Torah · MussarMussar32. Entering an Abandoned PlaceTzidkat HaTzadikPart 32Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 10, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:55Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:03Tzedkat ha-tzadik, אות ל״ב. In this piece, you need a little bit of a background.0:05We already said the story of Eliyahu Hanavi and Rabbi0:11Yossi, and there the Gemara concludes that0:15אין נכנסין לחורבה. A person should not enter an abandoned, ruined place.0:19The Gemara asks, how come a person should not enter such an abandoned place?0:23And the Gemara gives two answers.0:25The Gemara says one answer is because0:27מפני החשד, that a person should not be suspected.0:30What does it mean, should not be suspected?0:32The Gemara also gives a little clarification0:33that some people might say that he's going to do some sort of aveirah over there.0:38He's meeting up with some lady over there0:40because it's an abandoned place; nobody will see them.0:42The other answer the Gemara says is0:46מפני המזיקין. What are mazikin? And that answer is demons,0:48maybe something not as common in our days that we live in cities,0:51but in abandoned places there are such a thing as mazikin, as0:55demons, as the Gemara speaks out throughout all of Shas.1:00So for these two reasons, a person is not allowed to enter an abandoned place.1:03Rav Sadok explains what this abandoned place represents on a deeper level.1:08So he first quotes the Gemara,1:12אין נכנסין לחורבה. What does that mean? He says,1:14פירוש: What's a churbah, an abandoned place?1:17מקום פנוי. It's a memoshav bnei adam1:20ha-metim. It's a place that's empty of true people that are living there.1:27As we know that mazikin are people, but they're just not real people;1:32they're spirits.1:34They have a tzurah, they have an image.1:37If a person is able to see them, when a person sees them, he could see them, he could sense them.1:42In fact, they can do damage,1:44so they have some sort of physical abilities as well,1:46but they're not true people;1:49they're not real people.1:51So the same thing, same idea over here.1:53He says this represents1:57מקום מצוה. Real people is a real thing.2:00A real thing is a mitzvah.2:02To enter or to do something that's abandoned,2:08abandoned from real people,2:09that means if you're doing something that's not a mitzvah,2:12so what is it? Not an aveirah either.2:13Because, like we said earlier, in earlier notes, in2:21number, in os lamed, is that Rabbi Yose wasn't doing an aveirah, but he could have done it better.2:26You're not supposed to really enter.2:27Lechatchila, you're not supposed to get in there.2:29So there's something we find, one of the earliest sources that I can remember2:35is in Chovot HaLevavot about a thousand years ago,2:37and something that's called davar mitzvah and2:40davar hareshut. Even though Chazal also bring it, but he kind of categorizes it a little bit more.2:44In things that we do in life, it's either a mitzvah, either an aveirah, or2:48reshut, or something that's not a mitzvah or2:50aveirah. It's optional. You could do it. You don't have to,2:52and it's not a sin to do it.2:54This is called2:55davar hareshut. So he says, this makom churban represents3:01machshevet hareshut, doing things that the Torah didn't tell you you have to do,3:03and obviously not things that you're not allowed to do.3:05Things are optional.3:06He says, why don't you enter there?3:08You can't enter there alone. Why not?3:11Mipnei hachashad. So one answer in the Gemara is because you're not allowed to enter an abandoned place3:16because people might suspect you, even if you're really good,3:19but there's a suspicion that maybe you're meeting up with someone over there3:23to run after your desires.3:25So he says also, there's a3:27chashad if you're going to do something that's not a mitzvah necessarily,3:31sheyachshod le'atzmo, you have to always suspect yourself.3:35Why are you doing it?3:36Hashem didn't tell you to do it.3:37Why are you doing it?3:38You have to always question yourself, challenge yourself.3:41What's driving me to do this thing?3:43Perhaps there's a certain taavah, certain desires that you're running afterwards.3:48The other explanation in the Gemara why you can't enter in abandoned places is because of mazikin,3:52and he explains what that represents.3:53Umipnei hamazikin. The other reason is, it could be mazikin.3:56What does that mean?4:00The kol makom hapanui mikedushah, yesh makom lamazikin vekoach hayetzer gover. As we know a4:02rule, the rule is that whenever there's no—there's no such thing as empty space.4:08If there's an empty space, that means it's empty of4:11kedusha. There's room, or there's a chance for the4:15yetzer hara, which is represented by the mazikin, to get in there.4:18If you have something to do that's not something of a mitzvah,4:23then there's room for the yetzer hara to come and attack4:26and to interfere and to disturb the person.4:29That's the second reason the Gemara gives.4:31And the Gemara gives yet a third reason,4:35that it could be a physical sakana,4:37that if you enter an abandoned place,4:39it's not a place that's been maintained.4:42Especially back in their days, their cement wasn't really,4:45their structures were not really on the best.4:47The Gemara talks constantly,4:49especially in different4:50masechtot, they kind of designated to talk about these kind of structures,4:54that they always need maintenance,4:55and sometimes they could be shaky4:57and they could just collapse on the person.4:58A person could die there.4:59So this was a very common thing, unfortunately, in those days.5:03So he says, the Gemara says also5:05you can't enter an abandoned place,5:09mipnei hamapolet. Why? Because it might just collapse on the person,5:11and the whole thing might fall on the person and kill the person.5:14He says,5:15u'mipnei hapolet. The Gemara gives a third reason,5:17is that maybe the thing might collapse on you.5:19It's sakana.5:20What does that represent?5:21He says,5:25destam chovara raa, sheein la kiyum, kemo sheamru. So he says,5:26we know that the reason why you can't enter an abandoned place,5:31because it's not maintained.5:31Because it's not maintained, it's very shaky.5:33And things that are shaky5:35could fall down and break apart very easily.5:38What does that represent?5:40He said that represents5:43shaker, as Chazal tell us,5:45shaker ein lo raglayim. Chazal tell us the famous words in the Midrash,5:48that shaker lies don't have legs.5:54So, simply meaning that, you know,5:57eventually a lie will be caught.6:00People can only escape with a lie6:03for a certain amount of time,6:04but after a while,6:05you know, their lies are discovered.6:07People discover that this guy is cheating in business,6:09and this guy is stealing from other people,6:11and this guy is not faithful,6:12and this lady is not faithful to her husband.6:15Lies are eventually discovered.6:16You can't hold on to a lie for so long.6:21But, and we all know the6:23derasha, sheker actually stands,6:24all these letters,6:26shin, kuf, resh,6:27all stand on one leg,6:29as opposed to6:30emet, that each one has two legs;6:31they stand more solid.6:33Okay, that's a6:34remez. But we learn from this concept,6:37sheker ein lo raglayim, is that it's very shaky.6:38A lie is very shaky.6:40When a person lies,6:41like I said,6:42eventually it's bound to be exposed.6:44Every lie is bound to be6:45exposed. We see by the6:47parashah, and by everywhere.6:48Even in history,6:48we discover things later on6:50of what people did,6:51you know, in the past.6:53So,6:55sheker ein lo raglayim represents the6:57mapolit. That's another thing where a person7:00cannot enter a davar reshut alone7:03without obviously discussing it with daat Torah,7:06because it could be that there's lies;7:08you're fooling yourself.7:09So, three reasons over here7:11that Chazal told us not to enter a bed in place.7:13Number one is,7:14why should you not enter a bed in place?7:18Because of7:20ta'avah, because of7:21chashad, suspicion of7:22ta'avot. Number two is because of7:25mazikin, that's the7:27yetzer hara. And number three is7:28because of the7:30mapolit, which represents the concept of a lie.7:32Yeah, when you do things7:33that's not a7:34mitzvah, again, it's not an7:35aveirah, you always have to suspect that,7:37hey, what's really pulling me?7:39Or it could be something that's,7:41you know, illusional.7:42It's a7:43sheker. It's things that will7:44collapse afterwards.7:45You have to think about it very well7:47before you do7:47it. That's what we're saying.7:49Says Rav, now,7:50in the story of7:51Rabbi Yose, he entered there to pray,7:53and it's clear that,7:57ואפילו לצורך עבודה להתפלל אין נכנסים, ויכול להתפלל בדרך. If you have a better option, you...8:00Not supposed to enter there, as Eliyahu Hanavi tells Rabbi Yosi, you should have prayed8:04b'derech. What's the derech? What does it represent?8:09B'derech hu derech hamelech, filon mefulash avodat Hashem. If there's a smoother way to go, if you see there's a successful path in8:18avodat Hashem, you don't need to create a new path. You know, sometimes you look and you see that there are systems that work.8:25You look at yeshivot that have existed for hundreds and thousands of years,8:31as Chazal tells, even Avraham Avinu had a yeshiva.8:34It's a tradition, a mesorah that we have of how to run a yeshiva, how things should be run.8:39Yes, challenges in each generation, each times we have to adjust a little bit,8:43but the ikar mesorah has to be passed down.8:46And we see those systems work, yet sometimes people come, they, as they say in English,8:50they want to reinvent the wheel. They want to, like, let's try to come up with a new idea.8:55But why? The system is working. If it's working, so keep it.9:00Oh, there's some faults? Fix the faults. Don't reinvent the wheel,9:05right? You have a flat tire, you don't take out the whole tire,9:07you just get a new rubber or whatever it is, or the new bubble.9:12You don't throw out the whole car. You just fix the9:16wheel. So that's the idea also of derech hamelech.9:20If a person has a path, let's say, if there's no path, you're stuck, maybe.9:24But when you're coming to do something, it's not a mitzvah, but whatever you want to do,9:28even when your ultimate goal is for a mitzvah, you got to question yourself,9:32what's pushing you to do this? Perhaps it's your own personal9:37ta'avot, and you got to be careful. There's going to be a tremendous amount of challenge in the9:40yetzer hara that's going to challenge you, and also might be illusional.9:45You might think of things, but it could be just sheker. People put ideas in your head.9:50So he says,9:54Ve'af al pi shederech hamelech hu maleh me'ovrei derachim. Now, in the story of the Gemara, if you tell me that the derech represents9:58that the path... That, you know, people take, but it says in the Gemara10:02that there's a lot of travelers on that road,10:05and many people. He says, והם מפסיקין להולך בדרך השם, and they can interrupt you from your prayer.10:09Still, even though you might have been interrupted10:13by other people, right? They're going to interrupt you. They're going to disturb your kavanah.10:18It's better to pray there than to go into10:20a churban. Still, he says,10:27מוטב לעבוד שם עבודה קצרה, כפי יכולת, מלהיכנס לחורבה מחשבת חוץ לצורך עבודה. Better to go in the path, even though there might be disturbances10:31amongst the way, and to do it that way,10:34than to try to, like we said, reinvent the wheel.10:38I'll give you one idea, one practical thing.10:40When I first entered yeshiva, it was a new concept for me10:43at the age of 18,10:46and when you want to study, it's not like I studied much, Baruch Hashem, you10:50know, I was blessed with different talents of how to get the answers for10:54tests. But in any case, when I wanted to study in the past, if I really needed to study, I needed10:59complete quiet. So to come to yeshiva and you enter a beit midrash,11:03everybody's learning, and there's a lot of noise, right? So sometimes a person might11:07fool himself and say, No, I need some quiet time on the side.11:12Maybe certain times call for it. But in general,11:15we see that sitting in the beit midrash, even though it's very loud, actually works.11:19Actually works very well, because it may have a disadvantage11:24at very, very few times, but the advantage most of the time11:27is that it encourages you to come. There's many people there,11:30and if you don't come, you feel like you left out. People are there to realize if you're sitting in the room11:35by yourself learning, you don't really have somebody to be on top of you telling you,11:39Hey, where have you been? So being part of a group, or being11:44in an area where there's a large group, actually is very, very, very good.11:47There's certain people, individuals throughout history of Klal Yisrael that did11:51better when they were alone, but those are the exception, not the rule.11:55Now you want to go and you want to start your own thing. You want to learn your own thing in your own house.11:58As I know one person came back from yeshiva, says, I'm going to learn my own. I'm going to sit in my house12:03and learn all day. Yeah, it might be good the first couple of days, but12:07eventually it breaks apart. There's a mapolet. It breaks down.12:12You start getting distracted. There's your phone.12:15You go on your phone. You go on the computer. And if there's a TV in the house,12:19you get distracted by the TV. And if you have kids in the house,12:23whether they're your own kids or other members in the family,12:26you get disturbed by that. Then you go to the kitchen a little bit more,12:30and there's some housework to do. There's always things that come up.12:34So don't try to reinvent the wheel. There's a system that works.12:37Yeah, but if I go to beis medrash, there's other people there also. Sometimes they come over, they talk.12:41You're right. There are other people there, and they could disturb you at times,12:45and somebody will, as they say, chap a shmooze with you, and somebody will perhaps distract you here and there.12:50Well, you got to first of all set certain boundaries, but even once in a while you get distracted,12:55still it's better that way than the other system.13:01Good. However, if there's a newly abandoned place,13:06which means it's been abandoned only for the last year or whatever,13:11in that case, Gemara says it's better that way.13:14That one you could enter.13:16He13:21says, It's not good enough to enter in an abandoned place that's only been abandoned recently.13:26You must enter with somebody else, and that's what he's telling you also.13:29You want to try that new path. It's not so new, actually.13:34It's an abandoned place maybe, but you're going with somebody else.13:38And it can't be with anybody, Gemara says. It has to be with people, the Gemara says,13:42kesherim, that are what? Kosher people, the people that shouldn't suspect you.13:45Because if you go and hang out with somebody, you still have the reason of13:48chashad. The Gemara says if you go with somebody that's suspicious, that somebody's known to be a13:52baal aveirah, so what'd you gain? You're still entering a place with, you know,13:55you still have the problem that people might suspect you going to do an aveirah because you're entering.13:59So therefore, if you're going with people that are14:03kesherim and in a newly abandoned place, basically not so off the path,14:08shekol kavanatan la'avodat Hashem, and these people's kavanah are to serve14:14HaKadosh Baruch Hu. And the Gemara says also it's not out there in the wild where nobody knows about it. We look at it,14:19and like we said, in an abandoned place or in a far place away from civilization14:24where the yetzer hara could have a power over them, that's okay.14:28But you see, it's done al pi daat Torah. It's done with the approval of the chachamim. That's14:33ikar. So to be mechadesh, for a person to come up with a novelty, a new concept in Judaism,14:39we've always had that. But it's done by people14:42that are kesherim or through the advice of people14:45that are kesherim. And like we said, a person always has to be careful of and know, be aware of the faults14:52or the problems that could come along the way.