Torah · MussarMussar204A. Torah Thoughts vs. Nonsense ThoughtsTzidkat HaTzadikPart 204Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 22, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0017:27Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat Tzadik, ot reish daled, 204. It seems to be that we're going to have part one and two,0:07so this will be part one. Let's see. Hopefully we'll finish it in two parts.0:11In 204, reish daled, let's begin. It says like this:0:19Hanoten divrei Torah al libo, mevatlin mimenu kol minei hirhurim. If this quote is actually, that Rav Chaim says over here, is actually word for word0:23what we just said right now, it's word for word in0:29Avot d'Rabbi Natan. Avot d'Rabbi Natan, it's a0:33Tosefta braitot that are mesudar, kind of like when you have Toseftas on0:37masechtot, so you have it on masechet Pirkei Avot, which are Mishnayot,0:39so you have it also on Pirkei Avot. It's called0:45Avot d'Rabbi Natan. In the beginning of perek 20, the 20th perek, it says like this:0:54Rabbi Chananya ben Segan HaKohanim omer. Rabbi Chananya ben Segan HaKohanim says,1:00Kol hanoten divrei Torah al libo, mevatlin mimenu hirhurei cherem, hirhurei ra, so on and so forth.1:03Anybody who puts upon his heart divrei Torah, they take away from him thoughts1:11of—and then it goes on to list a whole bunch of things.1:12So that's what he quotes over here. That's what Tzadok says over here.1:16Kol hanoten divrei Torah al libo—person puts divrei Torah on his heart,1:21that means his mind is occupied.1:24Now, we always refer to the heart as the thoughts of a person.1:28Now, the thoughts are usually in the mind,1:30and the difference is there's an intellectual thinking,1:33and then there's what a person kind of is occupied.1:37So when we say his thoughts, we don't mean to say the thinking per se.1:41It's more what he's occupied in,1:44what he thinks about all the time.1:47So I hope you're getting me, because I'm trying to explain it in English the best that I can.1:53Hirhurim are like ideas that pop into a person's head, right?1:57But this is what he honestly fantasizes or daydreams about.2:00But that really comes from the heart.2:02That's what a person really desires.2:04That's what he wants to think about.2:06So when we say that you put divrei Torah on your heart, right,2:10of course it means to think in2:12divrei Torah, but it means that you care to want to think about divrei Torah.2:15Let me give you a mashal, perhaps you can relate.2:17If you're married already, perhaps you could remember this.2:21Maybe, maybe, depends how old and depends how much you cared,2:23is when you got engaged, what were you thinking about?2:25You always constantly think about your wedding,2:28not necessarily planning.2:29If you had somebody else planning for you, like let's say your parents,2:31or you had a party planner, or the bride or the other side was taking care of it,2:37so it wasn't really, you know, thoughts, but it's thoughts.2:41You get what I'm saying,2:42right? You're just thinking about how it's going to be, how it's going to play out,2:44but you're not actually planning.2:45I'll tell you what actually planning is.2:47When you're told, okay, you need to set up the thing2:50and now you need to come up with a plan.2:51So you actually sit there and use your mind to kind of spell out all the details.2:57You see what I'm talking about, the difference in these two types of2:59machshavot? So the hirhurim is the first type,3:02where you're not really taking care of things, but it's on your mind.3:05That's what occupies you. That's called3:08hirhurim. That type of thinking, that type of thought, that is attributed to the heart.3:15And the other one, the second type, what we said, it's like the planning stages,3:19when you have to sit there and say, okay, how many people will be actually coming?3:23I'm going to have 350 men, 250 ladies.3:28How are they going to be sitting?3:29The flowers, the arrangements, the seats, the waiters, are they going to be served?3:34Is it going to be a buffet style?3:35That's actual planning and thinking that that's used in the mind.3:41Okay, that's just3:42mashalim. In any case, come back to us. When we say3:44a person who puts divrei Torah on his heart means to say3:46his mind is occupied in the thinking of Torah.3:51So what does it say in the Midrash?3:55Mevatlim mimenu kol minei hirhurim. They take away all types of thoughts.3:58Now over there, he has in parentheses an idea of it,4:01but maybe it's interesting to read it,4:04because I found this also when I read the details,4:07I found them to be actually very helpful for me.4:11So it's good to hear it.4:12It's good to hear some4:13musar. So give me while I digress for a second.4:16Here, the4:17braita, I'm going to read you from the4:19braita, what happens when you actually put divrei Torah on your heart.4:23And the braita says, what happens when you do, what happens when you don't.4:26So when you do, then we know what happens:4:30mevatlin mimenu. They take away from him the following items.4:33Now there's eight items over here.4:35Listen to what they are.4:38Mevatlin mimenu hirhurei cherev, thoughts of a sword.4:40What does that mean,4:40thoughts of a sword?4:41Thoughts of being killed.4:43You know, some people always get what we call nervous4:46and paranoid a little bit of what's going to be,4:49or4:50chas v'shalom, it could be death.4:51So the person who has divrei Torah,4:53they mevatlim that kind of4:55hirhur. Hirhurei ra'av, they take away hirhur of hunger,4:58of not being able to survive and have money.5:03Hirhurei shtut, thoughts of foolishness.5:06Hirhurei zenut, thoughts of zenut, immorality, let's say.5:13Hirhurei yetzer hara, thoughts of the5:16yetzer hara. Hirhurei eshet ish, they take away from him hirhurim of married women,5:18not your wife, of course.5:22Hirhurei devarim betelim, and thoughts of nonsense things.5:25Hirhurei ol basar vadam, they also take away from a person the5:29hirhurim of that other people will have ownership over you.5:40So again, katuv bSefer Tehillim, as it says in Sefer Tehillim, mitzvot Hashem yesharim, mesamchei lev, mitzvat Hashem barah, me'irat einayim. The mitzvot of Hashem are straight;5:44they make the heart happy.5:46A person who has worries like that,5:49who's thinking about cherev and ra'av and shtut and so on and so forth,5:53he's not a happy person.5:54Therefore, you need to put the Torah in there.5:57Now the braita continues and says,6:00vechol she'eino noten divrei Torah al libo, one who does not put divrei Torah on his mind.6:04It's not what's occupying his thoughts.6:06Guess what happens?6:17Notnim lo hirhurei chereb, hirhurei ra'av, hirhurei shtut, hirhurei zenut, hirhurei yetzer hara, hirhurei ish, hirhurei devarim batelim, hirhurei ol basar vadam. It's the same exact opposite things.6:20And then the quote of pasuk in Sefer Devarim, Parashat6:28Ki Tavo, Tachat asher lo avadta et Hashem Elokecha besimchah uvetuv levav. So see, it's the happiness.6:30When a person is happy, he's thinking about something.6:32He's occupied with his thoughts of happy thoughts.6:35If you're happy with Hashem's mitzvot,6:38that's what's going to be occupying you.6:40You're not going to be thinking about the other,6:44what we call non-essential things.6:46Back to Rav Tzadok over here.6:48So now, in parentheses,6:51I just want to show you a very interesting idea6:54what Rav Tzadok says over here,6:56and he says,6:58Look in there, like we just read.7:02You count them:7:12chereb, ra'av, shtut, zenut, yetzer hara, hirhurei ish, eshet ish, hirhurei devarim batelim, and hirhurei ol basar vadam. That's eight things.7:13So they listed eight things over there.7:17Vehem neged shmoneh... So he explains,7:20vehem neged shmoneh middot... So we mentioned this concept of the ten sefirot in the past,7:24and we mentioned to you that if you look in the Petichat Eliyahu7:29HaNavi, zachur letov, and over there it talks about these ten sefirot.7:32And these ten sefirot, which just very quickly,7:35they're known as7:40chochmah, binah, da'at, and then chesed, gevurah, tiferet, hod,7:44yesod—no, hod—netzach, hod, yesod, and then malchut.7:47Those are the ten sefirot.7:48If you're familiar, familiar;7:49if you're not familiar,7:50you'll notice that really,7:53although we said binah was, you know, the second one,7:56it's really da'at is the first.7:57It's called the keter,7:59and then comes...8:01Chochmah then comes bina. So it comes out that bina is number three. But when you count backwards from number ten, which is malchut, going backwards, it comes out that the bina is number eight, right? Because you have two beforehand.8:16Now, another thing you have to know is that bina, in Petichat Eliyahu Hanavi that we just said, Petach Eliyahu, it says over there that bina is not represented by the heart, but it's where the heart is. And I think we've discussed this in the past. In case you don't remember, I'll just remind you again.8:34We discussed this in the past, and that is that bina... That bina in the heart corresponds more to women. That's why Chazal tell us that nashim, Hashem blessed the women with bina yeteira, with an extra level of understanding.8:53Bina means to understand deeper than the surface. So why do the women have that? Because bina is in the heart, and women are more emotional, which usually comes from the heart, and that's their connection to the midah of bina.9:07In any case, bina is at the heart. So he says over here that, Why is it that a person is saved when he puts all Torah on his heart? Why is he saved from eight different types of bad thoughts, and vice versa?9:24He says because really, where do those thoughts start from? Where do they stem from? He says they stem from the heart. As the Torah says, the heart of a person is ra from the moment he is born.9:41However, that's from the heart, but higher than that doesn't reach.10:01The evil thoughts, the yetzer hara's thoughts and his twists and deceit, he cannot get us in the mind. The mind is on a much higher level. The mind represents the high level, which is the neshama. That neshama, as we say every morning, neshama shenatata bi tehorah. It's completely pure. It's untainted by the10:23yetzer hara. And he says, if you go higher than that, higher level, which is the keter, that for sure is something which is higher. So what he means to say over here, a little bit of Kabbalah,10:36like we told you, we've always mentioned that the three things— The three parts of the three sefirot, the first three sefirot, Chochmah, Binah, Daat. You know, I'm saying out of order. Really it's supposed to be Daat, which is also keter. Sometimes they're interchangeable, keter, then Chochmah, and then10:53Binah. Those three things are usually harder for us to understand, but what you do have to know is that they represent three different levels of a person. There's the level which is the, let's start from the lowest, which is the Binah, which is where the heart is. Then there's Chochmah, which is where the actual physical brain is.11:11And then there's Daat, which is keter, the crown, that's literally connected to HaKadosh Baruch Hu's kisei hakavod, that's the neshama, that's a very high level. That is untouched. The keter is not something that the evil could even touch and taint.11:30But the Chochmah, which is the mind, and the Binah, which is the heart, yeah, there evil could be. However, the yetzer hara only is by the heart, and he could send messages to the mind, and eventually the mind could get, unfortunately, crooked and, you know, be influenced by the yetzer hara. But really the thoughts really stem from a person's heart.11:52It's a very deep concept that we're saying over here. If you think about it, even on a psychological level, it's very, very true as well, that a mind is really straight. It's a person's heart and desires that make him want certain things, and they start to twist his way of thinking.12:10Lemashal, you know, there's a famous story of, I think it was Rav Chaim Soloveitchik or the Brisker Rav, I'm not sure, one of them, or maybe none of them, but the lesson is the same. Basically, he saw a former student of his in his yeshiva, and his yeshiva was a great yeshiva, and he saw a former student of his smoking on Shabbat.12:30And this guy has left yeshiva for many, many times. So he approaches, he says, My dear student, what are you doing? It's Shabbat. You were in my yeshiva. You're one of the top guys. You know what Shabbat is all about. So the student says, Rabbi, I had questions in faith. Because I had questions in faith, therefore I am what I am today.12:51Basically, the student is saying that the reason why he went off the derech, he doesn't believe anymore because, you know, he had questions on Hashem. So the rav says to him, Let me ask you a question. Did you have these questions before you went off the derech or after? Stops for a second, thinks. He says, I had these questions actually after. I had these questions here, but it developed after I went off. He says, No, no. So you don't have questions. You have answers.13:19What is the rabbi telling him? Means to say, you decided that you want to follow your heart's desires, your yetzer hara, your temptations. And part of it is to, you know, to break Shabbat, for whatever it is. Maybe it started off with going to work, not necessarily smoking, but once you're breaking Shabbat, you're breaking Shabbat.13:38But now, how could you live with such a guilt? How could you live knowing that you're doing something wrong? So therefore you have to justify what you're doing something wrong. How do you justify? By finding problems in the religion, so this way you don't have to keep it. So really, the heart gets the mind to be twisted. Why? Because when we decided to follow our desires, so now we come to justify it.14:06That's the meaning that the brain could get messed up from the heart. Now, we're a little bit off the subject, a little bit of what Rav Tzadok is saying, but I think what we're saying is very, very important, though, to keep in mind. It's still on the idea. So I see already it's almost 15 minutes. Let me finish the paragraph, and we'll leave the rest for Hashem. For another recording.14:30So he says over here, Ki haTorah nikret emet. We find the Torah. So we said, why is it—let's come back to the point—why is it when a person puts divrei Torah on his heart, it takes away all these machshavot? The answer is, Ki haTorah nikret emet. The Torah, we find, is called emet. Mamash hipuch dimyonot hevel shehem shav. And the thoughts, these fantasies that we said about, these daydreams, they come, like we said, these are just imaginary things.14:56And because they're imaginary, when you put truth, they take away all these imaginary things. Even yetzer hara, even temptations, they're really imaginary, because it's a fantasy that the yetzer hara plays with our minds.15:13Va'ida nichnasim mochin degadlut begalui, when the talmid katanut. And like we explained beforehand, there's mochin degadlut dekatnut. If you didn't hear this, go listen to the recordings of two or three, Resh Gimel. Over there we spoke about mochin dekatnut and degadlut. Dekatnut represents the dimyonot, and gadlut is the emet. And therefore, when I put emet, it takes away right away the imaginary, the fake stuff.15:38Vegam dechol echad yesh zman shehu bekatnut, vefshar lihyot le'olam begadlut, vlihyot Torah. Now, you might think that, Oh, I must be a person that I'm always daydreaming. And he says, You can never be perfect. Every person goes up and down in mochin dekatnut, mochin degadlut, right? So he says, That's a reality, just like we find the Torah in the world. Excuse me.16:00Like we find that HaKadosh Baruch Hu created sleep, ve'amru shehu tov me'od. Chazal say about sleep, Sleep, שינה זה נועם, ... טוב מאוד. Sleep,16:09because when you sleep, you're able to wake up now and get a new life.16:15So too, like we said until now,16:17the daydreams that a person has, his mind wandering, is part of death, which is part of sleep.16:25It's like dreaming.16:29That's why at times, sometimes, yes, your mind drifts a little bit,16:33but that hopefully is like a sleep, and it brings you back into reality when you come back to the Torah.16:41Now, we all know there's sleep and there's sleep.16:42There are people that sleep just the minimum so they can wake up and they have a full day of work,16:46and there are people who just sleep, and they sleep,16:50and they wake up at 10, 10:30, and then they decide to take Shacharit, and then they go to sleep.16:54In the middle of the day they go to sleep again.16:56You know, they're just wasting their time in sleep.16:58It's the same idea also of people's minds.17:01There are people who are, Baruch Hashem, they're עוסק all the time in Torah,17:03but at times their mind drifts.17:05Yes, it happens. It happens to everybody.17:07And there are people whose mind is always drifting.17:09There's never divrei Torah on it.17:14But even then, as your mind is drifting, it all depends on the person's level,17:18and everybody on his own level and how much Torah he puts on,17:21that also is going to affect the17:23drifting. We'll stop over here. It's still to be continued.