Torah · MussarMussar221B. Forgetfulness and Sounds From HashemTzidkat HaTzadikPart 221Rabbi Uri Nahum · October 9, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0015:28Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot0:02reish chaf alef. This is part two, what perhaps looks like from three. Let's see what we're going to do.0:08In the last piece, we spoke about shichcha, that forgetfulness is the beginning of all evil.0:15And then we spoke about how everything starts from there.0:18When a person starts to think about other things, makes one forget Hashem,0:23and from there, eventually, he starts to do things that he's not supposed to do.0:27And we said that, however, that the voices is a voice that's constantly around,0:34and for those who want to hear, could hear it.0:37And sometimes we could feel and hear those voices.0:39We explained how those voices are still in the air.0:42If you would like to hear more, listen there.0:45We're picking up from that point, and Reb Tzadok says,0:48V'kol hu klal, v'dibur prat.0:51When you see in the Torah the different expressions for what seems to be speech,0:56in one place it says kol, which sounds like a sound,0:59and dibur, which is translated as speaking.1:01So he explains, kol is really the general, the generic, you could say,1:06and the dibur is the more specific.1:11Like the Zohar says, that kol is klal and dibur is prat.1:17V'lachen Torah shebichtav nikra kol, v'Torah shebaal peh nikra dibur. This is why the Torah shebichtav is called the kol, and the Torah shebaal peh is called dibur.1:22Why is that? So1:24because the Torah shebichtav is really more general.1:27It says, for example, Lo tevashel gedi1:30bachalev imo, do not cook the baby goat with its mother's milk.1:35But we know the details, which is the Torah1:38shebaal peh. There's a whole full few perakim in Masechet1:42Chullin about the issur of basar1:45bechalav, and halavit, not halavit, ninety percent of it is1:49oral Torah. So that's the detail.1:57V'lachen Torah shebichtav nikra kol, v'Torah shebaal peh dibur. V'chein hashma'ah lalev hu, rak b'derech klal, lada'at elahot yitbarach u'lechapes acharav. So too, when the heart starts to hear,2:01when the feelings start to feel2:05the sounds that we're talking about,2:08it's only... To know about HaKadosh Baruch Hu and to search after Him,2:13like it says in the pasuk,2:20Im techapsenah kakesef, ukematmonim tachpesenah, az tavinat yirat Hashem, uvinatah belev adam bifrati pratut kefi hatzarich lo. If you search for it and you dig for it,2:24then you'll be able to dig up what you need for yourself2:27to be able to understand it.2:31V'chen hamalachim mashmi'im beyirah, yachad bekol divrei Elohim chayim. We also say that the angels are2:35mashmia, they give over for others to hear with fear altogether2:40the words2:43dibbur Elohim chayim. That's the detail.2:46Vhu vadai nishma lkol ish Yisraeli. And what the angels are saying, you should just know,2:49every Jewish person has access to hear it.2:55Shemechino ozneiv lavo likach beyirah, as shomea divrei Elohim chayim. If you prepare yourself,2:57if you prepare your spiritual ears to hear with the fear of God,3:01you will hear the words of God.3:08V'hainu divrei Torah shenikraa kem vlashon Chazal, Moshe amru, Elu veelu divrei Elohim chayim. That's the divrei Elohim chayim.3:11Divrei Elohim chayim. This is what the malachim are saying.3:14This is the Torah.3:16This is exactly the Torah, as we find Chazal refer to the Talmud of Torah.3:21She taught even the opinions of the chachamim as divrei Elohim chayim.3:27These are also words of Elohim chayim.3:29That's what the angels are sending out every single day.3:37Uvkol hainu bederch laretzon Hashem yitbarach, beoto yom kemalachim ein odim yoter. And what it says3:39in the tefillah,3:43that mashmia bekol. The angels give over a sound.3:45What sound is it?3:46It's the sound of that specific day,3:49because really the angels don't know more detail.3:51They just give over that sound,3:52which, like we said, is more generic,3:54which is Torah3:56shebichtav. But the Torah shebaal peh, they don't have the ability.3:59He's going to mention one idea,4:01but we're going to say also,4:03we know the Torah shebaal peh was given to us here in this world,4:06that we, as hachamim of the4:08dor — not us, not me myself,4:10but I'm talking about the rabbis who are the talmidei chachamim of the generation,4:14or Chazal who started this in writing4:17— is their explanation of the Torah4:22shebichtav, that is something that's ours.4:25Therefore, the angels don't have that access.4:27They only give over from HaKadosh Baruch Hu4:29what He gives over.4:31The Torah4:31shebaal peh hu4:35lematah, bidei chachmei Yisrael, u'vapratim hein, devarim al yedei bnei adam bato yom. The Torah4:36shebaal peh, that's not for the4:38malachim. The dibur,4:39that's for us over here,4:41the4:44brei Elohim chayim, the kol — they're mashma'im bekol, which is the messages from4:47HaKadosh Baruch4:47Hu.4:51U'fi shehaShem yitbarach nikra Elohim, ba'al hakochot kulam nikra etzlo, dibur4:52shehu dibur4:53bifratut, and4:55being. So why is it then,4:56if it's really4:58sending out only5:00kolot, why does the statement say5:03by the angels, it says,5:05'Dibrei Elohim5:07chayim,' right?5:07Mashma'im bekol,5:11just told me they send out the kol,5:12so why does it say5:13dibrei? I thought dibrei is the5:15prat, and the answer is5:16because Elohim5:18is the name of HaKadosh Baruch Hu5:20that signifies HaKadosh Baruch Hu's complete power5:24in all areas of life.5:27And therefore,5:28the Elohim has to talk about pratim as well,5:31because that's the idea of Elohim,5:34who has power and control in every area5:37and every facet of life.5:47כמו שמבטא מבין ולא מבינה, ידיעה שהמלאכים אין להם בינה, דהיינו הרגשה בלב, שזהו רק לבני אדם שהם חסרים וצריכים לזה. Says,5:48the way I understood5:49about — he brings down,5:50he says,5:53there's mevin v'lo bina. Those who understand,5:54but not in the level of bina.5:55So he explains that the angels have no level of bina.5:59Chochmah is a wisdom that a person learns from others,6:02but to be able to dig deeper into something,6:04to go in depth in the concept,6:07that's something that the angels don't have.6:09That's only something that's attainable by human beings.6:12Why is that so?6:13Because we as humans lack,6:17and because we lack,6:18we need to be able to have this kind of wisdom6:21to dig through it.6:22For6:23example, take a person who's been thrown in a forest.6:26Now, many stories, they have people who got lost in the forest6:28and they figure out their survival.6:30Were they trained?6:31No.6:32If you were trained,6:33that would be called6:35chochmah. A person was trained to go into a6:36forest and live there and survive.6:38He's been given the wisdom of what to do to survive,6:41what to drink from,6:43which plants are poisonous,6:44which plants are not.6:45A person who's thrown into an6:47area where he has to figure out his livelihood,6:49by the way,6:49it could also be in the business world,6:52right?6:53He starts to use everything in his capability to learn6:55and to, you know, learn from his mistakes6:57and to adjust6:58and to learn from other people.6:59That's called7:00binah. Chochmah is if they go to school7:02and they train you,7:03this is what you're supposed to do.7:05You do this,7:05you do A, B, C, D.7:11Hashem Yitbarach mevin kemoha bnei adam hu margish, aval lo beminah, sheharei eino chaser. HaKadosh Baruch Hu also has this kind of7:14binah, but not the way we have it,7:16because we have it because we lack7:18and we need it.7:20HaKadosh Baruch Hu doesn't lack7:20and therefore He doesn't need it,7:21but He has control of7:23it and He has an understanding of it.7:30However, the malachim, v'kach hamalachim ein yod'im hadibur shehu hargashat halev shel kol echad ufrat. Therefore,7:30but the angels who lack this7:33binah, therefore they don't know actually7:35about dibur,7:36which we said dibur is the detail.7:38And the dibur, like we said,7:39is based on the person's feelings,7:41and that's why it7:42says the angels have no clue7:43what is going on in a person's feelings,7:46because they don't have access to the dibur,7:48which comes from the7:55binah. But the kol in general7:56is not heard by people,7:58like he says about—8:00But when it says in the Zohar, חכים ולא בחכמה, the angels have chokhmah, but not Adam. Bnei Adam don't have such a chokhmah, which means they don't have that access to the kol all the time.8:20Hashem, חכים ולא בחכמה, כי מלאכים, and Hashem's wisdom is not like the wisdom of the malachim. והם משמעים בכלל שהוא חכמה מה שקיבלו מאחרים. What they are giving over is only what they heard; they just give it over.8:25This is what's called chokhmah. It's more like what we call something like a tape recorder.8:28The chokhmah of the malachim is that they hear and they transmit it afterwards.8:33They don't really have a full understanding in the details of it.8:41Then, when a person picks up a little bit, he starts to investigate more and to think about the idea more,8:49and each one on his level, how much he digs into the concept to understand Hashem,8:53that's how, everyone on his level, that's how much he'll be able to expose the idea or bring up the idea.9:03And even though there may be disagreement in what that message is coming from9:09HaKadosh Baruch Hu, it's all considered divrei Elokim chayim, because each person is revealing what he is looking into.9:17He's revealing from what his neshama, from his personality, wants to dig out from it.9:25However. Not every person could just come along and start to give his own explanation of the sounds that he picked up.9:32You need to have yirat Shamayim. You need to have a fear of God when you give explanations to the Torah.9:38Why?9:42Because what do we mean when we talk about angels?9:45People think of angels as the ones with the wings and the, you know, the little halo things on top of them.9:50A very, very distorted picture of the angels based on Hollywood.9:58Yes, the pasuk says in Sefer Yechezkel a description about angels.10:06Go look at Rabbeinu Bachya, who explains that it means really tallitot.10:11They're all wearing tallitot that look like wings.10:13If you've ever seen somebody with a white tallit, it looks like it's wings if you look at it from the back.10:17In any case, he says over here the meaning of malachim, when we refer to malachim, it means the power.10:24Malachim are messengers to carry out an action,11:14... because that's the only thing that really a person has control over.11:18As it says in Chazal, everything is in the hands of God except for fear of God.11:23That's the only way a person can inspire himself.11:33זה person wants to initiate this whole process begins with11:38his yirat shamayim. It begins with him thinking about God, how Hashem is full of the whole world,11:45how we're here for Him, we're created by Him for Him. We all have a mission in life.11:51We all came here for a purpose.11:53Thoughts of things like that bring a person. That is yirat shamayim.11:58That is having Sheviti Hashem לנגדי תמיד. That's having Hashem in front of you at all times.12:02Those kind of things allow you to hear the voice.12:04When you hear that voice, then you take that voice and you start to feel it,12:08and you start to dig into it, you start to look into it.12:11Perhaps you're not so knowledgeable in Torah, and you're not able to understand it more.12:15You understand it properly, so you go to a rabbi, you go to hear a class,12:19or you yourself, who are a little bit more knowledgeable, and you're learning,12:22and you see, mamash, sometimes the Torah talks to you.12:24Mamash, the daf that you're learning—everybody's learning the same daf12:27Yomi—but it speaks to you. At that point, it speaks to you, connects to you.12:31You open up a book that you were supposed to open up yesterday,12:36but you didn't have a chance. You open up another, you open up today, and boom,12:39right there it talks to you and it tells you directly exactly what you wanted to hear.12:44He says that is the bina, that is the dibur that you're extracting.12:55But to begin this whole process, you got to start.12:58How do you start? And that is through yirat shamayim.13:01Forgive me, I'm going a little bit longer now. I know it's 30 minutes,13:04but I just want to finish up this last piece.13:11However, to listen to the kolot—remember, the kolot come from HaKadosh Baruch Hu.13:14Those kolot of Matan Torah, that you don't need so much the yirat shamayim.13:19You just have to be ready to hear it.13:21Right, and we mentioned before the bat kol. He brings this in parentheses, in brackets,13:24which we're not going to go through right now.13:26But we mentioned before the bat kol in previous recording.13:28This is the same bat kol that's also from the sounds of Yirat Shamayim.13:36V'zeh kol, lechen amar Yaakov lo. And v'zeh kol, excuse me, this is easy. This is easy to hear.13:40The other one, you need to really pump in a lot of Yirat Shamayim to hear.13:45But this is easier to hear.13:46Those kolot of the sounds of the Matan Torah, it's easy to hear.13:52And the pasuk starts to speak to an individual.13:59It says, Im shachoach tishkach, and then v'halachta acharei elohim acherim, and then says,14:04ayekev lo sh'ma'tem, and then says, all of a sudden it turns into14:12the rabbim. Ki ader sh'ma'at harabim, gorem shechalei achid. Hashem, because really, when a group of Jews together are not listening to the voices,14:19it causes shechahim by the individual,14:21because we're all affected by our surroundings.14:24When a lot of people around us are not listening,14:27it causes us also to be distracted with them from all their sh'tuyot as well.14:35Sh'mati dama gaman shchach v'haya shehu lashon simcha. He says another thing about forgetfulness.14:38It says v'haya, and it shall be if you don't listen.14:42Now we know Chazal tell us, whenever it says14:44v'haya, it implies something of happiness.14:50What do you mean?14:52We just said that forgetfulness leads to sin and leads to problems.14:56He says, true.15:01However, when you do fix it, there's a tremendous15:05simcha. So although the forgetfulness, it's not a good thing,15:07it's not a choice that we should try to make,15:10but when a person comes to the realization that he's been forgetting,15:13now he wants to wake up, and he does15:15teshuva, it's a tremendous amount of simcha that can be brought out.15:18And with this we finish15:21Otresh Chaf Aleph. The deeper piece,15:22I agree,15:23but hopefully we can get the message from it to our own level.