Torah · MussarMussar59. Explanation of the Birkot HaTorahTzidkat HaTzadikPart 59Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0017:06Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot0:03nun-tet. In this piece, Rav Tzadok talks about Torah and the berachah of Torah,0:09which is appropriate for the three weeks,0:12as Chazal tell us in Masechet Nedarim0:15that it says in the pasuk,0:17‘Al0:19mah avedah haaretz?’ Why was the land destroyed?0:22And Chazal tell us that this question was asked0:25to the neviim and didn’t have an answer.0:27It was asked even to the0:30chachamim, didn’t have an answer.0:31It was asked to Malachei HaSharet, according to one girsa in the Gemara,0:33and nobody was able to answer except for Hashem.0:36Hashem says, ‘You know why Eretz Yisrael was destroyed,’0:38referring to the time in the Beit0:41HaMikdash HaRishon, and the reason is0:42‘asher lo0:44berchu baTorah techilah,’ because they didn’t make a berachah on the Torah0:46techilah. And there is a famous bach0:49in the halachot of Berachot HaTorah in Shulchan Aruch,0:51in the Tur really,0:53not Shulchan Aruch, in the0:54Tur, where he discusses this Gemara and he explains0:58‘shelo berchu baTorah techilah’ means they didn’t have an appreciation1:00for the Torah that Hashem has given them.1:03So it’s appropriate now, in these three weeks1:04where we are commemorating1:07the destruction of both batei mikdashot,1:10the first and the second,1:12to learn about Torah1:13and to learn about also the berachot of Torah.1:18Let’s see this piece, a beautiful piece.1:19Torah1:24נקרא לשון מורה דרך, שהוא מורה ומלמדת לאדם. You ever notice the word Torah1:25is very identical to the word of1:28hora’ah, which is really guiding.1:30Also horim in Hebrew1:32refers to parents,1:34which are supposed to guide you.1:35Torah is the same thing.1:36It’s a moreh derech.1:37It guides you.1:38It shows you the path,1:39and it teaches a person where to go.1:41Now, the simple understanding of this,1:43you might think, is,1:45‘Oh, of course, because I look in the Torah1:47and it tells me,1:47Kabed et avicha v’et imecha, respect your parents,1:52Shamor et yom haShabbat, keep the Shabbat, and all the other laws,1:54so it’s guiding me what to do.’1:56Says, no, that's not what he means.2:01V'eino tono lomar, b'ma shemelamed et hachokim u'mishpatim. And that's not what we mean to say,2:03that when you learn Torah2:04and you learn the laws,2:06you get that by any book,2:08when you open a book and2:09a guidebook because you have instructions.2:11That's not what it means.2:14Shegam keshelomed Seder Kodashim nikra osek baTorah. Even when you're not learning the laws2:16that are practical,2:17for example, Seder Kodashim.2:19We know that there's such a thing called shas.2:22Shas is2:24Roshei Teivot, shisha2:26sedarim, six sets, or six volumes, you could say.2:30The Torah shebaal peh is divided into six volumes.2:33One of them, the fifth one, is Kodashim,2:35which deals primarily,2:37and not primarily, but almost exclusively,2:40with the halachot of the Beit HaMikdash,2:42which we don't have today.2:44We don't have korbanot,2:45we don't have korban2:47minchah, we don't have2:49zevachim, we don't have all that.2:50And yet a person who's learning the2:52Torah is also considered learning Torah2:55that guides you.2:56Guides you what?2:56We don't have these things;2:57they're not practical in our days.2:59Of course, we hope the3:00Beit HaMikdash should be built soon,3:01but we don't have them.3:02But still that's called3:07osek baTorah, and it's still part of the3:10horaah of guidance.3:10So what's the pshat?3:11How does Torah guide a3:13person? He says that's like the Midrash says3:16in Eicha, in the3:18Petichah, kemo she'amru zal,3:23hama'or shebah machazir lemutav. The light of the Torah3:26itself brings a person to do good.3:29It's a powerful statement right there,3:30the Chazal3:32tell us, and all the mekubalim speak about it,3:33the Ramchal brings it3:35in Derech Hashem and other sefarim as well.3:37When you learn Torah,3:38that itself pulls you to do good.3:41Even if you're3:43osek, even if you're learning parts of the Torah3:45that has nothing to do with practical application.3:48You know, people sometimes enter yeshiva,3:49a lot of people enter yeshiva,3:50the most common masechtot are learned in yeshiva3:54are usually the3:56Nezikin, like Bava Kamma, Bava Metzia,3:59Bava Batra. Or in Seder4:01Nashim, Ketubot, Yevamot, Gittin,4:03those are the most common4:05masechtot learned in yeshivot throughout the world,4:07okay?4:08And I remember personally4:09when I first entered yeshiva,4:11it bothered me a lot, like,4:13hey, why can't we learn something4:14a little bit more practical?4:15You know, like,4:16lemaaseh, what in the world4:18do I need to know about4:21shor shenagach et haparah, an ox that gores a cow?4:22It bothered me for many years.4:24And eventually you realize that4:26that's4:27eisek haTorah. It doesn't make a difference what you learn.4:29When you're4:30osek b'Torah, the Torah itself has this power4:31to pull you to do good.4:33And somehow or4:34another, look, it's working, right?4:35People enter yeshiva4:37and they're learning Gemarot4:38most of the day,4:39like 80% of the time,4:41if not 90% of the time,4:43and they come out better people.4:45How is that possible?4:47They're not learning this.4:48Yeah, of course4:49they learn also some4:50Musar, some4:50halacha, but that's only 10%.4:52Majority of the day4:52they're learning other things.4:53In fact, some people don't even know4:55anything about4:56halacha, but they come out to be better people.4:57The answer is4:58the or of the Torah.5:00That's where the word of Torah comes from,5:04hora'ah, moreh derech.5:05It's the light in it.5:08Ve'orah tovah. However, to be zocheh to the5:11or haTorah, which, by the way,5:12he brings in brackets,5:13protects a person5:16and it saves him from sin,5:17like it says in the Gemara.5:19And5:19who's zocheh? Not everybody is5:20zocheh that when they learn Torah,5:22they get this light of the Torah.5:24You know who's zocheh to it?5:26Hu rak al yedei mevinim bah.5:28It's only for those who are5:31mevinim, who are ready in it.5:33I'll explain what that means in a second.5:35Hu samad chayim, which gives you the potion of life.5:38So the Gemara5:40brings—you need to understand a little background5:41to what he's referring to over here.5:43The Gemara says— That,5:45on the words,5:49v'samtem et devarai אלה. The word5:50v'samtem, which we say every day in Kriat Shema,5:51you shall place those words5:54al levavecha, on your heart.5:55And the Gemara says over there,5:57v'samtem can be actually divided into two words:5:58sam, tam.6:00And even though it's spelled with a sin,6:02the sin and the samech are interchangeable.6:05So the word sam, samech mem,6:07means a portion,6:09like when you get medicine,6:10it's called a, like a liquid.6:12You know how children have the liquid Tylenol6:14or whatever, or liquid antibiotics.6:16So that's how they used to make portions6:18in olden days,6:19to take for medicine.6:20Sam, tam.6:22So the Gemara says6:23there's a6:26potion that's a medicine6:28that6:29gives—this medicine gives you life,6:30gives you protection.6:32What is that?6:33Et devarai אלה. Those are the words of the Torah.6:35However,6:36the pasuk says,6:39Biminah osher6:44v'chavod. Actually, biminah, orech yamim biminah, bismolah osher6:45v'chavod. There's a pasuk that says6:47in6:48Mishlei that there's long days6:50in its right6:52and in its left,6:54osher6:54v'chavod, wealth and honor.6:56And the Gemara is doresh on this pasuk6:58that actually has a deeper meaning6:59than the simple.7:00What does it mean,7:01biminah, in its right?7:02It says,7:03l'maiminim bah,7:06for the ones who use their right.7:08Now we have to explain what that means.7:11Then you get7:12orech yamim, long days and life,7:14and that's referring7:15in Olam Haba and everything else.7:17Basically, you're guided in the right place.7:19Bismolah, l'masmilim bah,7:20the ones who use the left hand,7:22it seems like,7:23it's only7:24osher7:24v'chavod, wealth and honor.7:26What is the meaning over here,7:27l'maiminim bah?7:29To be a righty,7:30or, you know,7:31today we know there's people7:33who are on the right7:33and people on the left.7:35It's very identical to that, actually.7:37The left is more liberal.7:39More loose,7:41more relaxed.7:42The right hand refers to7:43the strong hand usually.7:46I don't know if there's a statistic that's done7:48of how many people are righty,7:49how many people are lefty,7:50but based on my surroundings,7:52I can tell you the majority of7:53people that I know are righties,7:55not lefties.7:55I see how they wear their7:57tefillin. So majority are, of course, enough.8:02Number of lefties, but the majority are righties. So, in the words of Chazal, the right hand and the left hand are not referred to as, when the Gemara says yamin or the Chazal says yamin, actually doesn't mean what we call the hand on the right and the hand on the left. It means the strong hand.8:16So, maiminim ba, the people who learn it with the strong hand, meaning to say that they're not relaxed about it. They're very careful to do it in a strong way, meaning that they're careful to do every detail the way it's supposed to be done,8:31as Chazal referred. That's called l'shem shamayim. L'shem shamayim means I'm doing for Hashem's sake, not for my own personal interest. For my own personal interest, I want to make it as easy as possible for me.8:39But when I'm doing it because that's what Hashem tells me to do, then I have to be careful that I don't miss any details out, because I don't know what Hashem is makpid on. Hashem said to do this,8:47and I have to be careful and I have to look, you know, I have to worry about chumrot and everything else. And the other guy who really is looking for his own comfort is always looking for that loophole, for that easy way out, for that kula, for that leniency in the sfek-sfekot and all the other kulot that's found in the9:04Torah. L'maiminim ba, orech yamim, it gives you long life. That's the middah chayim. That's what he says over here. Who's zocheh to this or haTorah? When does a person who learns Torah merit that he should be able to be pulled by the light of Torah?9:21That's only if he ma'aminina, like it says, v'chayim v'or hakol echad. Life and the light, it all comes together. It says in pasuk, Ki עמך מקור חיים, באורך נראה אור. Same pasuk says, With You, Hashem, is the source of life; with Your light, that's how we see light.9:38What is that referring to? That's the Torah that gives us life, and it's our guiding light to guide us, and it does this naturally. Even if we're not learning Torah, we know naturally what the right thing is.9:50Aval, that's if you're learning Torah lishma. A person is not learning Torah lishma; he's learning shelo lishma. Why would a person learn Torah shelo lishma? The answer is for many reasons.9:59It could be that, you know, it's impressive when he has information and he could go around and impress everybody with his knowledge. Ooh, I know more than you. I could tell you things that you don't know. I can tell you all the halachot, Shulchan Aruch, that you don't know,10:11and I always correct people, and I feel very powerful, actually. You remember those days when we had to wear a mask, and if you didn't wear a mask, people would go, Hey, put on your mask. Why? Why do people get such a pleasure out of that?10:22What do you want from me? I'll get sick. No, because it gives you a certain sense of power that you tell people what to do: Put on your mask in this building, put on your mask or get out of here.10:33You remember those days, right? So you might be still living them, by the way. But there's a certain power that people feel when they commend other people, when they feel like they're better than other people. I'm wearing a mask and I'm good. I took my vaccine. I'm better than you,10:48right? So there's such a thing. So yeah, also by now, of course, the people who took the vaccine, there are other people who took the vaccine just want to be protected, not going around yelling at people, Take your vaccine and put on your mask,11:00because they're doing it just to be protected. Same thing in learning Torah. The people who learn Torah l'shem Shamayim, because they want to know, what does God want from me? What does Hashem want from me?11:09What's my goal in life? And if Hashem tells me, you know what, help other people because they need to be corrected, I'll help them in the way the halacha says. I'll ask the rabbi, Rabbi, how is this supposed to be done?11:19And there are other people that learn Torah because, yeah, you know, it comes with a little bit of pride, and it comes with a little bit of power. Hey, fix your tefillin. You know what you're doing is not kosher. You know that, right? You know that meat is not kosher that you're eating. You know that, right? Right?11:33So it gives a sense of power also. That's also a Torah that's learned, but shelo lishma. He says, Eino masig ha'or, but that Torah shelo lishmah, where even though you're learning, you're not zocheh to that light.11:46It's unbelievable, right? Two people learning the same Gemara, same halacha, one gets the or and the other one doesn't. U'meila, eino moreh lo, u'machazeiro l'mutav. And if so, if you're not zocheh to that light, therefore it doesn't guide you, and it doesn't bring you to do good things.12:02V'ein ze shem Torah. You hear that? That's not called Torah itself. Rak hu bichlal petatiya d'oraita. This is what the Yerushalmi brings: words of Torah. That means they're good. Baruch Hashem, the guy is at least osek b'divrei Torah, but it's not actual Torah.12:18That's why when we make a bracha every morning—now this is Ashkenazim; Sefardim don't have this nusach—Ashkenazim saying birchot haTorah in the morning, Baruch atah Hashem, Elokeinu Melech haolam, asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu, we say al divrei Torah. They say, right, they say la'asok b'divrei Torah.12:36But the point that he's about to make, it's the same idea; we just don't have the word la'asok. But why does it say—why do we make the bracha, asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu, al divrei Torah, or la'asok b'divrei, on the words of the Torah? Why don't we say,12:53asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu, al Torah? Why divrei Torah? He says, d'man d'safin u'man rakia lihyot batuach sheya'asok bah. Who can guarantee that we are actually osek in the actual Torah, not just the words of Torah? Remember, like we said, the words of Torah could also be shelo l'shem Shamayim. Who could guarantee that what I'm learning is really l'shem Shamayim? How do I really know what's in the depth of my heart?13:12We all may fool ourselves and think that we are learning l'shem Shamayim. Of course, why else would I be learning? But who could guarantee it? Like, hakol panim b'divrei Torah, but it doesn't take away from the fact that it is divrei Torah, and that's why we say the bracha al divrei Torah, or la'asok b'divrei Torah. U'ptatiya d'oraita she'otam ha'diburim hem Torah b'makom acher. And these are words of Torah. They are considered words of Torah somewhere else. It's not the actual Torah, but it's words of13:43Torah. Then he goes on to explain the beracha on the Torah. He says, ודבר זה הוא גם כן מצוה, וברך הקב״ה ... מצוותיו. And don't think that just because you're learning Torah shelo lishmah, I'm not keeping mitzvah. No, you are doing a mitzvah. Even the guy who's not learning l'shem shamayim. And that's why it deserves a beracha as well. And we say, שקדשנו במצוותיו, שמכניס קדושה בלב כל כחול המצוות. It does give also some sort of kedusha. It's not the light of the Torah. It's not the one that we spoke about, but it does have some sort of kedusha as well.14:08ונלמד מציווי בדברתם, and we can learn this with Chazal explain on the words in the Torah, בדברתם, speak in them. Chazal said, ולא בדברים בטלים. Speak in Torah and not nonsense things. At least a guy who's עוסק בדברי תורה, the real Torah, he's זוכה to the or. And even the guy who's just doing a שלא לשמה, at least he's learning, saying the words of the Torah.14:33At least he's מקיים what Chazal say, ולא בדברים אחרים. You see that there's some sort of mitzvah to just say the words of Torah.14:45Even to avoid talking about non-Torah things. If you learn Torah only to avoid talking about non-Torah things, that's also good enough.14:55And that's why right after this beracha of אשר קדשנו ... בדברי תורה, or לעסוק בדברי תורה, right away we ask Hashem, והערב נא את דברי תורתך, please Hashem make Your words pleasant.15:11Then we ask Hashem, please make our toil in Torah, our involvement in Torah, make it that it should be l'shem shamayim.15:23How? על ידי עריבות מתוק שדברי תורה תהיה בפינו. We may come in and just say divrei Torah. We may come to class because there's other people coming to class. We may come because there's a good15:28food. We may come because we just want to learn information to show how smart we are. We may come just because to make our wives happy or to make our kids happy.15:35Or we may come just because I enjoy just the, you know, the stimulating arguments of the Gemara. And not really because I want to keep what you are telling me to15:45keep, or maybe just to prove my point, right? I don't know. There's a lot of shelo l'shem shamayim.15:51But, but we ask Hashem that even those shelo l'shem shamayim, which is the dibrei Torah, make it pleasant, b'finu v'idgaber.16:00And make it so desirable,16:06that we should reach the point of learning your actual Torah.16:10Look at the words.16:12Hashem, make your words pleasant in our mouth,16:17right?16:25And we should learn your Torah.16:28Don't say, we want from—we are going to make a bracha of divrei Torah,16:34because we don't know if we're really16:35l'shem Shamayim. We really don't know,16:36real deep down.16:38But we ask that we should make it so pleasurable,16:40so enjoyable, that we should learn Torah,16:43that we should be zocheh to be learning Torah.16:50From the lo lishma, perhaps we could come to16:53lishma. And that's the berachah every day.16:54We first make a16:56bracha just even on the words of Torah,16:58and we pray17:00that we should be zocheh to learn Torah17:02lishma, to get to that light that guides us.