Torah · MussarMussar211A. Torah & Tefilla 1 Part 1Tzidkat HaTzadikPart 211Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 21, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0015:00Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat Tzadik, ot0:03resh yud alef, 211. Today's piece is a little bit on the easier side, you could say. Maybe we could explain it a little bit easier.0:09But it still probably will be part one. Let's begin.0:13We've been talking about tefillah a lot. We've been talking about the miyonot and how tefillah,0:18and then we spoke about also in comparison to Torah.0:22And now, Rav Tzadok in this piece focuses on Torah.0:26He starts a little bit to discuss Torah and tefillah, but then eventually he focuses on0:31how a person's approach to Torah should be. Let's begin.0:38Torah u'tefillah tzrichim shenehem b'yachad l'adam. Torah and tefillah are both necessary for a person.0:41You can't have one without the other. They both need to be for a person.0:45Like it says, for example, in the Gemara,0:49V'lo garsa ela hecha d'matzlei. The Torah talks about praying where you learn, and learning where you're0:54praying. It's a very, very, as you say, chashuvah zach. It's a very, very important thing.0:58Gemara says, Rabbi Ami and Rabbi Asi lived in Tiberia,1:01and they were greats, greats of the greats.1:04And Rabbi Ami and Rabbi Asi, the Gemara says, even though there were thirteen shuls in Tiberia,1:08for those of us who know what it means, the settlements back then,1:12you know, a big, big place was considered like maybe two hundred families.1:16That's called a big city.1:18Here in Tiberia, they had thirteen different shuls.1:20Still, Rabbi Ami and Rabbi Asi, where would they learn?1:24They would only learn—excuse me, where would they pray?1:26They would only pray where they learned, between the pillars of where they1:30learned. And that's something that's brought out throughout1:33Chazal. You can't have one without the other.1:35You need to learn only where you pray.1:37V'chein l'hefech. Also, praying is also necessary for Torah.1:40For example, the Gemara says,1:43Masechet Yevamot, the Gemara says,1:46Kol ha'omer ein li ela Torah, afilu Torah ein lo. A person who says, All I have is Torah, I have nothing else,1:50the Gemara says even Torah he doesn't have.1:52Why?1:52So he explains, his Rav Tzadok style,1:58she'al yedei zeh chas v'shalom yavo l'iskochach. Because a person who says, All I have is Torah, and he doesn't pray,2:01then he's going to forget his Torah.2:02As we know, the Chazal tell us,2:04a person has to pray to be able to retain his Torah.2:10Because the concept of tefillah is that you lack and you need.2:21HaKadosh Baruch Hu. The inyan hatefillah, he says, hahakarah shehu chaser, mevakesh Hashem yitbarach sheyemalehenu. If it's that you're lacking, and you ask Hashem to fill in what you're lacking.2:27And that's why prayer is not limited only to2:33Mincha, Arvit, and Shacharit. Prayer is at all times.2:35You're looking for a parking spot, you pray. You're lacking, no?2:38Especially if you're in a big city where it's very hard to find parking.2:42Whatever you need, you need to make a business deal, you pray.2:45You need to make sure that your kids listen to you,2:49your wife listens to you.2:50You want to do anything, you got to pray.2:52You're lacking, basically,2:53and you ask Hashem to fill in that lacking.2:56That's the2:58tefillah. Ve'al yedei haTorah. But if a person doesn't have tefillah, only has just Torah,3:03yachshov shehu maleh. A person might think that he—not might think,3:06will probably think—that he's full.3:10Then, ve'az afilu Torah ein lo. Then he doesn't feel that he's lacking.3:12If he doesn't feel that he's lacking,3:13he's not praying, obviously, because he doesn't feel like he's lacking.3:16So then even Torah he doesn't have.3:19Ki lo ניתנה תורה אלא לחסרים. Why not?3:20Why?3:21Okay, so he's not praying because he doesn't feel lacking.3:23So why doesn't he have Torah?3:24And again, Rav Tzadok explains,3:26because Torah is only given also for people that are lacking.3:32Makirim chesronam u'mevakshim laShem yitbarach sheyashlim. This is given only to people that are lacking,3:35and people that recognize this weakness or this lacking that they have,3:40and they're asking Hashem to salvage them.3:49Kemo shene'emar, like the pasuk says, haaniyim vehaevyonim mevakshim mayim ve'ein, leshonam. The aniyim and the poor people, the ones that are destitute,3:56the pasuk says in Yeshayahu, they request water, and there isn't.4:00And he brings down the famous4:02derashah, Mayim ela Torah. And there's no— and whenever the term water is used, it's referring to Torah.4:07So who is Torah for?4:09The Torah is for people that are aniyim, that are lacking.4:13And now you can understand, by the way,4:15why the angels had a debate against Moshe Rabbeinu, and they're arguing to Hashem,4:20why should a human being get the Torah?4:22And Moshe Rabbeinu's response was,4:24precisely because we're human beings, we need the Torah.4:26You are angels. You're perfect. You don't need the Torah.4:35Back to Rav Tzadok: ... והיה רק לכבודו, וקדושתו ... And that's really the essence of why Hashem created the world.4:38It's for His honor, as4:46the pasuk4:50says,4:51Kol ma4:54shebara HaKadosh Baruch Hu b'olamo lo bara ela lichvodo. Everything Hashem created is only for His honor,4:57u'lekluso, people should praise Him,4:59not because Hashem needs our praise. The opposite5:01is that people should have that relationship with HaKadosh Baruch Hu,5:04but you're only able to have a relationship with HaKadosh Baruch Hu5:07when you realize that you're lacking5:08and you need His involvement to help you,5:12right? So a person who has a very good relationship with his parents after marriage5:17is a person who is either a real big5:23tzaddik that knows that, you know, my parents are lacking and I need to help them,5:27or a person that needs his parents.5:31You always hear these stories, unfortunately,5:33from people that have rich parents,5:35and they, you know, as soon as their parents get very, very old,5:38all of a sudden they start to show up to the house5:40and they start to, you know, become friendly5:43and to spend more time, take care of their parents.5:45It's an investment.5:47It's a, you know, it's a fifty million dollar investment for a few weeks5:50before the parents pass away so they could get the will, unfortunately.5:53So that's when they feel they're lacking.5:55They feel that they need to keep— that's why they keep the relationship.5:58Now, of course, a lot of us... We are always lacking,6:02and we have the recognition,6:03we have that we turn to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.6:07And that's, Hashem wants to be part of our lives.6:13V'amina HaKadosh Baruch Hu mit'aveh לתפלתן של צדיקים. That's what we said.6:14Hashem desires the tefillah of the6:16tzaddikim, and we know that some of our greatest tzaddikim in human history,6:21Abraham,6:23Yitzchak, Yaakov, they were born lacking.6:25Like it says,6:28the avot were akarim, their imahot were akarot. Why is that so?6:30Says the Gemara, because HaKadosh Baruch Hu wants the prayer of the6:33tzaddikim. So you see, even greats such as the avot hakedoshim,6:38our ancestors, Abraham,6:40Yitzchak, Yaakov, and their wives, which were also the greatest tzadkaniyot in the world6:43in history,6:44still Hashem created them lacking6:46because of that relationship that Hashem wanted,6:48that they should always be turning to Him.6:50And that's ta'akar, that's why you need tefillah and Torah together.6:54And this, on this the Midrash says,6:57it brings now a very interesting Midrash,7:00and a beautiful way of explaining the Midrash.7:02Midrash in Parashat Nitzavim.7:05Torah says that over there7:07Hashem gives the Torah to the Jewish people.7:09He tells them, it's for your own good.7:11The Midrash says7:15the following: Shema tomar l'ra'atchem natati haTorah. You may say,7:17I gave you the Torah only for causing you bad.7:22The Midrash answers7:23that Hashem7:27responds, Lo nitnah ella letovatchem. The Torah was only given for your own good.7:31That's the Midrash.7:33Interesting, right?7:33Hashem tells the Jewish people,7:34you might think that I've given you the Torah to harm you.7:38No, no, no, no, no.7:39I've given to you for your benefit.7:43Now what's going on over here?7:48Says Rav Tzadok, vadai chas v'shalom, איך יעלה על הדעת שיהיה לרעתכם. How could even one ponder,7:50how could even one contemplate and think for a7:53moment that the Torah was given to harm us?7:57Why would Hashem give us such a thing?8:00Right, so what was the hava amina? What was the initial thought that the Midrash, that the Hashem has8:13said to us? And the answer is, d'salka da'atchach shezeh tov yoter, shekovea adam b'chol rega al Hashem yitbarach, she'ein lo ma la'asot v'ech lehitnaheg. You might thought to say that instead of having a book of laws and what to do,8:19it might be better that a person should have a constant relationship with the Kadosh Baruch Hu through prayer,8:26and constantly be turning to Hashem to help him to understand what the right thing to do in every single moment.8:33So, for example, we go to a store and we want to shop.8:37So we know we need to buy kosher.8:39Who told you you need to buy kosher?8:40Because you learned that the Torah says you need to have kosher food,8:43and therefore when I go shopping, I know what to do.8:46I know which aisle to go in.8:48I know what food. I know what symbols to look for, because that's what God wants of me.8:53But you might have thought that without the Torah, you might have thought to say that now I have a law.8:59I know, and those who know halacha can understand a little better,9:01those who know halacha well, you know every step of the way, you know exactly what the halacha decides.9:06But those who don't know halacha, you see nowadays, Baruch Hashem, there's a lot of good people,9:11they're constantly texting the rabbi.9:13They're constantly asking the rabbi.9:14So now, in olden days when it was, the rabbis didn't have texts, so, you know, and rabbis had special time when to call them, it wasn't so easy.9:21Today, a lot of young rabbis, Baruch Hashem, that know halacha and they know what to do,9:25so they're constantly getting texts from their talmidim, from their students,9:29and they're asking them, Rabbi, what do I do this? What do I do here?9:31So that builds a relationship with the rabbi, right?9:35Because they don't know.9:37Had they known, it wouldn't be such a big relationship.9:40I mean, personally, when I first started out in kollel, every day I would go up to my rosh kollel and ask him questions in halacha.9:47As you get older and you start to learn and you start to know how to look up sources,9:50so no, I don't go up to my rosh kollel every day.9:53In fact, not even every once a week.9:55Because most of the cases, you know how to look it up, you know what to look for.9:59Now, of course, every once in a while you need His input, so you go back to Him.10:03But in general, you don't have that because you don't have those questions,10:06so kind of the relationship is not as strong.10:08So one may think that the Torah that was given to us, in a way, kind of distances us from Hashem,10:16because had there been no Torah, I would be constantly turning to Hashem and say,10:20Hashem, open up my eyes. What do I do here?10:22I'm standing and I want to pray, and I'm praying to You.10:25How do I step away from this?10:28Open up my eyes. All of a sudden, the idea pops in my head:10:30I'm told to the King I should step back three steps,10:34right? I don't know that says that in Shulchan Aruch, because there's no Shulchan Aruch.10:37I'm always looking for Hashem to help me.10:39What do I do here?10:40Which food should I eat? I should not eat?10:42And all of a sudden Hashem answers me, and I get this sensation, and I know that I should eat this food, which is kosher.10:49So that's the סלקא דעתך, that's the הוה אמינא, that's the initial thought10:53that you may have thought to say, that maybe it's better without the Torah,10:58because I could have a constant relationship.11:07ולא שיהיה לחוק קבוע כשולחן ערוך, זה הדרך לכובו, שאין צריך לסמוך להשם יתברך בכל נתיבותיו. And it's not as good as having a Shulchan Aruch, where I know exactly what to do.11:11Now I don't turn to Hashem, I open up the book and I say, Hey, which way should I go? Right?11:15Makes a lot of sense.11:17So that was11:19a הוה אמינא, אבל באמת הוא לא טובתך. That's what Hashem comes to answer.11:21You may think that giving you the law book is actually not good for you; it's actually for your own good.11:32Why? Because it's a great, strong, powerful light that will illuminate your soul, and you could rely on it.11:40You could have a משענת, meaning to say you could rely on it, you could be completely dependent on it, on this book.11:47Because had there not been Torah, you would have been a very anxious person, even OCD.11:57Why? Because every time you do something... How do you know that's really what Hashem wants?12:01And you can be a nervous wreck. Maybe that's not what Hashem really wants, and maybe you're making a mistake.12:06Aval haTorah nikra mashan. But the Torah is called the support.12:11Like the Gemara says, masechet Chagigah, Torah is called the support.12:14That's why, like again, I'll tell you, the world of before knowing halacha and the world after halacha, it's two different worlds.12:22Anybody who learns and studies halacha will tell you the same thing.12:24It's such an unbelievable thing that when you know halacha, you know what to do in every moment.12:28And when you don't know halacha, you're constantly nervous: am I doing the right thing, not doing the right12:31thing? So you're always calling the rabbi, but what do you do on Shabbat when you don't have access to somebody to ask?12:36You're always nervous: am I doing the right thing or not doing the right thing?12:38That's why the Midrash also calls the Torah amud barzel.12:42That's called the12:46Mishnah. What is it, kemo achilat man. It's kind of like the eating of the man.12:48The eating of the man, we know the man was not something that was stored in the fridges or in the freezers,12:53because the man came on a daily basis and it was finished, and you didn't know the next day when and how you're going to get it.13:03At all times, they were constantly turning to Hashem. They should supply them with their livelihood.13:10And by the man, what does it say by the man?13:16It says, Va'anicha vayar'ivecha. As we're going to read in another week, Hashem, it says that Hashem made you suffer and made you hungry.13:24Why is that called suffering and hungry by eating the man?13:27The13:29pasuk says, meforash, zeh inui nefesh, because when a person doesn't have a support, he doesn't know where it's coming from,13:34it's a little bit of an13:35inui, right? A person who, you know, let's say, for example, you need to have a job. You have to have a job.13:43You lost your job, and you don't know what to do.13:45Best example.13:46A person who loses a job,13:48you're nervous, right? What's going to be?13:50When you don't know—of course Hashem is going to take care of you, you know Hashem is going13:53to—but you're still nervous.13:55How? What kind of job would I be able to handle it?13:57Will it be accommodating to my special needs, my religious needs,14:04... Where do we find a remez14:06that tzumin don't enjoy their food and they get14:08inui nefesh, even though they're eating and they're tasting the food?14:11Because, pasuk, when you don't know what you're eating, the man didn't have a texture, didn't have a form,14:17therefore called14:19inui. Shegam him lo ra'u. Also, the people ate the man didn't see, didn't know exactly where they're going.14:24Vchein haTorah, hu ora me'iru b'lavachi. And so too, the Torah is the light that shines for you and illuminates the way for you.14:34And without the Torah, hu holech bachoshech. A person's like walking in the dark. Af al pi shemotze, gam bachoshech. And even though you may find your way in the dark, you don't feel a satiation,14:39like the blind person that eats, even though he's eating. But he doesn't find satiation from what he eats.14:48Why?14:49Because you're not seeing it. You have to be able to see it.14:52That's the Torah.14:53You're able to see and you know that what you're doing is right,14:56instead of just relying that Hashem will put the right ideas in your head.