Torah · MussarMussar211B. Torah & Tefilla 1 Part 1Tzidkat HaTzadikPart 211Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 21, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0011:01Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat HaTzadik, Resh Yud Aleph 2, 11, part 2.0:06We'll be discussing Torah and tefillah and how both are necessary.0:10And we discussed in the last recording a very important concept of Torah,0:14that Torah is for those who are lacking.0:17And there was a beautiful midrash of Tzadok went on to explain,0:21and he says that the midrash, it says that Hashem tells the Jewish people,0:25You might think that I gave you the Torah to harm you, but it's really not so; it's only for your own benefit.0:28And Tzadok explains, how can one think that Torah is there to harm him?0:31And we said that perhaps Torah should be like0:35tefillah, that just like tefillah I'm always turning to HaKadosh Baruch Hu because I'm0:39lacking, so too Torah. There's a hava amina that maybe one should think that0:43Torah is actually going to give me the confidence or to give me the law book,0:49which makes me now turn away from Hashem, because now I don't need to turn to Him0:52to always find out what to do next. I'm turning to the Torah and I read the0:56Torah and the Torah tells me what to do. So now Hashem says, No, Torah is only for your good. Why?1:02Because when you enjoy it much more. Turning to HaKadosh Baruch Hu for help,1:09that should give you this divine assistance. You may always doubt1:14and be fearful that maybe you're doing the wrong thing, but when you know the Torah1:17and you know what to do because that's what it says in Torah,1:21you have what to rely on, and you can enjoy it much better knowing with confidence1:25that what you're doing is what HaKadosh Baruch Hu wants you to do.1:28V'rachein, now he continues and he brings, again,1:31Rambam says, V'chein amru, ha'marich b'tefillah me'ayen bah, ba lidei ke'ev lev. The Gemara says, a person who extends his tefillah and he's me'ayen in it,1:41which the Gemara says, Rashi says over there, that means he looks to see if he's going to get answered,1:46will lead him to heartaches.1:49Gemara says, Mai takantei? What should he do? Ya'asok baTorah. Gemara says his takanah is he should be1:55osek baTorah. How's that so? What's going on?2:02שהתפילה נקראת תחלת ממושכה, שאינו בטיחוד גמור. That's the explanation Reb Tzadok explains.2:05How does Torah fix your, basically, your ayun tefillah?2:12He explains, first of all, tefillah, we know it's called2:16tochelet memushachah. Tochel means a yearning that's extending.2:19You're praying to HaKadosh Baruch Hu. You're requesting something from Hashem,2:24and you're waiting to see.2:26You're waiting to see if you can get2:29an answer. And you're praying and you keep asking,2:30Please, Hashem, please, it's really necessary.2:33Please, somebody is sick in my family.2:34Please, I need this parnassah. Please, I need this thing.2:37My whole shalom bayis is dependent on it.2:40Please, Hashem, I need this. Please, Hashem, I need that.2:42Please, I need Hashem for my kids.2:43And there's a lot of these things that we know are not quick fixes2:47unless you're like mamash, you know, the Baba Sali or something.2:51If you are, please contact me. You know my number.2:54I'd like to come and speak to you.2:55Anyway, but that's how prayer is.2:57Prayer is a very, very long process sometimes.3:00You're praying, but you3:01should—of course, we know Chazal tell us you got to continue praying.3:03I'm sorry, going off tangent, but I want you to think,3:06and therefore you should not pray.3:06No, that's part of prayer, is that it's memushachah, it extends, it3:11pulls. And the Gemara tells us that if you think that Hashem has to answer you3:17because you prayed very well, you may be very disappointed.3:21That's what you see from here, is that prayer is not guaranteed.3:26Even though we do have statements from tzaddikim, like the3:30Chazon Ish, who says that tefillah is guaranteed, it's just the answer could be no,3:33or it could go to somebody else.3:35And we know that our prayer definitely have an effect.3:37But who says that Hashem has to bend to us?3:42Who says that Hashem says that what you ask before is good for you?3:45The most obvious example of this is that imagine a3:50person's praying that he should be a wealthy person.3:52Who says that wealth is good?3:55Not—first of all, a lot of people are wealthy and not necessarily having a good time.4:00To tell you a very quick story,4:02I've heard this from a very rich person.4:04Unfortunately, this rich person, as they got older, they made a lot of money.4:08They weren't so rich when they were younger.4:09When they got older, they made tons of money,4:14Baruch Hashem. But unfortunately, it also caused a lot of strife in the family.4:18And this person once tells me a story4:21that his parent, one of his parents, goes to visit someone who's sitting shiva for their mother,4:27and that person was sitting in an apartment building.4:31And the parent walks in.4:33Now, this is the parent of very, very wealthy children,4:36okay? The children are very4:38wealthy—not wealthy, very, very wealthy.4:40Good?4:41So now, and unfortunately, this family has been struck with the curse of the wealth,4:46and that is that there was strife and fighting between each other because of money.4:50So what happened?4:51So the parent walks in to visit this other person sitting4:56shiva, and they walk out4:58crying. Not because of the person that they visited,5:02not because of the person who passed away,5:04but because that apartment building was a floor above their previous apartment.5:12When this family was younger, they lived in this apartment building.5:17They wouldn't have so much money.5:18For those who are not familiar with, in Brooklyn,5:21Baruch Hashem, most of the people actually5:24live—Baruch Hashem, Hashem has blessed most of the5:26people—and they have their own houses.5:28Even those who don't have their own houses and they're renting,5:30they're renting at least a half a floor,5:31but they're living pretty much in a house,5:32but they're not living in apartment buildings.5:35So... When they were here, I guess many, many years ago,5:38they were living in this apartment building.5:41And this parent walked out crying,5:44remembering the days when they were living in the apartment building.5:47They called their son and they said,5:48Do you remember this apartment?5:49Yeah, of course, we grew up there.5:51Remember how good life used to be over there?5:54True, the apartment was small.5:56True, they dreamed of having bigger houses.5:58But at the end of the day, there was peace and everything,6:01and there was no money, but there was peace.6:02There was serenity,6:04and that's what we call6:06shalva, right?6:07So, rabotai, wealth is not necessarily the best thing.6:10So the guy is praying for wealth, though,6:11and Hashem is not answering him.6:12Yeah, because it's not guaranteed. Why not?6:14Not because prayer doesn't work.6:17From your end, you think you need money.6:19HaKadosh Baruch Hu, on the other hand, says,6:20Are you kidding?6:21Trust me, stay where you are.6:23Stay where you are.6:24In other words, some tzaddikim, for example, understood this.6:27L'mashal, the Brisker6:29Rav in the6:30sixties, when he was living in6:31Eretz Yisrael, and it was a very, very dire situation,6:33a lot of poverty in those days,6:35and he had a kollel, and he had to support the6:39Brisker kollel. Where's the money going to come from?6:40It wasn't a person that traveled to America6:42and raised funds. It wasn't like that.6:44Somebody once came to him and gave him enough money6:46for the next two months.6:50The Brisker Rav took the money he needed for the next month,6:52and he gave him back the rest of the money.6:54He says, What are you doing, Rabbi? I'm giving you the next couple of months.6:56He says, Do you want to take—the Brisker6:59Rav answered—do you want to take away my7:02mazal? But tachon. This is why I look for every month,7:04I'm waiting for HaKadosh Baruch Hu to send it to me.7:06You're going to take that away from me?7:08So it's going to come.7:09How it's going to come, you don't know.7:10Hashem has His own ways.7:12But it's going to come, but that's7:14tefillah, not so by Torah.7:17Like we said till now, the divrei Torah is different.7:25It's a kish Hashem yirachem, me'ir shepa'al, ma sheyitpalel. Zehu mishan chazak veta'ava baa. When a person's praying7:30and he doesn't know if he's going to get answered.7:31But when a person's learning, he7:33understands that what he prayed for may get answered7:35or may not get answered,7:36because maybe as you're praying, as you're learning,7:38you come across something that you7:40learn and you realize, hey, I've been praying for the wrong thing the whole time.7:42I've been praying for money. Money isn't good for me.7:45I love my family.7:46I love this7:48achdut. I don't like,7:49as another wealthy person told my wife,7:51that when they were younger and they had a smaller house,7:53everybody was together. When they got richer7:55and they got this big house7:57and everybody had his own room, they...8:00They didn't have that bond again,8:02because everyone was in their own room,8:03whereas one person told me, you know,8:05I have to call my kids8:07to come down for dinner because they can't hear me.8:10Because if I yell in the house,8:12they can't hear. I have to go all the way.8:13I called them. That's, it's too big.8:15We don't feel so together.8:17So there is such a thing.8:18Hashem gives that to a person.8:20A person learns Torah, he understands it.8:23Now, oh, now he's confident.8:24Now he knows what the right thing, what the wrong thing is.8:26And even though he sees8:29that his prayer didn't come true,8:30it's not extended anymore.8:32It's not in pain,8:35because either he realizes8:37that what he prays for8:38is perhaps not something that he should be getting,8:40or by learning8:43he understands and he8:44puts his trust in HaKadosh Baruch Hu more8:46that He's going to salvage him.8:48And therefore, like the Bitskover story,8:51that's how it works.8:52That's supposed to be.8:53And therefore it's not considered8:56heart pain.8:57That's how it's supposed to be.8:59However, there's a Midrash that says,9:01now, and he says,9:04The Torah was only given9:05to the people that eat man.9:06Now we know if the Torah was given to the people that eat man.9:09Now the concept of man was that9:11you never know how it's going to come.9:12And we said Torah is more like with certainty,9:15confidence, and exactly clarity9:17what to do.9:18So he explains,9:21because even in divrei Torah,9:23really,9:24you also need to conduct yourself9:25like the people who ate the man,9:28which is what,9:32... orot mechudashot b'divrei Torah. That person has to constantly9:34turn to HaKadosh Baruch9:35Hu and expect and hope from Hashem9:37that He'll illuminate9:39and shine for him9:41new ideas and9:42understandings in the words of Torah.9:47And he shouldn't be just relying on what it says,9:51but to give him an understanding9:52in what it means, what it says.9:53As we all know, those who learn Gemara,9:55it's not so clear sometimes,9:57and a person thinks he understood.9:58You need to pray to Hashem to really open up your10:00mind to really understand that you understood the Torah.10:09Because really,10:10even after Hashem is giving the Torah,10:13Hashem is still involved with us.10:16Hashem still shines for each person.10:19Specifically10:20of how he himself10:21should conduct himself.10:24Va'zeh b'keish David HaMelech, and this is exactly what David HaMelech prayed10:26in many places in Tehillim.10:28Here's one of them:10:30Havineni Hashem, let me understand Your Torah,10:32because when You give me an understanding,10:33I'm able to understand10:34where to go and what to do.10:41V'chein b'kamah pe'amim b'midrashim, b'shulchan tov she'ein lo nechah b'beit Torah, rak ma sheHashem yitbarach me'ir u'melamed lo. And a few times in Midrash,10:43the Midrash points out that David10:45did not feel at rest, did not feel10:48yet calm,10:49until HaKadosh Baruch Hu10:51illuminated for him and gave him the understanding10:54how to truly understand the10:56Torah and to teach him Torah.10:58And with that, we finish,10:59b'otai, Reish yud aleph.