Torah · MussarMussar204B. Torah Thoughts vs. Nonsense ThoughtsTzidkat HaTzadikPart 204Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 26, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0013:05Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:01Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot reish daled, 204. This is part0:05two. In part one, we spent a long time explaining some important concepts.0:11In very, very short, in part one we explained, and this is what the theme of the whole subject is,0:16is that basically non-Torah thoughts, or, you know, nonsense thoughts,0:21that we explained them, mochin dekatnut, and those thoughts are, you know, the daydreams,0:27the drifting, spacing, all the different thoughts.0:30We said that a person who puts divrei Torah on his mind, all these other thoughts will disappear, will go away.0:37And we explained because Torah is emet, and the Torah that's emet is able to be0:43docheh a lot of the sheker, which is really what all these thoughts that come into our minds0:48really are, these important nonsense thoughts.0:52The Torah has the ability to push away those kind of0:55thoughts. In any case, we move on now.0:59Oh, one more point, and that is, it was mentioned also that a person, even a person who puts divrei Torah,1:08it's just not possible that person's mind is fully in his control, that he could always be thinking about it.1:15Now, there is a Rambam, I just want to point out, there is a Rambam that talks about the level of1:21nevi'im, what kind of level they have to be on, and he says that they have to be on a1:26level—he uses the lashon of that he never removes the love of Hashem from his mind,1:30tamid. I think he uses the word tamid, constantly, at all times.1:34So there are levels and levels of different people.1:37Most average people, their mind will drift at times here and there.1:41Now, but still, even at that time, there's a difference, and this is the last point that he mentioned,1:47that we mentioned in part one, and we're going to pick up from there.1:50Even at times when it does drift. And you're not totally focused and you don't have the Torah thoughts,1:57even at those times, a person himself still, there's levels.2:02That means the guy whose mind is always thinking about Torah, now that drifts. What does it drift to?2:08So he brings an example,2:11like we find by Yaakov2:14Avinu. Remember, all these drifting, it's daydreaming, it's literally dreams.2:17So look at his dream.2:25Look at Yaakov Avinu's dreams2:27when his mind is drifting, when his mind is not in his control. What are his dreams?2:31His dreams of Hashem standing above him.2:34And that's a difference in what your dreams are.2:37Yes, we don't have full control, but even those of us that work very hard on trying to keep our mind pure,2:44when our mind is drifting, what does it drift to?2:45And he says, like we find by Yaakov Avinu, his mind is dreaming and drifting to thoughts of HaKadosh Baruch Hu standing above him.2:58The dream of Yaakov Avinu is a tremendous level to anybody, anybody else.3:04It's a very, very high level, Yaakov Avinu's dream only, right?3:08And now you can understand from that idea to everybody else and their level.3:17One person, what he thinks, that he's thinking about Torah, for others it's on a lower level.3:23That's called the3:29dimyonot. Because that person looks deeper into the Torah to figure out the truth and the depth of the Torah.3:39This is when we say something is true, it means it's full of, fully, you know, through and through.3:46You're going all the way in and looking at all angles to make sure it's true.3:55That's so clear. It's so clear in his heart, in his mind,4:02mash'ein kein, nikra dimyon. And anything less than that, where it's not 100% emet, that's what's called a4:11dimyon, and not bezohar. Al uviad haneviim edameh. As the Zohar brings down on the pasuk, the pasuk says,4:21And in the hands of the prophets, edameh. What does it mean, edameh? The dimyon hu haspaklaria shelo nahara. Dimyon is a screen that's not so clear,4:27emunah, which is called emunah, umdat4:30layla, and that's represented by the evening when it gets dark and not clear.4:36And that's when it's dark, and a person's mochin, that's the mochin degadlut, are dark and not so visible.4:44As the Rambam brings down, that the image that a person sees, that a navi sees, is not so clear,4:51not so clear, and he has to be able to interpret it.4:54How clear is the image? It's based on his4:57midot. Somebody like Moshe Rabbeinu, who was the top of the ladder,5:02he worked on his midot to refine them to the best that they could be.5:08His nevuah was very, very clear. His nevuah was a kedei. That's what's called5:19haara panim. It's called, like I said, we read in Parashat Behaalotcha, that pe el pe adaber bo. I speak to him mouth to mouth, straight forward.5:22Hashem sees, תמונת ה' יביט. Hashem is—He sees clearly what He needs to see in the nevuah so He can interpret it properly.5:37נרמז, ומקום מקום, דמיונות שלו, שהשם נסב עליו רק שהוא באמונה בלבד. That Hashem still appeared to him in the dream for5:41Yaakov Avinu. That's on the level of emunah,5:46v'lo b'omek libot. It wasn't in the depth, but zeh hem kodemyonot shel navi, ekshot, and that's the dimyonot of all true prophets.5:49Their dimyonot is their dreams, which in itself is a nevuah, like we're saying.5:59And this is actually the level of6:02nevuah. Nevuah is actually on a lower level than wisdom,6:10kemo she'amru b'Batra, that Chazal tell us that chacham is adif min navi. A chacham is greater than navi. And sometimes people wonder, like, what does that mean?6:15We have chachamim, we have6:18talmidei chachamim, tell me they're greater than neviim, but the neviim have to also6:21be talmidei chachamim. What it means to say is the person—it's two different powers.6:26The power of chokhmah, talmid chacham, is the power of6:29chokhmah, and nevuah is what Hashem gives6:33them. The power of chokhmah is much higher level than6:36nevuah. Nevuah, remember, like we said, it's like6:38dimyonot. It's not, per se, chas v'shalom, that they're imagining things, but something that Hashem sensed to them like that.6:44But chokhmah—chokhmah is the person using his mind.6:49That's on a higher level.6:50Now, this doesn't mean that the6:54neviim were not chachamim, chas v'shalom. In fact, one of the conditions is that they have to be on a very high level of6:59chokhmah in order to be able to get the7:01nevuah. But again, what they're exercising, what they're using in that aspect, in that point,7:06the chokhmah is definitely greater than the7:13nevuah. V'hu nevuat Moshe Rabbeinu alav hashalom, b'aspaklaria d'nahara, b'dat emet. And that chokhmah is the same level of Moshe Rabbeinu's7:19nevuah, which is the midat haMishnat Torah,7:21shehi chokhmah v'lo nevuah, because Moshe represented the entire Torah.7:24And Moshe, in fact, is the one who gave us the Torah,7:26and therefore his nevuah was on a level of7:29chokhmah. It's not a7:30level of—it's emet7:33la'amitah, shu bekoach, as Chazal tell us, the difference between Moshe and— All other7:38nevi'im is that Moshe Rabbeinu would say,7:40Ko amar, this is, you know, other nevi'im would say,7:42No, no, this is like Hashem.7:45Zeh hadavar, Moshe would say, This is exactly what I'm telling you is what Hashem said.7:48Moshe had no sfekot, had no doubts from the nevuot that he got.7:53It's like the chokhmah that a person learns.7:55He knows, vadai, it is what it is.7:58Emunah is a belief.8:00You don't know for sure; you just have to believe it is that way.8:03So Moshe Rabbeinu's nevuah is chokhmah.8:08The other nevi'im's prophecy was like emunah,8:13which is,8:15דהיינו ההידמות שהוא כזה ולא עצם הדבר. That's why they said the word,8:17כה אמר ה'. It means it's like this, but it's not actually this,8:22because it's on a lower level.8:23But Moshe Rabbeinu, which represents the higher sefirot,8:32he's madregat הדעת, שלא היה אצלו דמיון כלל. By Moshe, there was no imagination.8:35He didn't have to figure out anything.8:37כי זה הדבר, like he says,8:38זה הדבר. This is exactly what Hashem says.8:42הדעת דבקות מגולה. He is on the מוחין דגדלות, a very clear and open, you know, prophecy.8:48I mean, he sees clearly what it is.8:57כי לא היה דברי תורה אצלו לבד רק בלבו, דמשה מלגאו, וחכמה מדברי תורה, ומבו דמיון, וכוח המדמה, שחוץ לדברי תורה כלל. Because for Moshe Rabbeinu, his mind and thoughts and everything about him, through and through, was with divrei Torah.9:08Everything was divrei Torah,9:10and therefore, because everything was divrei Torah, everything was9:16Torah, everything was emet. There's no safekot by him.9:17There's no doubts by him.9:19There's no dimyon,9:21and there's no room for a prophecy to be interpreted not the way it's supposed to be.9:26That was Moshe Rabbeinu.9:31אבל לדברות נאמר, והיו הדברים האלה על לבבך. It says that these words, the words of Torah, we say, should be on your heart.9:37And you ever wonder why it doesn't say,9:39בלבבך, it should be in your heart?9:41Why?9:43שזה אי אפשר. Says Rav Tzadok, because to have it ממש in your heart, that's not possible.9:49ולא קם נביא עוד בישראל כמשה, because nobody ever, as the pasuk testifies,9:52there's nobody ever that came around9:54that's on Moshe Rabbeinu's level,9:58שיהיה עצם לבבו ונפשו רק דברי תורה, whose whole essence, everything about him, through and through, is only divrei Torah.10:04לכן נקראת התורה על שמו. This is why we call it Torat Moshe, the Torah of Moshe,10:08כי הוא ממש כולו דברי תורה, because Moshe was entirely Torah.10:13אבל זולתו, anybody besides Moshe Rabbeinu, had divrei Torah10:16רק על הלב. His divrei Torah, at best, is that's on his heart,10:20but it's not through and through.10:23והלב דבר אחר, and the heart is something else,10:25דמיון. And the heart, like we said10:28beforehand, that's where imagination is contained.10:33Therefore, the heart is different from the actual Torah.10:38Vechochmah u'metzad hadimyon hu nevuah, and that's from the dimyon is where nevuah comes from.10:43Ki daat davar Hashem hu shelo מצד חכמת האדם. Knowledge of Hashem is not from the wisdom,10:48but מצד כוח המדמה. It's from the10:50emunah. Nobody could say, I know HaKadosh Baruch Hu.10:53It's because it's not on our level to understand.10:56We have to be11:00ma'amin. And being that everybody has different levels,11:04וכן הרי החכמה היא בביתא בדמיון, והדמיון עצמו חכמה. Comes out that the chochmah is kind of clothed with the dimyon,11:11with this power of imagination.11:13Imagination itself, right, it's not the chochmah of11:17Torah, it's not like the wisdom of Moshe Rabbeinu.11:19It's a little bit like we said, it's an imagination,11:22which means it's not something that you could see concretely.11:26It's something that you have to believe in.11:35וכן החכמה חלוקה מן הדמיון, מה שחידושים בחכמתן אינו דבר ה', רק חכמת עצמן. So too, just like dimyon is not11:39chochmah, so too chochmah is not dimyon.11:41And therefore, a person who's mechadesh something with this11:45chochmah, right, it's not called anymore Torat Hashem.11:48It's called11:50uvtorato יהגה יומם ולילה, as the pasuk says.11:52It becomes his own divrei Torah, his own12:00chiddushim. כי דבר ה' ממש מגיע אליו בכוח המדמה, בלא תוספת העמקת חכמה משלו. The Torat Hashem, divar Hashem, is what Hashem sends,12:03without you adding to it from your own intellectual powers.12:08It's something Hashem only sends you.12:14... Moshe Rabbeinu, right. And they don't become part of you.12:16So that's the difference between the chokhmah and the dimyon, in this case, or12:22nevuah. It's the level of understanding is two different levels.12:25Moshe Rabbeinu's level, where the Torah becomes part of him,12:29as opposed to the other, the chokhmah.12:32That's chokhmah.12:33That's also when we learn Torah and we come up with12:37a chidush, and we, you know, we strain our minds a little bit to try to understand something12:41and to develop an idea,12:43that's called chokhmah,12:44as opposed to an idea that just pops in your head12:46and you never really thought about it12:48and just imagining it.12:49That's more like a davar Hashem that's not using your wisdom.12:52Now, some people's minds just worked that way,12:54that they connect different things.12:56That's also their chokhmah, that they worked to get the information12:59to put it all together.