Torah · MussarMussar206A. How to Stop the דמיונותTzidkat HaTzadikPart 206Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 5, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0017:00Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat HaTzadik, resh vav, 206,0:04be'ezrat Hashem, hopefully what we haven't done in a while, that this piece will be in one recording, be'ezrat Hashem.0:11Let's begin. Now, I just want to tell you before we begin, actually, just a few points, and that is that it's a very Kabbalistic piece.0:18Not that the item, the concept is not Kabbalistic, but the terminologies that he uses back and forth to try to prove his point are a little bit Kabbalistic.0:26I'll try to explain whatever I can. Whatever I can't explain, it's not because I don't want to; I just don't understand myself some terminologies.0:33I called my local mekubal, and he himself wasn't familiar with some of the terminologies that Rav Tzadok used.0:42Let me see if you need other— okay, let me give you another introduction. Ready? A little bit of background.0:48You go to a doctor. Imagine you develop a rash on your skin. Or better, this is, I know because the following happened actually to me.0:55Imagine you get a pink eye, okay? So what's the first thing you do? You don't want to go to a doctor, especially eye doctors.1:03I don't know why eye doctors take so long. Every eye doctor I go to, there's like a whole waiting thing.1:09Every, you know, it's not— I'm not talking about the one that's just like local, regular. I'm talking about the ones that really examine the eye and everything else,1:15okay? You sit there for hours. You don't want to do that. So you know, you see pink eye, you Google it, you look on Amazon, you know, pink eye treatment.1:23You ignore every warning, and you just buy the drops, and boom, pink eye is gone, right?1:30Now, what happens later on usually? Usually what happens later on, it comes back.1:35Okay, so you use the drops again, it comes back. Now it comes back worse, and now it comes with pain.1:39It comes with other things, and now you get nervous. What's going on? You go to the doctor.1:45The doctor tells you, Why'd you come to me before? You say, What do you mean? I was treating it.1:48He says, No. What's going on is that there's an infection in your eye, and the infection is showing externally on the white part of your eye with red, redness.2:01Now, you treated the redness, but you didn't treat the infection. So we all are familiar with such treatments, which are external.2:10But an expert—what makes him an expert is that you have to wait to see him. No, I'm kidding.2:15But an expert is a person who is able to look deeper to the source and understand where the problem is stemming from.2:24This is a very big, big yesod in expertise in every single area.2:30I'll just give you an example medically, but it's also in construction.2:34You get people that are, you know, what do you call it, house inspectors. If you've had bad experience, like some of us did,2:43so you know that when you get an inspector and they're supposed to look at the house, they see a beautiful house because that's what the seller wants you to see.2:51An inspector is supposed to look deeper and see if this house may have some potential problems.2:56Like, for example, there could be leaks in this house. They know how to look for that.3:01There could be water line damage, and they know how to look for that.3:04Electrical damage, electrical problems that you could only see once you move in and once you start to use it on a regular basis.3:11That's the difference between a regular person and3:14expertise. Rabotai, it is the same thing when it comes to the spirit, when it comes to spirituality.3:21It's the same thing also emotionally. People pay top money to go to therapists.3:26What the therapist is trying to do is to dig deeper into the problem.3:30The following, I would say, is an emotional, spiritual digging to figure out the source of certain problems.3:38So, as we told you till now, that we've been discussing dimyonot. If you've been following us till now, even if you haven't been following us,3:47basically we've been discussing two things are opposites:3:50dimyonot versus chokhmah. Dimyonot are imaginations.3:57You know, things are not real, basically. It's imaginary. It's not realistic.4:01You're not in tune with reality, basically. It's just ideas4:04that happens to be the— The system, or the way a person gets4:11nevuah, it's also in that olam, because it's not something that you earn; it just develops on its own.4:18And chochmah is something that you earn, that you work, that you toil for, that you produce yourself,4:25not something that is a result of whatever it is.4:28So now, when it comes to dimyonot, when it comes to dimyonot, they stem, we said, it could be from what you look at.4:35So he says over here, but even what you look at, we said this in Parashat Shelach here in the shul, those of us who were here,4:43is that it says in the Torah,4:48V'lo taturu acharei levavchem v'acharei eineichem. Don't stray after your hearts and your eyes.4:51And everybody asks the question, it should be the opposite,4:54because when you see something, then you desire it.4:57So why does the Torah say first don't stray after your heart and then after your5:01eyes? The simple answer is you'll only be able to notice things that you want to notice.5:09That means if you take two people now walking down the street, right?5:13You got a father and a son,5:15okay? Now they're walking by many, many different items.5:19At the end of the walk, they come home, and the mother says, Oh, how was your walk today?5:24So you say, Oh yeah, we took a different avenue, a different route from shul to the house.5:30What did you see?5:32Each one will notice something else.5:34The father will notice, Oh, I saw beautiful houses.5:36The kid doesn't even notice the beautiful5:37houses. He says, I noticed I saw beautiful bikes.5:41Well, the kid who is a child, well, his heart is telling him he needs a new bike.5:45He likes a new bike, and he can't wait for a new bike,5:48so he notices the bike.5:50The father couldn't care less about a bike.5:52He cares about a nice house,5:54because his wife is complaining there's no storage and there's no room for the kids5:57and there's no room and it doesn't look good and you need a bigger house.6:01So now he got into his head,6:04so he wants also the new house,6:05so he sees big houses.6:06That's what he notices.6:07So it's really the levav,6:09it's the heart that makes our eyes notice what we end up noticing.6:17So we said that already, that those come from the heart and the things.6:19But the shoresh of all that... I mean to say, what is it in our hearts that makes us see or notice certain things,6:28or makes us want certain things?6:30So this is what Rav Tzadok says, discusses in the beginning of this piece,6:35and then he gives us a solution a little bit later on.6:37Let's get to it.6:44כלל הדמיונות והרהורים שבאדם הם קבועים בשלושה שורשים. The dimyonot of the person, they're really rooted into three things.6:52What are these three things?6:53These are the famous three evil traits6:57the Chazal tell us could destroy a person,7:01מוציאין את האדם מן העולם, could remove a person from this world and the world to come.7:04What are they?7:07קנאה, תאווה, וכבוד. The three major, the three major bad traits are jealousy, taavah, which is running after desires, and kavod, and the need to have honor.7:23Now, honor could be prestige, could be recognition;7:26it's all under kavod.7:28שמשורשם מידות רעות. As we all know, these three midot are really the source of all other bad7:35midot. Now, kaas is not listed here,7:37but kaas is under the kinah,7:39because people get jealous of other people and they get upset at them.7:43It could be also as a result of7:46taavah, because one doesn't get what he wants and he gets upset.7:49Now, these three are the source of all bad7:51midot. However, שורש השורשים, the source of these three bad midot, הוא הגאות. If you go deeper.8:00The deeper you think about it, these three bad midot, as terrible as they are,8:05as hasanah, talas, kinat, ta'avah, kavod, are really rooted into one horrible8:09midah. What is that?8:12Ga'avah. Ga'avah, very—how am I going to translate that?8:16It should be not, you know, they call haughty. That's not just haughty. Ga'avah is a person8:22is out of place.8:23It says in the pasuk, Adonai malach, ge'ut lavash. So is ga'avah bad? And we're8:29supposed to follow the ways of God. Hashem is ge'ut. It says He's above. He's above everybody.8:34For Him, ga'avah, it's befitting Him. But for all of us, ga'avah is when we think beyond8:42ourselves.8:43For Moshe Rabbeinu to go up to Korach and say, You better back off. I'm the leader here,8:48and Aharon is going to remain the Kohen Gadol, that's not a lack of anavah. That's not8:55ga'avah. That isn't anav.8:56But he recognizes his place. He knows where he's supposed to be, and he understands that9:00it all came from God.9:02He's not anything. And even those who recognize that they're supposed to be leaders, if they9:07don't understand it came from God, that's also ga'avah. They think that they did it themselves.9:10Ga'avah is not recognizing the reality of where you're supposed to be, trying to, you9:26know, take credit or trying to take something beyond what your abilities can handle. So he says, really, ga'avah is the source of these three bad midot, which are themselves9:32the source of all bad9:34midot. Now, for a second, let me just tell you how this is so, because I see already I'm going9:38to have to go into a second recording anyway.9:41Ga'avah is a source of jealousy.9:44How is that so?9:45Well, if you don't—why would you be jealous? In the words of the Ibn9:50Ezra, the Torah says, Lo tachmod, the tenth, what we call the Tenth Commandment, right?9:57The tenth dibur, Hashem commands, Lo tachmod eshet reacha. Do not desire your friend's wife. Do not10:03desire his home. Do not desire his money, his shoro v'chamoro, his ox, his donkey. It says the Ibn Ezra, how in the10:10world do you expect a person not to desire? It's a feeling. You see, you're a single guy10:16trying to get married, and you see everybody's getting married, and you see this guy married10:18the girl that you really wanted. You don't want that. You see people have beautiful homes.10:23How can you tell the guy, don't desire it? He wants it. He, you know, he has a large family10:29crammed into a one-bedroom apartment, so he wants the larger house. He wants the nicer car. How can10:34you tell a person not to?10:35So Ibn Ezra gives his famous mashal. He says, imagine what we call a peasant, a poor10:44person, who happens to be by a parade where the king is, you know, coming, and the king is sitting10:54in this beautiful wagon, and together with his daughter. Would the peasant ever think11:00or desire that daughter? Of course not. He doesn't think about the daughter because he knows it's out11:07of line for him. It's beyond him. It's not something that's for him. And also for all11:11of us, when we get jealous of other people, it's really because we feel that we also11:18should get such a thing. That means you won't be jealous of somebody that's majorly rich,11:24majorly rich, no, but you'd be jealous of somebody that's within your league, somebody11:27within your community, somebody on your block, somebody within your neighborhood, somebody11:31that you could relate to. So it comes out that when you're jealous, really, even when11:36you're jealous of the guy in your community or the guy on your block or your best friend,11:39you really—it's a source of ga'avah because you feel that you deserve such a thing. If11:44you desire the princess's daughter, it's because you feel you could marry the princess, excuse me, the princess. That11:51means you feel you're on the level to be the king's son-in-law. You follow what I'm saying?11:56So that's if you're ever jealous, it really stems from gaavah. So we explained how12:00gaavah fits into. What about taavah? How does gaavah fit into taavah, desire? And12:06the answer is the same idea. What we desire—now, we're not talking about a person who has to eat12:11or has to do things. We desire because we feel we deserve it. We feel we could have it. And12:17therefore, a person who's running after the desire, he feels—he's not thinking, I'm a12:20baal taavah. Remember, all these people that have these bad middot, they don't think they have12:24bad middot. Nobody could live with such a conscience. They feel that they're fine. A12:29person who's always running after his desires and is running after his taavot because12:32he feels like, you know, I need a little break. So that also stems from gaavah. And12:38kavod is clear. A guy who feels that he needs a certain respect and a certain prestige,12:45and who demands a certain level of kavod, it's obviously—that's clear to understand.12:51That's very easy to understand that that could stem from gaavah. In any case, we went12:56a little bit longer because it's a beautiful idea in itself, but let's come back to what13:02we're saying. So the source of dimyonot comes—they stem from bad middot. The bad13:08middot are stemming from the three middot, kinah, taavah, and kavod, and these three stem13:13from gaavah. So now we found the source of all dimyonot, right? It's gaavah. So he13:20says on the gaavah, as is known, the source of evil comes from an empty place, which is shvirat hakelim. This is13:30a concept that one should understand in Kabbalah. When they talk about13:35shvirat hakelim, it's something that basically cannot handle. To understand what that means,13:40shvirat hakelim, take a box. You know those boxes that you get from supermarkets, like a bingo's box13:44or Shmueli's box, you know what I'm talking about? So take a box. And what are you supposed13:48to fill it up with? These boxes are made to fill up groceries. Take that same box and13:52go fill it up with bricks. No, the bricks that they put on top of the houses. Fill it13:58up to the maximum. Pick it up. What's going to happen? The whole box will fall apart.14:02It's not made to handle such weight. This is called shevirat keli. This is the14:07keli, which is a box, has been broken. When you overstuff something beyond its ability, that's14:15called shevirat kelim. Now take that on a spiritual level. When a person gets in what14:20we call over his head, when he gets into something over his head, means beyond what14:25he's able to handle, that's called shevirat kelim. So that's really14:32gaavah. Gaavah is the source of shevirat kelim. What does it come from? From the fact that a14:38person thinks, Ani emloch. I will rule. We mentioned Paro in the last recording, that Paro said14:43about himself that I am God. I created myself, and I am the boss. Now, none of us will say,14:50I will be the king, but we all feel to a certain extent, I am going to take control14:54of something. U'mizeh nolad yetzer hara. And this is really the source. This is how we create our own yetzer hara. The15:03פירוש יצר is a machshavah, as we all know. The word yetzer means a thought, vehirhur balev. The shem hu hatchalat hara balev, because that15:13in the heart is exactly where the yetzer, where the thoughts begin from. Remember, the yetzer hara is created15:22from this. We create our own yetzer hara from this machshavah of gaavah, that we feel15:27that we deserve, we feel that we should get something that we shouldn't get. And that15:32thought, again, might be very fine, but that creates the— The yetzer hara. And why15:43is it created, the yetzer hara? Because that's the yetzer hara. Remember, the thoughts come from the heart. And Chazal tell us, Masechet Berachot, where does the yetzer hara come from? He says over here, yoshev al shnei miftchei halev. The yetzer hara comes, he sits by the openings of the heart. Meaning,15:56it's like imagine you have a flame.16:00And you blow gas, what's going to happen?16:03It's going to ignite the flame.16:06So the yetzer hara is the flame. It sits by the heart.16:10When we have those machshavot, when we have these hirhurim,16:13it ignites that flame and it creates a16:17yetzer hara. Where do these machshavot come from?16:19It's just air. It's just air.16:21And remember, we say that the yetzer hara is from eish, from fire,16:25as we say in Yom Kippur, right before we finish our Amidah.16:28The yetzer hara is that flame.16:32Our machshavot, which is of the hirhur, is just air.16:34It's nothing. It's not real. It's a dimyon.16:36Where does it come from?16:37It comes from our machshavot of16:40gaavah, that we think that we deserve certain things,16:42which is the source that creates the kenah, taavah, and kavod,16:46and that ignites the flame and creates a16:49machshavot, creates a yetzer hara, and that it's a vicious cycle.16:53We're going to have to stop over here because of the timing.16:55B'ezrat Hashem, in the next recording,16:56we'll pick up on this idea and continue.