Torah · MussarMussar24. How Long Should One Sleep?Tzidkat HaTzadikPart 24Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 1, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0010:41Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot chaf dalet.0:03So the next few otiyot, in each one, Rav Tzadok HaKohen0:08gives a little bit of a remez, or a little bit of a deeper understanding of the0:14simanim in the language, in the words that Chazal have used to describe the0:19simanim. As we explained already, the Gemara says that the0:22mishmar—there are three mishmarot in the evening, which means that the night is divided into three parts,0:25as some say it's four0:27parts—and the siman to note when the end of each one is,0:33is things happen at that time.0:35So the first one, it says the chamor is0:39ne'or, which pashut pshat means, you know, he just makes noise.0:42The second one is the dogs bark,0:44and the third one is the baby starts to nurse and husband and wife start conversating.0:49So now that Rav Tzadok HaKohen is going to go take on the words that the Gemara uses,0:54and he's going to explain something a little bit on a deeper level.0:57It happens to be this particular piece in chaf dalet becomes a little bit of a1:02halacha, like he brings an interesting side point that kind of proves a certain idea in1:06halacha. So I hope it doesn't get too complicated,1:08but we're not going to spend so much time on it,1:11but we'll see.1:12Let's read it inside.1:14I am skipping the brackets, as usual, because those brackets are side points that he brings up,1:20and let's begin.1:23Mishmar rishon balayla, chamor no'er. Chazal tell us that on the siman for the conclusion of the first mishmar in the evening1:29is that the donkey makes noise.1:32What does it mean,1:32no'er? No'er could also be from the word1:34ne'or, means he's awake.1:36So he says, like I said, it's a little bit of a halachic point.1:39Says,1:42shene'or adayin, lefi shehu zman shel chinuch kapro bnei adam. Means he's still up.1:44He's making noise,1:45he's still up,1:46because it's still time for people to go to sleep.1:51Meaning, most people don't go to sleep in the1:53middle, but in that time frame, that first mishmar is when people start to go to sleep.1:57Most people are starting to go to sleep at that time.1:59It says,2:07says until that time, you could still hear him because he's still up.2:10But afterwards, they tie him up to his place where he's eating.2:15The ebus is basically the food bucket where he's eating from.2:21They tie him up over there, and they keep him there for the rest of the night.2:24But he's still up at that time because still people are still up.2:28However,2:32dogs you can still hear.2:34Why? Unlike donkeys. Donkeys are animals that you don't let,2:37just, you know, if you're owner of a donkey, you don't let them go wild.2:41You know, it's kind of, you have to, like, put them in the barn afterwards.2:43So the fact that you can hear means that the owner is still up.2:47He just didn't park him in.2:49The second mishmar, you hear the dogs.2:52Why don't you hear the donkeys?2:54They might be up, but it doesn't make sense.2:55You don't hear the donkeys because they're already in the barn.2:58But dogs usually run wild.3:00They don't get tied up.3:02Now, even if they're caged in, still they run around.3:06They don't stay, you know, they don't stay tied up for the whole entire evening.3:08So he says that's why the dogs you could still hear by the second mishmar,3:13because they run freely.3:16And he explains, right, that this represents the idea of3:21tza'aka b'tefillah, which is only in the heart,3:24and then the side point.3:28Ub'tchilat mishmar shlishit, now the beginning of the third mishmar,3:30which is really right after the dog's bark,3:32שוב נעורים, they wake up again.3:36וכן אין זמן שינה רק משמר אחד. It comes out that really...3:40The time to sleep is really when?3:43Only from the end of the first mishmar3:46until the beginning of the third mishmar,3:50because, like we3:51said, v'hainu arba sha'ot, which comes out to be about four hours.3:53Remember, the evening usually is divided,3:55the day is divided into two parts,3:57and there are 24 hours in the day,3:59and each day has 12 hours.4:01And the 12 hours are divided into three parts4:03because we said there are three mishmarot,4:05so it comes out that each part is four hours.4:07So if we're saying that you hear the donkey4:09at the end of the first mishmar,4:11it means that the donkey people are still up4:13because they haven't tied them in.4:15Good?4:16So now, right afterwards, you don't hear the donkey4:18because it's time to go to sleep.4:20As the Gemara says, that's the time when most people go to sleep.4:24Now, the dogs bark at the end of the third mishmar,4:27and already even couples,4:31they wake up at the end of the third mishmar.4:32But the beginning of the third mishmar,4:33already people are starting to wake up.4:36So he says it comes out that the time to sleep is four hours,4:38since there are three mishmarot in the evening,4:40each one is four hours.4:41It comes out that the time to sleep is really4:44arba sha'ot. That's one way of explaining4:48the Gemara.4:50And the Gemara—one second,4:53but don't people wake up at the end of the mishmar?4:55So it's a machloket in the Gemara.4:57One opinion in the Gemara says that4:59people start to awaken,5:01you know, when that third siman,5:03when couples start to wake up.5:05One opinion in the Gemara says5:05they start to awaken at the beginning of the third mishmar.5:10So it comes out that the Gemara is defining5:13how long a person should sleep.5:14According to that opinion,5:15sleep is around four hours in the evening.5:18According to the second opinion—5:20That people who start to5:22converse, they converse usually the end of the third mishmar,5:24which means that's when people, humans, start to wake up.5:27So if so, it comes out that, he says,5:31zman5:33shemoneh sha'ot, comes out that the time of recommended sleep is about eight hours,5:36and that fits how the Rambam was posek in5:39Hilchot De'ot, perek5:39daled, halacha daled. The Rambam was5:41posek that a person should get eight hours of sleep.5:45To understand the depth of the Rambam,5:47he's posek like,5:47you see, like the Leshna Batra,5:49like the second opinion in the Gemara,5:50as his style is in many places.5:52The Rambam usually possek like the leshna batra.5:57Over there, the Tosafot says5:59that on the Gemara,5:59the Gemara says,6:00Lo6:03nivra layla ela l'shinta. The night was only created for sleeping.6:05That's what the Gemara says over there.6:07Says Tosafot,6:08Kemo lele tekufat tamuz,6:10like the night in the summer.6:12The6:13nights in the summer are usually very short, right?6:16But again,6:17they're about6:18shmoneh sha'ot. They're considered like about eight hours in6:20Eretz Yisrael. It's not twelve hours;6:21it's eight hours,6:23because usually a twelve-hour night,6:26although we calculate it as twelve hours in6:29halacha, but it's a much shorter night6:31because the days are very, very long,6:36right? So, leta'anidim b'chamisha asar b'Av, tzarich lehosif, v'hainu mechatzit tekufat tamuz6:40u'mechatzit ul'ma'ala, matchilet ligdel halayla. There's something called tekufat tamuz.6:42We know that there are seasons,6:44and the Gemara also recognizes there are seasons.6:47In fact, the Torah also talks about seasons.6:48The only thing is,6:49we call the seasons fall, winter, spring, and summer.6:55The Gemara calls them by the names of what we know as months.6:59So the Gemara will say, for example,7:00tekufat7:01Tevet, which is what we would call winter;7:03tekufat Nisan,7:04what we call spring;7:05tekufat Tamuz,7:07what we call summer;7:09and there's something called tekufat7:12Tishrei, which is what we call fall.7:14Tekufat Tamuz is what we call summer.7:17Good,7:17and the Gemara says7:19that in7:21hamisha asar b'Av, which is smack in the middle of the summer,7:23already the night starts to get longer and longer.7:27As we know right now7:28happens to be we're in these days of June,7:30wherever you are in the world,7:31unless you're below the7:34hemisphere—I mean not hemisphere,7:36below the7:37equator—so then everybody usually on the upper part of the world,7:41right, not in Argentina,7:42but in the upper part of the world,7:44North America and all these places,7:45Middle East,7:47your summer days will be much longer than your winter days.7:52So, and in June especially,7:54that's when the day is the longest.7:56As we get closer,7:58or as we get deeper into...8:00The summer, in the middle of the summer, which is the8:03chamsha asar b'Av already, the Gemara says at that time already the night starts to get longer,8:06and the Gemara says over there you're supposed to add in the night, you're supposed to add more time to learn.8:20So he says over here, again, lefi shehatzilah olam k'siyum v'ad chati ket halayla. In any case, he says, why is it that the night starts to get longer8:24from the middle of the summer?8:26He says because we find this concept all the time in all other places,8:30that any time up to middle of something, we find that that's already considered the main part,8:36as we have the concept called8:38rubo k'kulo. Whenever you have something in halacha,8:40where you do the majority of something, you might consider like you did the whole entire thing.8:43We find in many different places.8:45We find in issur, for example, of let's say,8:47according to opinions that say you can't bathe yourself on Yom Tov8:50— not the opinions, everybody holds that way8:52— but the halacha brings down also,8:55you can bathe part of your body, but8:58rubo k'kulo. If you bathe the majority of your body, it's like you bathed your entire body, which is a problem.9:02Not talking about showering, we're talking about bathing.9:03It's a whole big sugya, I don't want to get into it.9:05In any case, you see this concept, rubo k'kulo, all over.9:08Same thing also over here,9:09that tekufat Tamuz, which is known to be the time of the shortest night,9:14when that's the time you can get a full night's sleep, because it's only eight hours,9:19that goes up up to middle of the tekufah, because already once you pass the middle,9:25you're already considered9:34rov and rubo k'kulo. VehaArizal katav deshitin neshmei shisha shaot hayaim bMikdash. Again, it's all a halachic point.9:36He brings now the Arizal.9:38The Arizal's famous thing is that when the Gemara says that, you know, when you sleep sixty neshmei, sixty breaths,9:45and it says in the Zohar that David HaMelech never surpassed more than sixty breaths,9:51according to the Arizal that means six hours.9:53In halacha, the pashtanim don't learn it that way.9:56They learn it about a minute or something, something very, very short.10:00But according to the Arizal, that means six hours.10:02But basically, in this piece, like I told you, it's more of a halachic idea.10:06It's trying to show you the different opinions of how long a person needs to sleep.10:09And happens to be, medically, it's more like between the Arizal and the Rambam.10:14We saw one shitah holds four hours, another shitah holds six hours,10:17that's the Arizal,10:18and the Rambam is posek you need eight hours.10:20Everybody says we recommend you should sleep eight hours if you have full energy.10:23Most of us realistically sleep between four to six hours.10:26Below four hours is like you're really deprived.10:29Eventually your body will catch up to itself and make sure to knock you out.10:32But interesting, the Rav Sadok brings the three shitot,10:36and we know, happens to be, most people sleep within that range.