Torah · MussarMussar40. When עבירות Turn Into מצוותTzidkat HaTzadikPart 40Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 21, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0019:37Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:03Tzidkas HaTzadik, ot mem. Before we get to the next piece, I would just like to tell you that I believe the next piece0:09is one of the deepest ideas I've read from Rav Tzadok. In my personal book, it's starred.0:17I've read this piece numerous times. I've shared it only select times with select0:25group of people. It's not something that is so easy. You have to really, really understand0:32what he's saying, and you have to know that you can't even alter a little bit from his0:37understanding, what Rav Tzadok is trying to say. The idea is a very deep idea. It's0:42a very amazing idea when you think about it. And I'm asking that after you hear the explanation here,0:48I'm asking that you keep thinking about the idea. And if you're not sure, go back0:53again to either the recording or go back to the piece itself. It's ot mem, number 40,0:58in Tzidkas HaTzadik, and read it very, very well, because, has v'shalom, a little bit of1:04deviation from this idea could perhaps mess up a person in his emunah in HaKadosh Baruch Hu, not in HaKadosh Baruch1:13Hu only, but also in the whole concept of sachar and onesh. We all know that the Rambam brings1:17down there's 13 ikarim, the 13 fundamental things that we, as a Jew, we have to believe in. If you1:24don't believe in all 13 of them, you're not technically a Jew. Sefer HaYer'im narrows1:30it down, or basically combines it all and concentrates it all, and he puts it into three:1:39emunah in Hashem, and Torah min Shamayim, and number three is reward and punishment. That one of1:45the fundamentals, one of the amudim, one of the pillars of Judaism is that you get rewarded for your good deeds,1:50and you get punished for your not such good deeds. Yet we all know this concept of teshuvah,1:56that when you do teshuvah and you fix your ways, you're forgiven for your not good deeds.2:05And this concept of teshuvah actually kind of, if you think about it really deep, not2:09on the superficial level, it doesn't, like, make so much sense. I can do something wrong,2:14then, like, all of a sudden it gets erased. So, with the introduction, before I get to the2:18next piece, I would like to quote what Chazal bring down and the Rambam brings it down2:21also in Hilchot Teshuvah, and that is, Kol ha'omer, Echta ve'ashuv. A person who says, I'm going2:29to sin, but don't worry, I'll do teshuvah. To give you an example, when we were kids,2:33very, very young—people don't do this today; I teach in school and we can't do this2:37today—but when we were kids and we do something wrong, like really wrong, our punishment2:41was—now, I'm not talking about in the old country. In the old country, we just got beat up.2:44That was, like, you know, the easiest thing for the teacher and the best way to keep us in2:48training. We can't do that anymore; you get arrested, at least not in America, especially2:52with cameras around. In any case, but the olden days, the punishment was, okay, now2:57you have to write me an assignment. You're going to write down, let's say—it depends3:01on the age—but let's say a 600-word essay or assignment of explaining what you did,3:09why it was wrong. And you have to—some of them will be even, like, more machmir, they3:13say—and you have to number each word. Oh boy, right? 600 words, and you have to sit there.3:18So, in my days, we had people with insurance assignments. That means, let's say you got3:24this assignment from a certain teacher, so, Dear Mister, and left blank, and then3:29they'll write, I'm very, very, very sorry, ta-da-da. It's all a general thing. No3:33teacher is actually reading a 600 assignment written by a sixth grader with sloppy handwriting,3:37but kids would sell it, right? Because, meaning to say, they had this prepared. They knew that3:42somebody's going to do something wrong. So you can't go—and we had a bit of3:45midah—you can't take animals and put them on the side and say, Okay, I'm planning to do a3:49chilul Shabbat tomorrow, and that's going to be a korban chatat. Just like you can't do that, you also3:52can't do that with teshuvah. You can't plan a mistake. You can't plan an aveirah and say,3:58בעזרת השם, I'm going to do the aveirah and then fix it.4:03Kol ha'omer chata v'ashuv, Chazal say, whoever says that, ein מוחלין לו, is not forgiven. In fact, it's brought down in4:08the Rambam, and Rabbeinu Yonah also brings it down, of the things that are me'akev teshuvah,4:12things that people don't get forgiven for, is this concept. So with that introduction,4:17I would like to now put them on the side and try to understand, let's come together and4:21try to understand, what means, and see how it fits exactly with this concept. So listen to this.4:27Ikar teshuvah, the main part of teshuvah, the point where a person reaches the highest4:33level of teshuvah, הוא עד שיאיר ה' עיניו שיהיו זדונות כזכויות. Until you4:38get to the point when you could understand, when Hashem lets you understand and see how your4:44aveirot that you did b'mezid are actually zechuyot. Pause. Let me explain a little background.4:50Chazal tell us that a person who does, what's called aveirot, a person who does sins, he4:59is going to get punished for them. And you can do them either b'shogeg, by mistake, or5:03you can do them b'mezid. The Gemara says, when a person does teshuvah, there are many5:08different levels of doing teshuvah. One of the levels of doing teshuvah is called teshuvah5:12me'ahavah. That's the highest, highest level. You're doing it out of love. That's a whole5:17explanation of what that means exactly. We don't want to get into it. But the5:20Gemara says how great is teshuvah out of love is that it turns the zedonot kzechuyot. It turns your aveirot, even though you did b'mezid, it5:29turns it into actually mitzvot. They become mitzvot. It's strange. I did an aveirah, all5:34of a sudden, not only do I not get punished for it, but actually it's considered zechut5:38that I get reward for it. It's a very deep concept. But anyway, he says the5:42ikar teshuvah is that when you get to the point when you could understand and see how5:46your zedonot are zechuyot. Let's continue6:00now. Sheyakir ha'adam shekol mah shechata haya gam ken b'ratzon Hashem yitbarach. What is the meaning that my sins, which have been done b'mezid, are zechuyot? Rav Tzadok explains that this is where the scary line is. Make sure you listen to the6:04whole audio, is that you understand that even that which I sinned was the will, or6:11with the will, of HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Like it says in the Gemara, Masechet Berachot, it says, shlosha pesukim—now, three pesukim the Gemara says in Masechet Berachot—that if it6:21wasn't for them, there would be no hope for the Jewish people. One of them is,6:30Ve'ata hasibota et libam achoranit. You, Hashem, are the one who turned their hearts backwards. If you think about this6:36Gemara, we all read it; it's part of the Haggadah, we just go through it,6:41Daf lamed aleph, amud bet. That's one pasuk. But if you think about it for a second, what are we saying? Hashem,6:46you can't blame the Jewish people. It's You who made their hearts go backwards.6:49How can you say such a thing? What do you mean, the Jewish people did it willingly?6:53Go ask each person who did the aveirah. Hashem turned his heart? No, he wanted to do it.6:56Yet there's a pasuk that says that. One of the nevi'im, the navi tells Hashem,7:02Atah hasibota et libam achoranit. You're the one who turned their hearts backwards. How can you say such a thing?7:06Also another pasuk says, Va'asher hara'oti. That Hashem says, kind of like in a regret—he says in Sefer Micha, he brings this7:16down—and Hashem כאילו says, And that which I have done evil. Whoa. Hashem has done evil?7:23We have done evil. I have done evil. I kind of twisted their heart. How can that be?7:27But Rav Tzadok is explaining, chas v'shalom, this is not to be understood that Hashem causes you to do7:35aveirot, because if so, there's no point of any punishment. You can't punish a person;7:38it's not Hashem's fault. And you can't reward any person because it's not, you know, he did the mitzvah because7:43he's born that way. It's not because, oh, Hashem made him that way; Hashem made him do7:50the mitzvot. Mi Hashem made me do aveirah? So therefore, I would like to tell you a very important thing to understand7:53this Rav Tzadok, and I'm not done with Rav Tzadok. There's still much more,7:56and I hope I can get to it in the time that I try a lot to this thing.8:00And that is, there's a concept called lechatchila and bediavad. Lechatchila means when I'm coming8:06to do something, and bediavad means, okay, once it's done. We find this in halacha all over.8:10There's things that you learn in halacha. For example, lechatchila, if you're coming to pray,8:15you have to pray Shacharit in a specific time in the morning, Mincha in a specific time in8:19the afternoon, Arvit in the evening. What happens if a person misses the tefillah? So it8:24depends. Did he miss it b'mezid or b'shogeg? No, he got distracted, or usually prays at the store in8:30the summer, and now there was no minyan in the store. He came back home, and when he got back home,8:35he just went on his daily activities and he forgot about his tefillah, and therefore he8:40missed Arvit. So what do you do? In the morning, you say Shacharit pa'amayim. You pray Shacharit, or the Amidah of8:45Shacharit, two times. Now, that's called bediavad. You can't do this lechatchila. You can't say,8:53No, tonight I want to go out, I want to enjoy myself. I'm planning to get drunk and not pray. Let me8:59enjoy, and what are you going to do? Tomorrow I'll pray twice. If I, I'll pray three times9:02if you want, you know what I'm saying? No, that's bediavad. You can't do that. If it happened9:06already and you did it, you fixed it. So that's the same thing with every aveirah. With this concept,9:11you have to understand there's a lechatchila and bediavad. Teshuvah is bediavad. You can't say,9:17Ichtav ve'ashuv. The concept of teshuvah, the whole idea of teshuvah is only bediavad. Yes, it has been9:25created in the world. It's part of nature, but you can only use that card of teshuvah,9:32bediavad, if you already sinned. But to plan a sin, you cannot do such a thing. And therefore, when the pasuk says, Vataasimot lemama acharanit, how could that be? It sounds like it's lechatchila, and the answer is not lechatchila. You have to understand the9:46depth of it is that HaKadosh Baruch Hu, כאילו, that's part of the world. He brings this concept that the Arizal explains in the book called9:55Arba Me'ot Shekel Kesef. I'm not familiar with the Arizal's books, and I cannot tell you exactly what he's talking about10:00over there, but he says over there the Arizal explains the difference between yediah and10:04bechirah. And he explains, sheneihem emet; both are true. As we know the famous question, the Rambam—we know,10:10we don't know—but there's the Rambam that asks the big question. Really, it's a big philosophical10:15question that everybody, you know, wonders this question, and the Rabad criticizes the10:20Rambam for bringing it up and writing about it and not giving an answer because it's a very deep concept.10:25He says, Why'd you bring the question? You can't even answer it. The question the Rambam brings10:28over there, he says, How can it be? Hashem knows what we're going to do, then where's the freedom of10:33choice? Hashem knows what about to choose, so I must choose it because of the fact that He10:36knows it. So this is, you know, in the simple sense—there are many, many different answers10:43that have been suggested throughout the generations for this question—that yediah and bechirah means10:49the knowledge of Hashem and the choice that we make seem to contradict each other, and the Arizal10:55says, No, they're not. They're both true. Each one in its own place. In the place where a11:05person has room to choose, there's no yediah for Hashem, and where Hashem knows,11:13שם באמת אין מקום לבחירה, and Hashem's knowledge of something, there's really no room for a person11:18to make a choice. וכשמשיג לאור זה העצום, as shebo causes... ובלתי יוצאים מעומק ידיעת השם יתברך, והוא ודעתו... And when a person reaches this understanding, which he's calling this great light.11:35Where a person sees that his zedonotav, that even what he did with his choice to do,11:43and, you know, mistakes you could say maybe you could say it's min shamayim. You were set up in a11:48certain position that kind of brought about a sin. But not when it comes to zedonot. Zedonot means11:55I did it on purpose. So how can it be that if you did an aveirah on purpose and that can be considered12:00the will of Hashem? And the answer is, when you get to that point of understanding that you're in12:04the point of yediah, there's no bechirah over there. Again, a very deep concept.12:10But now he gets the next paragraph. It's a little easier. He says,12:15Being that you get to the understanding that this was all Hashem's will,12:20then, really, although what I did looked like an aveirah, it's certainly went against what it says in the Torah.12:26But since I discovered that that was Hashem's will, again, all b'yad. After the12:33sin was done, and I think about—and again, also another important concept to know is that teshuvah,12:38like we said, has many levels. But not—you know, teshuvah is not a one-time thing. The same12:45teshuvah that a person is doing for a certain sin could be upgraded. Kind of like, imagine,12:51give you a mashal. Imagine you have a bookcase, right? And the bookcase started falling apart,12:58and now you fix it. You could fix it in many different ways. That means, let's say you fix it13:04by putting the shelves back on. But then you see, you know what, it might fall again. Then you decide,13:08I'm going to put an L-bracket to make it stronger. Then you see, you know what, it's a little bit13:13scratched from the, you know, wear and tear throughout the years. I'm going to paint it a little bit. Then13:16you say, you know what, I want to give it a little bit more support. I want to maybe perhaps13:20nail the bookcases. And you keep—and you know what, I'm going to add molding to it. And you know what, I'm going to add nicer looks to it. So you13:27see, you keep upgrading and fixing the same bookcase. It's the same thing with teshuvah.13:33When we do an aveirah and we come to do teshuvah, it doesn't have to be a one-time thing. Okay,13:36Hashem, I'm stopping, chatati, aviti, pashati. I, you know, beat my heart on Yom Kippur and I move on. Chazal tell us,13:42aveirot, the sins that a person did, that, excuse me, the sins that a person was mitvadeh, confessed for this Yom Kippur,13:50he confesses for it on another Yom Kippur as well. What do you mean? Why should I do that?13:57Aveirot, I did it, I already confessed last year. Why do I have to bring it up again? Remember, and the answer is14:02because there's always room to fix more and better. There's always, you can make that bookcase14:07nicer and stronger and better looking. So that's the same thing with our aveirot. I did teshuvah,14:13okay, but you can do a better teshuvah on the same aveirah. I'm not doing it anymore.14:16True, but you could enhance your teshuvah. You could bring it to the point of teshuvah14:20me'ahavah. And when you get to such a high level, says Rav Tzadok, the highest level is when you come back and you14:26say, Wow, this is all min shamayim. Even with the aveirah that I did, it's all min shamayim. It had to have14:34been Hashem's will. That's when it turns into zechuyot. That's when it turns into zechuyot,14:40because what is exactly a zechut, as he's going to explain in a second?14:45He says, v'zocheh lekaparah gemurah. When you get to that point, when you realize that even14:49the aveirot were Hashem's will, that is a zechut. ShebYom Kippurim, he says,14:55ze sod ha-se'ir la'azazel. He says the same idea we find by the se'ir la'azazel. As we know,15:02every korban, when you bring it into the Beit HaMikdash, you have to do shechitah on it in the Beit HaMikdash.15:07And if you do shechitah outside, it's actually not just you didn't do a mitzvah. If you bring a15:13korban outside the Beit HaMikdash, it's considered shechitah chutz. That's one of the worst aveirot. How do I know it's one of the worst15:18aveirot? Because the punishment is karet. It's karet, shechitat chutz is karet. Yet we find that the15:25Torah commands a very strange korban, and all the mefarshim also deal with this, like what's going15:31on with this korban. It's called the se'ir la'azazel on Yom Kippur, one of the highlights15:35of the Yom Kippur, where Hashem commands that we're supposed to take a certain goat to a certain15:40mountain and throw it off the cliff, and that will be the korban. Says the Talmud, think about it for a second.15:48Ilu asahu hu ha'adam atzmo, if a person would do this without Hashem commanding, they should do the15:56se'ir la'azazel, hayah over avodah zarah gamur. You would be worshiping avodah zarah. That's avodah zarah.16:00That would be under the category of lo yehyeh lecha Elohim acherim al panai.16:03And he says that this lo yehyeh lecha, hu yesod kol hamitzvot lo16:08taaseh. All mitzvot lo taaseh are under this category of lo16:11yehyeh lecha, v'chol haaveirot v'ha'aveirot min haratzon Hashem yitbarach, and it also includes this lo yehyeh lecha, includes with it all sins, anything that goes away16:18from the will of HaKadosh Baruch16:20Hu.16:26Now that you throw the se'ir laAzazel specifically on Yom Kippur, all of a16:34sudden na'asa od16:36mitzvah gedolah. That action, which if it would have been done under different circumstances would have been16:40the worst sin in the world, shechitat chutz, sacrificing outside the Beit HaMikdash, now16:47becomes not only a mitzvah, one of the biggest mitzvot, the highlight of the day of Yom Kippur.16:52V'kach pershu Chazal in16:56Perek Beit Leazer, and look in the Ramban, Parashat16:59Acharei Mot, and noteim chelek laAzazel, shehu hara mah sheHashem yitbarach kibelet lo, and na'asa aveirah mitzvah.17:02And the Ramban there on se'ir laAzazel explains the same way.17:05Like we said before, all the commentaries, all the rabbis, all of them are bothered how17:10to explain this whole concept of17:13se'ir laAzazel. Says the Ramban, we're not bringing, chas v'shalom, a se'ir to some demon, to some sitra17:19achra, chas v'shalom. No.17:21We are bringing the demon because Hashem said so.17:24He gives a mashal: if a person is making a seudah and he invites the king,17:29in the middle of the seudah who walks in? One of the biggest enemies of the king.17:33The king can't stand this guy.17:35Would you serve him?17:36Absolutely not.17:37This guy is an enemy to my king. I will never serve him.17:39In fact, I'm going to kick him out.17:40All of a sudden the king pulls you over and says, It's okay, give him a meal.17:43Serve him like every other guest.17:45Give him... Five portions, all the food, give it to him. Don't give anything less.17:52Now, when you give that person, the enemy of the king, are you doing the will of the king17:57or against the will of the king?17:58Obviously you're doing the will of the king. He just said to give it to him.18:01Hashem in general says, don't bring any offering outside of18:07the Beit HaMikdash. And if you do it, you're doing the worst thing in the world.18:09But here Hashem says, give it to him. It becomes a mitzvah.18:13So you see, the act that we do is defined as a mitzvah or an aveirah based on the18:20will of Hashem.18:20If it's the will of Hashem, then it's a mitzvah. If it's not the will of Hashem, it's an18:27aveirah, it's a sin.18:28And here is the yesod, the foundation of the idea that we started with.18:35When you come to realize that what your actions were, even though they were sins, was really18:42the will of Hashem, that's what Hashem wanted it to be.18:45Again, b'diavad, not lechatchilah, what Hashem wanted from the beginning.18:50Now, when you get to that point, that's when they turn into18:54zechuyot. Now, before you get to that point,18:58there's aveirot. When you were in charge of your choices and you made the choice to do an aveirah, that's19:05your choice. It's not Hashem. You can't blame Hashem for your choice to do the aveirah. That's19:10a sin.19:11But when you do teshuvah b'diavad, which, like we said, after the fact, and now after19:16doing teshuvah and contemplating about it and thinking about it more and more, you come19:20to realize, hey, that was what Hashem really wanted, and you come to discover that, that's19:24when they turn into19:26zechuyot. So we took a little bit longer, but like we said, it's a very deep idea and point idea.19:31If you have any questions for this, please contact me privately.