Torah · MussarMussar43. Difficult נסיונות in LifeTzidkat HaTzadikPart 43Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 23, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:42Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:01Tzedkat HaTzadik, ot mem0:04gimel. Another deep idea by0:07Rav Tzadok, and I'm asking that please don't stop this recording in the0:11middle. Make sure you hear the entire thing from beginning till the end,0:15as with many ideas are very deep.0:17If you cut and paste and you only hear what you want to hear,0:19it could be very dangerous because,0:23you know, it could,0:25chas v'shalom, like we said, sometimes borderline on0:27getting the wrong thoughts when it comes to0:31bitachon, when it comes to0:33bechirah, when it comes to freedom of choice,0:35schar va'ones, and all these other things. Therefore, make sure you hear the entire thing from beginning to end.0:40And I'll tell you a general rule: whenever you hear an idea,0:42you're probably driving or whatever it may be, and you're listening to this,0:46and you hear an idea and you see that,0:49you know, afterwards you're like, Did I understand it right?0:52It doesn't make sense. I always learned not that way,0:54right? So that means you probably—it doesn't make sense.0:57You have to go back and hear it again and hear it well with concentration.1:00Okay, let's read mem gimel.1:08Pa'amim yesh adam omed b'nisayon gadol, kol kach ad she'i efshar lo shelo yecheta. Sometimes a person is confronted with a test1:12that's so, so big.1:14He's being tested in such a difficult test that it's actually1:18impossible that he'll walk out without sinning.1:20He is going to sin 100%.1:22When do we find this? We find Moshe Rabbeinu1:25telling HaKadosh Baruch Hu,1:27when it comes to chet ha'egel, Moshe Rabbeinu1:31tells Hashem, Hey, you know, what do you expect1:34of Klal Yisrael?1:36Kesef1:39vezahav hirbeiti lahem. You gave them so much gold and so much silver when they came out of Mitzrayim.1:43How could it be that they won't sin?1:45And he says, the Gemara brings Masechet Berachot, daf lamed bet over there,1:48brings1:50a mashal. It says, imagine you take a kid, you adorn him beautiful clothing1:54and you put on beautiful fragrances and you put him in the shuk1:58shel zonot. Mah ya'aseh ha-ben shelo yecheta? What do you want the kid to do, that he shouldn't sin?2:01How could that be?2:02So you see there's such a thing.2:04Now, the fact the Gemara that Moshe Rabbeinu sets such an example2:07is that when a person is placed in such a situation, you can't blame him for the sin.2:12It can't be; he just can't stand it.2:20U'vezeh hu nechshav ones gamur. This is what's called2:21ones gamur, de'Rachmana patrei. Hashem will be poter such a person from a punishment2:25of the sin.2:30V'gam b'hastatat hayetzer b'tokef atzum. This is not only2:32if a person has such a difficult test2:35that he can't stand,2:36but also sometimes the yetzer hara comes2:40to deceive the person.2:42He plays with him and he tries to convince him something.2:44Sometimes the yetzer hara is so strong2:48she'efshar l'natzcho, when it's impossible to defeat him,2:51that's also sheyach ones. That's also considered2:59ones. V'im Hashem3:01yitbarach hesib et libo, harei ein chetzei chet klal, kemo rak sheratzon Hashem yitbarach hayah kach. If3:02it was Hashem who turned his heart, like we see Chazal telling us3:04in a few areas where we see great tzaddikim of the3:08Tanach, like Yehuda and Tamar,3:10right? And how could that be not a sin,3:13and over there from there comes Mashiach? Because if the fact that Hashem controlled it,3:16then that's what Hashem wanted that should happen.3:20Vayema she'amru. And to get an idea of this,3:22we find a very interesting3:25halacha in Masechet Ketubot. So the halacha is like this,3:29a little background to the3:31halacha before we get to read the Gemara. The halacha is that3:34everybody besides a kohen3:37who is married to a woman, a woman has to be faithful to her husband.3:40If the woman is not faithful to her husband,3:42and we call in lashon la'az in the modern day,3:45she's cheating on her husband, she goes with a different man3:48while she was still married to her husband, obviously,3:51then that lady becomes what we call a3:54sotah de'oraita, and she's forbidden on her husband.3:55However, in the rules of sotah, the pasuk says,4:00V'hi lo nitpasa. She was not held down,4:02which means the only reason why she becomes a4:05sotah is because she was not held down. What does it mean, not held down?4:06She was not forced, basically.4:09Nitpasa means held down, literally, but it means forced.4:11We learn from here that a lady who was forced,4:15or in the words of the Gemara, ne'ensa, or in our language is raped,4:20a wife that has been4:22raped does not become a sotah to her husband again,4:24excluding a kohen for different reasons,4:26but not a kohen. Everybody else who is not a kohen,4:28Levi, Yisrael, obviously everybody else in that category4:31in Masechet Kiddushin, in any case, in those people,4:34if their wives get raped, they're still permitted to their husband.4:39Why? That's called4:40ones. She was ones, and the rule of4:44Rachmana, excuse me,4:47ones Rachmana patrei. If it's ones, Hashem is poter, will definitely apply over here,4:49as long as she's not participating.4:51In the words of the Gemara, it's karka olam.4:52In fact, we find that such a thing happened to Esther.4:55Esther was originally married to4:58Mordechai, and she was taken by Achashverosh against her will,5:00and she was still considered the wife of5:05Mordechai. What do you mean? Her husband was with her the whole time.5:08The answer is no. She was karka olam. She was being raped. She5:11was not in her will.5:12That's the difference between ones and ratzon, two opposite things.5:15Ones is against a person's will.5:18Ratzon is a person's will.5:21Only when Esther decided that she's going to visit5:24Achashverosh and she initiated the, you know, getting together,5:27that's when she tells5:31Mordechai, Ka'asher avadti, avadti, just like I lost my parents when I was young,5:33I'm going to lose the remaining of my family, which is you,5:36Mordechai, because now I'm going voluntarily to5:39Achashverosh. At that point, she couldn't be his wife anymore.5:42So that is the din of ones versus ratzon.5:47The Gemara asks the5:48question: What would be the case of5:52techlato b'ones and sofo5:54b'ratzon? What does that mean? A woman is raped,5:56and she hates it. Ew, get off, get off, get off.5:59A woman that's married, obviously, is raped.6:01But in the middle, all of a sudden she likes it. She's enjoying it,6:06right? Not only she's enjoying it, says the Gemara,6:09techlato b'ones, if a woman started getting raped,6:12but in the middle,6:14as somebody comes to pull away this guy from her,6:22v'sovachat, right, and she yells afterwards,6:23No, leave him alone. I would hire him6:27now. I'll pay him to continue.6:28So clearly she wants it.6:30What's the din in that case? Says the Gemara,6:37muteret leba'ala. Techlato b'ones v'sofo b'ratzon, muteret leba'ala. If it started b'ones, she didn't want it at all.6:40Now she's sketching herself, right? But she didn't want it at all.6:42In the middle, she started, you know, enjoying it. She wants it.6:46Still she's6:49muteret leba'ala. Mai ta'ama? Says the Gemara, okay, what's the reason? What's the pshat over here?6:51Ratzon is sotah. What's going on?6:54The Gemara answers,6:58yetzer albesha. The yetzer took over her.7:02The yetzer took over her. It was not in her control.7:03What is Rav Tzadok trying to bring out from this Gemara?7:05Says7:09Rav Tzadok, harei deze mechshav ones gamur, af al pi shehu meratzonah. You see, this is called ones, even though she wants it.7:13Mikol makom, but still, it didn't happen that7:16way.7:18Yetzer gadol kazeh. Being that she was put in such a situation against her will,7:20she didn't want it from the beginning.7:23She only wanted it afterwards. But you see that when the yetzer hara takes over,7:27yefshar b'adam l'kufo, there's a point that you see the person has no power7:29against the7:32yetzer hara, and there, v'hu ones gamur. In such a case, it's considered a complete7:36ones, ve'ein bozeh onesh, and there's no punishment for such an act.7:39Af d'asa issur, even though he didn't actually7:42issur, kivan d'haya onus, but that's what we call7:44an onus. So we always understood that onus, it means it happened by accident.7:47I was forced into it, somebody put a gun to my head.7:50Yes, that's certainly7:52ones. The chiddush of Rav Tzadok over here7:54is that even if the yetzer hara is so strong that a person, in a way, has no choice.8:00But to listen to the yetzer hara, that's also called ones, and it's not something that's considered punishable.8:08However, this is the main line of the whole thing. You cannot miss this line. I'm reading you the words of Rav Tzadok. He says,8:19Aval ha'adam atzmo ein yachol leha'in al atzmo b'zeh. But a person can't say that I was anus. You can't say,8:24listen, the yetzer hara came, I had no choice but to listen to him. You can never be8:30a valid witness to such a thing.8:34Maybe you did have the ability to overcome8:38the yetzer hara. You just didn't try hard enough, as we all know. So now are we justifying every rasha? The answer is no,8:45not at all.8:46You can never know. It's after 120 that Hashem could tell the person, Don't worry, that was way beyond you.8:53Now we know a person doesn't get a test unless, you know, what happened to the rule of you don't get a test8:59unless you're, what do you call it,9:02unless you're able to defeat the yetzer hara, because otherwise how can He give you? And the answer is true.9:07But again, like we find some cases in Tanach, like Yehuda and Tamar, like the case we gave beforehand,9:13where they were put in such a situation, not because he asked for it, like David and9:16Bat Sheva. David and Bat Sheva was a problem. There he was put in the situation.9:20He asked to be put in such a situation, unlike Yehuda and Tamar, that he was forced into it.9:25There,9:26by9:27Yehuda and Tamar, Hashem put him in a difficult situation9:31that he couldn't get out of it. In the words of Chazal, the malach had to push him,9:36kibyachol. So if a person falls in the hands of the yetzer hara, you have to do9:41teshuva, and you have to maybe work harder to work on it. Is it possible that maybe he was completely honest? Possible,9:47but we can never know. We can never test on it. He brings over here an idea.9:51He says, At the end,9:54kemo sheshamati b'zeh me'inyan Zimri sheta'ah bazeh. He said, I heard that was a mistake also of Zimri.10:00Zimri, as we know, the one in the end of Parashat Balak, that's where he made this mistake as well.10:06He felt that he was anus completely. He had to save his people,10:09and his mistake was that it was beyond his control. Therefore, it wouldn't be a sin to be with Kozbi10:16bat Tzur. But that was his mistake.10:18He could have overcome his10:21yetzer hara, but he felt, on his level—he was 200 years old, and he was much10:26older—and he felt that if I'm being pushed, it's old min hashamayim, and that's not true.10:29He made this mistake. So you see, somebody even as great as Zimri can make such a devastating mistake.10:35And therefore, we cannot say, Oh, the yetzer hara is too big; it must be this is Hashem's10:39will. Not at all,10:41chas v'shalom. But the concept exists. The concept of something sometimes being out of a person's control, that he's anus, exists.10:49Maybe we can be melamed zechut on other people. We cannot apply it to ourselves,10:54but maybe when we see other people, we can be melamed zechut. Who knows? You know, maybe it's beyond his will.10:59He's totally addicted. He's gone. Maybe he put himself in such a situation also,11:03true, but to be melamed zechut, we can use that.11:05But for us, we have to be realistic with ourselves.11:08I don't know. Maybe I could have pushed myself a little bit more.11:10Maybe I could have prevented myself from being in such circumstances that brought me to the sin that the yetzer hara got me.11:16That would be my fault. In the case of Esther,11:18she was invited by Achashverosh. It wasn't considered her will; it was11:25ones. When she went to Achashverosh, even though the actual ones happened that night, that evening,11:31it's still called ones. It's not called ones; it's called ratzon.11:33So you see, if you put yourself also in this situation, which is going to lead the yetzer hara to get you,11:38you can't say that's ones. That already becomes ratzon.