Torah · MussarMussar210B. Connection to Hashem via Prayer vs. TorahTzidkat HaTzadikPart 210Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 19, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0014:05Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzadik or Teres Yud 2:10. This will be part two. In part one, we spoke about0:06that connection to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, the focus0:10to connect to HaKadosh Baruch Hu through tefillah is the same0:15level of a nevuah. We said that happens when you completely separate yourself from the body0:21and you only focus on HaKadosh Baruch Hu. And since you could only focus on HaKadosh Baruch Hu,0:26and again, that's how you prepare yourself for tefillah,0:30that's exactly what navi is. Navi is completely disconnected from his body. However, we said that0:35level was gone, and0:38even though that level is gone, it doesn't mean the ability is gone. The ability to attach yourself to HaKadosh Baruch Hu and remove yourself from this world0:46is still possible, but it's possible through the learning of Torah. It's not on the level of prophecy anymore because you don't have that level.0:54That's why the Zohar says,0:57Karov lanevuah. It doesn't say it's nevuah; it's karov lanevuah, but through the learning of Torah,1:01because kudsha brich hu v'Orayta v'Yisrael chad hu, because they're all one. When you attach yourself to the Torah, you have nothing else.1:09You know, Chazal tell us—it's a side point, Rav Tzadok doesn't bring this here, not1:17before—Chazal tell us, Ein divrei Torah mitkaymim ela b'mi shememit atzmo aleha. In order for divrei Torah to be mitkayem by a person, a person has to kill himself1:21over it. It doesn't come just like, you know, because you have extra time and you're just, you know, learning because you have nothing else to do.1:27You want it to be mitkayem by you, you have to kill yourself. You have to push yourself. That's a1:32pashut pshat. We could also say,1:35Ein divrei Torah mitkaymim ela b'mi shememit atzmo aleha, a person who kills himself, a person who makes himself like a dead person to everything around him.1:41So you remove yourself from the physical, you remove yourself from this world, from olam hazeh, and you attach yourself to the1:48Torah. That's how you could attach yourself to HaKadosh Baruch Hu as well, which is the same level as a navi, and if not greater.1:57We'll pick up from that. Idea,1:59we continue. UvZohar, parashat Shemot, it says,2:04Hataam delnavi hu rak lezimnin. Why is it that a chacham is greater than a navi?2:08A chacham adif min navi. Those are the words of Chazal. The Zohar explains, because a navi only gets that closeness, that attachment to Hashem2:16at times. It's not constant.2:19Menukat peshitut hagashmiyut al2:26yedei dibuk bHashem yitbarach, bhakarat hanoach hazeh efshar klal lihyot bitmidut. Because that focus, to be completely focused on HaKadosh Baruch Hu with a complete detachment from this world,2:34that's an impossible thing to do constantly. Moshe amru, yachol yitpalel kol hayom kulo.2:42Vezimnin. The Gemara says2:44in Masechet Berachot, you might think a person should or could pray the entire day.2:49The pasuk says, vezimnin. There are times of tefillah, as we know. There's2:54Shacharit, Mincha, and Arvit. Each one comes in a specific time, and the Gemara learns it from a pasuk in Daniel, right?2:59So you see from here,3:01the concept of3:03tefillah is not something constant.3:06And again, like we said, tefillah is that love of attaching to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.3:14It says, efshar klal lihyot kol hayom bitfillah lifnei Hashem yitbarach, because it's impossible that a person should be constantly a full day in front of HaKadosh Baruch Hu with tefillah.3:23Veeino bkoach haadam shebeguf klal, and it's not in the ability of any human being who's still bound to his body.3:33Even the appearance of malachim,3:36even HaKadosh Baruch Hu revealing Himself to malachim, and as the navi Yeshayahu says when he saw3:43Maaseh Merkavah, he says, kmareh habazak. It's like the appearance of a lightning. How does the lightning come? It's a second, and that's it.3:49That is the extent of the devekut with HaKadosh Baruch Hu.3:54Even for those that have a clear recognition of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, it's only temporarily.4:10Rabbi Elazar ben Durdaya, heirbabet vela'ashes. The Gemara tells us in Masechet Avodah Zarah about a baal teshuva who was called Elazar ben Durdaya. But at the end, when he came to do teshuva from his sin,4:14this is that—I can't go through the whole story, but for those who know,4:17this is that famous person who was with a zonah until the zonah made a comment to him that made him really sincerely do4:28teshuva. And he asked the mountains and the sky and the earth to pray for him, and nobody wanted to pray for him4:33until he says, Ein ha'davar talui ela bi, and he cried himself until his soul came out and the voice came out,4:42Rabbi Elazar ben Durdaya mezuman lachayei ha'olam haba. This is Rabbi Elazar ben Durdaya. Now it says over there he prayed to the point that his neshama left him.4:48Pashut pshat is that he did such a sincere teshuva that he died of4:52teshuva. He explains, Hein mekoach ribui tefillah ke'ein mekoach adam... He prayed too much, because a human being cannot possibly... tolerate or cannot handle such a level of devekut, to be consistently praying,5:09to be too much praying. We pray, but we're attaching in and out.5:13We're getting a signal here and there, if we're getting the signal.5:16Levai we should get the signal even once in a while.5:20Gemarei haBazak would also be good. In any case, right, the Rabbi Elazar ben Durdia prayed so much, that means he was fully connected,5:28that it was intolerable for the human being.5:35חזל tell us that tefillah is called5:40avodah shebalev. Again, we're far from this because we don't even put a little bit of effort.5:44A little effort, we'll get a few words out here and there with a little bit of kavanah, just the5:49words. But to be דבוק to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, how far are we from that?5:52He explains, because it's avodah shebalev, it tires a person, it wears a person out.5:58However, the Torah, we don't find it's called—although there is a pasuk that says, Tushiyah,6:03it's mateshet kocho—however, we do find the Torah is also called6:09lechem, לכו לחמו בלחמי, and mazon, it's considered like sustenance,6:14v'etz chayim hi lamachazikim bah. The Torah is also called a tree of life,6:16because6:18היא נותנת קיום לאדם היושב בחדרו בחדרו, because really Torah gives a person life.6:23It empowers him,6:25it strengthens him,6:26it gives him the energy through the wisdom that he gains from the Torah.6:32It actually boosts him up more.6:38לכן אמר בה, לא ימוש ספר התורה הזה מפיך. The Gemara, the Torah, the pasuk says, as we say all the time in Sefer6:43Yehoshua, the Torah should never leave you at all times.6:46Why is that so?6:48Because the Torah, unlike6:50tefillah, you through Torah, you can be mamash attached to it and constantly with it.6:54שלא יבטל אפילו רגע אחד, even for a moment.6:57Now, before he continues,6:59this is—just today somebody asked this question,7:01so it fits very7:02well—who's exempt from...7:06Tefillah. Chazal tell us7:08everybody is chayav in tefillah. People are7:09patur from tefillah. People like Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai and7:13his chaverav, where they completely spent every moment of time in Torah,7:19they're patur from tefillah. So you see from there the same idea,7:22that because they're getting their attachment through the Torah,7:25they don't need the7:26tefillah. They can forego it.7:28Anyway, let's come back for it.7:34Let's come back. V'zeh ta'am, oved lifnei hamelech v'sha'al lifnei hamelech b'rachot. The Gemara, the end of perek7:37Rebbi... very interesting Gemara.7:38Gemara says over there7:39about Rabbi Yochanan—I think it's Rabbi Yochanan ben7:43Zakkai—who had a son that was sick,7:45and he sent a message to Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa.7:48He7:49tells Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa, Please pray for him.7:50Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa prays for him, and the son is healed.7:54So Rabbi Yochanan's wife comes to him and tells him,7:56What is this?7:57Your talmid is greater than you.8:00Students greater than the rabbi? He answers, no. He is like an eved lifnei hamelech, and I'm like a sar lifnei hamelech. He's like a slave and I'm like the minister.8:11And simply put, a minister, of course, has a higher position than a slave. But who gets to be in8:18constant contact with the king? The slave, he's always there around the king, helping and8:22serving him. The minister needs a special appointment. He'll get the appointment, but he needs a8:28special appointment to see the king at times. So he explains over here, that's the idea of eved. Eved is avodah shebalev; that's the tefillah. That's why he compared him to an eved, because he is8:40the avodah shebalev. Ve'sar is a person who is a talmid chacham. So the פירוש רשי, rak ha-sar hu talmid b'veit hamelech. He says, although Rashi says what we just said before, that really it's the opposite, that the eved is always by the8:52king. No, he says, without taking Rashi's פירוש, the simple meaning of the Gemara, I could also say that the sar, the minister, is always by the king. He's always got to be ready for the king's questions, to give him advice.9:08Aval eved rak me'eset ha-musho, not so by a slave. The slave needs to be called in only when we need him to clean up or we need him to serve us, then we call him in. Not like what Rashi said, but that's what Rav Tzadok wants to say on this Gemara,9:20that's the talmid chacham. The talmid chacham is the sar, that's Rabbi Yochanan, and by the king at all times. Now, it has to fit exactly how come, how did he answer really his wife's question?9:30Okay, that's something else. Continue now in the last paragraph on this piece, Rabbi Hanan ben Dosa, who was known as the man of tefillah, the man of9:40miracles, he says, Lo timtza b'chol ha-shas mimenu shum halacha. You will not find any halacha in the name of Rabbi Hanan ben Dosa, with one exception: Zulat, except the one exception, Masechet Berachot, in what we call Perek Avot,9:56in Perek gimmel, Mishnah tet, it says, Kol sheyad chato... Kodemet lachochmato. A person whose fear of sin precedes wisdom, right,10:08is considered like a tree that has deep roots, and vice versa if it's not.10:17V'chol shema'asav. And a person whose good deeds precede his wisdom, again he gives the same idea, it's considered like a person who's grounded, and not vice versa.10:31U'misharim kemo Tziporav, m'moftav b'tefilotav, ki ze kol asko. It's the only concept that you find about him.10:34Otherwise, everything that we know about Rabbi Yochanan ben Dosa is just a story in Chazal about his miracles.10:39There was a snake that was biting people. Okay, so he goes there, he puts his foot, the snake dies.10:43They needed tefillah for something, they go to Rabbi Yochanan ben Dosa, he prays, it comes,10:47because that was really his whole eisek. His whole eisek was davka in tefillah.10:57V'shoresh nishmato baTorah hu b'otah memra, d'chochmato kodemet lachochmato. But the shoresh of his neshama was really in the Torah, was in that statement.11:02Meaning to say, every single Jew has a—his neshama has a source; it's connected to one of the words of Chazal, one Torah concept.11:17So this is what he spoke about his whole life, because that's really what was highlighted from Rabbi Hanan ben Dosa:11:25that the chokhmah deTorah was not the ikar for him.11:28It's the yirat chet, the fear of God.11:34The ma'aseh shel Rabbi, ki ze kol hiskaveto tefillah, ka'avodah, because his eisek was the ma'asim, which is tefillah.11:43Veyirah, kemo she'amru zal al pasuk, Yir'u Hashem, as Chazal tell us on the pasuk Yir'u Hashem, that a person has to have yirat shamayim and he has to pray together with a netzach11:49hamma. That's the yirah, which is tefillah.11:51So you see that the avodah of Rabbi Hanan ben Dosa, which was tefillah,11:59was expressed in his statement when he said,12:02right, that yirat chet has to be kodemet lechokhmah, which is, like we said, is prayer.12:07V'zehu midat eved, avodah. And this is the level of eved, who just an12:12avodah. Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, what did he say?12:15He considered himself like a12:18sar. Dabuk baTorah. He was a12:21talmid chacham, as the Gemara says about Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai in Masechet Sukkah,12:27it says, shmonim talmidim hayu lo l'Hillel; eighty students of Hillel had.12:29The smallest of them was Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai,12:32and he didn't leave any part of the Torah that he didn't know.12:38Sheheiyeh baki b'Talmud. The person was constantly attached to HaKadosh Baruch Hu12:41at all times. That's a different level,12:46and that's nekra sar. V'lo niftachim kol sodot haMelech. And therefore, a person who is a minister,12:49he has access to all the secret vaults of the king.12:59Uvadai kol avodah ... sheyesh, keshelo yif'ol b'tefillah tovah, kach imashgichin alav. And certainly, whatever Hashem is doing for him13:01is doing for good,13:02and therefore Hashem reveals to him all the good13:04when he's not able to do it through his tefillah13:06because he's attached to Torah.13:08Hashem opens it up for him.13:11Masha'enken ha'eved. However, not so by13:14an eved. They don't reveal to him the secrets of the king.13:24But being that the eved is requesting from the king13:27that he should do good for him,13:29that's the same idea when a person is praying.13:31So Hashem answers him because otherwise he doesn't understand13:34it's not good for him.13:35So therefore Hashem has to answer him13:36just because, you know, he requested.13:43And then he has to work on seeing13:44that whatever Hashem is giving him is actually the good.13:47But13:49in mitzvah avodah, not so. The sar, the minister, has access to the inner vaults of the king.13:53He has access to the secrets of the king.13:56He doesn't need to—I mean, his avodah is in the limud Torah,13:58but he's completely there with the king at all times,14:01and that's a level of Torah14:03that he completely attached to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.