Torah · MussarMussar66. Praying Even When DecreedTzidkat HaTzadikPart 66Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 22, 2022−15Play+30Position0:008:59Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:03Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot samech vav. Although a short piece, it's a beautiful piece, an important piece, as it deals with0:09tefillah.0:10As we know, tefillah is something that's very close to heart to all of us.0:14So let's see.0:15Tefillat tzaddik l'chol davar, af al pi she'nigzar meHashem0:18yitbarach. Says the tzaddik, you need to pray for everything,0:21even though it's already decreed from Hashem, you still need to pray for it.0:26And that's really an answer to a big question that many of us have:0:31if it's decreed, why do I need to pray for0:33it? Now, he's going to prove it in a second from Eliyahu HaNavi and a few other places.0:37I would like to just point out something and to prove it to you as well.0:41Did Abraham Avinu pray to have kids?0:44Of course he prayed to have kids.0:47Now, Hazal tell us that brit bein habetarim took place when Abraham Avinu was seventy years0:53old,0:55okay? And in brit bein habetarim, Hashem is talking to Abraham, and Abraham tells Hashem, you know,1:04I already saw in the stars that I will not have any children.1:09So what does Hashem do?1:10Hashem picks him up above the stars and tells him that, Habet na, look down on the stars.1:15You're above the mazal.1:17These are the famous words of Chazal that Rashi brings down in Parashat Lech Lecha and the1:21whole story of1:22brit bein habetarim. So Abraham was seventy years old, and at that point he knew that he wouldn't have children based1:29on the stars.1:30Did he pray?1:31It seems like he did pray anyway,1:33even though it's a1:34gezeirah. So we know that our tefillot can be1:39mevatel a gezeirah. Okay, it's not a big1:40chiddush. Even something is a gezeirah, we still could pray and it can be1:44mevatel it. In fact, Chazal tell us that although a gezeirah that Hashem makes, it cannot be1:50mevatel. Well, it says, however, through korban may be mevatel, but al yedei Torah, you know, and tefillah, it can be1:57mevatel. We have the power to be mevatel it through tefillah.2:00Very good.2:01But here, I think what Tzadok is saying more than that,2:05he's not saying just to pray to undo things.2:09He's saying even when it's decreed that it's going to happen, you still need to pray for2:14it as well.2:15Not like what we think, oh, of course, even Hashem is decreed on something, we can always undo2:20it if it's something that we don't want.2:23No.2:23Even if it's something that we do want, and Hashem decreed it and we know it's decreed,2:27we still have to pray for it.2:29As he says,2:30listen to this,2:31here's the proof.2:32Hello to Eliyahu.2:33Eliyahu2:35Hanavi, in the times—now, Eliyahu Hanavi is known because he, you know, he lived throughout all the generations.2:41He never died, and he appears many times.2:43But Eliyahu Hanavi, when he did live in this world as regular Eliyahu Hanavi, as a regular2:49human being before he turned into Malach Hashem, it says over there, there's a whole story2:54with2:55Achav. I'm not sure if we mentioned in the past, but very quickly, Achav basically was the king of3:00the northern Shevatim, and he was a big rasha.3:05In fact, he is one of the people listed in the Mishnah, Masechet Sanhedrin, as3:08not having a3:10chelek l'olam haba. And he also suffered from Eliyahu Hanavi because Eliyahu Hanavi decreed that there should be3:16no rain for three years.3:17We know that part of the story;3:19we mentioned that recently.3:21But the second part of the story is that Eliyahu Hanavi promises to bring rain after a showdown3:26in Har HaCarmel, where he proves that Hashem hu HaElokim, Hashem hu HaElokim, that there's only one Hashem, there's nobody else who's powerful,3:31and all the nevi'im, the prophets of the Baal, which is the avodah zarah, were there,3:37and they lost.3:38Clearly they lost to the eyes of all the spectators, all the Jewish people that were watching.3:43They saw that Hashem is the God; it's not the Baal.3:45And after that debate, Eliyahu Hanavi promises to bring water, and Hashem tells him. Go, show3:53yourself to Achav, and I'm going to give rain.3:56That's what it says.4:00And even though Hashem promised him that He's going to bring rain, it still says that Eliyahu4:04Hanavi went to the top of Har HaCarmel, vayighar, and he prayed so much until rain came.4:12But didn't Hashem tell you that rain is going to4:14come? You see from here what we started saying, that even though—hear this—even though4:21things are decreed and it's going to come, you still have to pray for it.4:26It's not in the patur. Oh, I realize in Shamayim it's going to come, I'm good. No, you still have to pray4:32for it.4:34Now we're going to tell you in the Gemara, Masechet Rosh Hashanah says,4:41The gezar din hu b'Rosh Hashanah v'Yom HaKippurim. There's a machloket between Rabbi Yosi and the Chachamim of when does Hashem decide what4:49a person is supposed to get.4:50So according to Rabbi Yosi, every day a person is judged. According to Chachamim, Rosh Hashanah they're judged, Yom Kippurim,4:56it's the psak halacha, it's already sealed, as we know.5:00So he says, when Chachamim said that a person has a gezeirah of what he's going to get,5:06again, we're not dealing with what he doesn't want. We're talking about what he's going to get.5:09He's going to have a child, he's going to have a good parnassah, he's going to have5:12the health, he's going to have the success, he's going to have what he wanted.5:19Don't think that that's an argument machloket. Why in the world did Anshei Knesset HaGedolah set up a siddur and5:25tefillah that we have to pray every day with certain5:29texts? Already Chazal tell us in Masechet Rosh Hashanah that lefi shetatachmin, that we're possek, like5:33a person's psak din is sealed on Yom Kippur. It's decided Rosh Hashanah, sealed on Yom Kippur.5:39It's matarotzeh mechayim sheli. Why do I have to pray for it?5:41It's already decided.5:43What, am I praying only for the bad things that shouldn't happen?5:45No, it sounds like I'm praying even for the good things.5:47Panasa, it's decided what's going to happen.5:49No, there's no machlokes, because they go hand in hand.5:52Now you might say, what about the following?5:59The Gemara says, in that same page, the opinion of Rabbi Yose, we told you already, he holds6:03that a person is judged every single day.6:05And the Gemara says, if he wants, because the Gemara says it could also fit6:10with the chachamim. Nowadays we pray for certain people. Like who?6:16Ktzirei u'merai. And Chazal tell us who are ktzirei u'merai. It says in6:20Masechet Nedarim, Rashi brings it,6:21the ktzirei u'merai are the sick people.6:24We pray for sick people.6:25We pray for talmidei chachamim as well, who are usually weak by nature because they're always6:30studying Torah.6:31So he says, who are we holding like when we pray for the sick people?6:35The Gemara says like Rabbi Yose, because every day is a new judgment.6:39So it sounds like not like the chachamim, because the chachamim, that's it, it's decided,6:42there's no point of praying.6:44He says, no, that's not — you misunderstood the Gemara.6:52That we pray so much to try to rip up the gzar din. That's the pshat of6:56Rabbi Yose, that says every single day you have the ability to have a new7:00gzar din. What does it mean,7:03it should be like that?7:08But אמרו כן להלכה מכוון. The Chazal said this, the halacha is like Rabbi Yose, that we pray every single day.7:12It's because like Rabbi Yose, who says that we get a gzar din every day. Why?7:19That they wanted to say that our prayer should be like the7:25opinion of Rabbi Yose, שיועילו אף לקרוע גזר דין דראש השנה, that they should be able to rip the7:30gzar din in Rosh Hashanah. Meaning to say, there was, in the way Rav Tzadok is explaining it, is that it's like we hope that it should7:36be like that.7:37We hope that our prayer should be so powerful. That should be able to rip even the7:42gzar din that's already decided by Rosh Hashanah.7:46And we see from here this concept again, to reemphasize: you have to pray,7:51not only for bad things that shouldn't happen, but even for good things.7:55Oh, but it's decided, you still have to pray for it. And if it's decided, you still have to pray for it.8:00The famous words of the Baalei Mussar, based on the Gemara, and Rashi brings it down also,8:06is that when Adam HaRishon was created, we know Hashem said that there should be grass8:10already, and they didn't come out until Adam HaRishon prayed for them.8:14Had they not come out8:15because there was no rain.8:17There was no rain, and v'geshem ayin ki ein adam, because the pasuk says there's no rain8:20because there's no human being.8:22Only when the human being came and he prayed for it, then it came down.8:25That's the way life is.8:27Things don't come unless you pray for it.8:30Rav Shimshon Pincus points it out.8:32He says that's a klal in life.8:35Just like a thought in your mind remains a thought and it's nothing until you express8:41it through words,8:44that's the same thing also.8:45When a person, when there's a gezeirah in Shamayim, it doesn't come out until it's8:49expressed through our words to bring the dibur into a davar, to turn the words into physical things8:55that Hashem should carry out the gezeirah, to kabbalas רצון.