Torah · MussarMussar38. Using a Filter Between Our Thoughts and MouthTzidkat HaTzadikPart 38Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 20, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:54Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:02Tzedkat tzaddik ot lamed chet. A short piece,0:04and in this short piece, I believe,0:07will be also the final piece0:09that is going on the0:11Gemara Masechet Berachot.0:12As we told you in the beginning,0:13the first couple of pieces0:17are all focused on the Gemara Masechet Berachot,0:19and0:21really it's the first0:2338 pieces.0:24And in this final piece,0:26we will conclude — I don't conclude,0:28but at least, you know, not focus on the Gemara Berachot0:31anymore. Rav Tzadok will now go on to other0:33deeper concepts from all over Shas,0:35and really, really, really,0:37I think0:38we'll now be going up a0:40notch, and you'll enjoy the sefer0:43very, very, very much.0:44Okay, to understand the next Gemara,0:46the Gemara says over there,0:48Lamed leshoncha lomar, 'Eini yodea,'0:53shema titbadek veteheyeh. The Gemara gives you advice:0:53train yourself to say,0:55I don't know. Why?0:57Because you might get caught,1:00and1:01titbadek — excuse me — you might be found wrong,1:03and then you'll be, quote unquote, caught,1:05basically that you did something wrong.1:08Let's give you a background1:09of the story. The Gemara says over there1:11that Moshe Rabbeinu, when he's telling1:14Paro about the final1:15makah, makat bechorot,1:16he tells him,1:20Kechatzot halayla, around chatzot layla, around midnight,1:22HaKadosh Baruch Hu will come out1:23and strike the Egyptians1:24and basically kill every1:27firstborn by the1:29Mitzriyim. But the pasuk says,1:31kechatzot. Kechatzot is very different1:32than bechatzot. Bechatzot means exactly at midnight.1:35Kechatzot is around midnight.1:37So now, one second,1:38Moshe Rabbeinu doesn't know when chatzot is?1:40The Gemara says, no, he does know. Of course he1:42knows. The problem is the Mitzriyim don't know.1:45We're working on something that's based on measurement.1:47That could be1:49some — and if everybody's not using the same measuring stick,1:51there could be a problem.1:52So, for example, if I don't have a measuring tape1:55and I say, Hey... Show me what six feet is.1:57So it's based on this guy's evaluation1:59or estimation.2:00He thinks that six feet is over here,2:03and I don't have the same yardstick,2:04and I'm basing on my head, and I think six feet is over here.2:07So it could be that I might be 100% right,2:09it could be he's 100% right.2:10But one thing is for sure, that2:12it's very, very likely that we won't meet at the same point.2:15And if he's totally convinced that he's right,2:17he's going to think that I'm a2:18liar, that I ripped him off.2:20I was supposed to give him six feet, I gave him something less.2:23It could be the exact opposite,2:24that I'm right and he's wrong.2:26So Moshe Rabbeinu, in this case, was 100% right.2:28He knew what chatzot is.2:29But the problem is, there's no clock that we could all work by,2:33and therefore they may make a mistake2:35and blame Moshe2:37and, chas v'shalom, that could come2:39to create problems2:41in the kedushat Hashem2:42that Moshe was trying to make over there.2:44So the Gemara says from there,2:46train yourself. It's good to also train yourself2:48in general to say,2:51Ein yodea. When people ask you something, train yourself to say,2:54Ein yodea. Before I get to2:55Rav Tzadok, I would like to point out something that2:58I personally like to say3:00about this Gemara.3:02The Gemara is not telling—who is the Gemara talking to?3:04Is the Gemara talking to the person that3:06doesn't know, and the Gemara is telling the3:08guy, Hey, you that don't know,3:10train yourself to say, I don't know.3:12That doesn't make sense.3:13If you don't know and you say you know,3:15you're a fool and a liar3:18and a cheater,3:19right? You don't know something. Why are you answering it?3:22Yes, we do know3:23that's minhag ha'olam, that a lot of people3:25will always answer something even though they don't know.3:27But still, that's foolish.3:29You don't know, you don't answer it.3:31But who's the Gemara talking to? The Gemara is talking to3:33the guy who even knows,3:35even though the guy really knows,3:36and the Gemara is saying, Train yourself to say, I don't know.3:39Even though you know,3:40train yourself, I don't know.3:42Why? Because it's not.3:44That's3:45a yadua, because there are a few times that you may not really know.3:48And when you say you know,3:50or you say with such conviction,3:51you don't have to say, I know.3:52You could say with such conviction.3:54You know, I ever see that? There's certain people, like when they talk,3:56like you think they researched it3:58and they've done such, you know, great research,4:01and they talk with such confidence,4:03you feel like they're 100% right.4:04Meanwhile, it could be not.4:05They don't know what they're talking about.4:07And you see many times,4:09the best is when you have two people with the same character trait4:12in the same conversation.4:13You have a group of people, five people,4:15and one guy says with such conviction,4:17the other guy says, No, it's like this.4:18Ah, then you know something's for sure wrong,4:20right? It can't be that they're both right.4:23In any case, the Gemara is telling you,4:25train yourself to say, I don't know.4:28Okay, now comes Rav Tzadok and explains4:30what the Gemara's4:32intention is.4:35V'Rav Tzadok says,4:39Af bidvarim haberurim bemachshavah. Even when you know4:41something in your thoughts4:42to be 100% clear,4:44and 100% that you know4:47clear that this is what it is,4:51kesheba'im legilui, when they're coming to be out in the open,4:53basically when they're coming to4:54being exposed,4:57which is shehu הלשון המוציא לפועל, which means4:58when you take something from your thought5:00and you want to bring it out5:02and express it5:04through speaking,5:05through saying it,5:08ma shebkoach balev, which is basically your mouth5:11says and speaks5:12when you say words,5:13what you're doing is5:15you're bringing out what's in the depth of your thought.5:19You're bringing it out,5:19or what's in your heart, you're bringing it out.5:21You're expressing it.5:22Make sure when that happens,5:25when that step is happening,5:27when you're expressing and bringing out5:29what's hidden in your thoughts,5:31you teluyim bsafek. So always be5:34in doubt.5:35What does that mean?5:38Ki ha'adam alul la-ta'uyot. He said, no, a person5:40is liable to5:41make mistakes.5:42We are created in such a way.5:44We're bound to make mistakes.5:46It's part of our nature.5:48It's very common. It's very real.5:54Therefore,5:55whatever you want to bring out5:57has to be 100%.5:59It should never be out6:01unless it's 100%,6:03in whatever form of expression that is.6:05It could be in the form of expression of writing6:07or speaking.6:10But something that you,6:12in your mind,6:13you think it's 100% clear,6:15it's 100% to you in your mind,6:18it's a different thing6:19when you have to say it.6:20You have to know when you come to say it,6:21always got to have some sort of doubt with it.6:23Don't be so easy to say it.6:26Now, before he finishes, one last line,6:30Rabbi Shor, my rosh yeshiva from6:32Monsey, used to say the following.6:34He says, and it's very, very true.6:35It's not everything that we think6:38we're supposed to really think.6:39Let me say, you know, thoughts6:41pop in our heads.6:43You know, all those thoughts, a lot of them should not be thought about, really.6:46But even what we think,6:47we thought about already,6:49okay? Even if we could control to a certain extent6:51what we think about,6:52not everything that we think should be said,6:56and not everything that's said6:58should be written,6:59and not everything written7:01should be read,7:02and certainly not everything read should be repeated.7:05This was said,7:06I've heard this maybe over twenty-something years ago,7:10and back then,7:11I don't remember if we had texting. We didn't have texting.7:13I don't think we had texting.7:15I think we just had cell phones.7:16We didn't have texting yet.7:18And how true it is today with social media,7:21right?7:22People think that the fact that I see it,7:24I can just spread it, I can share it.7:26First of all, how did it come to?7:28How did it come about?7:30And the answer is because somebody thought of such an idea.7:32Right away he put it into a text,7:33or he expressed it, or somebody took it7:36and he put it in a video, whatever it is.7:38It was expressed, it was brought out from the7:41machshava to, like the Rav Tzadok HaKohen is saying, bring it out of7:44here without any7:45filtration,7:46without any thinking about it,7:49if it's true, if it's not true,7:50if it's supposed to be said, even if it's true,7:51if it's good for people, not good for people.7:54Basically, you gotta put a7:56filter in your mind before7:58it gets expressed.8:01Don't just say whatever pops into your head.8:04That self-restraint of what we think to be expressed is what makes us human.8:11I'm repeating it.8:12Our self-restraint to control our thoughts that they shouldn't be expressed is what really makes us human.8:20Think about it for a second.8:22Animals don't have this concept of8:25self-restraint. They don't have the—they don't hold back for anything.8:28If an animal feels something, they'll just do it.8:30A dog.8:31You ever see dogs, right?8:32A guy walking with his dog.8:35Looks like a nice day.8:36The dog's enjoying running up and down.8:38He sees another dog.8:39He goes all crazy.8:41Control yourself.8:41There's no control.8:42There's another dog.8:43He has to bark back,8:45and the other one starts to start, you know, they start8:48dog fighting. There's no8:50self-control. Animals that want to8:50mate, there's no bathroom.8:52They just do it.8:53You could train them maybe to go to a certain spot, but they're just going to do it.8:57There's no8:59self-restraint. And unfortunately, with some humans, we see the same thing,9:02but much more so when it comes to our speech,9:05because we live in a society.9:07We think you're not going to say something,9:10they're going to think you're a fool,9:11and you don't know what to answer.9:13We recently had in Chutz LaAretz, we just read Parashat9:17Balakha, and the Parashat Balakha talks about Moshe Rabbeinu being humble,9:20and says,9:23V'ha'ish Moshe anav me'od mikol ha'adam asher al pnei ha'adamah. Moshe Rabbeinu, the man Moshe Rabbeinu, is the most humble person on the face of the planet.9:31What is this humility?9:32Please read the Ramban.9:34It's a very short Ramban9:35there at the end of the parashah, pasuk9:37gimmel. Unbelievable Ramban.9:39Says, you know what his humility is?9:40He heard,9:41he knew what to answer,9:42he did not answer.9:43He did not fight back.9:44That's humility.9:45That's9:47anavah. All the anavah classes that people go and they hear and they say9:50and they, you know,9:52Lefi ani da'ati, people say, and really I'm humble and they don't want to be.9:56You want to know9:57anavah? Don't answer back.9:59Not when you don't have what to answer.10:01When I do have what to answer,10:03I hold back.10:04I don't have to answer.10:06You have a question if you should be10:08answered, maybe I should open my mouth,10:10people are going against religion,10:11maybe,10:12or maybe they're doing it because you're answering back because it's a personal insult.10:16And I'm not talking about because10:18of halacha, permissive, let me do it.10:19Yeah,10:20the halacha is halacha permissive, but you want to know if it's called10:22an aveira. No, it's not10:24an aveira. Aveira is10:27self-control, not to do it,10:29not to do it,10:29not when you could do what you want to do.10:31Some people, once heard somebody say,10:33I'm not scared to say it,10:35or my kids would say, I'm not scared,10:37I'll do it.10:38You know,10:39one of my kids said, Yeah, you know,10:41we're talking about going to Israel,10:42the Arabs, I'm not scared of them,10:44I'll just go.10:45You know, you call the fool.10:47You know, you call the fool.10:47If you put yourself in a place where the crazy people10:51just do what you want to do,10:54you think they're going to be quiet?10:55They're going to answer back,10:56they're going to fight back,10:56they're going to do all crazy things.10:57You're not a brave guy,10:59you're a fool.11:00Same thing,11:01just because a guy says, I know what to answer,11:03I'm going to answer back,11:04that doesn't make you strong.11:05It doesn't make you a macho man.11:08You're a fool.11:09You have to be a fool to control yourself.11:12The Tzedakah Cohen has explained to us on this piece,11:16is this exact point.11:17It's when you do know what to say,11:19and you know you're right,11:21but you're about to express it.11:22Before you express it,11:24train yourself not to just express everything that you want.11:27No. And you see that a lot of times in a conversation,11:29especially people that started to learn11:31and they get excited that they know some information.11:33Somebody says something, and right away they pop up11:35and they answer.11:37You11:39don't have to go, Oh, I know.11:41Okay, so it's like a child also,11:43he first begins to speak,11:43he just blurts everything out,11:45right? You say something,11:46he remembers something that he learned about that in11:48school, and he blurts it out.11:50No restraint,11:52no, you know, self-control in anything.11:54Okay, there are people that are starting,11:57but that's not mature.11:59When you mature,12:00you start to put a little bit more control.12:02The more you are in control of yourself,12:04the more human being you are.12:07The more different you are from animals,12:09and that's called working on12:11midot. The main midah is12:14gevurah, self-control. Let's finish up, and he says,12:20Now, this is all talk about an expression.12:23What you think about,12:25and it's something that you feel is real and it's12:28emet, and you have a clarity on it,12:29you can think whatever you want.12:31The filtration process has to begin12:33when you're taking that thought12:34and you want to bring it out to be expressed,12:36whether you're expressing it in speech,12:40or in writing,12:40or even in some sort of remez,12:45or hints,12:46or winks.12:47You have to be careful,12:48very careful,12:49before you express it,12:50to think about it very, very well. Baruch...