Torah · MussarMussar205A. How Torah Counters הרהוריםTzidkat HaTzadikPart 205Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 29, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0017:33Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot resh-heh, 205. This will be part one, as we see that definitely we're going to0:07need more parts, and probably maybe even part three, we'll see. It's a beautiful idea that puts together0:13a lot of the ideas that we've been saying till now, so we need to give a little bit of a background.0:19But today's, this piece, this recording, it's an unbelievable deep idea. It's gorgeous. You know,0:29pay attention. You're going to love it. So let's come back and we explain that we said there's two things are opposites. One is called the dimyon, one is called chokhmah. So the hirhurim,0:37thoughts, we said daydreaming, spazzing, all these things are called hirhurim. These are dimyon.0:43And the chokhmah is a person who uses his own intellect, his own mind to, you know, basically0:48he's in control of it, and he creates it. He studies a subject, he learns something, and he creates it.0:55We said these two things are opposites. When one is there, the other one cannot be there,0:59right? With this chokhmah, there's no dimyon. Chokhmah is facts and real things, as opposed to dimyon,1:05just imaginary things. It can be it's real, it can be it's imaginary. That's the two options.1:10Imaginary, it's not real. It's just your mind's, you know, taking facts, bringing together,1:16very identical to, we said, to like a dream. Now, a dream, Chazal already have told us that a1:22dream is one sixtieth of nevuah, of prophecy, because prophecy is really the same idea. It's not your1:28chokhmah. It's what it is, is it's the dimyon. It's the not the, you know, fake dimyon, not a true dimyon. It's not what we call1:39imagining things which are not real. In this case, you could say it is real. It's just not.1:45What's it called? Just not coming from your own initiative; it's coming from1:52HaKadosh Baruch Hu. So it comes out that chokhmah and nevuah are really also two opposites.1:58Good, keep that in mind. That's going to be needed also for the end of this piece.2:03And one more last thing, and that is that although chokhmah and demyon are two opposites,2:11Chazal tell us, Chacham adif min navi. Chacham is greater than the navi. Why? Because, like we said, one is given to you.2:21A navi, although he has to work on himself to get to the level, but still, at the end of the day,2:26as far as wisdom is, it comes—the chokhmah, which is the person producing that2:34wisdom, is greater than the navi who gets it from an external source.2:40Okay. Now you could understand a side point. This we did not say beforehand, but you can understand.2:45There's a Gemara, Masechet Bava Metzia; it's a famous Gemara, where there was a debate between Rabbi Eliezer and the Chachamim regarding2:51a certain halacha in tumah and taharah, regarding a certain tanur, if it's kasher, if it's tahor, if it's not tahor.2:58And there was a big debate between the rabbis and—they kept on trying to bring proof. Finally,3:02Rabbi Eliezer says, If the halacha is like me, let the walls of the beit midrash cave in.3:08And even though the walls started caving in, the rabbis said, No, the walls are not a good proof.3:13He said, If the halacha is like me, let a stream of water run through the beit midrash, and a miracle3:19happened. And finally, finally, finally, at the end, after the whole discussion, Rabbi Eliezer gets up3:24and he says, If the halacha is like me, let a heavenly voice, a bat kol, come out and say,3:28Halacha is like me. And a voice came out and says, Mah lachem etzel Rabbi Eliezer? Halacha kemoto b'chol makom. Leave him alone. Halacha is like him.3:35Rav Avigdor Miller gets up on his feet and he says,3:40Ein mashgichin b'bat kol. We don't care about the bat kol. Bat kol doesn't take an effect in halacha. Now you're wondering,3:45when you learn this Gemara, what's going on? What do you want? That's what Hashem is telling you.3:49And the answer is, no. Rav Avigdor Miller told us,3:53Lo bashamayim hi. There's a pasuk that says the Torah is not in shamayim. What does that mean? It means3:59it was given through a nevuah, but it was meant to be taken into this world, and the4:05chochmah, that a person has to use his mind to bring it about. It's not something that's in shamayim,4:10and therefore even though in shamayim they are declaring that the halacha is like4:16Rabbi Eliezer, but that's coming מכוח הנבואה, which is4:18dimyon. Chacham is adif than navi. Chacham is greater than a navi, and therefore us chachamim here, that we came to our conclusion4:25that the halacha has got to be the way it's got to be, we don't care much about what the4:33bat kol is saying. Okay, all that is an introduction that's really not only for4:37today's recording, but it's also for the next couple of recordings as well, but all under the4:43אות רשה 205. Now let's get to the words of Rav Tzadok. Hopefully with that introduction4:49makes it a little bit easier. There's some beautiful ideas over here. I wonder if I4:52could go off tangent a little bit, because just to bring out the depth of it. Let's see,5:00בעזרת השם. Okay, says5:06the Gemara, says Rav Tzadok, הדמיונות כולם נולדים מן הלב שבו הם ההרהורים. All the dimyonot, all the, like we said, the imaginary things, are all created,5:14are all a result, the sources from the person's heart. Like we said in the past, there's hirhurim,5:20which are the heart, and then there's the intellect, which is the brain. So it5:25says, where is the source of the dimyonot? That comes from the5:31lev. That comes from the heart. That's where the hirhurim are. From that point, they travel.5:41Uvenimshachim mimenu lamoach. They travel from the heart to the mind. That's one source of the dimyonot, the heart.5:48Also, dimyonot come, and he says,5:56umin haayin. They also come from what the eye is exposed to. She'al yedei hare'iyah nichnasim hirhurim lalev, because through what the eye sees, that's also what brings thoughts to the mind.6:02And we can all relate to this. He quotes Gemara Masechet Avodah Zarah, but without the6:08Gemara, you ourselves, we all understand. You know, you're walking, you see something, all of a sudden6:12things pop up in your head. I'm not talking about necessarily bad things. You can see somebody's house,6:16and all of a sudden you start to imagine, hmm, what would it be if I would have such a house?6:19Or, you know, all these thoughts and everything, it's endless. You understand what I'm6:25saying. V'chen amru sham, he says, that's what we find in6:30Avot d'Rabbi Natan, re'iyah divrei Torah mevatlim hirhurin. Over there, the Pirkei Avot d'Rabbi Natan says,6:38the seeing of words of Torah is able to counter and to nullify the6:45hirhurin. Where does it know this from? It brings a6:59pasuk, Mikera dme'irat einayim samechei lev. Quotes a pasuk, Torat Hashem temimah, me'irat... the Torah, as the pesukim say in Tehillim, mesamchei lev. All these are the words of the Torah. That's what they do.7:04There's two things over there. It says7:07me'irat einayim, that they enlighten the eyes. That's to counter the hirhurim that come from the seeing,7:12and mesamchei lev, to counter the hirhurim that come from the heart.7:19Ve'asru lehistakel bifnei adam rasha. We find Chazal warn us, you're not allowed to look at an adam rasha.7:24Why is that so? Listen to this beautiful deep idea.7:30Ki bepanim boltim kol minei hirhurim shebalev. Lamevinim kedei... as the Zohar explains, in a person's face you could see all of his hirhurim that he has in his mind.7:37Now, you might say, I don't see it. So, like he says over here,7:42lamevinim, for those who understand, they can look at the person's face and see what he's thinking about.7:48The hikiru b'echad, as the Gemara says over there, hikiru b'echad shehayah lo machshevet aveirah shepanav morikot. The Gemara brings a story about a person who was paling, and they said, You're thinking of...8:04Of aveirah. Which aveirah? Specifically the aveirah of zenut. How did they know this? They saw his face paling. So what? Because you could tell from the face what's going on in a person's mind.8:12It could be for good or for worse. In this case, his face was paling, so that's why they said you're thinking of a sin of8:21zenut. And we find the same thing, he says, he brings over here in brackets. Vechen amria bMasechet Sotah, paneha morikot. We find in Masechet Sotah, the Gemara describes in detail the punishment of an isha sotah,8:34and it says over there that when she drinks from the, what do you call it, when she drinks from the water in the mei hamarim, what happens? Paneha morikot. A lot of people think that she turns green.8:46She doesn't turn green. Morikot, from the word rak, empty. She starts to pale. Why in the world is she paling?8:53That's the consequence. We're going to see in a second the reason, but that's the consequence of a person who does the aveirah of zenut, which is the isha sotah.9:02Her face starts to pale. So if so, we find that face paling, when a person's face is paling, it's because of machshevet ra.9:12Now don't go around and start telling this to everybody, because it could be somebody is also not feeling well, they're sick.9:18You know, I don't know. You know, we're not on the level that we could actually come and tell everybody. But those who do understand, that's one way that they could tell.9:27Good. So now he says over here, beautiful idea: Ki aveirah hu mitaleh nefesh. Why? Because the sin is really killing that part of the soul.9:37And we know that in Masechet Gittin it says that a person who dies, mina panav morikot,9:43that there's an angel, as we say it in Yom Kippur in our vidui, an angel comes and he drops three drops which kill the person.9:53And those three drops that killed the person, the Gemara says the words, ממנו פניו מוריקות. From those drops of the sword of the angel of death, the panim, the face, is morik;10:03it becomes, it starts to pale. So again, we see this concept of paling when it comes to death, and that's what we're saying.10:12A sin is also a form of death because it's killing that part of the soul, and that's why it brings about the paleness.10:21So a person starts to, you know, he becomes, he starts to pale. Now, let's continue outside the brackets.10:31That's what we're saying. That's when you look at a person. Why can't you look at a person? That's lashon hara, because you look at them and you can see everything about them.10:38That's why he brings over here the pasuk, הכר פנים. Right? The pasuk says,10:46הכר פנים, לא נתבם. The recognition of their face answered upon them. What does that mean? It means you're able to see who they are,10:53not just obviously recognize them by who they look, but what they really think on the inside by just looking at the face.11:00And the pasuk says,11:02הכר פנים. It's הכר פנים, from the face you could see, and that's exactly what we're saying right now.11:07The face of the person could tell you what's going on on the inside because the hirhurim of a person come out to be in his face,11:14right? You never thought about that, but you got to be careful. Everything is on your face.11:19Now, so what happens? So why can't I look at them?11:23The answer is, when you look at whatever you're looking,11:28נכנסים הרהורים בו. Whatever you're looking at, whatever thoughts he has actually enters you.11:34Has v'shalom. So if it's an aveirah, it enters you. That's why you can't look at a dam rasha, because his hirhurim will be into your face.11:40והיפוך, and the opposite is also true.11:42ויראת מתלמיד חכם, right? Seeing the talmid chacham, seeing him, you see his hirhurim. What's his hirhurim all about? It's all about Torah.11:49That's what enters you.11:52כדאיתא, דחזיתיה לרבי מאיר... as the Gemara says,11:54that Rabbi Yehuda Nasi says, You know why I'm so great? Because I saw Rabbi11:58Meir. I didn't even get to see the whole face. I just saw him from the back.12:01And we wonder, like, okay, so you saw him.12:04Did you learn Torah from him? No.12:06So you saw him. What does that mean? So I put up a rabbi picture.12:08Yes, you have a rabbi picture will actually have an effect on your neshama,12:13because his hirhurim will be in your thoughts.12:18And that's such a good idea, to have in the house pictures of rabbis.12:21And I will add, it's my own little addition, I think it's also true,12:25and that is that try to get also pictures of the rabbi,12:29not as at a political event or regular event, but try to get him at an12:35event. Now, of course, ultimately hachamim are usually thinking Torah all the time,12:38but try to get him as he's doing a mitzvah,12:40because at that time that he's doing the mitzvah, from his panim12:43you'll get to see the actual hirhurim, which is the hirhuri of Torah,12:48which will have an effect on you.12:49Unbelievable, powerful idea, rabotai. It's an unbelievable thing.12:52So he says over here,12:55u'vechen. This is a beautiful idea now he brings.13:00We find Chazal made it very difficult to live in the same neighborhood as a13:05goy. For example, you want to make an eruv, and a goy shares an area with you.13:09Chazal said you can't let him share. You have to buy him out.13:12Buy him out. The guy is going to flip out. He's going to think that we're buying him.13:15Yeah, that's exactly. They made it very difficult on purpose.13:17They don't want you to live amongst goyim.13:19Why is that so?13:21Because not just looking at him will have an effect on you negatively.13:28Because living around the person's area,13:32and in that person, in that goy's possessions13:37and that goy's homes,13:40the power of the person actually extends.13:45As Baal Shem Tov, the Baal Shem Tov pointed out,13:48the Chassidish sefarim all point this out,13:50that a person's kochot... are extended beyond not only his guf,13:57but also extends also to his possessions.14:03Rav Tzadok, I think, I don't know if we mentioned this in the past,14:05but Noach, why Noach and not specific animals were saved,14:08because his kochot extend everywhere.14:10And we find this also in the concept of14:15metzora, that Hashem says if He's going to punish a person,14:19He doesn't— Baal HaRachamim, the Torah says Hashem is a big merciful God,14:23and He doesn't punish a person right away.14:25He first gets his clothing or his house, then his clothing,14:29and then only then He'll attack his body.14:32What do you learn from there?14:33You learn from there this concept that we're bringing,14:35that the person's clothing, the person's possessions, his house,14:38is part of his14:40neshama. Otherwise, what are you punishing his house?14:41What'd the house do?14:42And it says because kochot hanefesh extend even there.14:45So that's also true by the14:47goy. The goy's kochot hanefesh extend also to his property.14:53Therefore, through his property as well,14:56that's also another way for a person to get those15:00hirhurim, in this case bad15:05hirhurim. He says, I heard this idea:15:09the air space or the area of the land of the goyim,15:16it enters, it penetrates inside the hearts of a person,15:19the zadon, the wickedness of the goyim.15:24And the opposite is by Eretz Yisrael,15:29the avira machkim, because the air space of Eretz Yisrael gives wisdom, as Chazal tell us.15:33Why is that so?15:34Because each person, he says, brings over here a Midrash,15:37unbelievable Midrash.15:38It's כדאי to read the entire Midrash.15:40Even the Midrash has a whole different—not whole different,15:42but the Midrash talks another point about this,15:47but he brings it.15:50Ki brit haruk la'avirot, כמו שאמרו בראשית רבה. Over there in the Midrash, in Bereishit Rabbah, I'll tell you where to find it,15:55parashat Noach, perek lamed-daled or tet-vav. Read the whole Midrash.15:57Here he just brings it as a source.16:00Of course, but read the Midrash. He says over there, Midrash, Hashem made a covenant with the avirot.16:06Now, the Midrash says over there, in order to allow people to live in all the different places in the world,16:12Hashem made a deal with parts of the world that they will be inhabited by certain people.16:16But here he brings it that Hashem gave each area in the world a certain power based on who's living there.16:23Hashem designated the boundaries of the world to each nation,16:35and each nation represents a different power.16:39So therefore, just like each nation has a different power, so too each place in the world has a different power to each nation.16:50Therefore, the airspace where a certain nation lives there, and they own it,17:00it's able to punish it from its power inside of the hearts of Jewish people.17:04And that's why you see wherever the Jewish people are, wherever they are in the world, anybody,17:07they're affected by the society, not because of the people they live around,17:10but mamash, even if you live there by yourself, you will be affected.17:19It's inevitable. You'll be affected by the people in the place.17:24Why? Because that's the avirah of the place.17:27We went a little bit over time. This is part one,17:30be'ezrat Hashem. Part two, and maybe part three, we'll see.