Torah · MussarMussar46. Don’t Let Anyone Tell You to “Get Out”Tzidkat HaTzadikPart 46Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 29, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:42Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat haTzadik, ot0:02mem-vav. In this note is a very, very interesting understanding and deeper idea,0:09and I'm sure by now you've seen some things that,0:14you know, not necessarily are commonly spoken about or thought about,0:19but that's the beauty of the sefer,0:22some very interesting ways of looking at things,0:25and that's a side of0:27a tzidkat haTzadik. And listen to this one, it's very, very interesting.0:30It's a deep idea.0:33Again, when we say it's a deep idea,0:35you need to think about it a little bit more, listen to it well,0:39perhaps even look at the book together as you listen to the recording,0:41because a lot of the things he quotes are some words here and there,0:45and then if you have your own rabbi, discuss it with him,0:47how to understand it. This is a beautiful idea.0:50There's a pasuk,0:51in Tehillim, perek nun, pasuk0:52tezayin. The pasuk says,0:57Larasha amar Elokim, mah lecha lesaper chukai. To the wicked person, Hashem says,1:01What in the world are you doing speaking of My laws?1:04Meaning to say, don't speak of My Torah.1:06Get out of here. You're talking about My Torah?1:09Sometimes we personally feel that way when we see a rasha1:13learning Torah. You learning Torah?1:14You just came back from the club, you're coming to a class, right?1:17So, pashut pshat, Hashem is even saying that.1:20Hashem is saying that to the person, right,1:24is,1:26mah lecha lesaper chukai. Why in the world are you speaking My words?1:31Now, says the Radak, side point,1:33he says,1:37Vahadavar ze yidvu hadavim. Ah, we all have to feel terrible about this. Why?1:40Because who's a rasha?1:42Well, Chazal tell us,1:45ki haover al daat sofrim nikra rasha. A person goes against the words of the1:48Rabbanan, of what the Chachamim are metaken, is called a rasha,1:54kemo shamru bYoma, daf chaf, like it says in the Masechet Yoma, daf chaf amud aleph. So now, sounds like horrible.1:57Hashem is telling you, stop learning Torah.1:59A guy might know himself and say, you know,2:01I'm2:02over aveirot. You want me to just not even do anything?2:04A guy even come to class?2:05Hashem is saying,2:09Malach haShem... Says, regarding this person2:12who wants to become better, actually,2:14Chazal tell us the following.2:16What do they say?2:23Kol ma she'omar baal habayit aseh, chutz mi... Whatever the boss or the owner of the house tells you,2:27if you're a guest by somebody's house,2:30whatever the host tells you,2:32you have to do, except for one thing.2:34If he tells you to get out,2:35you don't have to get out,2:36believe it or not.2:36What do you mean?2:37He's kicking me out of his house.2:38You don't have to.2:39You don't have to listen to him.2:41But everything else2:44that's minhag, you do like minhag hamakom. If he tells you do this, do that,2:45even if it's not your derech, you do it.2:48Of course, we're not talking about issurim over here.2:50But if he tells you to leave,2:51even if it's also not2:52an issur, you don't have to leave.2:54What does that mean now?2:56So that means2:58this is—he's trying to apply this also over here.3:01Hashem tells you,3:02don't learn my Torah, get out of here.3:03No, you do it.3:05Like I once heard the famous story of Elisha3:09ben Abuyah, who was a tremendous rabbi.3:11He taught Rabbi Meir Torah.3:12Rabbi Meir used to follow him,3:13even when Elisha3:15ben Abuyah went off the3:16derech. So this great rabbi, Elisha3:20ben Abuyah, he was, what's it called, he got such a high level3:21that he reached a3:22level that only four3:24were zocheh to reach that level:3:25Rabbi Akiva ben Azai,3:28this Elisha3:30ben Abuyah, and the other one is3:33Ben Zoma. So what happened?3:35One person died,3:37couldn't handle what he saw.3:37Another person went crazy,3:39and this Elisha3:41ben Abuyah went off the3:42derech, became a3:43kofer. And only Rabbi Akiva was the only one3:44who came out of there,3:46I guess you could say normal,3:47or he was able to handle what he saw.3:52נכנס בשלום ויצא בשלום. And since ever since then,3:57... to his mechanech, Shabbat before ... he couldn't care less about anything.3:58That's what it seems to4:00be. And one day, Rabbi Meir was learning Torah4:04from this ... Abuha,4:06and he told him in a hintful way,4:08Rebbe, chazor bach, do4:12teshuva. And ... Abuha says,4:13I would, but I've heard that there was a bat kol that said,4:18Shuvu banim4:19shovavim, all those children of mine4:21that went astray,4:22that went, you know, off the path,4:25come back and do4:26teshuva, chutz4:27me'Acher, except for Acher, except for me.4:28I'm not allowed to do4:30teshuva. So what do you want me to do?4:32I can't do4:33teshuva. The doors are stuck by me.4:34At the end of the story,4:36it says, you know, when he died,4:39Rabbi Meir says,4:39When I die, I'm going to make sure4:42I get him, you know, I get him forgiven.4:43When Rabbi Meir passed away,4:45all of a sudden4:47they saw smoke coming out of his4:48kever, which means he got into4:49Gehinom to start getting the cleansing process.4:51When Rabbi Yochanan, when he passed away,4:52he says, I'm going to take care of this also.4:55And when Rabbi Yochanan passed away,4:57they saw that smoke stopped from5:01Rabbi Elisha5:02ben Abuyah's kever, which they knew that he was5:04admitted5:05into Gan Eden. So there was a5:07solid tikun, but he felt that he couldn't do it in this way.5:09Why? Because he heard5:11the bat kol. Once you have a beautiful idea,5:12what do you expect from the rabbi?5:14What do you expect from Elisha5:16ben Abuyah? He heard the voice.5:17How do you expect to do5:19teshuva? So he says,5:22the mashal is, imagine a person is stranded on an island.5:25His boat gets knocked.5:27He's the only survivor,5:28or at least he thinks he's the only survivor.5:29He's on some stranded island.5:31He's starving, cold.5:32He hasn't eaten for a couple of days.5:34He's so weak.5:35There's no food in sight.5:37All of a sudden, he looks in the distance.5:38He sees a house,5:40and smoke is coming out of the house.5:42Looks like something's cooking.5:43He goes to the house.5:44He knocks on the door.5:46The door is open,5:46and he sees a beautiful table set up5:48with food and everything,5:50and all wonderful things.5:52Ah, warm environment.5:53He says, Please, I've been starving three days.5:56I just came, and you see me.5:57What? I just came off the ship.5:58Please, you got to have something to6:00eat. You're the only ones here.6:01And the guy says, No, I'm sorry. Goodbye.6:04Closes the door.6:05What would this guy do?6:05He says, Ah, he doesn't want to let me in.6:07No,6:08you knock, you knock. This is your life depends on this.6:11So true, the guy is not letting you in,6:13but your life depends on this.6:14You're going to do whatever you can to get in there.6:17That was the nisayon of6:18Yonah ben Amittai. He went so off6:20that he needed to be told,6:22Get out of here. We don't want you.6:23And that's the same idea over here.6:28Even if a person gets set up, Hashem says,6:30Get out of here.6:32Don't say6:33my divrei Torah. I don't want you speaking my6:36divrei Torah. Still, we have the rule6:41called, Ma shebaal habayit oseh, chutz mezeh. You listen to whatever the baal habayit tells you to do,6:43except if he tells you to get out of here,6:46and you're going to go.6:47You're going to push even more.6:50And he brings a proof.6:52Ready? What the proof is?6:52Very interesting, something we read recently.6:54In the end of parashat6:56Shelach — not in the end, in the middle of parashat6:58Shelach — after Bnei Yisrael were given the terrible news7:01that they're going to spend the next forty years7:03dying in the desert,7:04the next morning7:05a group of people get up7:07and they say,7:08We want to7:09go into Eretz Yisrael. And Moshe says,7:10Hazak baruch, but it's too late.7:11So, No, no, we're going to go anyway.7:13He says, Don't go.7:14V'lo tatzliach. It's not going to be successful.7:16They go anyway.7:16These were known as people,7:18they were known as the7:20ma'apilim. They went ahead anyway.7:21He says,7:25Why in the world is the7:27Torah mentioning that whole episode?7:29Like, okay, so they wanted to go,7:31they ended up getting killed.7:32What is that coming to teach us?7:36Didn't they believe that Moshe,7:37whatever Moshe told them,7:39took them out of7:40Mitzrayim and everything else,7:40they realized they made a mistake.7:41So now Moshe is telling them,7:42Don't go7:43into Eretz Yisrael. Why are they still going to7:48Eretz Yisrael? So how come over7:50here Moshe told them,7:51Don't go7:51into Eretz Yisrael? One day7:52they listened, were they foolish?7:53They just saw the day before7:54he told them7:55by the7:56Meraglim, Don't listen to the7:57Meraglim. Look what happened.7:57The next day he told them,7:58Don't go into Eretz Yisrael.8:03You know why?8:04Because the ma'apilim thought8:06that this is part of the same thing8:08that you're not supposed to listen to.8:10When you want to do the will of Hashem,8:13and8:14Hashem is telling you, Don't do it,8:16you do it.8:17You go. That's the right thing to do.8:20Again, we're not talking about8:22what it says in the Torah and you want to do8:24because you want to do and Hashem says don't do it.8:25Not like that. You're doing what it says in the8:28Torah, kein derech that says in the Torah,8:31but for certain, under specific circumstances,8:34you were told,8:36Get out of here.8:36You cannot do it.8:38Then that's what the ma'apilim thought.8:40Hashem is pushing us away, but no, we're going to8:42do the right thing. We're going to go into Eretz Yisrael anyway.8:45He brings more.8:49The Zohar brings this whole story8:50of the8:52meraglim, and he connects it to the concept of8:54learning Torah.8:56He says that the8:58punishment was8:59that they will not be able to understand9:01the Torah fully.9:06And that's9:07why they were9:09ma'apilim. They wanted to understand the Torah,9:11even against the will of9:13HaKadosh Baruch Hu.9:15Kemo she'amru zal—now this is chutzpah, right?9:17Think about it. When you do something like,9:19Hello, I told you not to. What are you doing?9:21That's chutzpah.9:25Hazal אמרו זל that chutzpah is9:28מלכותא בלא תגא. Chazal said9:30in Maseches Sanhedrin, the concept of chutzpah is like9:33a government without a crown.9:35What does it mean, a government without a crown?9:36A kingdom without a crown means9:38a crown represents9:40the leader, right?9:43And he's going to explain,9:44actually, why should I say it.9:46It says,9:48פירוש, כידוע, מלכות הוא כנסת ישראל. We know malchut represents9:50Knesset9:52Yisrael. And the crown, which is the keter,9:56hu shoresh retzon Hashem Yitbarach, represents9:57the source of the ratzon of HaKadosh Baruch Hu,9:59those who understand a little bit of Kabbalah.10:04Ratzon lomar, memshalah me'atzmo beli ratzon HaRotzeh. What it means, chutzpah, is that a person10:06who decides to do things on his own10:07without the ratzon of those,10:11of the crown, which is HaKadosh Baruch Hu.10:15Vitkarvut Bnei Yisrael me'atzmam. Here the closest the Bnei Yisrael10:16wanted to get to HaKadosh Baruch Hu10:17was of their own.10:19So that's what the ma'apilim is.10:21They wanted to get close to HaKadosh Baruch Hu10:23even though Hashem said, No, get away from me.10:25Why did they do it? Because they felt that,10:28hey, we have to do it.10:31We don't listen.10:32Hashem is telling us10:33to stay. The rule is, if a baal bayit tells you get out, you don't get out.10:36You don't have to get out.10:37But we see that they10:39were not10:42matzliach. Vim lo hotzlichu bazeh, but they10:44weren't matzliach. Why not?10:47Because10:48they were too premature.10:50As Chazal tell us,10:51that this concept of10:53the baal bayit tells you to get out and you don't get out,10:54it's a little bit of chutzpah, right?10:56But there's a time for chutzpah,10:58and the time has not come yet.11:00When would the chutzpah have its time?11:04Famous Gemara in11:05Masechet Sotah, the last amud,11:08says, In the days of Mashiach,11:09in the heels of Mashiach,11:11that's the last days.11:12That's what's going to happen then.11:14Chutzpah is, as we see11:16nowadays, there'll be a tremendous amount11:18of brazenness, of chutzpah,11:22she'az hu et lezeh. That is the time11:26when the chutzpah,11:28when even if a person feels so distanced11:30from HaKadosh Baruch Hu,11:31you go ahead.11:34And I can be medayek Moshe11:36when he tells the11:38ma'apilim, You guys want to go11:48into Eretz Yisrael? V'hi lo tatzliach. Why did he say11:50v'hi lo tatzliach? He should have said, V'lo tatzlichu. Sounds like11:50that Moshe was telling them,11:52it's a good idea what you're doing, what you're saying,11:54that you're going to go, even though Hashem said11:55you're not going into forty years,11:57you want to go anyway.11:58It's a good idea,11:59but you're not going to be successful.12:02Why not?12:05Vehi, שבכל מקום דרשו זה, הִיא ולא אחרת. Chazal, usually12:06whenever it says the word12:07hi, they tell you it's an emphasis,12:11diyuk, here but not somewhere else.12:15Vehi lo tatzlach. This, that you, the mapilim today,12:17want to go12:19into Eretz Yisrael, this will not be successful.12:24However, sheyezman אחר, shematzliach. Sounds like12:25another time it will be successful.12:26When is that?12:29V'hu zmanenu zeh, sherak bיאת המשיחה. That's what he says 150 years ago.12:30In his days,12:32which is rak bיאת המשיחה, we could say even more today,12:34that we see a tremendous amount of chutzpah.12:37This is12:38when it's going to be matzliach. Yes, even now when a person feels so12:41distant, and you know what?12:42I know great people12:44that when they wanted to enter yeshiva12:46and they were told, This is not for you.12:48You are a little bit too far.12:50You need to go like to more,12:52like, you know, lighter yeshiva12:54that maybe will, you know, be accustomed12:56to your own settings,12:57take it on your own pace.12:59And the person says, No,13:01I want to learn Torah. I want to get closer13:02to Hashem. I want to understand more Torah.13:04And they pushed themselves,13:05and they pushed themselves a little more,13:08and they didn't listen to the person13:09who says, Say, get out of here.13:11And when that other bachur that was kicked out of yeshiva,13:14he could have said, You know, I'm a loser.13:16No. And you heard people say,13:18Nothing good will come out of you.13:19And there are people that did terrible, terrible13:21aveirot, and they messed up very, very badly in their lives,13:23and they caused a tremendous chillul Hashem.13:25And everybody told them, Get out of here.13:28And they went and they did13:29a full13:32teshuva. What's pshat? It's a tremendous amount of chutzpah,13:33and there's Mashiach. And you know what?13:35They were successful at the end.13:37They were zocheh to learn Torah,13:42and they were matzliach in learning Torah in their teshuvah as well.13:44That's the message over here.13:45From13:47HaKadosh Baruch Hu, don't let the people tell you, or anybody tell you,13:49or yetzer hara tell you,13:51Eh, you're good for nothing.13:53Only what's going to come out of you.13:54Look how much you messed up.13:56Chutzpah13:58tisgeh. In the times of the me'apim, they were not13:59matzliach. You can be14:01matzliach. If you get that voice in your head,14:03don't think, even if you think it's a bad call,14:05if it's really a bad call, which is, you know, a little rare that you can get a bad call,14:08but let's say it is a bad call.14:10But still, we have the klal,14:11kol14:14ma she'omer lecha baal habayit, aseh chutz metze. If the baal habayit himself is telling you,14:15Get out, you don't listen to get out.14:17You work hard and you do it.14:19It's not going to be easy.14:21You're going to have to knock and knock and14:23knock to break that door down14:25until he lets you in,14:26and sometimes you may have to force yourself in.14:28But your life depends on this.14:30That's how you have to look at it.14:30Your life depends on this.14:32Of course, you can't go against14:34halacha. You got to go with the14:36halacha. But you're going to fix yourself.14:37You're going to become a good person,14:39and, be'ezrat Hashem, you'll be matzliach.