Torah · MussarMussar37. Women in the FieldsTzidkat HaTzadikPart 37Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 17, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:11Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat Tzadik, ot lamed zayin.0:02If you look in the piece itself, it's very, very short.0:06It's about four lines, five lines maybe, if you count this other one.0:09Okay, so there's five lines in Tzedkat Tzadik in this section.0:14However, you need a lot of background information0:17to really appreciate what the Rav Tzadok is saying.0:21So we're going to give you that information.0:23In Gemara Masechet Berachot, daf gimmel amud aleph,0:25we already mentioned, the Gemara warns a person0:27that he should not enter an abandoned area.0:31Why not?0:32So the Gemara gives three reasons,0:34and it seems to be that these three reasons,0:37the way the Gemara is presenting,0:38it seems to be that they disagree with each other,0:41but they're all true.0:42They're just because three separate reasons,0:45that person should not enter.0:48And the Gemara says,0:51Tenu Rabbanan, mipnei shalosh devarim ein nichnasin lachurbah. Because of three reasons,0:53a person should not enter an abandoned place.0:55What are these three reasons?0:58Mipnei chashad. One is because of1:00chashad. Chashad means suspicion.1:02What does that mean, suspicion?1:03So Rashi explains,1:05shema yomru,1:06shelo yomru1:07zonah muchanet lo sham.1:09They see a guy entering an abandoned place.1:11What's going on?1:11Why is this guy entering an abandoned place?1:12Who's there?1:13So people shouldn't suspect you,1:15that maybe people will1:17think that the guy has a zonah waiting for him over there,1:18like some sort of prostitute.1:20The second reason the Gemara says,1:22mipnei hamapolet.1:23What's hamapolet?1:24Rashi explains again,1:28shechomat hachurbah re'uah, umsukan hu pen tipol hachomah alav.1:29The walls are very shaky1:31because, as was explained,1:33an abandoned area usually,1:35you know, lacks maintenance.1:38So it could be that,1:39chas v'shalom, he's putting himself in physical danger1:42where it could fall,1:43the whole property might fall on him1:45and actually could kill him.1:47The third reason the Gemara says,1:50mipnei hamazikin. What's a1:50mazikin? We already explained this a bunch of times.1:52The mazikin are the demons, are found1:54in abandoned areas.1:56Now, the Gemara says,1:57seems the Gemara is understanding it1:59later2:00on—this is a beraita that they2:01quoted—then the Gemara says,2:02Hold on a second.2:03If you tell me this reason,2:04one second,2:05there's another reason that may apply.2:06And they start challenging2:08each reason.2:09Why do you say,2:10for example,2:11why do you say mipnei hashad?2:13Why aren't you worried about2:14mazikin? The Gemara says,2:14No, we're talking about a specific area.2:16So it comes out that2:17the beraita seems to be saying2:18three different reasons2:19that disagree with each other.2:21So I just want to focus on the last part2:23the Gemara says.2:24According to the last opinion,2:26he says,2:26Don't enter an abandoned place2:28because2:30hamazikin, good?2:30Because there could be demons over there.2:32The Gemara asks,2:33Why do I need this reason?2:35Tipuk lei mipnei hashad2:39umapolet. Why don't you2:39just—it's good enough to say that2:42hashad umapolet are good enough reasons2:44to say that the guy should not2:45enter an abandoned place,2:46right?2:48So why do I need the third reason2:49also of2:50mazikin? So the Gemara gives one answer,2:52then it says,2:53Ve'iba'it eima, I could tell you2:55we're talking about a case over here,2:58bechurba chadati. We have a new abandoned area,3:03so the walls are what?3:05You're not worried about mapolet over here.3:08Why are you not worried about3:09mapolet? Why aren't you worried3:10the walls will fall?3:11Because it's,3:12you know, you know that people3:13were living here last year.3:14It's been abandoned for like3:15less than a year3:16or something like that,3:17so you know that3:18it's not going to fall3:19in such a short time.3:21Also,3:21deka iba dabra.3:24This property happened to be3:26also this abandoned area3:27is in the dabra.3:29What's dabra?3:29Rashi says means3:31sadeh, not a midbar, not a desert.3:32Dabra means in the3:34sadeh, in the field.3:35So what's,3:36so therefore,3:38dehatam mishum hashad leka.3:40Over there,3:41there's no people3:42that are gonna suspect you.3:45Remember,3:46chashad is people3:46are gonna suspect you3:47there's a na over there.3:48But in the3:49sadeh, in the field,3:51there's no worry,3:52because women3:52are usually not found3:53in the field.3:55De'isha bedabra lo3:57shechicha. Isha in the dabra3:58is not common.4:00And4:01also,4:02it's pretty much4:03a new abandoned area,4:04and you're not worried4:05it's gonna fall on you.4:05That's why I have to tell you,4:07mipnei hamazikin. But when it's abandoned,4:08we know4:08mazikin enter there.4:09What comes out4:10from this Gemara4:11is the Gemara is saying4:12it like a rule:4:13isha bedabra leka,4:15lo4:16shechicha, excuse me,4:16and a woman is not commonly4:18found in the field.4:19It's not common4:20to find a woman in the field,4:21talking4:22obviously4:22in their days4:23and our days.4:24But Gemara4:24has established a point,4:26and on that4:26Rav Tzadok explains4:28on a deeper level4:29what does that mean,4:29that women are not4:31commonly found4:31in the field.4:33He says,4:34sadeh hu4:38hitpashtut leorech verochav. The concept of a field4:39is a completely open area,4:42as opposed to a structure,4:44like4:45let's say4:45you say4:45a4:46chatzer, a yard.4:48Chatzer is defined4:48by the fact4:49that it has an4:51enclosure, a building,4:53a house.4:54Any other type4:55of real estate4:57is usually defined4:59by walls5:00or some sort of5:02enclosure, fences, whatever it may be.5:03Not so when it comes5:04to a field.5:05A field is just5:06completely open.5:07It's what we call5:09hitpashtut, complete openness5:10to the length5:11and to the width,5:12completely open.5:14He says,5:17kemo sheshama'ata hapasuk, v'atteta basadeh lach,5:18like he says5:19the way he heard it5:20regarding this pasuk.5:21So there's a pasuk in5:23Mishlei, perek chav-daled, pasuk5:24chav-zayin, that says the following:5:31Hachen bachutz melachtecha, v'atteda basadeh lach, achar uvanita beitecha. Pasuk says,5:33prepare your5:34melacha on the outside.5:35That means5:36go do business,5:36as the Gra explains,5:38go do your business dealings5:40outside,5:41v'ateda b'sadeh lach,5:42and then in the field,5:44you5:45should—what ateda, he says, from the5:46lashon of atudim,5:47some types of5:49flock—and have a lot of flock5:50in the fields.5:51Afterwards you can build5:52your house.5:53That's a5:54pashut pshat of the pasuk.5:54He says that he heard5:56on this pasuk5:57that it represents5:59that the6:00sadeh, ateda sadeh lach,6:01is that it's a6:02berachah, kind of.6:03Like when you have6:04a6:05melachah, then you can bring it6:06into6:07sadeh, that it should completely6:08extend without6:09any boundaries,6:10right?6:10Any businessman will tell you6:11what that means.6:12Now, when you have a business6:14and you want to be successful,6:15how successful6:16do you want to be?6:16No boundaries,6:17as much as I can.6:18How big6:19do you want6:20your bank account to be?6:21How much money6:21do you want to have in there?6:22No boundaries,6:23especially6:24if today's dollar is worth.6:25In any case,6:26so he says6:27that's the concept6:28of a6:29sadeh. A sadeh is6:32a completely open area6:33without an6:36enclosurement. And the Gemara says again,6:37a woman is not found6:38in the field.6:39Which woman6:39are we talking about?6:40Woman specifically,6:40the Gemara is talking about6:41a woman that's like a6:42zonah, where a guy is running6:43after6:47ta'avot. In a completely open area,6:50we don't find6:51that there's a6:52chashash where that person6:53is going to be running6:54after his6:56ta'avot. Interesting,6:57just a side point,6:58when6:58something's completely open area6:59and it's not an7:01enclosurement, there's no issur of7:03yichud. Why?7:04Because technically7:05you're not alone.7:06You're open,7:06you're completely exposed7:07to everybody,7:07everybody can see you.7:08But he's saying7:09something very interesting7:10over here.7:11He's7:12saying something deeper.7:13He's7:13saying in open areas7:15where it's not7:17enclosurement, you don't find7:18ta'avot, because really7:19if you think about it,7:21ta'avot— Actually limit a person.7:24People think the opposite.7:24What do you mean?7:24If I can have any taavah that I want,7:26I'm7:26not—no, the opposite.7:27Taavot kind of limit you,7:29and they put you7:30in a certain7:31encroachment. As we know,7:32addictions,7:32which are really7:35the person's loss7:37of control7:38of his7:40taavot. That's what every addiction is,7:42that you lost control7:43over your7:44taavah, and therefore7:45you intake so much7:47of whatever it is,7:48if it's drugs,7:49alcohol,7:50ice cream,7:51candy,7:52fatty foods,7:53you name it,7:54or any other7:55types of addictions,7:57right?7:57It's basically7:57your loss of control of—8:00You lose the ability to control yourself in these ta'avot, and therefore you become trapped by them,8:07that you can't function without these ta'avot. That's what addiction is.8:14That's not really—there's, whatever, addiction and the other word of it right now.8:18But addiction also, that when you have it, you can't control yourself.8:22You know you're supposed to—doctor tells you you're not supposed to have so many fatty foods.8:24You can have a little bit of fried food, so you take a few French fries, but you lost your control.8:29You can't. So really, ta'avot are only found in enclosures, because it puts a person in an enclosure. In an open area,8:38there's no ta'avot over there.8:40Also, when you're exposed, when you're around other people—not other people that you should be around people,8:45meaning to say where people could see you, could view8:48you—you also don't have the ability to run after your ta'avot, and it kind of gives you a support in your8:56self-control. I'll give you an example.9:00Sorry for giving this example, but we got to be real9:03life. Once upon a time, before the computers, when the internet was only—excuse me, before the phones,9:09when the internet was only on the computers, people may have had cell phones, but it wasn't, you know, on their phones.9:16The internet was on their phones yet; it was on the computer.9:18So imagine somebody decides, you know what, he wants to go and watch some improper things on the computer.9:26Which computer will he use? Will he use the one in the office where there are cubicles, where everybody's walking around?9:31Of course not.9:32If he has a private office, where he could go in and lock, or it's a time when nobody could see him, that's when he does it,9:38when he's not exposed to other people.9:41Today, it's the same thing with the idea with the phone.9:45Imagine. Right? Taking out your phone in public in front of9:48everybody, and your phone is actually, you know, reflected, or it's like magnified on a large screen.9:57That thing's called screen sharing,9:58and everybody could see your screen.10:01Aren't you going to be careful what you look at?10:03You know, in school, when I have my smartboard, and my computer is connected to the10:09smartboard, so when I need to put on the smartboard to show the class, sometimes I need to check my email.10:12And if I see somebody, or I have my WhatsApp on it—that's why if you're getting late responses from10:19my WhatsApp—I have my WhatsApp on it, so if somebody texts me a question, a halacha, you know, it could be something private.10:23I don't want the students to see it, so I don't put it on in front of everybody,10:27right? It's a private thing. Somebody's asking me a private question.10:30You would be very careful what you look at, right?10:35Now, I'm not talking about here desires, but still, when people are watching you,10:39you're much more careful. You're much more aware, and you have the ability for much more10:44self-control. Even that guy who's running after his ta'avah, and he's going into the privacy of a room,10:48the reason why he's doing it is because he's not an open area.10:52Open areas are areas where people could see you.10:56Actually gives you—there's no11:00... not common.11:01Yeah, there are people that two things are not common, but it's not common.11:05That's, I think, the lesson we could get from the depth of the words of Rav Tzadok HaKohen over here.