Torah · MussarMussar39. Is סייעתא דשמיא a Good Sign or Not?Tzidkat HaTzadikPart 39Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 21, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:00Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat haTzadik, ot0:04lamed tet. From now, like we said in the last clip, from this point on, it's not based on0:10masechet Berachot. It may not be pshat masechet Berachot, but it's not natzal, but it's different random ideas. And0:16you'll see, be'ezrat Hashem, I hope that you can enjoy it as much as I do. Some beautiful, beautiful ideas,0:23deeper thoughts about some things, some concepts that we're familiar with, some concepts we're not. Let's begin.0:29Pa'amim nidmeh le'adam sheyesh lo siyata dishmaya le'davar shehu oseh.0:33Sometimes it appears to a person that he's getting0:37divine assistance for what he's doing. He sees what we call siyata dishmaya. He says, Wow, Hashem is helping me out.0:44He says, You can't say the fact that Hashem is helping me0:49must be that what I'm doing must be good.0:53Dilma kein lo ya'azor Baruch Hu. Doesn't make sense. Would Hashem help me otherwise?0:56Would Hashem help me be successful in what I'm doing if it's not something that He wants?1:01So it can't be that what I'm doing is wrong. In fact, I'm getting assistance must be Hashem wants me,1:06or He's helping me, must be I'm doing something very good, and He gives Himself a seal of1:11approver. He says, Lo rak, because you can't say that. You know why?1:18Sherak le'ba'al litaher mesa'ayin oto. And he thinks that he's getting the divine assistance for what he's doing and it must be good. You know why?1:25Because, pasuk, it says, Haba litaher mesa'ayin oto. Aval ba le'tame, amru, and the Gemara says, rak potchin lo1:34v'lo mesa'ayin. The Gemara brought down a few places in Shas that says, Haba litaher, a person who comes to purify himself,1:40mesa'ayin oto. They assist him. And haba le'tame, a person who wants to make himself tameh, basically1:46he wants to do the wrong things, in Shamayim they don't assist him.1:49They allow him to just do, potchin lo, they allow him to do whatever he wants.1:54So this person's thinking, I see siyata dishmaya. Must be what I'm doing is2:00a taharah. Must be what I'm doing is something very good, otherwise why would Hashem help me? However,2:04comes Rav Tzadok and proves not so.2:08D'mi kol makom pa'amim yesh,2:14de'lenisayon siyuhu v'keyotze. Sometimes, no. We find that in Shamayim they assist the person, but really not because he's doing something good.2:21The opposite, it's actually a test to test him.2:25Where do we find this?2:28כמו שנאמר במיכה, like it says about Micah. Not to get confused with the different Micahs that are mentioned,2:33so we want to tell you which Micah this is, and we'll tell you the story.2:36The story in Micah, there was a person in Sefer Shoftim, towards the end of Sefer Shoftim,2:41not all the way to the end, but towards the end of it,2:43there was a person called2:45Micah. This Micah was a person who had an idol, an avodah zarah, in his house,2:52and he wanted to basically open up, quote unquote, imagine like in today's age a person how, you know, people get excited,2:59they want to open up a shul in their basement, in their garage, in their house,3:03and, you know, people have this beautiful, you know, desire to do something for Hashem.3:09So this guy, lehabdil, this Micah had3:13an avodah zarah, and he wanted to make a house of worship for this3:17avodah zarah. And over there, he was looking for somebody to lead, you know, the whole thing.3:23You know, just like if you want to open up a shul, you need a rabbi, unless you think you're the rabbi3:26and then you open up your own shul.3:27But otherwise, you know, you're going to get a rabbi, get somebody to lead the congregation.3:31So also he wanted to get a leader for the3:33congregation. He wanted what we would call like a kohen, like a priest, basically, to lead the thing.3:38And it happens to be that there was somebody from Shevet Levi3:42who happens to become this Micah's priest,3:47the priest for his pesel, for his3:51avodah zarah. And Chazal point out that this avodah zarah actually caused so much damage to the Jewish people3:55because it brought about a sin. It led many people towards3:59avodah zarah. It was horrible. It was really horrible.4:00This is a story that's brought down in Sefer Shoftim.4:02Over there, the fact that he gets this person from Shevet Levi who becomes the leader4:08was a tremendous success for4:11Micha, because it allowed him now—he became very popular, a lot of people came,4:14and now, you know, he had a full-functioning house of worship.4:18And it says over there, she'amar, Micha says when he gets this Levi,4:22he says, Atah yadati ki yeitiv Hashem li.4:25Now I know that Hashem is going to be good to me.4:28Why? Ki haya li haLevi lekohen.4:32Because now I have this person who is from Shevet Levi,4:35who is the priest, who is the one leading the worship of the4:39avodah zarah. Look what he says: Atah yeitiv Hashem.4:42He said Hashem was the Shem Havayah, which is a name of kodesh.4:45It's not4:47Elokim. You know, we all know that the word Elokim could also mean a regular god.4:50It could mean even a beit din,4:52and it could also mean refer to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.4:54But Yud-Kei-Vav-Kei, there's no other way of understanding it;4:57it only means Hashem.4:58And look what this person thought.5:00This guy, Micha, who has a house of5:04avodah zarah, where it says clearly numerous times in the Torah,5:06stay away from5:08avodah zarah, he thought that5:10he's getting siyata dishmaya. The fact that this guy from Shevet Levi5:15came—harei chashav shehaya lo sheyatad dishmaya, ve'ezeh Eloki lezmin lo haLevi lekohen,5:17veletiv lo.5:17You see, a guy is doing something totally, totally wrong,5:23and he's seeing success.5:25He's seeing, you know,5:27siyata dishmaya. And what does he think?5:29He thinks, he himself is fooling himself,5:31and he thinks, Oh, must be I have5:34siyata dishmaya, the fact that Hashem sent me what I needed.5:36So don't fool yourself, says5:38Rav Tzadok. You cannot fool yourself and think,5:41Oh, the fact that I'm getting5:42siyata dishmaya must be I'm doing something good.5:44In fact, there's a Chazal that says5:46that a person, before he robs a5:48house, he also prays to Hashem and he gets5:52siyata dishmaya, right?5:53So... It's not necessarily that5:57yechol l'haten shmaya means you cannot define your deeds6:01based on the fact that6:03yechol l'haten shmaya, or you don't yechol l'haten shmaya necessarily.6:05He says later on at the end of the piece,6:07he says, V'ayin lekaman ot6:09samech daled. He says, look in ot6:11samech daled as a similar idea or continuation to this idea,6:15and being that we're not up to that,6:17so we'll just tell you that,6:19you know, it's the same idea.6:20Maybe we'll bring it very quickly,6:22and then when we come back6:23maybe we'll tell you to refer to it here.6:25In samech daled he says,6:30Sometimes a person sees that6:32Hashem is assisting him,6:34and it seems like he's agreeing with him.6:37Same idea he's bringing over here also.6:39It doesn't mean that necessarily what he's doing is right.6:45And pasuk says,6:47Hashem guides you in the way that you want to go,6:52... to teach you.6:53Whatever way you want to go,6:55Hashem will guide you.6:57Where do we see this from?6:58We see it from7:00Bilam, the Gemara says.7:01What happens?7:02Bilam says to7:03Hashem, I would like to go and curse the Jewish people.7:05Hashem says, Absolutely not.7:07He asked Him permission in the beginning.7:09Then he comes back to7:09Hashem, says, No, what do you mean?7:10They're all here. Come on,7:11they all came to see me.7:12Hashem tells him, Go.7:14Ah, what is Bilam thinking?7:16Hashem approves me to curse the Jewish people,7:18which we know that was far from the7:21truth, far from the truth.7:22Yet Bilam was convinced that7:24I convinced Hashem,7:26or Hashem agrees with me,7:28and it seems like he's getting7:30yechol l'haten shmaya. They offered him more money.7:31Can you imagine for a second?7:33I mean, you know, you have to be in Bilam's head to really understand this,7:38because, you know, derech ish yashar b'einav, the pasuk says,7:39the way of each person,7:41in his eyes he thinks he's doing the right thing.7:43All of us are like this.7:44We hope that we're doing the right thing,7:45but we don't really know if we're doing the right thing or not.7:48So7:49derech ish yashar b'einav, every person's ways are straight in his eyes.7:52So you go put your head in Bilam's mind for a7:54second. This guy is a person who loved— Prestige, honor, money,7:59you know, recognition.8:00And here, what happens? The first group of people come, they offer a tremendous amount of money,8:05without saying the exact amount, but they tell him, Come, we'll take care of you.8:09And he knows what it means that with the government and the leader and the king is telling you to come8:14and we're going to take care of you. It's not like just a regular rich man.8:17This is the king of the whole country telling you, We'll take care of you.8:20He knows he's offered a lot of things, obviously. Yet, what happens?8:24Pay attention. When Bilam tells them, I'm sorry, Hashem doesn't let me come with you,8:29they come back with more money. And then Hashem says, You could go.8:34So Bilam is thinking, Amazing, look at the siyata dishmaya. If I would have agreed beforehand, I would have got much less money,8:39and now, ah, Hashem is assisting me. And he gets a korbanot. Everything is working out for him.8:48And, you know, if he would know, there's a whole parashah written about him, Bilam would say, Look, the proof that I'm right.8:52A Torah came out of my deeds. Must be what I'm doing is8:55right. Yet we know that the opposite. He's one of the people listed in Mishnah, in9:01Maseches Sanhedrin, of ein lo chelek l'olam haba. So what's the solution? We're back to9:05Lamed Tet. Again, I don't want to go through the whole piece of9:08Samech Daled, but it's the same idea he brings in Samech Daled. Back to9:11Lamed Tet, it says, Omnam, Chazal amru b'Tanah d'Bei Eliyahu, ki Micha kafar b'Anochi. What's the story with Micha over there?9:21He was kofer in the first of the Aseres HaDibros, Anochi Hashem Elokecha. And he explains that the idea of kefirah is that you completely are kofer means you rip yourself off from the Jewish roots.9:35Right? And only by such a person, you see a person who completely cut himself off in such a way,9:39where he brought avodah zarah. He introduced—he was one of the first people to introduce the concept of9:44avodah zarah. This is in Sefer Shoftim. This is in the early stages of the Jewish people in9:51Eretz Yisrael. And for us, how are we supposed to know really the shoresh of our actions?9:56Here, look at Micha, who got this Levi. By the way,10:00Chazal tell us that this Levi that came to Micha was actually a descendant of Moshe Rabbeinu,10:06a very close descendant of Moshe Rabbeinu.10:09The pasuk hides it, and I'm also not going to say exactly how he was a descendant of Moshe Rabbeinu.10:14But this Micha, can you imagine when he looked at the birth certificate of this Levi and he says,10:21Wow, look at that, from the family of Moshe Rabbeinu. Unbelievable.10:25Can you imagine what tzi'at ha'daat he probably thought he had, yet he didn't.10:29So what do we do now?10:30How are we supposed to know if what we're doing is really the right thing for Hashem wants us to do and not wants us to do?10:36And this is a question that, I'll tell you the truth, bothers me all the time.10:39Am I really doing—am I pushing enough? Am I pushing too much?10:42Is this a sign from Hashem that I shouldn't— I shouldn't be pushing,10:44and am I missing the opportunity?10:47Am I not taking the opportunity?10:49And it's a question that bothers me. It still bothers me constantly.10:53I'm not going to tell you that it bothered me once and I discovered the answer.10:55No, I don't have an answer either.10:56But I was happy to hear recently from one of the important roshei yeshivot in America, Rav Gershon11:06Ribner, who said that this is a question that everybody struggles with. And I was happy to see that at least I'm normal.11:11I'm not the only one who just goes through these thoughts.11:14And everybody. And he brought a good11:16point. A guy who is dating and is dating for a while is always doubting himself:11:21Did I give up my, you know, nasib, my beshert, my11:26zivug? Did I miss that opportunity?11:28And the guy who is at work and says,11:31What happened? What would have happened if I would have taken that job?11:34We have to believe it's ... at the end of the day.11:36But again, it's a question that plagues everybody's minds.11:41Stay tuned for the next piece, ot mem, a little bit of an answer to that.11:45In any case, what do you do, though?11:47How are you supposed to know?11:48He says,11:49The only advice for a person who wants to do the right thing and he wants Hashem's11:59yeshua is tefillah v'tachanunim lerachem Shamayim, ... lafik gama shoresh. The only advice is that a person has to pray with his full heart12:03and beg Hashem, really, really sincerely beg Him12:07that He should guide him in the right way.12:10And there Hashem could actually,12:12he says, then He could12:14... it could even turn your roots.12:17If your roots are messed up,12:20that means the roots of your actions, of what you want to do,12:23really are from a bad source.12:25You have the wrong intentions.12:26Hashem is not happy with it.12:27But when you pray that Hashem should help you,12:29He could even overturn that.12:35... Lift the horn ... The pasuk says,12:37David HaMelech says,12:38Hashem, create for me a new heart, a pure heart.12:42You already have a heart.12:43The word bara, as Chazal tell us,12:47is yesh me'ayin. What does it mean, yesh me'ayin? It's a new creation,12:49as opposed to the word yatzar12:52is taking something that already exists and putting it together.12:57Beri'ah is, Bereishit bara Elokim, there was nothing and Hashem brought it to be.12:59David13:03HaMelech is praying, Let the whole beri'ah li Elokim. You could even create for me a new heart.13:06How can he pray13:07for what does it mean, a new heart?13:09And the answer is,13:09he's not looking for a heart surgery or a heart transplant,13:14no. Beri'ah li Elokim, he's asking for tahor.13:16Yes,13:17even if your intentions are13:20tamei, with prayer Hashem can turn it into tahor.13:23And that's advice.13:24When we are doing13:26and we would like13:27siyata dishmaya, even before13:29we're getting siyata dishmaya, don't be convinced that what you're doing is necessarily the right thing.13:31You got to pray that Hashem should purify your heart.13:34You should have a lev tahor,13:36and it should be with the good intentions,13:39that your13:40intentions—obviously you think you're good;13:42we all think that what we're doing is good.13:43Otherwise we wouldn't really do it,13:45and you got to be really evil to know what you're doing is wrong13:47and to continue doing it13:49and not feel bad about it.13:50But that what you're doing is good,13:53and Hashem should help you bring out your good machshavot l'maaseh.