Torah · MussarMussar58. Are Accidents Really Accidents?Tzidkat HaTzadikPart 58Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 12, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:05Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat haTzadik, ot nun chet. Another one of those deep ideas from Rav Tzadok. Let's begin.0:07Bedavar sheha'adam naki mimenu ve'eino shum negi'ah veta'avah. In an area that a person is clean. Clean means one thousand percent clean.0:18Clean means like the plate when you go to a restaurant and you get it and you sit down to be served, and they put a plate in front of you.0:25Imagine you look down and you see some residue on it. What would you do? You give it right back.0:31Clean has to be one hundred percent without anything. We're talking about a person who's clean from aveirot over here. We're talking about that clean.0:39Clean one hundred percent. He's clean from the aveirah. He's clean from that ta'avah. He doesn't have any desire to it.0:46In that area, whatever that area may be, and we know there's a lot of areas in the mitzvot of HaKadosh Baruch Hu0:53in the olam that a person can make himself clean in,0:56nikra tzadik l'oto davar. You're called a tzadik just for that thing. He proves it in the brackets.1:01He brings proof from the Rashba in the opposite way. We find what seems to be a contradiction in the Gemarot.1:10The Gemara in Masechet Niddah says that the Gemalim, the people who used to travel and ride camels, that was their business.1:17They would travel on camels and they'd either carry merchandise or travel place to place riding camels.1:22The Gemara calls them kulam resha'im. Yet in the Gemara Masechet Kiddushin, it says that the majority of the camel riders are1:30kesherim. What's going on? So the Rashba explains that in the area where there are not such good people, they're called1:39resha'im. And in an area where it doesn't affect that specific aveirah, so they're called1:45kesherim, meaning to say one has nothing to do with the other. You're not defined as a rasha for everything, and you're not a tzadik for everything.1:51You can be a tzadik in one specific thing. So if a person is clean from a certain aveirah, he's very, very clean from it.1:59All the way, let's say in kashrut. Guy is very, very careful in kashrut, and then he will be called a tzaddik in kashrut.2:07He may not be a tzaddik when it comes to Hilchot Shabbat, may not be a tzaddik when it comes to Hilchot Lashon Hara, or watching his eyes,2:15but he's a tzaddik in kashrut. You could be called a tzaddik for that thing.2:20What's the difference now if you call him a tzaddik, you don't call him a tzaddik, because it's just a title,2:25like when you get to shamayim, you get a certificate, You're a tzaddik. And the answer is no.2:34לעניין שעליו הכתוב אומר, לא יאונה לצדיק כל און. There will be no mistake or problem that will happen to a tzaddik. That's a pasuk in2:43Mishlei, perek yud-bet, pasuk chaf-alef. Let me read you the full pasuk:2:48לא יאונה לצדיק כל און, ורשעים מלאו רע. For a tzaddik, there's no problems. Avon from the word on, there's no problems, as the Gra explains, even במחשבה, בדיבור, מעשה, there's never a problem. It will never happen.3:01And Chazal used that all the time when tzaddikim were saved from certain mistakes or averot,3:10the Gemara would say, those rabbis, those amoraim or tannaim would say about themselves, לא יאונה לצדיק כל און. Look how Hashem protected me.3:18That's what it means that you get the certificate of a tzaddik3:21in a certain mitzvah. If you're naki, if you're clean in certain averah, you will not get a mistake. You won't even do the averah by mistake.3:31ולכך, he says, that's why we find, השוגג נקרא חוטא. Even an averah a person does by accident, he's called a sinner,3:40וצריך כפרה, and he needs to bring a korban for it. Why? What do you want from me? I didn't do it.3:46It was a mistake. I understand the guy who does the aveirah on purpose,3:50okay. But the guy, he was tzaddik. He was very careful in eating kashrut, and all of a sudden he ate food by somebody's house,3:58and it was chelev. And the chelev is asur d'Oraita, but it was by mistake. He didn't realize it was4:03shogeg; it's not his fault. But he did it, and therefore he has to bring a korban.4:07Why is that so? Why does he need a kaparah? Somebody just asked me yesterday,4:11Abba, I didn't want my kids, sorry, Abba, if let's say the shochet doesn't do a good thing and we eat that food,4:18do we get an aveirah? So, you know, it's hard. How do you explain that to the kid?4:22You know, look, we're obviously somech on the takkanah kashrut, but it could be they made a mistake.4:27What if they make a mistake? Who gets aveirah? I don't know who gets aveirah or not.4:30At the end of the day, we ate non-kosher, and it has an effect on our4:33neshama. And if it would have been something that's chayav karet, we would have to bring a korban.4:38The question is why? What did we do wrong? We followed procedure, right?4:42We followed protocol. We followed the things.4:44The answer is that you still see the guy who doesn't mistake, there's something wrong over here.4:49Sheme'achar, he explains why:4:54Sheme'achar sheElokim mina leyado, hu le'ot ki adayin einenu naki. The fact that this happened to me, it's a sign I'm not 100% clean.4:59If I'll be 100% clean, the pasuk says,5:02Lo ye'uneh la tzaddik kol aven. Tzaddik will never ever have such a mistake.5:05If you're very careful in the area, yes, you will not have such a mistake.5:08I want to tell you a short story.5:11It happened to a bachur many years ago. He was, I believe, 16 or 17 years old,5:17and I don't know where he's holding today in this concept,5:21but the concept that when a person is very careful in the area, Hashem protects him wherever he goes.5:27So this guy is a bachur, learned about Beit Yosef,5:29and he got very, very dedicated that I'm not going to eat anything that's not Beit Yosef,5:33very, very makpid, only Beit Yosef.5:35So he goes away to sleepover camp by Ashkenazim.5:38When he gets there, it's all Ashkenazim, maybe 95% Ashkenazi, 5%5:42Sefardim. So he goes to the kitchen. He asks to speak to the cook,5:45and the lady comes out. He says, How can I help you?5:46She says, I'm a Sefardi. Do you have any Beit Yosef?5:49He says, Actually, no, we don't have Beit Yosef.5:51I'm sorry. We're, you know, it's an Ashkenazi camp. We don't eat Beit Yosef.5:54He says, Okay, fine. I'll just have the chicken.5:57He says, No, you know, this rabbi eats it.5:58He says, I know, I'm not saying anything. I'm just, I'm gonna eat only the chicken.6:04Okay. That same day, somebody comes to him. He says, They want you in the kitchen.6:08He says, Me? What do I have to do?6:09He's like, The lady wants to talk to you in the6:11kitchen. He goes to the kitchen, and the lady tells him, Come, I want to show you something.6:16She shows him a box.6:18He's like, What am I looking at?6:19She tells him, Read the label.6:21It says on the label, Beit Yosef.6:23She tells him, In my whole life, we always ordered meat from, you know, a certain butcher,6:30and usually we get the meat that we ordered.6:31We don't make mistakes.6:33This is the first time there was a mistake. They sent us a Beit Yosef box6:37instead of the regular glatt kosher,6:39right? And she recognized it must be for the zechut of this young6:44bachur. If a person's very careful in a certain area,6:46Hashem will make sure to protect him wherever he goes.6:48Now, it was only one box.6:49He told me afterwards that he didn't get more than that.6:52He only ate chicken.6:53But again, this doesn't mean every time you go somewhere,6:56Oh, I'm gonna be machmir, and then all of a sudden a box of Beit Yosef is gonna come out,6:59you know what I'm saying?7:00But the idea is that when you're very careful, and we see this all the time,7:04people are very careful in a certain area, Hashem will protect them.7:07There is no such a thing.7:09The pasuk says it,7:11Lo yuneh tzaddik kol aven. You want to get that certificate to be called a tzaddik in a certain area,7:15you have to be 100% clean.7:16And if you did make a mistake,7:19and if you see there's a stumbling block that happened7:21by accident, somebody served you the food that was not,7:24it's a sign that you're not 100% clean.7:27And he's going to give you now a few proofs.7:28Gemara Masechet Sotah says,7:30we know about the whole procedure of the7:33sotah. A person's wife is suspected that she might be with somebody else.7:37So after a whole procedure,7:39she's brought to the7:40Beit HaMikdash and she's given special waters to drink.7:42But the Gemara says it is a condition.7:45The waters don't necessarily have an effect on the lady,7:48because there's a condition. The Gemara says,7:54Bizman she'ein ha'ish minukeh me'avon, ein ha'mayim bodkin ishto. The condition is the husband.7:55If the husband himself is not clean from this sin,7:58if the husband himself is also...8:00Not faithful in the relationship. He's sleeping around also. It could be with other eshes ish or stam other women,8:05and he is not really careful. And the Gemara says, I believe even more than that, even the family is also not careful.8:11And guess what happens? The waters will not have an effect. They will not test his wife.8:16Interesting, no? Why? Says the Psak, you know why?8:23Because it's coming to protect him.8:26The whole idea of the waters of the sotah, they have an effect on the wife, is to protect the man from sin.8:35What does that mean? There's an issur de'oraita for a man to be with his wife if she is not faithful to him.8:44That's in the cleanest terms I could say it.8:46A lady that's not faithful, it's asur for her husband to be with her.8:49When a person suspects that his wife is not faithful, and why is he taking her to8:54beit din? He doesn't want to do a sin.8:55Hashem wants a woman that he's forbidden to be with,8:57so he brings her to beit din to see if she's really kosher or she's not kosher.9:00But you yourself are not careful of that sin.9:04If you cared so much about the sin, then you yourself would be careful.9:07You wouldn't be schmoozing with married ladies, and you wouldn't be hanging out with married ladies,9:11you wouldn't be doing these things with married ladies.9:12So why all of a sudden you're bringing your wife?9:16That's a sign that you're not so clean.9:17But when you're clean, Hashem will make sure to protect you as well,9:20that your wife also will see if she's clean or not.9:25Okay, another proof.9:27We find a drashah from Chazal, the Rashi brings in9:31Hoshea. It's a famous haftarah that we say:9:33Shuvu banim, shuvu Yisrael, ki kashalta9:36ba'avonecha. The pasuk says, Come back, the Jewish people,9:40ki kashalta.9:41What's kashalta?9:43Kashalta means,9:44the Mefarshim explain, which means a stumbling block.9:46You stumbled. You tripped over your sin.9:49You stumbled. You tripped. That refers to what?9:51An accident.9:53Kashalta b'avonecha sounds like you did an aveirah by accident.9:57So it says the Rashi over there,9:58Ba'u lecha michsholim ba'avonecha. You know why you stumbled?10:03Because you have sins.10:05The regular way that we understood is that, yeah, you made mistakes in life.10:09You made mistakes in Torah, come do teshuvah.10:12No.10:14You only got the mistakes because you're a sinner.10:17You did these10:19aveirot. You had the choice to be careful from the aveirot, and you weren't,10:23and therefore Hashem brought upon you other sins as well.10:26And he says,10:30Not only that,10:34from the mistakes that we make,10:36we could actually discover the things deep down in us that we're not so careful with.10:44So when you, next time it happens and something happens and it's an accident, it's a mistake,10:49understand that there's no mistakes.10:50There are no accidents.10:52You may not be a rasha.10:54Hashem's not telling you that you're a rasha and you did it on purpose like other people,10:59but it's a way for you to discover what's really deep down.11:04Hey, why did this happen to me?11:06Why did such a mistake happen to me?11:08It doesn't say in the pasuk,11:12Lo ineh la tzaddik kol aven. Must be I'm not a tzaddik. From this mistake, I could see I got to look deeper into a certain area.11:18And not only that, we find another place in the Midrash about Lot.11:21We know that Lot, the last thing the Torah tells us about Lot is that he went with his daughters.11:27And amazing,11:28the rabbis say,11:32Kol mi shelahut acharei zenut, sofo ochel oto davar. If a person runs after, you know, zenut, basically,11:39Hashem will feed him zenut at the end.11:41Lot was a person who was very into11:45zenut, and that's why at the end he ended up with his own daughters,11:47certainly something that Lot may not have wanted.11:51But Chazal tell us that since it's there in the depth of his heart,11:55that's what he really11:56wanted—not his daughters,11:57but he wanted this kind of12:00thing—so he got this kind of thing.12:01He got it with his daughters,12:02even though it was by accident. He got drunk12:04and they forced him in a way.12:06No, no accident,12:08rabotai. It happens because there's something there.12:12ולפעמים הם מקרים במכוונה. This is a deep thing that we started saying in the beginning.12:16Sometimes the accidents are actually on purpose from HaKadosh Baruch Hu.12:21Why should I be held accountable?12:23No, Hashem sends you these mistakes12:29כדי לעוררו על ידי כן שישוב על אותו דבר. No, to rouse you that you got to fix this area.12:32He gives you the mistakes that you should say,12:35Hey, oh my gosh, why did this happen to me?12:37and fix your ways.12:38And this way, it's like a wake-up call from Shamayim.12:42The accidents could also be wake-up calls.12:45So we learn from here two things.12:46Number one is that the accidents that happen show us that we're not 100% clean.12:51And number two is sometimes the accidents are from Hashem directly to tell us,12:58Come on, fix this area.13:00There's something dirty over here.13:01Fix it up.