Torah · MussarMussar203B. Source of a Person’s ThoughtsTzidkat HaTzadikPart 203Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 15, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0012:56Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:01Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot resh gimel two or three. This is part0:05two. We might have a part three as well. We'll see,0:08be'ezrat Hashem. But this is part two. In part one, we started talking about the concept of0:15daydreaming and thoughts of nonsense,0:18and how, you know, we got into very0:21Kabbalah and different things. But he explained basically that,0:25basically, if a person is daydreaming, it's like0:29he's killing that time. If he's killing that time, that's what Chazal referred to as0:33resha'im bechayeihem nikra'im metim.0:36Look over there. Let's come back now and continue, pick up from those things, that0:42machshavot are that come from the imagination,0:45nonsensical, that come from the imagination. Really, you're killing your time. He says,0:51Chazal did say, though, that in0:53daydreaming—excuse me, in dreams itself—they did say a concept. They said,0:57We find there are some dreams1:02that are more powerful. Some dreams are1:06one out of sixty of prophecy.1:09There are dreams that are one out of sixty of prophecy.1:23Says because we are Jewish people,1:27and we come from Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and therefore1:30even that which is not seen on the outside,1:35but it's only on the inside, which is our thoughts,1:39our plans, our ideas that are not1:42out yet, right? He says those are things that1:46we inherited from Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, that1:51we inherited the ability that all1:54our thoughts and all our machshavot are really for the sake of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.1:58That means deep down in every Jew, that's what he wants to live for. He wants to live2:03to do Hashem's will. He wants to do what God wants him to do from this world.2:10He says, We know2:12that... Children, or boys, come from the2:15mind of the father, meaning to say that from what the person2:19thought about, that's how he's able to affect what kind of children he has.2:25That's what we find, that although,2:28Chazal tell us that although a person sinned, he's still called a2:31Jew. Gemara learns it from2:36Pesukim, Maseches Sanhedrin, that afilu shechata, even if a person sinned2:39b'maaseh, let's say he committed chilul Shabbat and he's going to be killed,2:42he's still called a Jewish person. How can you call him that way? He sinned.2:47And it says because in his source,2:53ki b'shorsho, chochmah binah daat, because the source of a person is2:55not his body, but his thoughts. And his thoughts,2:58deep down, chochmah binah daat, really in the source,3:02that's something that we inherited from the Avot, Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov, and therefore3:06you can never really tamper with that. You can never really affect it.3:10Therefore, let's go back to the bahashavah of a person, which is also the same thing that we3:14inherited, l'kach hadimyonot betelim. Therefore, a person3:18who has such a dimyon, it's really batel.3:27Being that they stem3:29from a person's depth3:32in the binah, daat, in those deep areas,3:34remember we mentioned those three levels,3:36chochmah, binah, daat, are very high levels that we don't have an understanding in.3:40So he says they really have an interpretation.3:46Deep down, it's not just3:48random ideas. That means although there's a lot of daydreaming,3:54there's a lot of, you know, but again, if it doesn't come from an outside source,3:56but the guy who's just daydreaming and fantasizing and things are running in his mind.4:01Actually, they're one out of sixtieth of prophecy.4:04What does that mean, the one out of sixtieth of prophecy? That means there's some truth to them.4:08What does that mean, some truth to them? Something.4:12Just they're covered with other external things. Like the Gemara says,4:15that when you see a dream, even when it's what we call,4:19quote unquote, a real dream, even if we would call it a real dream,4:24this dream is actually something4:28deeper than that. This dream that you're seeing is actually4:31a prophecy. But the Gemara says every dream has a lot of4:35nonsense in it. So there could be a small detail of the dream that's true,4:39and a lot of the other things are just nonsense. And the majority of the dream may be4:43nonsense except for that one little point. And those who know how to interpret dreams4:47will know how to hear a dream and know how to point out4:51the exact thing that's4:55real, and everything else is just external. So that's how dreams4:59work. And therefore a person's machshava, even though it's nonsense, it could be nonsense,5:02but there's some part of it, even though it's only one out of5:07sixtieth, some part of it that is also real.5:10And that's exactly what we said also by dreams. That's Chazal tells by dreams.5:14So now we're learning that dreams, when Chazal said that there's a concept of5:19nevuah in dreams, that dreams are one sixtieth of prophecy,5:22it's also in daydreaming a little bit.5:28And the Zohar mentions this,5:31and he calls it learnings of5:34shetutah, of fools, that from there you can learn5:38actually some words of wisdom.5:44And that's also a similar idea5:46of when a person interprets a dream, he brings it out5:50into this world and therefore could have the power to take effect.5:54And why? Because Hashem made such an ability in the mind that5:58that mind, when it gets some sort of thought or some sort of dream, you could take it and6:02bring it out into this world.6:06And not only that,6:09nevuah. As he's going to quote the Rambam in a6:12second, this is a prophecy, which actually the real, real prophecy,6:15the 100% prophecy, that actually only comes in the dream.6:20As the Rambam writes,6:24Prophecy is very different from wisdom. Wisdom6:28is an understanding of real things. Nevuah is a different level. So he says, Excuse me, sorry, I missed a line. Because it comes also from the power of imagination, like it says in the Gemara, and therefore it also has six levels. And Zohar explains the six levels of nevi'im, and so too that means every six member has always contained in it another ten subcategories. So it comes out that there's 60 levels of nevuah, and those 60 levels of nevuah, when we say that one out of 60th is a dream, that's this idea of imagination, that one out of 60th. Now, those levels that we're talking about, what are these levels? We said there's six levels, and when you look at it in full detail, there's actually 60. But what are these levels? He explains that these 60 levels, or six levels in general, are defined in the following: when a person knows that this machshavah, that this thought that popped into his head, right, it's really from HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Good, and that's what Hashem, Hashem actually put.8:00In his mind. The more you know of that, that's on a different level. We take this thing in his mind.8:11And not like everybody else who gets just, like, some ideas. When you get an idea and you know it's like Hashem is speaking to you,8:18that's the difference in levels of nevuah. Other people, they get thoughts.8:22Not Hashem speaking to them. Remember, it's their imagination.8:29How does a person zocheh that the thoughts that pop in his head are messages from Hashem8:35and they're not just his imagination? You know, there's some people that they think they're Mashiach.8:40There's some people that they think that God spoke to them, and we call them crazy.8:44Now, a navi that actually had a communication with HaKadosh Baruch Hu, we don't call them crazy.8:51We don't call the nevi'im that we have in Tanach crazy people. They actually communicate with Hashem.8:58Why are they not crazy? Why are the people nowadays crazy9:01and say, Well, nowadays we don't have prophecy? Yes, but there's a certain level of ruach9:06hakodesh. How do certain gedolim know that this is—you know, when they ask them certain questions9:11and they say certain things, and poof, it's like lemaalah, you can't even imagine it.9:15And the answer is, they know that this is something—they can tell the difference between imagination9:20and something that Hashem has told them, or something that came from Hashem.9:25What is it based on? It's based on how much a person cleans his thoughts from all other matters,9:32from other things that he has a personal interest in.9:43So let's say you have imaginations of, or dreams of, you know... Winning the lottery, having big places.9:51So I don't know if that's from Hashem. It could be maybe it's from Hashem,9:54but most probably it's not. It's because you once heard about the lottery numbers9:58and you imagined, what would I do with that much money?10:01All of a sudden these thoughts started going into mind. Now buy this house, and now I do this and do that.10:06That's really a thought that you created, not coming from HaKadosh Baruch Hu. You created.10:12If Rav Chaim Kanievsky zatzal would have had a thought like that,10:15then I could say maybe that came from HaKadosh Baruch Hu.10:17He doesn't think about money. He was not interested. He wasn't interested in money.10:21He lived his life interested in Torah. In fact, he used to pray that Hashem should make him forget everything else that's not Torah.10:26So such a thought pops in his head, he could tell the difference10:31and say, Hey, this is from Hashem or not from Hashem, not us.10:43He says, Therefore, if a person knows that his mind is clean of those thoughts,10:49and all of a sudden this idea pops in his head, that's coming from HaKadosh Baruch Hu,10:54because he says the middot themselves that we have are six, as we explained beforehand,10:59and they are divided into ten other categories, which is11:07sixty. And these... Six correspond to the six bad middot the Chazal speak about,11:13and they are—he just lists four of them over here:11:17ta'avah, one's desire; ka'as, anger; ge'ut, ga'avah, nitzachon, beating, trying to beat other people.11:24It's basically the six, what do you call it, the six middot that we know,11:29chesed, gevurah, tiferet, Netzach, Hod, Yesod, but in the negative way.11:33Chesed, which is doing kindness, loving other people, the evil part of that is11:39ta'avah. Gevurah, which is self-discipline and having to work hard, the evil part of that is11:46ka'as. The tiferet, which is the combination, midat ha'emet, the evil of that is ge'ut, which is11:55ga'avah, right? Because the whole idea of tiferet is to bring pride to HaKadosh Baruch Hu,12:00and you try to take pride for yourself, that's12:03ga'avah. Nitzachon corresponds to the middah of12:06Netzach. Netzach is the middah of overcoming and beating the yetzer hara and completely defeating him for eternity.12:13That is a higher level than12:16gevurah. So this nitzachon is trying to compete and beat other people.12:21It doesn't list the other two, but again, the idea is when you work on these six,12:27you're able to clean yourself from all types of hirhurim, which then you're12:33zocheh that the machshavot will be clean.12:39And a navi, as much as he cleans himself from those types of12:43machshavot, that's how he's able to go on a higher level of12:48nevuah. And with this, I will pause also over here for part two.12:52We'll have part three, be'ezrat Hashem, in a different recording.