Torah · MussarMussar224A. The Different Levels of Commitment to TorahTzidkat HaTzadikPart 224Rabbi Uri Nahum · October 29, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0014:55Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Sefat HaTzadik, ot reish chav-daled, 224. It's a long piece in 224. We'll see if we could pull it off in two recordings,0:10might be half to split into three, we'll see.0:14Kol adam tzarich lekabel alav ol malchut shamayim bechol yom betachlit0:24hatokef, shemitratzeh limtzor atzmo legamrei ulekalel mimkoro. Big sentence. It says every single person has to accept upon himself the yoke of heaven.0:30What does it mean, the yoke of heaven? It means the responsibility. He has to accept upon himself the responsibility to do everything that Hashem, HaKadosh Baruch Hu, gives him.0:40Now, responsibility could go for a long way. There's a lot of different definitions of responsibility.0:48There are people that, you know, have a certain responsibility, but when they see a little bit of struggle, they forego that responsibility.0:57For example, a person who accepts a job. So when a person accepts a job, they take responsibility. They're going to show up, they're going to work, they're going to perform whatever is being asked of them.1:08So usually on the first day, many, many people are committed, and they take full responsibility.1:14And that commitment actually is a very, very strong commitment, because even things come up, even things happen on that day, on that first day to work,1:25they'll still somehow figure out or manage to get to work. That's most people.1:35However, however, when things get a little bit rougher, a lot of people may just say, you know, what do I need this job? And they don't take the responsibility.1:42So for example, let's say a person is hired to work as a manager at a certain store, and The store has a lot of complaining customers.1:53So, ma li lakeva zeh? What do I need this headache for?1:59And by the way, what they could do or what they might do is say, okay, they're not gonna work anymore.2:04They're not gonna come to work because they don't need this headache, in their words.2:09They don't need that, you know, complaining from all these customers.2:13So that would be not really fully committed.2:17You took responsibility, but when it got a little rough, the person doesn't show up.2:21And of course, it can be many things along the way.2:24Now, when we come every day and we say,2:27Shema Yisrael, Adonai Eloheinu, Adonai Echad, Chazal tell us that's called2:32ol malchut Shamayim, we're accepting upon ourselves the responsibility and the commitment to do whatever HaKadosh Baruch Hu asks of us.2:38But to what extent? How far?2:40So that's what he's saying over here. A person has to do it to the extreme,2:45to the extreme that he's ready to completely give up everything2:51so this way he can be part of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.2:54Which is interesting. This is why, perhaps, now perhaps,2:57but we know that a person is supposed to have these words, Shema Yisrael, Adonai Eloheinu, Adonai Echad, on his lips.3:03These are the last words on a person's lips before he departs from this world.3:06The idea also that even in the last moment,3:10as Chazal tell us the story of Rabbi Akiva, as he was being killed and he was saying3:14Shema, and his students tell him, Rabbi, ad kan? You're saying3:19Shema Yisrael even now in this moment? He says, Of course. What do you mean?3:21This is the moment I've been waiting for.3:23The idea is that the person to take full responsibility all the way through and through.3:31This is exactly what Rabbi Akiva was trying to impart to his3:35students. He says, now this responsibility, this commitment comes,3:39v'hu parashah, v'zo parashah rishonah d'Kriat Shema.3:43This is represented by, or this is done by the first paragraph of Shema.3:54The second paragraph of Kriyat Shema, Chazal tell us,3:58it says the pasuk, v'asafta daganecha. A person has to collect his grain.4:04Chazal from there learn that a person, although he's supposed to be committed to learning Torah,4:11also he's supposed to be4:15noheg bahem minhag derech eretz. What does it mean, minhag derech eretz? He's also supposed to incorporate in his life also the ability to,4:20or not the ability, but the, you know, to work and to basically make a livelihood.4:27Shub4:28l'shon rabim. Now, it's interesting, for those who are l'fisheim what I'm about to say,4:32but there's a famous—let me take a pause for a second,4:36and even if you don't know, I'll just start from the beginning.4:39Let's start like this.4:41There is a famous explanation from4:47Rav Chaim Volozhin, who was the first Rosh Yeshiva of the yeshiva4:50Volozhin, a student of the4:52Gaon of Vilna, who has a sefer called Nefesh4:53HaChaim. In his famous book over there, he explains about the difference between5:00the first and the second paragraph of Kriyat Shema.5:03He says, if you notice in the first paragraph of Kriyat Shema, it's talking in singular.5:09It says,5:09v'ahavta et5:15Adonai Elohecha b'chol levavcha uvchol nafshecha, le'ot al yadecha, v'hayu l'totafot bein einecha. All this is in singular.5:17Hashem is speaking to an individual.5:19In the second paragraph, it's talking of Kriyat Shema,5:22it says a lot of the same things, but it talks in lashon rabim,5:26talks in plural,5:27talks to many people.5:30As it says,5:35ukshartem otam le'ot al yedchem, v'hayu l'totafot bein einechem. You should tie them,5:36and over there the you, again, it's very hard to translate in English,5:39but those who understand the Hebrew realize that it's talking in plural.5:43So that's question number one.5:44Why is the language different?5:47Why in the first paragraph it's talking to an individual,5:50and the second paragraph it's talking to what seems to be to a group of people?5:54The second question he has is that the first paragraph all talks about the commitment to HaKadosh Baruch Hu,6:02loving Hashem, putting on tefillin, you know, mezuzah.6:09That's all it talks about.6:10And the second paragraph, it also talks about v'asafta deganecha,6:14collecting the grains and harvesting,6:17and basically talks about gashmiyut things, materialistic things6:22and materialistic gains from doing6:24the mitzvot. So he has this famous answer based on the Gemara Masechet6:29Berachot. The Gemara Masechet Berachot says that there's a machloket between Rabbi Yishmael and Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai.6:34According to Rabbi Yishmael, a person is supposed to basically what we call work and learn.6:38A person is supposed to study Torah,6:39but at the same time you have to have times also when you're supposed to work and earn a6:44livelihood. And Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai says if a person is going to be busy earning a livelihood,6:48there's always a season and he's always going to be busy,6:51and when is there going to be a real commitment to Torah?6:53Therefore, only learn Torah and Hashem will take care of you.6:55And the Gemara says that many individuals tried to do like both rabbis.6:59Those who tried to do like Rabbi Yishmael were successful,7:01and those who tried to do like Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai were not successful.7:06Now, I didn't exactly quote the Gemara verbatim because it would sound something in the Gemara7:10that many people tried, but some were successful,7:13but most in general were not successful like Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai.7:17Comes the Rabbi Chaim Vital, who lived actually in the 1800s, in the early 1800s,7:23and he says that these two paragraphs are actually talking about two different individuals.7:28There are those individuals that could commit themselves totally, totally to Torah.7:33They are what we call the klei kodesh.7:36They are the ones who completely are committed to learning Torah,7:39to distributing the teaching Torah.7:41They are those individuals.7:43That's the people who tried like Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai and were able to be successful.7:48And those individuals are the ones that are mentioned,7:51that the first paragraph of Kriat Shema is talking to.7:54That's why it's talking in singular, because there's not so many of them.7:57There's a few of them, not so many of them.8:00The second paragraph is talking to the hamon am, to everybody else.8:03And those are the people that weren't able to do, as Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai said,8:08but they're able to do like Rabbi Yishmael said, which is what,8:12learn Torah at the same time, balancing it together with earning a livelihood.8:17Those are the two different paragraphs, and that's why it mentions in the second paragraph,8:22you know, going out and harvesting and planting and working.8:26And it's also talking in lashon rabbim, talking to the multitudes, because most of the people are of this second type,8:34not of the first type. There's only a few that can be committed to that.8:41And this is Rabbi Chaim Vital—I mean, Rabbi Chaim Volozhin. I don't know if Rav Tzadok saw the sefer of Rabbi8:45Chaim Volozhin. They did live around the same time. You could say perhaps Rav Tzadok was a little bit later.8:49But before we continue, you're going to see that this piece is amazing,8:54that because Rav Tzadok himself says pretty much what Rav Chaim Volozhin says.8:59And since he doesn't quote him, it seems like he's saying it on his own,9:02because many times when he does say something, he keeps on saying,9:06Vera'iti, and I saw, and I once heard. Here he doesn't say anything like that,9:10and it seems to be on his own. So it's an amazing idea. So listen to this. He says9:16that when we said in the9:20pasuk, it says that, it's been said in plural,9:29and the Gemara says that many people tried to do like Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, which means to commit themselves to...9:35Torah learning without figuring out how to make a livelihood,9:39but they weren't successful,9:42as Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai was, right? Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai was in the cave and he was able to survive.9:48The yefshar l'rabim, because for the rabim, for the majority of the Jewish people to be on this level, it's not possible.9:55Ulchol ha'olam kulo lihyot k'Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, or the whole world to be like Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, that's not possible.10:00That's why it also doesn't mention,10:06v'ahavta et Adonai Elohecha b'chol levavcha, b'chol nafshecha, b'chol me'odecha. That's only mentioned in the first paragraph.10:18V'chol me'odecha is your money, shekirush mamoncha, lehafkir hakol, to be able to give up everything for HaKadosh Baruch Hu. It says, ein olam l'rabim. That's not for the10:24multitudes. Tzrichim linhog b'derech eretz v'hashgiach al mamonam. The majority of the people actually need to live, be part of this world,10:30and to actually keep an eye on their bank account and how much they're making, how much they're10:37earning.10:40Gam ken lihyot b'ma l'hitparnes b'kiyum chayatam, also to be able to have some sort of income to be able to10:45support themselves and their families. That's the majority of the people.10:50V'nikra parashah zu ol mitzvot. That's why the second paragraph is what Hazal refer to, accepting upon yourself the yoke10:56of mitzvot, which, in, I would say, easier language, I like to refer to it as11:03committing to keeping the mitzvot under all circumstances.11:13Ol mitzvot sherak mekabel ol mitzvotav yitbarach la'avodah ulshomrah, la'avodah ulshomrah ulgabotim laTorah. That's a person who commits to keeping the Torah as much as possible, to learning the Torah,11:19and to set times to learn Torah, and at the same time also he has to keep his job.11:25But, you know, he has a job to go to and he works, but again, that work has to be al pi Torah.11:36V'chol kefi koach adam v'lo latzet megvul umiddat derech eretz la'olam hazeh. But all these things, whatever he's committed to, he's committed to it11:40according to his ability, again, to balance his ability to make an income,11:50to make a parnassah, to make... It's basically to go to work and to earn an income to support his family.11:56However, the first paragraph, the first paragraph of Kriat Shema, ... Hashem koreh ... First paragraph is talking about the few individuals, individuals, as the famous word in English is12:10the elitist, the other elitist. There's no question there are people, you know, the geniuses, let's say, for example,12:17this is the elitist intellectual abilities. They're not so common; they're very rare.12:23But there is such a thing as a genius. We know that. Not common, very rare, but there is such a12:28thing, and we don't feel bad for it. There's just people that are born geniuses.12:32Everybody is given his own abilities. There are the elitists in Klal Yisrael. Those are the people12:38like Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai and the likes that can be totally immersed in Torah without any care for anything else.12:43For them, the first paragraph says that when you love Hashem, it says,12:47V'ahavta b'chol me'odecha. We love Him with all your money,12:53hainu lihyot mufkar legamrei, to completely give up everything completely.12:59V'zehu ol malchut shamayim v'ol Torah, and that's the idea of accepting upon yourself the yoke of heaven and the yoke of Torah.13:04What does that mean? Again, to be committed totally to13:08HaKadosh Baruch Hu and to the Torah. That's what the first paragraph represents.13:15... as Chazal say, somebody once told a rabbi, you know, that his kids are hungry, they13:20need—he says, Well, there's some food left in the pan. Let them go pick it up from there.13:24It's not food; there's reeds. Let them go pick it up and let them sell it. Meaning to say,13:28let them figure it out. I'm totally immersed in Torah, and Hashem has a way to support them.13:38There's a few statements of Chazal he's quoting over here where Chazal seem to be going extreme,13:44that a person just has to be committed to Torah and totally Torah and nothing else.13:48And a lot of people read that and they say, How are you supposed to make sense of this?13:52And they feel guilty that they're learning and they're working, or they're taking time away13:56from learning to work. So it all depends on the person. The person who's completely immersed in14:01the Torah, which is represented by the aron in the Kodesh Kodashim. That person is totally14:07committed to Torah, nothing else. Everything else, okay, they'll figure out, even his own kids,14:11to the point that Chazal say that the Torah we mitkayem only by a person who14:16kills himself for it, meaning to say, it doesn't exist in this world. He's totally immersed in14:21Torah. There are those individuals, and that's what we're saying is the first paragraph of Shema.14:25Now, I personally find this amazing because when we grew up in yeshivot, we always learned the14:29first part, we always learned the Nefesh HaChaim's explanation, and not to see somebody on a14:35completely different part of the world, and he was able to—not only, he's tapping into the same source14:40of the Torah to explain the same idea almost word for word as the Nefesh HaChaim without actually14:46seeing it. Mamash, Torah emet. Hashem reveals His Torah to great individuals throughout the14:52generations. We'll continue part two in the next recording.