That was the level that Bnei Yisrael reached when they stood by Har Sinai.11:29However, with the eigel, it came back.11:31Death came back to the world.11:33So how are you metaher a person from tumat met? With the mother.11:40The mother is the source of the11:42egel. So he explains this inside, and he says,11:44Ha'egel hu shoresh11:46hamitah. The egel is the source of death.11:48Zehu tzoa bena, that's the tzoah of the child.11:50Really, the egel is great; we can use it for its food, it has potential to grow.11:54But the tzoah— but there's also a bad part of the baby cow,11:58because it doesn't know how; it just makes all over the place.12:02So there is a bad part of the egel, and that is12:05about the death.12:07And what's going to clean it up?12:08The12:09parah. And the parah is the mother,12:12hamoledet, it's the one that gave birth to it.12:16That's the concept of that.12:18Who's the mother over here?12:20Mother represents— again, besides the physical things in halacha,12:24yes, there's a parah adumah, but here he explains the mother12:26that brought this to the world12:28represents that who gave this concept to the world.12:33Shehakol min Hashem yitbarach. Meaning to understand that you have to understand that the12:36egel— why is12:38parah adumah metaher tumat met? Just to understand that really all comes from Hashem.12:42Mimenu yatza hakol. When you come to understand that everything came from HaKadosh Baruch Hu,12:46al yedei ze hu kinuach otah12:49tzoah keneged ha'egel. That's how you clean up that mess.12:51When you go back to the source and find where the source is,12:54when you understand where the source came from,12:56now you can understand where you can be13:00metaher. Because really, the Maharal explains the same concept in13:05Parashat Chukat. Why is the parah adumah a tikkun for chet ha'egel and for mitah?13:11Well, chet ha'egel was really idolatry,13:16avodah zarah. And avodah zarah is to give power to something else besides Hashem.13:21The opposite of avodah zarah is when you recognize that13:25even what seems to have its own power really gets its power from HaKadosh Baruch Hu.13:31That means if I say that the malach Gabriel came and brought fire and destruction to a certain place—13:36I'm not really being13:39oved avodah zarah. I'm not recognizing that there's another power besides Hashem.13:42No, I'm just saying that Gabriel is doing it as a messenger of Hashem,13:48and that's easy because I'm talking about angels.13:50If I say that my boss makes a lot of13:52money, and that's how I'm able to13:56afford—actually, that's how I'm able to also get13:58parnassah, because he makes good money in his business,14:00and therefore I get a salary as an14:04employee—so it depends what's running through my head.14:07If I believe that my boss has his own power separate from Hashem,14:10that's a little bit of14:12avodah zarah. If I believe that Hashem has blessed my boss with parnassah tovah, with a good14:17parnassah, and therefore He is the shliach to send me my personal salary,14:24then I'm recognizing it's all coming from Hashem.14:27So it comes out, the avodah zarah and the antithesis of14:33avodah zarah, the exact opposite of avodah zarah, is just a very fine line.14:35Avodah zarah is that separation from Hashem.14:38If you look at the original place where avodah zarah came from,14:41the people started saying that the sun has its own power.14:45Nobody can disagree that the sun is very powerful. It gives vitamin D,14:48gives nourishment, it gives growth to the entire world, it gives warmth, gives heat.14:53Nobody can disagree with that.14:56The original avodah zarah started saying that they have its own power.15:00That's where they went wrong.15:02But to say that it came from Hashem, of course, that's recognizing that everything is from15:07HaKadosh Baruch Hu. So the egel was15:09avodah zarah. To recognize that the egel doesn't have its own power, but it has a mother,15:12it has a source, is the antithesis of15:18avodah zarah. That's how you battle against15:19avodah zarah, because it doesn't have its own power; it has a source.15:21Who's that source? It's15:23HaKadosh Baruch Hu. That's how the para adumah is15:26metaher tumahat met, is when you recognize that everything comes back to the source.15:31He brings it back. It's a side point,15:33which is not really connected to this point, but like we said,15:37we usually skip it because we want to focus on the point.15:39But it's a nice side point.15:41We find in history that there was another person that made the15:48eigel. When the Jewish people split their kingdom,15:51the king at the time was Rechavam, the son of15:55Shlomo HaMelech, and the kingdom split into two.15:57There were the two tribes that were focused around—16:00Yerushalayim, shevet Binyamin and shevet Yehudah, and the other ten tribes moved out to the north,16:06and they had the first king over them, and that was Yeravam ben Nevat. And Yeravam ben16:13Nevat, for whatever reason it is, I'm not going into it right now. We know what the16:17reason is, but he decided that we're going to build basically temples by us, and we're16:23going to put an eigel hazahav for people to worship in those temples. He says, interesting,16:30no, that the eigel was made by Yeravam. He says, really, I'm going to read this inside:16:36lachech na'asa gam ken al yedei Yeravam. That's why the eigel, which is the source of death,16:41which is like we said, it's the so'av, the bad part of the eigel, was made by Yeravam. Who was16:46Yeravam? Yeravam ben Nevat, who came from shevet Ephraim, who came from shevet Yosef.16:50Shehaya bo shoresh Mashiach ben Yosef, sheyatza mezerao meAbiyah. He actually had16:57a big neshama. Hashem told Yeravam to be the king. He selected him because he had a17:03big neshama. What was his neshama? It was sourced in the fact that he could have been17:08Mashiach ben Yosef, which we know now, she'ehyeh me'utad lehareg. Mashiach ben Yosef,17:14Chazal tell us—this is a new concept for you, so I suggest that you look into it a little bit17:19deeper—but we find in Chazal that there's two Mashiachs. There's Mashiach ben Yosef17:23and Mashiach ben David. And Mashiach ben Yosef is supposed to be the preparation for17:27Mashiach ben David. But one interesting fact that Chazal tell us is that Mashiach ben Yosef will eventually17:32be killed. So it's interesting that Mashiach ben Yosef has in him still the effects of17:39the eigel, which is death. That's the so'av of the eigel. And Yeravam ben Nevat made the17:45eigel. Why? Because he was sourced in this neshama. His neshama had this connection17:52to Mashiach ben Yosef because he himself came also from Mashiach ben Yosef, which was eventually17:56going to die. You hear that? That's why he explains that specifically he made the eigel.18:02How come it wasn't the other way? How come the shevet Yehudah was never the one to18:06make the eigel? Because they come from David HaMelech. David HaMelech, it says in18:12Tehillim differently: Chayim she'amcha natata lo. He represents chayim, life, a continuing life that will never ever cease. Even when it looks18:17like David HaMelech's entire family was wiped out by, you know, once in history, they came back.18:24Hashem made sure that He guarantees that they live. Not so by, interestingly, by Mashiach ben Yosef, we find death.18:30And why? And how is that connected to the eigel? Because eigel is a source of death.18:35It's a nice concept. At the end he adds—I just want to share that—I believe it's18:39a very nice thing to think about. It's much deeper than what we said as well.