Torah · MussarMussar64. Can You Be Sure That Hashem Agrees with You?Tzidkat HaTzadikPart 64Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 20, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0015:15Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Sifkat haTzadik, ot samech0:03dalet. It happens to be that this piece, we've had it earlier.0:07We didn't have it earlier, but we cross-referenced to it0:11when we ... one of the pieces earlier.0:13We said this idea that if a person sees that Hashem is assisting him,0:18it doesn't necessarily mean that, you know, he's really getting assisted by Hashem,0:23because there's a rule on that is,0:28b'derech she'adam rotzeh leilech, ba molichin oto. That's where they send him; they let him go that way.0:31So we had this piece earlier, and he said to look later on,0:34and so this may sound a little familiar, but now we're seeing it inside in the right place,0:40ot samech dalet. Let's begin.0:43Sometimes a person sees clearly that Hashem seems to be assisting him,0:48and it seems to be that Hashem is agreeing with what he's doing.0:55It calls, Zeh, ... Still, don't think that just because you see that it looks like, hey, Hashem is agreeing,1:01doesn't mean what I'm doing is the right thing necessarily.1:33On this, Yeshayahu Hanavi says in perek mem-chet, pasuk yud-zayin, Hashem will guide you in the way that you want to go. V'darshu Chazal, Chazal made a drashah on that: B'derech she'adam rotzeh leilech, molichin oto. The way that a person wants to go, that's the way they will take him. V'amar b'derech dirtza, right? Why did the Gemara use the lashon rotzeh? This he puts in brackets.1:36Excuse me, why did the Gemara use the word b'derech?1:40Why did the Gemara use the word b'derech?1:40D'ratza lomar, b'sefer ... derech haTorah, kemo shekatavti l'eil, because he says1:49the derech of the Torah. כי אין השם יתברך מסייע אלא כשהוא עפי דעתו הולך בדרך התורה. Because if Hashem really is going to be mesayea a person,1:53remember,1:54ba molichin oto, they'll take you.1:55But if you want Hashem to assist you,1:58it's only if you go in the ways of the2:00Torah. If you're doing something2:03al pi haTorah, and then you see siyata dishmaya, you2:08can say, Oh, okay, Hashem is helping me.2:12And you can say, What about2:14b'la'am? B'la'am also felt that Hashem was assisting him2:16because he felt like, Look, God is telling me you could go.2:19In fact— I think, I mean, it's harsh to say,2:22even though Hazal says Bilam was one of the worst people in the world,2:25but if you think about it,2:26Bilam actually got a command from God telling him what to do.2:29You could go with them.2:31We never got such a command.2:33But again, Bilam's Torah, he made up his own Torah.2:35He made up his own laws.2:37He was a twisted guy.2:38And therefore he really felt that Hashem was agreeing with him,2:40because based on what he thought is the way to serve Hashem,2:44so yeah, of course Hashem is agreeing with him.2:46In any case, he comes back and he says,2:49Prove this point,2:50that just because a person sees some divine assistance2:54or what looks to him like some divine assistance,2:56it doesn't mean he's doing the right thing.3:03We find, the Chazal tell us about Eliyahu3:06Hanavi. So let's give you a little background,3:08a very interesting story.3:09The story is, goes way back.3:12Just what makes it very interesting is that it all connects throughout all the years.3:16So we're going a little bit back.3:18Yehoshua takes over as the leader of the Jewish people.3:21They cross the Jordan,3:22and the first city they come to battle was the city of3:25Yericho, okay?3:27And it was a miraculous way of how they conquered the city,3:30because the wall that surrounded the city of3:32Yericho to protect them from the outside enemies3:35was as thick as it was tall.3:38You hear that?3:38So it was as thick as it was tall.3:39So if it was, let's say, 30 feet high,3:42it was also 30 feet wide.3:43People actually lived in the wall,3:45like Rahab herself lived in the actual wall,3:47which means you couldn't knock down the wall.3:48It was such a thick wall, you couldn't knock it down.3:51So how would you break through the wall?3:54There's no chance.3:55It was a fortified city,3:56and that was the first city they had to come to conquer.3:58So Hashem tells4:00Yehoshua, You're going to walk around the city with all the Jewish people for seven days,4:03each day one time.4:04On the seventh day, you're going to walk around seven times,4:08blowing4:09shofarot, and when they did that, what happened?4:11The whole entire wall got absorbed into the ground.4:14They walked into the city,4:16and they destroyed the whole city.4:19Yehoshua makes a declaration.4:20He says,4:20Nobody is allowed to build the city anymore,4:23as a reminder for all history of the miracle that Hashem did for the Jewish people.4:28And, he adds, whoever does, his kids will die.4:33That means when he starts building it, his oldest will die,4:36and when he finishes building it, his youngest will die.4:38Okay,4:39we fast forward now.4:41There was a man in the times of Ahab the king,4:44which Ahab, by the way, is one of the kings of the northern part of4:48Eretz Yisrael after way after the kingdoms already split.4:52This is also in the times of Eliyahu4:54Hanavi. So there was a man in the time of Ahab who was actually close to the king Ahab,4:57it seems like,4:58and he decided that he's going to rebuild the city of5:02Yericho. And exactly as it was prophesied by5:07Yehoshua, when he started building it, his oldest son died,5:09and kids started dying,5:11kids started dying,5:12till he finally completed the building,5:13and his youngest son died.5:15And he was sitting as an avel right now, as a mourner for his youngest son.5:20Who comes to visit him?5:21Ahab,5:21who himself was also a rasha.5:23And he brought avodah zarah to the world,5:25to the Jewish people.5:27His wife Izebel introduced the concept of avodah zarah called Baal,5:31which is a terrible, terrible5:34avodah zarah. And Eliyahu Hanavi also comes to visit this person5:37to be menachem avel. So Ahab makes some comment to Eliyahu5:39Hanavi, and he says,5:41Eliyahu, it looks like the student is greater than the rabbi.5:48What is he referring to?5:49He is referring to Moshe Rabbeinu, the rabbi, and Yehoshua, the student.5:54Moshe Rabbeinu says that,5:59Hishameru lachem pen yifteh levavchem, like we say in Kriat Shema, be careful,6:01that if you decide to go after6:04avodah zarah, va'avadtem mehera me'al ha'aretz hatovah, Hashem will be very upset,6:07ve'atzar et hashamayim vlo yihyeh matar. He'll stop the shamayim from giving rain and the land from producing anything.6:13And the student, Yehoshua said,6:15whoever rebuilds Yericho will have his kids died.6:19Well, people are6:22worshipping avodah zarah, nothing happened.6:23Life continues.6:25Rain is coming down,6:26the plants are producing,6:27everything is wonderful.6:29But Yehoshua said, whoever rebuilds the city of Yericho and his kids will die.6:33Looks like the student Yehoshua is great than Moshe Rabbeinu,6:37and he said this obviously in a sarcastic way.6:39Eliyahu Hanavi was a big kanai,6:41some say he was6:42pinchas. Eliyahu Hanavi says, Oh yeah?6:45Chai Hashem,6:45he gets up and he makes a swear that there will be no rain till I say so.6:49And from that point on, there was not a drop of rain for an entire three years,6:54and there was a tremendous drought6:56that people literally were eating their deceased children.7:00That's how much it was.7:01Now, let's come back to the story.7:04Chazal tell us,7:09Hashem was not happy with the rain stopping.7:14He was not happy that Eliyahu Hanavi made such a declaration.7:16In the beginning7:18of Masechet Ta'anit, the Gemara tells us of how he had to trick Eliyahu Hanavi to give him, quote unquote, the key to the rain,7:25because there are three maftechot, there are three keys, Gemara tells us.7:28One of them is techiyat hameitim, one of them is to have children, and one of them is the rain.7:33And Eliyahu Hanavi took that key.7:35He says, No rain will come down until I say so.7:38And Hashem really wanted to bring rain,7:40and he had to get somebody to die so Eliyahu Hanavi, when he wanted to do7:44techiyat hameitim, he could exchange the keys with him.7:48But clearly Hashem was not happy with the rain stopping.7:54Still, Eliyahu Hanavi had to go into hiding.7:57Why? Because Achav, when he saw that there was no rain and people were suffering...8:00Says, I want that man, Yehu, dead all his life. Hashem told Eliyahu, go hide, because8:05he wants to come after you. And the way Hashem assisted Eliyahu Hanavi from hiding from8:15Achav was in a very miraculous way as well. If Achav would have caught Eliyahu Hanavi, he8:22would have forced him to stop his decree, כמו שעשה אחאב כך, כמו שעשה יהורם לאלישע. Like the way we find Yehoram the king also8:29forced Elisha to stop his decree. So you see that Hashem was not happy with what Eliyahu8:35Hanavi did, yet He assisted him. So that's what Rav Tzadok wants to say: don't think8:40that Hashem is assisting you necessarily agrees with what you're doing.8:46So על זה נאמר לא בשמים היא, and that's what the pasuk means. We always understand8:52lo bashamayim hi as the way Chazal use it in particular cases, like, for example,8:58deciding the halacha, right? But he brings another point to it: lo bashamayim hi. It's not in shamayim,9:07ואף על פי שעזרו לרבי אליעזר בדרך נס על ראש הדינאמו, לא סמכו על זה. We find9:13this even in Chazal when they talk about halacha. There was a famous9:17machlokes between Rabbi Eliezer and the Chachamim regarding the certain oven, regarding the tumah of a certain oven. We9:28can't get into the technicalities of the halacha right now, but there's a big machlokes in Bava Metzia, and over there there was a debate back and forth between Rabbi Eliezer and the Chachamim. Rabbi Eliezer says,9:33If the halacha is like me, let shamayim bring out right now a miracle. Let there be a9:40stream of water. Let there be reeds. Let the walls of the Beit HaKnesset... let a sound,9:44let a bat kol come out from shamayim and say the halacha is like Rabbi Eliezer. And a voice9:47came out and said, Mah lachem etzel Rabbi9:52Eliezer, mah lachem etzel רבי אליעזר בן הורקנוס בכל מקום. Leave Eliezer; the halacha is like him. And even though a voice came out and said,9:57Halachah k'Rabbi Eliezer, from Shamayim they said, Halachah k'Rabbi Eliezer. Chachamim got up and they said—Rabban Gamliel got up and he says, Lo bashamayim hi, I'm sorry. It's not10:06decided in Shamayim. What do you see from here? In Shamayim they agreed with him, right? It doesn't10:11necessarily mean that that's what we do over here. How can it be? The question is, okay, we know the story,10:19we know the halachah, very good, but how could the Chachamim ignore what it says in Shamayim? If10:26Hashem is saying this, okay, shouldn't Hashem's opinion count a little bit? Shouldn't you rethink? You know what the answer is?10:31Says Rav Tzadok, an amazing answer. Rav Tzadok explains that the Chachamim felt that the reason why Hashem said10:38that is because that's what Rabbi Eliezer wanted Him to say. He was not asking Shamayim to decide10:44that—they felt that Rabbi, again, the way Chachamim felt about Rabbi Eliezer, they felt Rabbi10:49Eliezer wanted it this way because he wanted this way. That's why Hashem said it this way.10:57And this is the same complaint that we find11:02Klal Yisrael complaining about Moshe Rabbeinu. It always amazes me, every year we come to Parashat Korach and we read about how Korach made this11:08rebellion. Moshe said, You sure you guys want to go through this debate? You sure, Korach, you11:14and your 250 people? Everybody's going to die. Only one person will survive, the real person Hashem chose.11:19You sure you want to go? And they said, Yeah, we're going to go. And what happened? Korach and all11:25his family, besides the ones who did teshuvah, obviously, and all those 250 people and Datan and Aviram, all11:31those people that ganged up against Moshe Rabbeinu, were all either burnt, or burnt and absorbed in the11:38ground, or absorbed in the ground. Right, the earth opened up its mouth like a mouth, swallowed them. In fact,11:45Chazal tells us it sucked them like a vacuum. Tremendous miracle that has never existed before that time and was only created to prove Moshe's11:52authenticity. And right afterwards, Bnei Yisrael come and complain to Moshe Rabbeinu,11:57Atem hamitem et am Hashem. You guys killed them. What do you mean we killed them? You saw clearly they started the fight and12:02we warned them. How can you say, Atem hamitem? And the answer is, af al pi shera'u haflagat hanes b'omedam, even though they saw such an12:10unbelievable miracle in how the people that rebelled against Moshe were killed,12:16they still said, It's not based on12:23shamayim. You can't be somech on this to prove the halacha is like Moshe Rabbeinu against Korach,12:33because you wanted to go this way, and the rule is, b'derech she'adam rotzeh leilech, ba molichin oto, and your zechuyot is12:41bigger than Korach and his. And that's why they ended up dying, not because that's what Hashem wanted. It's what you wanted,12:46and Hashem just did what you wanted to go because that's the rule. Unbelievable, right?12:51B'derech she'adam rotzeh leilech, there's an unbelievable power that we have, but scary because sometimes it might12:56not be the right way, but they allow us to go even though Hashem may not agree with us.13:01So you have to be careful. What's the solution then? So we said this earlier13:05in the piece that we had earlier when we discussed this point, and that is to pray. You have to pray13:12that Hashem will assist you. You have to pray that Hashem should not let you fool yourself13:19to go in the wrong ways. You have to pray that Hashem should save you from your mistakes,13:26from twisted thinking. He should guide you in the way that He wants to guide us.13:30I would like to add on to this, Rav Tzadok. We find at the end of Sefer Shoftim,13:37the story of Pilegesh B'Givah, and it was a very, very sad time in Jewish history, where the entire13:43shevet Binyamin was wiped out except for 600 men. Imagine, women, children, everybody was almost13:48wiped out except for 600 men. How'd the fight start? Whatever, how it started, whatever they13:54wanted to do, din, whatever it is, but there was a battle, actually a few battles between13:59Shevet Binyamin and the entire Jewish people. And the Jewish people asked Hashem before they went out14:05to battle in the first two battles, Should we go out to fight against Binyamin? And Hashem said yes,14:12and they went out and they lost. It was scary. What do you mean? Hashem told you go, and you lost. Hashem was14:19not happy with it, because really, I didn't say the question the way they asked it. Chazal point out14:26that they didn't ask the question. They said, Who should go out to fight? They're already14:31deciding to go out to battle. And then Hashem said, Oh, you want to go out to battle? You want to know who should14:34go first? Yehudah, Shevet Yehudah go first. But they should have asked the first question: Should we go to battle or14:41not? But they decided. Again, it wasn't some random people that decided. It was great tzaddikim that14:46decided back then, but they didn't ask it in the right way. Didn't ask Hashem's opinion. They said, We14:51want to go. Oh, we want to go now. Hashem, what should we do? Okay, you want to do14:57it, do it. Shelach lecha anashim. You want to send messengers, send. But if you want to know my opinion, you got to ask clearly,15:05Hashem, what do you want from me? That's how we have to pray to Hashem: Help me. What do you want15:09from me? Not that we should decide and then try to drag Hashem along the way.