Torah · MussarMussar60. Causing Pain to OthersTzidkat HaTzadikPart 60Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 14, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:57Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:01Tzidkat tzaddik ot samech.0:03In today's piece,0:04Rav Tzadok says an idea.0:07Perhaps the concept is known from before,0:09from other places,0:11but it's good to always learn,0:13and he brings it out also over here.0:15He says,0:16Kol0:17minei tzaar v'yisurim sheyesh l'adam al yedei adam0:20acher. Any sort of pain or suffering0:23that a person has0:25from someone else.0:27So let's just put you in the center over here.0:30Let's say you,0:30your name is Abraham,0:33and you get0:35tzaar and pain and suffering from somebody else.0:37Somebody caused you pain.0:38Somebody insulted you.0:40Somebody made fun of you.0:42Somebody spoke lashon hara about you.0:43Somebody made sure that you get fired.0:45Somebody made sure that you don't get the job.0:47That's all tzaar and yisurim that you get from somebody else.0:50Sometimes it could come0:52b'meidaato or shelo midaato. Sometimes it could happen intentionally.0:54The guy, you know,0:56you're applying to a certain job somewhere else.1:00You or your son1:01was trying to date a certain family,1:03and then the brother-in-law heard that1:05you're going to be coming into the family,1:06and he said, came out of his way, said,1:08No way, absolutely not,1:10and for no good reason.1:12We don't want him in the family,1:13or we don't want him in this business,1:16right? That could be1:18b'meidaato. Sometimes it could be1:19shelo midaato. What is1:21shelo midaato? It could be b'grama, he says,1:25rak b'grama dilei, nigram tzaar l'acher. Just he caused it by whatever it is.1:28You know,1:29he saw the application to the business,1:32and that this guy applied,1:34and, you know, he didn't necessarily mean1:36intentional, this specific action to work.1:38He just says, We don't have, you know, jobs right now.1:40We don't need another worker right now.1:42He says,1:46V'chein afilu mochiacho al aveidah. Not only that, even other types of1:47tzaar where you're doing the right thing.1:49For example, you see somebody doing something wrong,1:51and you have to tell him off,1:54and you have to not, you know, I don't like the word tell him off,1:55although that's what the terminology that's used.1:58Tell him off sounds like very harsh.1:59No, according to halacha, there's ways of how to do it.2:01So you go to the person, you tell him,2:03Look, you're doing this and this thing wrong.2:05You're doing this halacha wrong.2:06So that causes a person a little bit of bad feeling.2:09He says,2:12Hu ha-retzu'at merdut lo al avono. It's basically the whip2:14of the person on his sin.2:17And therefore,2:23לכן יש לאדם לזהר שהוא יהיה נקי בזה. If you're causing other2:24people tzaar, again, whether intentionally or unintentionally,2:27you have to be2:27very—even when it's not only justified, but it's required.2:31You see a guy doing aveirah, you have to tell him off.2:32Oh, they're gonna feel bad. Everybody has that.2:34You remember, you know that? Oh, but he's gonna feel bad,2:36Rabbi. You can't say it.2:37No, you have to say it at the end of the day.2:40But when you are gonna say it,2:41you have to be very careful.2:44שיהיה הוא נקי בזה, that you yourself2:46have to be clean2:48of what you're doing,2:49of what you're telling the other person,2:51of what you're causing the other person.2:53So be very, very careful with this.2:55People don't realize this,2:56that—what I mean, that's what it says in2:58halacha—but you yourself are not careful.3:00You know, you see somebody coming late to3:02Shacharit, you feel like you have to tell him off.3:04But you yourself don't come on time.3:06You see people talking3:08in chazarah, but you yourself talk also in Kaddish.3:10Come on, right?3:13So he says3:14over here you have to be careful.3:16Any tzaar that you could cause somebody else,3:18no matter what area it is,3:20whether it's3:21halacha, not halacha, you have to be very careful that you're3:23naki, 100% clean of that specific thing3:25that you're telling other people about.3:27Moshe, while like it says,3:32וופקדתי את דמי יזרעאל על בית יהוא. It says in the pasuk, listen to this:3:41וופקדתי את דמי יזרעאל על בית יהוא, וְהִשְׁבַּתִּי מַמְלְכוּת בֵּית יִשְׂרָאֵל. So to understand this,3:42you need to know a little bit of3:44Nach. Not so easy, I had to review it as well.3:47Hoshea Hanavi is one of the trei asar,3:49and actually he's the first of the trei asar3:51if you open the sefer Trei Asar.3:53And by3:55Hoshea Hanavi, Hashem tells him,3:58וופקדתי את דמי יזרעאל על בית יהוא. Who's Jehu? Who's Yizreel? What's going on over here?4:00So there's a more famous king,4:02he was known,4:04and his name was4:05Achab. He was married to4:07Izevel in the times of Eliyahu4:10Hanavi. So Achab, what happened is4:12with Achab is that he had4:14a neighbor. And his neighbor4:16was actually his cousin,4:17and his name was4:20Yizrael. And what happened4:22is that he basically4:24wanted the property.4:26He asked to buy it. He didn't want to4:28sell it to him, his neighbor,4:29who was his cousin also,4:32and he ended up killing him.4:35Nabot HaYizraeli, that was his cousin's name, he ended up killing him.4:38Now the question is, how was he killed?4:40Was it because of Achav, or was it4:42Izebu who set him up? Basically it was a whole setup4:44that they brought him to Beit Din,4:46and two false witnesses claimed4:48that he cursed the king and he cursed also Hashem,4:50and therefore his property belonged to the king,4:52so they took the property.4:54Hashem gave a prophecy and He says,4:56Oh, this is what you do.4:58You're going to see, you're going to die a terrible death,5:00and it was a terrible death at the end.5:02Him, his wife, Izebel, they all got killed.5:05Who was the person that5:06carried out the execution5:08of killing out the family of5:11Achav? It was a person called Yehu.5:13This was a king,5:14Yehu, who killed out5:16Achav and his family. Why?5:18He came in the name of Hashem, killing out5:20that family. Six months later,5:22Yehu—now Yehu took over then5:24as a king—six months later,5:26Yehu himself gets killed5:28also. Why?5:29That's what the pasuk says:5:32Vefakadti et dam Yizrael al beit Yehu. The blood of5:34Yizrael, just like5:35I punished Achav for what5:37he did to5:38Yizrael, which is Nabot HaYizraeli, so too5:41I'm going to carry out the punishment5:43on Yehu. Why? Because Yehu5:46himself, who5:47carried out my mission of5:49killing out Achav, he should have been a5:51tzaddik. You can't just go ahead and kill somebody5:53else, even though you're doing it with dvar Hashem, and you yourself5:55are guilty of the same5:56aveirah. And therefore,5:58whatever I did to Achav, I'm going to do to Yehu as well.6:01Now,6:02what makes it very confusing is that6:03he connects it also to another piece,6:06which Rashi also connects it.6:07Another story that took place6:10actually much earlier.6:12There was a king called Baasha.6:14This Baasha6:16did the same idea6:17that Yehu did. But who did he6:20do it to? He did it to6:21the family of6:23Yeravam ben Nevat. You remember Yeravam ben Nevat, the guy who split,6:25who originally started the ten6:27mamlechot, and he is the one who made6:29the Egel Hazahav in the northern kingdom, not allowing6:31the Jewish people to come for the6:33shalosh regalim in6:35Yerushalayim. And he was always spoken about6:37throughout Chazal as the6:41choteh u'machti. Eventually,6:41Yeravam's son took over,6:44and6:45Nadav ben Yeravam, and Baasha ended up killing him.6:47But Baasha himself was also guilty.6:49He was also6:51oved avodah zarah. Therefore, when Baasha's son took over,6:53Hashem sends a prophet6:55called Yehu, not to be mixed with the Yehu6:57that we just spoke about that came later on,6:59that was a king. But the prophet Yehu7:01comes and he says7:03the following words,7:05and that is,7:06let me read for you,7:10pasuk zayin: V'gam b'yad Yehu ben Chanani hanavi. Again, this is a7:11different Yehu. This is the prophet Yehu.7:15There was7:18a devar Hashem: Haya el Baasha b'beito, al kol hara'ah asher asah b'einei Hashem. The words of Hashem came to7:19him about all the evil that he did in the eyes of Hashem,7:21which is7:24avodah zarah, l'hach'iso b'ma'aseh yadav lihyot kbeit Yeravam, to anger God7:25where he was exactly like the family7:27of Yeravam. And what does it say?7:32V'al asher hika oto, and also for killing out7:34Yeravam. But wait a second.7:35You killed out Yeravam's family.7:36That was exactly what he was supposed to do.7:40That's exactly what Baasha was told to do.7:42And now Yehu is7:43prophesizing about him, and then it says, yes,7:46the prophecy came against Baasha,7:48although you killed out the family of7:51Yeravam. Therefore, you should have been7:52a tzaddik, but you can't kill them if you yourself are not clean7:54of the same sin, and you did the same sin.7:56Therefore, you're going to be held guilty,7:58not only for the sin of avodah zarah.8:00But also for the sin of killing out the family of Yavam. Even though you did it originally because Hashem told you to do so,8:06but since you yourself were not clean of the sin, therefore you are held accountable.8:11And that's what Rav Sadok is trying to point out over here.8:12If we are causing pain to somebody else, even when the pain is justified,8:17we have to be careful that we ourselves are also clean from that sin.8:21V'lachen ne'emar, that's why Chazal tell us on the words,8:27Hitkosheshu v'koshu, kashot atzmecha v'achar kach kashot acherim. First you clean yourself up, and then you clean other people.8:30You know, there are a lot of people who, you know, mouth off what they want to say.8:34I'm not scared. You got to be careful when you open your mouth.8:37You got to be careful, even if you're in the position of a person that has a voice.8:43You got to be careful when you speak about against other people, to understand8:47whether yetzer hara, to understand if you yourself are not guilty of it. And if you are guilty,8:51you got to be careful how you speak and not to cause pain.8:53And sometimes, what do you mean? You have to say it.8:56L'mashal, let's say you're the rabbi, and you're also a person who can't control himself,9:00and you also speak when people tell you a joke in the middle, and you also speak.9:04But at the end of the day, you know it's wrong.9:06You know that what you're doing is wrong, and you know that your kahal is doing the same thing that's wrong.9:10How do you tell them off?9:11You have to say it so you're guilty also.9:13The answer is, you say it in a way that you don't make them feel bad,9:17and you say it together: Rabotai, I'm guilty as much as you guys.9:21I am also. I need to work on this on myself.9:23I also am not good in this9:26midah. I also have a problem with anger.9:28I also have a problem with talking9:30lashon hara. I also have a problem with not giving enough9:33tzedakah. I also have a problem of not learning enough according to my level.9:35We have to work together.9:36You see, it comes a little differently, as opposed to there's a problem here about that,9:40and you make people feel guilty when you yourself are also not clean of the sin.9:45Then he continues and he says,9:50Because if not, d'blav hachi nanash al kach. Because otherwise, if you yourself are not clean, then you also get punished on this.9:58Yisurim ba'im l'acher al yado shelo midaato. Now, yisurim that come to another person because of you, which were not done intentionally,10:07Ein HaKadosh Baruch Hu mevi'em ela al yedei mi shenaki b'davar. Hashem will only bring them by somebody who's clean of the matter,10:14כי אין הקדוש ברוך הוא רוצה להביא תקלה על ידי מי שאינו נקי. Because Hashem doesn't want it to happen to somebody10:17who's—He doesn't want to bring any stumbling block amongst another Jewish person.10:22And therefore, if you caused—let's put it this10:27way—if you caused pain to somebody else, with that intention whatsoever,10:32because of you it came to somebody else, if Hashem did it that way,10:36He will only do because that person was himself clean in that issue.10:43Or perhaps Hashem is making the person also get the sin of making other people feel bad,10:51so he should get that punishment as well.10:53Like we find Chazal telling us about a person who killed by accident,10:58a person who kills on purpose and he got away with it.11:00Hashem, what He does is He brings them in the same place,11:02and the person who kills by accident ends up killing another person by accident.11:08This time it's the person, the real murderer, and he ends up going to11:12arei miklat. So you see, here is an accident Hashem brought upon a person.11:15It caused pain to somebody else, but because the other person deserved the pain,11:18he got killed.11:20And this person who's now running to arei miklat, he also deserves to run to11:25arei miklat, but now Hashem set him up so he should be able to go to11:27arei miklat, because the first time he kind of ran away, he kind of escaped the punishment of11:32arei miklat. So you see that if Hashem causes somebody to cause pain to somebody else,11:37it's one of two reasons:11:39either— The person's clean and he's not going to get punished for it,11:42or the person deserves punishment and Hashem set him up in order that he should get his due punishment.11:48And now this connects to what we said earlier also in a different recording.11:57Gemara tells us in Masechet Sotah that if the husband is not clean himself from the sin,12:02the water will not check his wife. Why?12:05Think about it.12:07Imagine the woman was guilty. She has not been faithful.12:11She has been going with somebody else.12:13When she drinks that water, she's going to have a tremendous amount of suffering and pain and death.12:18Who's causing that? The husband.12:21The husband is bringing her.12:22In order for the husband to cause pain to somebody else,12:25even though it's justified, the Torah says, Isha Sotah, you have to bring her,12:29but he himself has to be clean also of the same sin.12:32If he's not clean of the same sin, then the waters will not work.12:35Hashem will not allow it to work.12:36Why? Because that's the same idea we're saying till now.12:40You know, if you're going to cause pain to somebody else, whether on purpose or not on purpose,12:44you have to make sure that you yourself are very clean in that area.12:48And only when you're very clean in that area,12:50then you have the right, sort of quote-unquote, speak and to say your opinion to others.