Torah · MussarMussar30. Lesson From אליהו הנביא & ר׳ יוסיTzidkat HaTzadikPart 30Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 9, 2022−15Play+30Position0:005:30Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat haTzadik, ot0:02lamed. The next piece is actually a small piece,0:05and he proves it based on the0:07Gemara. So if you haven't heard number 29,0:09we quoted the Gemara over there0:11with Eliyahu Hanavi and0:12Rabbi Yose. If you know the story in the beginning of0:14Masechet Berachot, daf gimmel amud aleph,0:16of Eliyahu Hanavi and0:17Rabbi Yose, it makes it easier.0:19So he brings a very nice idea0:22based on that story.0:23Let's first see the idea0:26and then see how he proves it from the story.0:27He says,0:33Af ma'aseh she'eina hagunah be'etzem. Even an action that a person does,0:36which in essence0:38is not 100%0:43okay, kol shehi hagunah kefi machshavat ha'adam. So long as0:46it's0:48okay, or a person0:49who's doing it feels that he's doing something right,0:52also0:53condition number two, vehi ma'aseh mitzvah, and it's also0:56a mitzvah.0:58It's not like an aveirah. It's something that a person0:59is doing; it's actually a mitzvah.1:04Rak shehayah lo la'asotah al tzad yoter tov. The only thing is,1:05the guy should have done it in a better way,1:13okay? Ein lanu limnoa mimenu asiyatah. If we observe somebody doing it,1:15we should not stop1:17him. Interesting, no?1:18Again, let's put it in simple words.1:21When you see somebody else doing something,1:26okay, and he's doing1:27something that actually he thinks1:29that he's doing is right,1:30and it's not1:33an aveirah, you know, and he's trying to do mitzvah,1:34the only thing is he could have been doing it better.1:37So he's going to bring the proof first1:38from the Gemara. We're going to see an example1:39from the Gemara, and then we'll try to bring maybe an example in our case.1:43So he says,1:44so if we see the person doing it,1:46even though he should have been doing it,1:47he should have done it in a better way,1:50we don't have to stop him.1:52Why?1:53We see this. What do we learn this from? From Eliyahu1:56Hanavi. It says by the story that we quoted1:58in 29 in Gemara1:59that Eliyahu Hanavi came and2:02saw Rabbi Yose enter2:05an abandoned area2:06in Yerushalayim, and he prayed.2:08And he stood and he waited for him2:10by the door.2:11Only when he concluded his2:13prayer, Eliyahu Hanavi tells him,2:14You should not have went inside.2:16You should have prayed outside.2:17Why don't you stop him beforehand?2:19So he says,2:21that's exactly the lesson2:25from him. He waited until he finished his tefillah, ולא אמר לו תכף. He waited for him.2:27And he waited2:28for him to2:29pray, and then he told him. Why didn't he stop him right away2:32to teach him a lesson?2:33Teach him this lesson before he walks in.2:35He knows he's going in to2:36pray, so stop him from right beforehand.2:38So you see that the rule that we said.2:41It's better that he would have done it2:42outside. The guy thinks he's doing something good.2:44Okay, let him do it.2:46You can teach him afterwards,2:47but you don't have to stop him from doing it.2:49So what's an example that we could give?2:51Well, we could give an example2:53by, let's say, a2:55person. You see a person learning Torah,2:57and he's learning it, let's say,2:59through using, you know, a commentary3:04or3:04books that make it easier.3:06And the guy is learning Gemara.3:07The real way of learning Gemara3:09is very simple. You have to learn3:10and try to figure out how to learn Gemara.3:12The guy's sitting there learning through3:14ArtScroll. ArtScroll kind of speaks out everything,3:16which is great, fantastic. You really get a clear picture3:19of the Gemara. The only thing is,3:21you'll never become3:23a good learner in3:25Gemara unless you actually use your mind.3:26It's kind of like exercising.3:28If somebody—if you're coming to lift up weights,3:31if somebody is helping you lift them up the whole time3:33and not letting you actually do some of the3:35heavy lifting,3:36you'll never build that muscle.3:38Okay, but he's doing it3:40for what? He wants to learn Torah.3:42And although he's not doing it 100% the right way,3:44okay, we have to stop him from doing it.3:46And there are many examples like that,3:48especially3:49by baalei teshuva. They're trying to do something good.3:51They're going to be doing more3:53lechatchila, okay? They're kashrut also,3:55right? You know that there's a certain standard of kashrut,3:59okay? And you've researched it,4:01not like you just heard.4:01You've researched it, and you4:04hold of this higher level of4:05kashrut. Now you have this guy4:07who's a baal teshuva, and he's coming, he wants to keep kosher,4:10and he's now, he's eating from the kashrut4:12that maybe you're on hold of so much.4:14You don't hold of it because4:15maybe they don't hold to your standard,4:16they don't hold such4:19chumrot. We're not talking about that they're mamash taref. So the guy thinks he's doing something right,4:21he's eating4:22kosher, but, you know, he could hold on a higher level.4:25Don't stop him. Let him eat that kosher thing.4:28It's something.4:29It's good. You want to teach him, you teach him later,4:31but you don't have to stop him and say,4:32Don't eat that. You would not want to eat it,4:35of course. You're on a higher level.4:36You have higher standards.4:38But this guy who's coming in4:40and he, you know, he's going from taref to kosher,4:42don't stop him from doing it.4:44Next part in the bracket he brings down4:48other options maybe why4:49Eliyahu Hanavi didn't stop him,4:51meaning to say, although you can learn this lesson4:53from the story,4:55he says maybe4:57another reason that you could say that he didn't stop him,4:59maybe because,5:03אולי לבל יתבלבל בתפילה, maybe he's home going in5:05and he was about to pray,5:06and he was already preparing himself for prayer.5:08It's not like us, we just jump5:09into the Amidah. He actually was preparing himself,5:11and maybe he didn't stop because he didn't want to confuse him5:14in his kavanah, even though the right thing was to do a prayer outside.5:18And5:19again, he has different,5:20maybe different approaches,5:22but he sticks to his lesson5:24that he told us in the5:25beginning, and we could also learn the same lesson5:28from Rav Sadok.