Torah · MussarMussar55. Forgetfulness Comes From the HeartTzidkat HaTzadikPart 55Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 6, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0010:53Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat HaTzadik, ot nun hei. One of those, another pieces of Rav Tzadok, where just when you think you understood something, he shows you that really our understanding is not exactly accurate.0:16So let's begin with a concept. He says, Ikar haaveirot ba'im machamat hashichachah. He says, no, the main reason why people sin is because they forget.0:28You might say, Oh, what are you talking about? A lot of people sin even though they don't forget. We're going to see, actually, it's forgetfulness. We don't have a correct definition of what it means to0:36forget. He says, shehu balev. There's two parts in our minds, in our bodies, where I guess you could say that's where memory is. There's the mind, the moach, and then there's the heart, which is the0:53lev. So when we're talking about the concept of forgetting, you might think that, hey, it's talking about the moach, the brain. That's where you store information. That's where information is stored,1:03and if you forget something, it means in your mind it wasn't there. Rav Tzadok is going to be mechadesh in this piece that really forgetfulness, shichachah, is actually mainly from the heart, not from the mind.1:16That's what he's going to prove. It's not the mind; it's actually from the heart. And he says, the ikar shichachah is in the1:25lev, כדאיתא במגילה, like it says in Masechet Megillah, daf yud-chet amud aleph. What does it say in the Gemara over there? The Gemara says over there, regarding the chiyuv of reading the Megillah.1:36So just to read you the Gemara, the Gemara says that, והימים האלה נזכרים, and these days, referring to the days of Purim, are nizkarim.1:46And the Gemara wants to prove that that's talking about reading. The Gemara says, we're going to learn it as a gezeirah shavah, and that you have to read it from a book, as it says by the war of Amalek,1:55Hashem commands Moshe, כתוב זאת זכרון בספר, write this as a memory in the sefer. And the Gemara learns from here that the gzeirah shavah teaches us that just like Hashem commanded to record the incident of Amalek in the sefer, so too the Megillah has to be written in a sefer.2:12Mases, one second, who says that zechirah means keri'ah? When it says, ha-yamim ha-eleh nizkarim, who says it's referring to the reading of the Megillah? Maybe it means just to think about it. Mases, lo sagadachi, you can't say that. Why?2:25Pasuk says by parashat Ki Teitzei, when it's talking about the mechiyat Amalek, of eradicating the mitzvah of, you know, that we read parashat Zachor, when we talk about getting rid of Amalek, it says, Zachor et asher asah lecha Amalek.2:42And the Gemara says the following words. Listen to this. Zachor, yachol balev. Gemara says you might think zachor, just remember in your heart. Comes the Torah and says, lo tishkach, don't forget. Harei shechat ha-lev amur.2:56So you see that there's already the Torah is telling you about don't forget. So what does it mean, zachor? It means you have to say it. So you see, just like parashat Zachor in the Torah has to be expressed and read, so too when it says, ha-yamim ha-eleh nizkarim, it means it has to be read.3:13But what's interesting from the Gemara is, when it talks about forgetfulness, don't forget, it doesn't say don't forget plain. It says don't forget from the heart. So you see that the ikar shechachah, that forgetfulness is not from the mind, it's actually from the heart.3:27Now what does that mean to us? And he explains. He says, she'afilu zocheh ba-moach, even if a person would remember in his mind, makom makom eino zocheh ba-lev, if he doesn't have it in his heart, he doesn't remember it in the heart, ki'ilu haya be'emet zocheh bahargashat ha-lev. Heart means he's feeling it.3:44It's not just an idea that he understands and he knows, but he actually feels it. If a person would really feel it, sheHashem yitbarach tzivah al zeh, that Hashem commanded him on this particular mitzvah to do it, or on a certain aveirah not to do it, lo ta'aseh ken, אי אפשר כלל שיעשה. It would be impossible for a person to really do it.4:05When you feel that's really asur, you can't do the issur. However. We do end up doing aveirot. Why is that so? The answer is because what the yetzer hara does is that he takes away the feelings. If you know about it in your mind, but you don't feel it, that's called forgetfulness, and that's why you end up doing4:26aveirot. And how does the yetzer hara work? How do you see the yetzer hara does that? Kanyan, actually, I know, like it says in Parashat Ha'azinu, Torah says, Shamanta, avita, kasita. You got fat, you got thick, and you became foolish,4:41v'tishkach El mecholelcha, and you forgot HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Meaning, of course you know that there's HaKadosh Baruch Hu in the mind, though, but you don't feel it. The thickness of the ta'avot that the yetzer hara makes your heart thick, or makes your feelings thick, that it doesn't allow that information to penetrate to your heart. That makes you forget it.5:03And he brings another proof. Teda, shemitzvat tzitzit hi lizkor al yado mitzvot Hashem. The Gemara tells us, the Torah tells us, excuse me, we just had it in Parashat Shelach, that the mitzvah of tzitzit is to remember the mitzvot of Hashem. Like it says, U're'item oto u'zchartem et kol mitzvot Hashem. You should see the tzitzit strings, and it should remind you of the mitzvot Hashem.5:24Good? So we know that the tzitzit is supposed to remind you. You look at your strings, and it's supposed to remind you of the mitzvot. Yet Chazal tell us a very interesting story, Masechet Menachot daf mem-daled amud aleph. Some of you guys may be familiar with this story, but we'll repeat this story for those who are not familiar.5:38It's talking about a talmid in a yeshiva that had this crazy ta'avah for a certain zonah in the far end of the world, and he paid top dollar to get to her. And he gets to the place, and he was wearing tzitzit, and he was—this is a guy who was very careful with the mitzvah of tzitzit, by the way, the Gemara points it out. He was very, very careful with the mitzvah of tzitzit,5:58and he gets to— She had like seven beds to climb on until you get to her. So he climbs to the seventh bed, and as he's undressing, the strings kind of whip him and brings him back to, you know, to remind him basically, hey, you know, you're a Jew, basically. So when the tzitzit strings whip him, he all of a sudden says, Oh, I can't do this. He controls himself. He stops what he's doing, and he doesn't commit6:25the aveirah. From that story, you see something very interesting. Was the guy knowledgeable of the aveirah that he's about to do? Did he know that he's about to do an aveirah, or did he forget? Of course he knew. But the mitzvah tzitzit is supposed to remind you, so he didn't forget, and it says, yeah, he did. When you don't feel it, that's called forgetting. Although he knew in his mind that this is an aveirah, what he's about to do, what changed? He saw the tzitzit, and the answer is he just felt it.6:52So the mitzvah, again, it's another proof that forgetting and remembering is not in the mind; it's in the heart. And just because a person knows in his mind doesn't mean he's going to actually keep something, because if it's not felt, it means it's forgotten.7:11Next, v'chein amru hakadmonim, and this is what the earlier mefarshim said. The Torah also, back to the mitzvah of tzitzit, the Torah tells us in the end of Parashat Shelach about the commandment of having tzitzit, and there's a reason why it's mentioned there. Why? Because right before that, the Torah talks about this person, according to some opinions, was Tzelofchad, who went on Shabbat and he piled up wood.7:35He was known as mekoshesh etzim, and the Torah tells us that he was chayav mitah. They warned him, It's Shabbat, stop what you're doing. He did it anyway. He was doing it b'mezid, and that's why he was chayav mitah. He was chayav sekilah. In fact, he actually gets stoned at the end of the day. And why does the Torah put Parashat tzitzit right after mekoshesh7:55etzim? The kadmonim, the mefarshim, explain because—8:00This guy needed a reminder of Shabbat. And since usually every single day a person has8:09tefillin to remind him, on Shabbat he doesn't have tefillin. We don't wear tefillin on Shabbat,8:14so he needs something to remind him.8:16So therefore, Hashem brings a mezuzah, tzitzit over here to teach you that if you wear the8:20mezuzah, tzitzit, and you have it on you even on Shabbat, it will remind you of all the8:25mitzvot, like it says, ... kol mitzvot Hashem. And then it will be easy for this guy to remember Shabbat, and he won't8:32come to be mechalel Shabbat.8:33Says Rav Tzadok, one second.8:36It says, sorry, the reason why Parashat Tzitzit is next to Mikoshesh Etzim is that he should8:49not forget that Shabbat.8:50What are you talking about?8:52V'harei Mikoshesh mezid haya. The Mikoshesh Etzim was a mezid.8:55He wasn't a person who forgot.8:56He knew that it was Shabbat.8:57They warned him it was Shabbat.8:58He still did it anyway.9:00Ah, the answer is yes, he remembered, but in his mind, but he didn't remember in his9:05heart.9:05And if you don't remember in your heart, that's called forgetfulness.9:09That's not where the memory is.9:10True memory is in the heart, when you feel it, not just when it's in your mind.9:15Another proof from the Gemara Masechet Nedarim. The Gemara says over there on the9:26pasuk, Nishbati va'akayema, right? David HaMelech says, I swore and I kept your mitzvot. And the Gemara learns from there,9:29Nishba'im l'kayem ha-mitzvot. A person is allowed to swear in order to keep the9:33mitzvot. Usually we have a shevuah called shevuat shav, an unnecessary9:37shevuah. A person who says that the sky is above us, and he swears that the sky is above us, it's9:43called a shevuat shav.9:44It's9:45an issur d'oraita. It's an unnecessary9:47shevuah. Everybody knows that the sky is above us.9:49So the Gemara says a person is allowed to swear to9:53be mekayem mitzvot. A person feels that he needs a little incentive or a little push to keep the9:58mitzvot. He says, I swear I'm going to put on tefillin tomorrow.10:01So the question is, how could that be?10:04Don't we know that10:06already we stood by Har Sinai and we all stood and we swore, as the Gemara says multiple times,10:12Mushba v'omed meHar Sinai.10:14You already swore by Har Sinai,10:15so how can you swear again?10:17So he says, V'af al gav d'mushba v'omed meHar Sinai,10:21lezeruzei nafshei. You're allowed to swear in order to inspire yourself to do10:28mitzvot. U'ma zeruz hu? asks Rav Tzadok. What's10:30the zeruz by you swearing?10:31And the answer is,10:32it's because when you swear, you make it more real.10:36You take it from the mind to the heart, and you won't forget it.10:39So forgetfulness is really in the heart.10:41So that's where the source of all sins.10:44Yes, people who sin forget.10:46Ah, but they know.10:47They don't feel it.10:48And if they don't feel it in the heart, that's called forgetfulness.