Torah · MussarMussar205C. How Torah Counters הרהוריםTzidkat HaTzadikPart 205Rabbi Uri Nahum · July 4, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0013:29Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:01Tzedkat HaTzadik, ot resh hei two oh five. This will be part0:06three. We've been talking about dimyonot versus real thoughts versus thoughts of Torah,0:12which is really called0:13chochmah. Last couple of letters, Rav Tzadok has been discussing this,0:16and this particular piece, Rav Tzadok clarifies more and0:21more, as we've been seeing a pattern.0:23Every time there's a group of ideas that come in different0:26otiyot, the later letters clarify much more.0:30In any case, we're dealing now with dimyonot versus0:35chochmah, and we explained that those are represented also by different things in the Torah.0:39And he explained how Mitzrayim, the last audio, if you were coming off the last0:44audio, explained how Mitzrayim, which is considered metzar yam,0:47it restricts the yam of the chochmah, and that's why there were two opposites.0:50It's the king of Mitzrayim was Paro; he is the king of0:56dimyonot. We will add right now, actually as we're thinking about it,0:59so much that he himself declared himself a god.1:02That's mamash a dimyon, as opposed to Moshe Rabbeinu,1:06who's, as the Gemara says in Masechet Megillah, he was considered ab1:11b'chochmah, because the Torah is called Torat Moshe.1:13Moshe is emet, where everything is1:15emet. Remember, dimyon is also the opposite of1:17emet, so he was also the ab of the chochmah, which is the opposite of Mitzrayim.1:21And we said yesterday that the derei Torah is not only able to counter the1:27dimyonot and tell you what's real and not real,1:28but actually the derei Torah is able to convert, kind of, not convert, but pull out from the dimyonot that which is real.1:37To understand this a little bit better, I think when I was saying yesterday I had some confusing looks1:43giving this, but basically, when you have a dream.1:48Chazal tell us that a dream has one out of sixtieth of1:51nevuah. We've said this in the past.1:52Also, Rav Sadok pointed this out,1:55which means that now a dream is a dream,1:56a daydream or a night dream, it's all the same idea.1:58It's nothing. It's fake.1:59But yet Chazal are saying there's something to it.2:01The taam is not lost.2:03There's something inside of it that's really actually real.2:07Now, if you are actually a2:11navi, where you get your nevuah in the dream,2:15so then it's not one sixtieth, right?2:18Your dream has much more than that.2:20Your dream has much more truth.2:23But even if a person is not a navi, like most of2:27us—I don't know about you guys, no, I'm2:28kidding—like most of us, like almost all of us,2:30none of us are2:31neviim. Okay, in any case, when we have a2:33dream, the real dreams that we have at least2:35are called one out of2:37sixtieth. It means 59 parts of that2:39is all2:40dimyonot, it's all nonsense things.2:43But yet there is that one part that's2:46emet. You go to a person who's a2:49chacham, like let's say, like we found by Yosef,2:51these are dream interpreters2:52that understood how to read a dream.2:54They're able to extract that one point of truth2:59out of the person's what he's thinking about,3:03you know, from the person's dream,3:05and show how it's true.3:06And in fact,3:09Chazal tell us, hachalomot הולכים אחר הפה. When you interpret dreams,3:11it goes, it follows3:12by the interpretation.3:13The reality of the dreams3:15is fulfilled by the interpretation.3:17So the same idea over here3:19with the Divrei Torah,3:20with a person saying Divrei Torah,3:21that Divrei Torah actually is able to3:25extract the ניצוצי קדושה from it.3:27And that's what we find,3:27that he says that in Mitzrayim, actually3:30after every3:31makah, which brought about more of a reality,3:34as the Rambam explains that in Mitzrayim,3:36even Avoteinu, even our ancestors in Mitzrayim,3:39were under the Egyptian influence.3:43And although they were not3:45kofrim, chas v'shalom, but people started to doubt:3:47is there really Hashem?3:49Does Hashem really have the power?3:51Is Hashem still controlling the world?3:53So every makah that Hashem brought, really,3:55was to show His control,3:59which, in our, for our sake at least,4:01we could say4:02that's the emet.4:04The dimyon was that there's other powers.4:07The sheep has power,4:09the avodah zarah has power,4:10the Egyptians have power,4:12Paro has power.4:13Every makah showed that they have no power;4:15Hashem really has the power.4:16And that's how we were able to be4:19mevarer, to be able to take out the bad—the good,4:22excuse me—that's inside of the bad that they have.4:25So we explained the last thing we left off is that4:27that's why after every4:29makah, Moshe would go inside of Paro's castle4:32to extract that good4:35that the time has come to take it.4:37Finally, right before4:39Makat Bechorot, he tells him,4:40You will never come to see me again,4:42because the day you see me,4:43you're going to die.4:44Moshe says,4:44You said very well,4:45because it's not for me to catch.4:47And from that we're picking up,4:48and he says,4:50וְכֵן אָמַר אַחַר כָּךְ לְיִשְׂרָאֵל. And Moshe tells Bnei Yisrael the same thing.4:55הגם שלא היו אדם מעל מדרגת משה רבינו, even though they were not on the level of Moshe Rabbeinu,4:58but Moshe Rabbeinu tells Bnei Yisrael the same line.5:00He tells them,5:01Just as you see Mitzrayim today,5:03you will not see them anymore.5:06Now when was this said?5:07This was said by Kriat Yam Suf.5:09Right before Kriat Yam Suf,5:10when the Egyptians were coming5:11and Bnei Yisrael were all getting nervous,5:13and Chazal tell us some people wanted to go back,5:15some people wanted to kill themselves,5:16some people wanted to fight,5:17some people wanted to pray,5:18and on all them Moshe tells them,5:21ה' ילחם לכם ואתם תחרישון. Stop. Nobody's fighting,5:24nobody's going back,5:25nobody's killing himself,5:26nobody's praying even.5:28We are going into the Kriat Yam Suf,5:30and you will never see the Egyptians again.5:32Now that's the same line5:34that Moshe told— Paro,5:37or Paro told Moshe,5:38and Moshe agreed to it5:39because there's nothing more.5:41There's no more5:42kedushah that we need to pull out of you.5:43That's because Moshe was on a very high level,5:46but Bnei Yisrael were not on such a high level.5:48However, it was said to them, b'kiatem suf,5:51because then they did attain a high level.5:53Like it says,5:54b'kiatem suf,5:59sheratah shifchah al yamah shel Yechezkel ben Buzi. Even the lowest level,6:01lowest element amongst the Jewish people6:03was able to see on such a high level,6:06higher than one of the greatest6:08nevi'im, which is Yechezkel Hanavi.6:13Then because they reached such a high level,6:16he told them,6:16You6:20will not see them anymore.6:22Now why did Torah have to tell us6:25that Paro declared6:26that, Hey, you're going to see me,6:27you're going to die?6:29What does that have to do with?6:30It's like a threat.6:30Okay, what do I need to know6:31every little detail?6:32I'm sure there was much more to the conversation.6:34Why did Torah select this threat to put6:39it6:40in?6:42Well, he says an idea.6:44Listen to this.6:44If Moshe Rabbeinu was able to6:47really extract the Jewish people with one6:49makah, he obviously didn't need to bring ten6:56makot. And he wants to say6:58that through every7:00makah, it brought about the truth of Moshe7:04Rabbeinu, that he has no7:05demyonot. He lives in the real world of reality.7:07When he says7:08the God of the Jewish people,7:09and Paro laughed at7:09it, What God?7:10What Jewish people?7:11I don't recognize Him.7:12It's a reality.7:13You know, it's like when7:15somebody—like imagine today7:16a navi would come and say,7:17This and this is going to happen,7:18and the people would make fun, is7:21either they hold that he's not really a navi,7:23or they hold that7:25whoever he's saying in the name of7:27cannot really do it.7:28Paro would hold the same thing about Moshe7:30Rabbeinu. He's not really a navi,7:31and even if he's saying in the name of God,7:33God has no ability to do such a thing.7:35So came out that7:36each makah was showing7:40that Moshe was 100% right.7:42He is real,7:42and Paro is in the world of imagination.7:48Until the7:50tenth makah. The7:52tenth makah represents the highest— Level,7:55which in Sefirot is called the Keter,7:58which is completely.8:00sealed from everybody. So, which is the reshit, which represents the first8:08ma'amar b'reshit, which represents really, like we said, the highest sefirah, which is called Keter, which8:11is very high level. It shows that he was able to win in all areas. In all areas he was real.8:20There's no dimyonot. Moshe Rabbeinu was holding, as we would say, in every area.8:29However, what does Paro tell him? The day that you will see my face, right?8:35That, which means if you're coming back to me and to appear to me again, then that means8:42I'm going to have a hashpa'ah on you, like we learned already. What you look at has an effect on you.8:46So that's what Paro was telling him, that the day you see me, where I'm going to have an effect on you8:51and you're going to have a dimyon, then I could see that you're really not a man of full truth.9:00Because a person who has gone through ten stages of purification,9:11it's a complete process of purification,9:17like we find by the Aseret HaDibrot, Aseret HaMakot, and same thing,9:24וכן אברהם אבינו... So too by Abraham Avinu, what does Hashem tell him after the tenth trial, which is the test of Akedat9:37Yitzchak? עתה ידעתי כי ירא אלוהים אתה. However, nobody dies unless some sort of sin.9:43ביום מיתתו מתגבר כתרוג אותו חטא, and the day a person is supposed to die, there's a great prosecution of a person on the specific sin9:49that comes against him,9:53and they come and they declare in Shamayim that he's not done yet.9:57He needs to be again retested and refined.10:01Now, a person who's already gone through ten steps of purification,10:06of clarifying and cleansing himself.10:10That's it, you've done it.10:12Olam hazeh, you've done all the ten levels.10:15Shekvar nitbarer already. It can't be done anymore in this world.10:18Therefore, in order to purify more, we need to bring him to a higher world,10:24which is the reason for death.10:25So in short, he's saying is that because Moshe Rabbeinu went through the ten stages,10:30he didn't need to see Paro anymore.10:32If he needs to see Paro, it's because he has to be mevarer more.10:35He has to filter out more from the10:37dimyonot. But already he's gone through the ten stages.10:40Unless you get to the world of emet, unless you go to the other world, which is olam haneshamot after death,10:46then you could go through more, you know, separation or more birur,10:52and that's why he tells10:58him, BeYom ... tamut. It's also brought down in the Midrash about Moshe Rabbeinu, on the day that he was supposed to pass away,11:03his flow of chokhmah was sealed,11:09uvistimut hachokhmah hu hitgabrut hadimyon. And as we said, the two opposites:11:12when there's no chokhmah, the dimyon kicks in.11:15And therefore, in the time that the chokhmah was sealed for Moshe Rabbeinu,11:19that's when the dimyon got bigger.11:22Like we said, they're opposite of each other.11:25Now what are we going to say?11:26Moshe has to undergo a process of purification to purify himself from the dimyonot,11:32right? But already we said he went through ten already,11:37and that's why, ... כתוב נביא. That's why all of a sudden Moshe is called a navi on the last day of his life.11:41We don't find,11:44ולא קם נביא עוד בישראל. We don't find a term. On Moshe Rabbeinu,11:50or a description of Moshe Rabbeinu as a11:52navi, except for that day, if you think about it.11:54Interesting, no?11:55Moshe is11:55the greatest navi; we say this all the time,11:57right?11:58But that Moshe Rabbeinu should be described as a12:01navi, we only find that.12:02We do find, בעל התולדות ה' tells Miriam and Aharon12:06that if there's a person,12:08im yihyeh navi, I speak to him,12:10but Moshe,12:11פה אל פה. But again, we don't find that he describes him directly as12:15a navi. We12:19don't מצא כן תואר זה עליו כי הוא היה חכם ולא נביא, שהוא מדמיון, because he was really a12:20chacham, not a12:22navi. Like we said, because a navi is not his own thing.12:24A navi comes from the outside.12:25That's what we compare to a dimyon.12:27Chacham produces his own.12:31But the day that Moshe Rabbeinu passed away,12:34on that day,12:35נקרא כן. That day, the Torah describes him as a12:40navi. Why? שננעלה החכמה, as Chazal tell us, because the gates of wisdom,12:43or the springs of wisdom, have been sealed,12:45and they have not been flowing to Moshe Rabbeinu.12:50Like we said the opposite.12:53And therefore,12:54just like we said, because the opposites:12:56when the chokhmah is sealed,12:57dimyon becomes more,13:01and when the chokhmah is opened up,13:04it seals the dimyon.13:06You're not going to seal the dimyon.13:08Dimyon is always there.13:09It's when you have more13:11chokhmah that's going to put away the dimyon.13:13And with that, we finish part three.13:15Rabotai, thank you for sticking it out.13:16It's really a really beautiful idea,13:18deep idea from Rav Tzadok,13:21but we're still not done. The next few pieces13:23also, he still talks about13:26dimyonot that come to a person.