Torah · MussarMussar209A. The דמיונות in TefillaTzidkat HaTzadikPart 209Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 11, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0012:23Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzadka tzaddik ot reshet 209, this will probably be part one.0:06We're still talking about a person's dimyonot, and the last recording we explained that the main battle0:14against the yetzer hara is in this area, but the reward is that you're able to be able to0:22mechaven, and it comes out like, excuse me, they're able to be mechaven tefillah. They give you the reward,0:26which is the door of the king, which is tefillah, and we explained that0:29in tefillah is really a great battle. We always wonder, our mind wanders tremendously0:36when we pray, and this is what Rav Tzadok says over here. We didn't say it on our own.0:42Rav Tzadok in this piece deals with dimyonot and tefillah. He says,0:45Be'et ha-tefillah yoter ha-dimyonot govrim ba'adam. During tefillah, this is the time when the0:52dimyonot and the daydreaming becomes the strongest for the person.0:59V'zehu ayun tefillah, shen adam nitzol b'chol yom. The Gemara says,1:02Masechet Bava Batra, there are three things a person is not saved from it every single day. One of them is ayun tefillah.1:10What does it mean, ayun tefillah? So the Tosafot over there explains that a1:14person cannot stay focused. Well, not Tosafot, really, I'm sorry. Others explain—Tosafot has a different1:21explanation. Others explain that a person cannot focus on doing his tefillah; his mind is always wandering.1:27There, the Tosafot brings,1:34Masechet Rosh Hashanah, ... lo kavenit kepashteh, and there the Tosafot brings a Yerushalmi. Now, in order to1:41appreciate the next part of the, what's it called, of the Rav Tzadok, I would like to pause for a second and quote to you the1:50Yerushalmi that Tosafot brings on the Gemara that says that a person is not saved from ayun tefillah,1:56which according to some opinions it means that a person every single day, it's impossible that he2:01will not be able—it will be able to focus completely on tefillah. He's always going to be able to space;2:05he's always going to have a battle of spacing out. So Tosafot brings the following Yerushalmi. It's2:11a very interesting Yerushalmi. I'm going to go to Yerushalmi for a second, aboutai. We get to learn a piece2:15of Yerushalmi. It's a very interesting Yerushalmi. We'll tell you what's halachah and not halachah in a2:19little bit. It says over there, Rabbi Yirmiyah b'shem Rabbi Elazar... Rabbi Yirmiyah says in the name of2:25Rabbi Elazar, Nitpalel v'lo kiven libo. A person who prays and did not have kavanah, that means, let's explain what kavanah means.2:31It means he wasn't focused on what he was saying. He just read the words, but his mind was not there.2:35He didn't actually mean it when he said, Hashiveinu Adonai eilecha, Hashem, bring us back to your2:43Torah, v'hazireinu b'teshuvah shlemah lefanecha. He didn't have kavanah when he said that.2:47When he said Modim, he didn't actually mean, Thank you, Hashem. He just read the words.2:53So, it says over there, Nitpalel v'lo kiven libo. Im yodea3:00shehu chozer u'mechaven libo, yitpalel; v'im lav, al yitpalel. If he knows that he could go back and pray the Amidah again with kavanah,3:06then he should go back. If not, he should not go back.3:09Now, the Rashba on this, Girushalmi in this Teshuvot, and the Tur, and that's3:16halacha also Shulchan Aruch as well, says a person who says the Amidah and he did not have kavanah,3:22he should not repeat the Amidah. Ah, the Yerushalmi says over here if he could be mechaven, he should go3:27back. He says, Yeah, because we're worried that you're going to go back and not be mechaven, and you end3:31up saying a brachah levatalah. And therefore, if you didn't have kavanah, sorry, it just goes. But you see again,3:36this concept that a person in tefillah is not able to concentrate in tefillah, something3:42very old, from over 2,000, not over 2,000, but at least 1,800 years ago, the Gemara in Yerushalmi is already bringing3:49this. Now, Gemara continues. It says, Amar Reb Chiya Rabbah. Reb Chiya Rabbah, which3:55Tosafot quotes in Masechet Rosh Hashanah, that's Reb Chiya Rabbah, the great Reb Chiya, this famous4:00Reb Chiya who was a student of Rabbi Yehudah Hanasi, says, Ana min yomai lo kavanit. I never concentrated. One of the commentaries,4:10Pnei Moshe, explains is that he was always troubled. His mind was always busy with thoughts of4:15Torah, and therefore he wasn't able to concentrate. He never ever concentrated in his amidah.4:22One time, I want to be mechaven, and I thought about it in my mind, and I was thinking4:29who would go in front of the king first, the arkapsa or the geluta, the person who's in charge,4:34who is considered the more chashuv. You know, basically, how do you go in to the king first? Do you4:42bring the more chashuv first, or you bring the people that are less chashuv and then the more4:47chashuv? Shmuel amar, Ana manit efrochaya. Me, when I'm praying, my mind is wandering and I'm counting the birds that fly around.4:54So he says over here that the Pnei Moshe again explains this is the efrochim that come from the—not the birds,5:01but the angels are flying from the machshavot of the Torah. Rabbi Bun bar Chiya amar, Ana manit dimusaya. I count the rows in the5:08building. Amar matana, machzik tebul leroshi. I have to be appreciative to my head. Why?5:18Dikad hava matem odim hu kara migarmei. When he gets up to Modim, my head knows how to bow down by itself. From all this, it sounds like5:26that even the great Amoraim weren't able to concentrate. Shmuel, we're talking about over5:38here, Rabbi Chiya, the son of Rabbi Yehuda Nasi. It's amazing, right? So there's another commentary here in the Yerushalmi. It's a peirush from the Sefer HaCharedim, and he says—this is one point—he says, what does it mean when he5:45said, I never had kavanah? Klomar, tefilah merosh ad sof bli shum hirhur. He says, I never had full concentration from beginning to end,5:53not that chas v'shalom that he never had concentration; he was never able to focus completely.6:00Shekedushim, he says, Halilah shekedoshim hallalu lo hayu mechavnim ela yehabea atzad ones hirhur over vchoshev mechaven. He says, if it happened—what they mean to say, that if it happened, they would not be able to6:13concentrate, that's only because of ones. But then they'd go back and they'd pray with concentration.6:17Okay, now we could come back to Rav Tzadok. After he quoted this6:25Tosafot that quotes the Yerushalmi, so he says,6:34Uv'emet, al anashim gedolim ka'eilu lachok min hazeh. To say such a thing about such great people, such the Amoraim—we're talking about6:40first-generation Amoraim like Rabbi Chiya—it's very, very hard to believe this. Like the Chassidim themselves says,6:47chas v'shalom, they didn't have kavanah, right? But Tosafot brings a kipshuto, like they didn't have6:52kavanah. He says,6:56Befrat Rabbi Chiya, ... especially Rabbi Chiya. He quotes the story very, very quickly, but basically there's a story7:02in Masechet Bava Metzia that says that they asked Eliyahu Navi, you know, how can we bring Mashiach? He says,7:10If Rabbi Chiya and his two kids, Rabbi Chizkiyah—if Rabbi Chizkiyah and the somchim would be Rabbi7:15Chiya's two kids, they could bring Mashiach. So they set it up in a way without them knowing.7:20Rabbi Chiya was a chazzan, and his two kids were by his side. When they got up to7:26the words Mashiv haruach, all of a sudden it wouldn't start blowing, and they said7:31Morid hageshem, all of a sudden it started raining. Every word that they said brought about. So how could you say that such great people like Rabbi7:36Chiya didn't have kavanah? What, they just started read words and it came down by itself? Obviously7:41they had kavanah. So, and not only that, Eliyahu Navi says these are the people,7:44so much so that in Shamayim they were scared that Rabbi Chiya would continue his7:51amidah, Mashiach would actually come because when he would pray for it. So therefore7:54they sent Eliyahu Navi, who came as a bear and distracted them completely.8:00From being able to pray, and he stopped the whole tefillah, interrupted in the middle, and everybody had to run away because of the bear.8:06So this is Rabbi Chiya who says, I never had kavanah. So he explains,8:11what does he mean when he says, Lo kavaneti, I didn't have kavanah?8:14Means lo hutzrach. He didn't need to put kavanah, the kavanah,8:21talei sheyach b'baal dimyon. You know who needs kavanah? You know who needs to concentrate?8:26It's like a teacher in teaching a class, whether it's adults or kids,8:29he says, Hey, moti, focus. That means he wasn't focused till now,8:35right? That's the one who we tell to focus.8:37You know who needs kavanah? A person who's a baal dimyon u'machshavot, a person who's in the world of dimyonot and his mind wanders,8:45he needs to focus. Shelashonו sholach ledaber, af shel bo bal amo. His tongue just keeps talking even though his mind is not with him,8:54and therefore he needs to have kavanah.8:57And that is most of us, right?9:00That is really how we all feel. We feel the same now we feel. That's how we all are.9:07Our mouth just reads the words, and our mind's not there.9:12Why? Because our mind is in the world of dimyonot and9:18machshavot. Rabbi Chiya, when he says, Lo kavaneti, I didn't have to be mechaven.9:23Now, this is Rav Tzadok's approach.9:25It's definitely not the simple way of understanding; the Yerushalmi,9:29certainly the mefarshim on the side had their own way, but this is how he's explaining it.9:32And that's what he's saying: I didn't need to be mechaven,9:40because Hashem was in front of him at all times.9:46And when he would speak to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, he knew,9:50he had such, like we said in the previous letter, he had such awareness of HaKadosh Baruch Hu9:55that he always spoke in the same manner that a person would speak to the King of Kings.10:01He says, now, how do you read the rest of10:03the... He says one time that he wanted to be mechaven. What does that mean?10:06He says, פירושו שצריך לכך. He says one day he needed to be mechaven.10:16Why? It means he needed to actually focus his mind. And that day, you know, there was a day that he needed to focus. Why?10:20Because he had things that bothered him.10:23Maybe he brings Rav Tzadok,10:27אולי היינו עומדא דבבא מציעא דליהו תלדיןהו. Maybe that was the case when Eliyahu Hanavi distracted him.10:30He came as a bear and he distracted the tefillah.10:35Then he actually needed to put the effort to focus because he had lost his connection,10:44his constant connection to HaKadosh Baruch Hu,10:47and it didn't help him. Why?10:50Because Eliyahu was sent specifically as a messenger from heaven to distract him.10:57Also, the other Amoraim that are quoted there,11:02they're also not talking about as a general thing.11:05They're all just saying at specific times only, when they had to put effort to concentrate.11:14But תמיד לא צריך כוונה כלל. But at all times, they didn't11:20need to focus. It's just natural.11:27But everybody else, it's almost impossible to be saved.11:30Do you understand the difference?11:31It's like the difference between when you were dating and you're married.11:35When you're dating, every word that you're, you know, the girl that you're going out with says,11:39you're like listening and you hear everything and you're there, you're in the conversation.11:44When you get married, how many times does the spouse have to tell her husband,11:47wife has to tell her husband,11:49Hey, hello.11:50Oh, what?11:51You're talking?11:52Oh, I'm sorry.11:52I'm talking to you. What do you mean?11:54What did I just say?11:57What happened?11:58So you kind of get used to it, right?12:01So that's the difference.12:02So you see,12:04you have to say focus when you're dating.12:06No, you're there.12:08But when you're married, you have to say focus because you get spaced out.12:12That's the difference between the two levels.12:14We're going to pause over here because otherwise, even though I might be able to squeeze it,12:18but I'm going to keep it over here for second part,12:20because that's the same part two12:22in a different recording.