Torah · MussarMussar198B. Love of Torah, Jews & HashemTzidkat HaTzadikPart 198Rabbi Uri Nahum · June 2, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0015:38Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkas HaTzadik, ot kuf tzadi chet, ot bet,0:06198b, to pick up a little bit a review of what we did in 198a. We spoke about0:12love of0:14things. There are three basic loves that we find in our religion: love of Hashem,0:20love of Torah, and love of the Jewish people. And we said that if you love the Torah, and0:24whatever you love, they love you back. And what that means is, is that when you have a real love0:30for one of those,0:31you know, in one of those areas, maybe all of them even, then when they love you back, they0:38become part of you.0:40So we spoke about the love of Torah, that if you love the Torah,0:43then the Torah reveals its secrets to you. And when you love0:48people,0:49like Aharon HaKohen did, also we saw that you get to understand people, you get to see0:56the depth in the people, you get to see into people much more than what people see on the surface.1:02And we're picking up from there.1:04We spoke a little bit about also people from Shevet Levi and Shevet Yissachar also, that they also had a certain,1:11you know, connection to the Torah and to1:14Klal Yisrael, to other people. So we're picking up from there. He says over here,1:18he brings the Gemara, Masechet Yuma. The1:21Gemara says, Masechet Yuma, Tanu Rabbanan, demoreh. If you find a talmid chacham that's moreh halachot,1:27that, you know, gives piskei halachot, that people are following his halachot,1:31miLevi, says the Gemara, miLevi o miYissachar. Either he comes from Shevet Levi or he comes from1:37Shevet Yissachar. Look at that1:40Gemara, Masechet Yuma, daf chaf-vav amud aleph. Vechen itam, we find also by1:49Shevet Yissachar, Rasheihem matayim, rasheisan hidraot. Chazal are doresh on the words Rasheihem matayim, that from Yissachar came the heads of the batei dinim.1:55Why is that so?1:57Ki im ... We find an interesting thing about Sanhedrin.2:00In order to qualify as a member of the Sanhedrin, he cannot be a person who is too old,2:06not because he's not smart.2:08No, he can be very, very wise. But the Gemara says because when he's too old,2:12he already has forgotten what it feels like to raise kids,2:17can't relate to people, to kids anymore.2:20And saris, a person who has never had children,2:22he has to know what it feels like to have children in order to be able to be a dayan.2:26So the tzarich, we see from here, says2:28Rav Tzadok, that in order to be a qualifying member of the Sanhedrin,2:35you also need to have love of2:37Klal Yisrael, because when you have love of Klal Yisrael, you're davuk to them,2:41you get be connected to them,2:43and that will also allow you to be2:46moree halacha. Remember, the connection, the connection is that Sanhedrin needed special kind of qualifications,2:53and the members of the Sanhedrin, the heads of the Sanhedrin,2:57were people from2:59Shevet Yissachar, and he explains why is he zocheh to3:02that. Vezeh Zechai Yissachar, why was Yissachar zocheh to such a level?3:06Ayedei demartzei, artzuyeh, because we find that Yissachar, how was he born?3:13So we know that the story is in the Torah, in Parashat3:19Vayetze, where it talks about how all the shevatim were born,3:24that Leah, Leah... Had dudaim, special flowers that were mesugal for having children,3:33and Rachel wanted them.3:34So she sold them to Rachel in exchange to have her husband.3:39Meaning to say, not to have her husband, it's her husband as well,3:41to have Yaakov for that evening.3:43And she tells him, tonight, instead of going to Rachel, you have to be with me3:48because3:50ki sachar secharticha, and that's why she calls her son that's born then3:53Yissachar. Now it says, look at that, the Gemara talks about it.3:56It says because she was3:58martzeh, she was the one who brought about the love of Yaakov to her4:02to allow her to have children.4:04He says that's the source of how Yissachar was born.4:09So you see, even from the source,4:11zehu tokef ahavah lebriyot, that's the greatest love that one can have for another person.4:14That's such a closeness, like the relations between husband and wife.4:19B'koach ze nolad, and that's how he was born.4:21And you see that's really the foundation of4:25Yissachar, which is ahavat Yisrael.4:26Now,4:29ma she'ein ken Yehuda. Yehuda, however, was not zocheh to be moreh halacha.4:34Why? Gemara says4:35Yehuda was called Hashem HaKadosh Baruch Hu.4:37You see, the entire name of Hashem is in4:45Yehuda: yud-keh-vav-keh and the dalet. Yehuda says he—the Gemara points4:47that out—that he has Hashem's full name inside of him,4:51kemo she'amru b'Zohar. Why is that so?4:53Ki ahavat Hashem mitbarach kavuah bo, because the love of Hashem is set inside of4:58Yehuda. Yehuda had the love of Hashem very, very powerful.5:02Milachein nikra Yisrael al shemo. This is why the Jewish people are called Yehudim5:05on the name of5:06Yehuda. Why? Because he possessed this midah of love Hashem.5:10Another Gemara that says the same idea.5:12It says,5:14Kol hakofer b'avodah zarah nikra Yehudi. The Gemara discusses5:17Mordechai. He's called an ish Yehudi, but he came from5:19Shevet Binyamin. The Gemara says, I don't understand,5:21is he from Shevet Yehuda or is he from5:24Shevet Binyamin? Today, we're used to calling all Jews Yehudim,5:27but really they were called based on their5:29shevatim that they came from.5:30This guy came from Binyamin, this guy came from5:32Reuven, this guy came from Ephraim, Efrati, right?5:35So why is Mordechai, who came from5:39Shevet Binyamin, called Yehudi?5:41And the Gemara says5:42because he went against Haman and his5:45avodah zarah. So therefore, he was given the title Yehudi.5:50And the Gemara says,5:53Kol hakofer b'avodah zarah nikra Yehudi. And we know that avodah zarah is the exact opposite of5:58love of HaKadosh Baruch Hu,6:00or basically6:01recognizing HaKadosh Baruch Hu.6:03So therefore, the exact opposite of6:05avodah zarah, which is the love of HaKadosh Baruch Hu,6:07that's what makes you Yehudi, and that's why6:10Yehuda davka, he's called Yehuda, and we're called basically on that as well.6:14Lachen amru Shabbi Yuma. Now,6:15the Gemara there, Masechet Yoma, asks a question.6:17Remember, we just told the Gemara,6:19daf chav-vav. It says6:20anybody who is moreh halacha is either from shevet Levi6:22or6:24shevet Yissachar. Asks the Gemara,6:25what about people from6:30shevet Yehuda? Now, by the way,6:30it brings proof why from shevet Levi and6:34shevet Yissachar. The Gemara says, what about6:36shevet Yehuda? It says in the pasuk,6:38Yehuda mechokeki.6:39He, mechokeki. The Gemara learns6:41in that that's referring to6:43making chukot,6:44making laws.6:46The Gemara says, yes, they make laws,6:47but they're not6:50masig shmaata aliba dehilchata. They're not6:52zocheh that they should be mechaven6:55the limud, whatever they're learning,6:58according to what the halacha is supposed to be.7:01Interesting.7:02What does the Gemara mean by that?7:05Shevet Yehuda is not7:06zocheh to have people that are moreh halacha.7:09What does that mean?7:10It explains:7:15Vadai mishpat min dakin migida, Hashem yitbarach megaleh lo seterav. If you love HaKadosh Baruch Hu,7:16Hashem Himself reveals7:17the secrets to you.7:21Ela deze eino aliba dehilchata. But that's not according to halacha.7:23What does that mean?7:24If Hashem is telling me,7:25if Hashem reveals to me how things are supposed to be done,7:27that's according to halacha.7:28No.7:32פירוש לשון הלכה היינו מלשון כתוב זה הדרך תלכו בו. Halacha means7:33the way to guide people,7:35the way you're supposed to go.7:36It's called halacha,7:37זה הדרך תלכו בו, go this path.7:40Now he's going to explain this concept,7:42a very, very important concept,7:45in leadership versus halacha.7:47Now, people that are7:48great leaders,7:49and there's halacha, two different things.7:52And now, it doesn't mean a person7:53does not know halacha.7:55A lot of people that know halacha,7:56but they're zocheh that they should be the poskei hador,7:59that people should...8:00Go with them in halacha, that's a different quality that's given to different people.8:05So he says, Regarding the way the world works, the Gemara says, Lo bashamayim hi. There's a famous Gemara about the debate between Rabbi Eliezer and the Chachamim, and Rabbi Eliezer says,8:19If the halacha is like me, let a bat kol, let a voice come out from Shamayim and say the halacha is like me.8:26And a voice came out from Shamayim and it says, Leave Eliezer, the halacha is like him.8:32And Rabbi Yehoshua gets up on his feet and he says,8:36Lo bashamayim hi. I'm sorry, lo bashamayim hi. The Torah says it's not decided in the8:43Shamayim. We decide for it down here. So you see, you could have, quote unquote, an opinion by HaKadosh Baruch Hu,8:50yet down here, if we decide that the halacha, based on the Chachamim, the way they want it to be,8:57that's how it's decided then. Hashem kind of gave in to that.9:01He allowed the Chachamim to make these halachot. Now obviously Chachamim are coming from somewhere,9:04but it's lo bashamayim hi. The Torah is given to us, and we here decide the halacha.9:09So on that point he says, before we get to that point,9:14he brings another proof, the Hakdamah of Akadosh... The Gemara brings another case where we find a machloket between what9:22Hashem says—Hashem says a certain halacha—and down here we said otherwise,9:25and here down here they won because that's halacha. What does that mean?9:29So he says, Ki Torah shebichtav min haShamayim nikra chukah, chakakti gezeirah gazarti. We find that in reference to the Torah shebichtav, which Hashem gave us9:40from Shamayim, the Torah is called a9:42chukah, as we find in Parashat Chukat, that it's called zot chukat9:48haTorah, and Chazal point out, chukah chakakti,9:52gezeirah gazarti, ve'ein lecha reshut leharher achareha. It's called a9:55chukah. Vechen haberi'ah. So too the way the creation is, the way the world runs,10:00the ma'aseh Kadosh... the chukot Shamayim va'aretz. We find also that the world and how it runs, like the way the sunrise and everything else,10:05the laws of nature, as we could call them, are called chukot10:10Shamayim va'aretz. And we told you that Yehudah... He's called Yehuda mechokeki, as it says in the pasuk.10:17For him, nitgalu lo chukot HaKadosh Baruch Hu.10:19Because of the deep love that Yehuda has for Hashem, Hashem reveals to him how He runs the world.10:29ודרך שאמרו בתוספתא ובבא בתוספות חגיגה. And like the braita says—you can find this braita in the second Tosafot10:35on daf bet amud bet, Masechet Chagigah, right at the end. The quote is a very short line.10:38It says over there like this:10:42אין למדין מתקועה regarding David HaMelech. What's the story over there?10:43It says over there, they bring a braita that one cannot ride on a mule.10:49A mule is a cross between a horse and a donkey.10:52And the braita says, well, if you can't work them together,10:57the Torah is oser kilayim. You have two different animals;11:00they cannot be placed in the same frame to be working the land.11:06Kavachomer, you cannot ride on an animal that's created from two different animals.11:12That's what the Gemara says over there.11:17Excuse me, that's what the braita says over there. The Gemara says, what do you mean?11:19David commanded right before he passed away11:21that when they inaugurate Shlomo HaMelech, he should ride the mule,11:24and the mule is a cross of a horse and a donkey.11:26And the Gemara says over11:32there—the words, I mean the braita says over there—אין למדין מתקועה. What is מתקועה? And all the mefarshim come to say,11:38תוקע עצמו לדבר הלכה, a person who decides his own halacha. What does that mean?11:43Explains Rav Tzadok, שהוא עשה שלא כהלכה, בלי שום טעם. David HaMelech decided what he wanted to do without any reasoning.11:47It's not based on halacha.11:50רק מפני שרצה בכך. This is what he wanted.11:51So what do mean?11:52He could do whatever he wants.11:57And David HaMelech relied on the fact that because he's so attached to HaKadosh Baruch Hu,12:01especially there comes from Shevet Yehuda12:05who are melachim, who are attached to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, if that's what he wants, that's what Hashem also wants,12:07and therefore there's no sin with it.12:10Even though there's no logic to it,12:12because when it comes to a person's will, there's no reason.12:15This is what I want,12:20as Kohelet says, Kol asher sha'alu einai lo atzalti, whatever I wanted, I never held back.12:23If you want something, there's no reason to explain myself.12:26That's what I want.12:27You ever get in the mood for something?12:29There's no logical explanation.12:30So that's a ratzon.12:32If there's a ratzon, it means there's no12:35taam, af lafe Torah, even though it may contradict the Torah sometimes.12:41Right?12:42For example, we find also12:44Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi also came from David HaMelech,12:46who came from Shevet Yehuda.12:47Also at times when he went against the Torah,12:50the whole writing of the Torah sheba'al peh12:52was written down.12:53Why was he able to do it?12:54There's no logic.12:55I mean, there is a logic with12:57Torah shebapasuk, but at the end of the day, the idea is that13:00they understand how HaKadosh Baruch Hu wants to run the world,13:03and that could sometimes be above explanation.13:07It's like a13:08chok, something that's beyond explanation,13:10beyond reasoning.13:16Like chukah, u'kilchatah, halachah l'Moshe miSinai, without taam, like we find by halachah l'Moshe miSinai. That's the way it is.13:18No logic to it.13:21However, that's not how halachah works.13:24Halachah does not work with just Kabbalah.13:25Halachah works with logic, with rules,13:29and following these specific rules.13:31And that's why Yehuda, again,13:33Yehuda was zocheh to a different type of level,13:36a level of hanhagah, of leadership,13:40and he knew how to run things, how to lead things.13:43And sometimes he did things who may not seem according to13:46halachah, but that's ratzon HaKadosh Baruch13:47Hu. And if you think about this idea,13:49and you think about Yehuda's history,13:50you'll see that there's much more that you could connect to this idea,13:53which right now we're not connecting because it's already 14 minutes.13:57Lachen amru,13:58now he brings the last point over here.14:01That's why this same concept you understand14:04by people that come from Shevet Yehuda14:05and they're high level. Again,14:07not everybody can just do this.14:08This is the kings who were zocheh to such a high level.14:17The Gemara says in Masechet Rosh Hashanah, בקש שלמה המלך עליו השלום לדון בלא עדים והתרעה. Shlomo HaMelech wanted to rule cases without witnesses and without warning. Halacha is not like that.14:22Halacha is, you must have a warning.14:25Even if the guy knows halacha, you must warn him,14:27and you must have14:29edim. How could Shlomo HaMelech want to do that?14:31Now you can understand.14:33Because we find,14:34says the pasuk about David,14:36about Shlomo, excuse me,14:37that he sat on the throne14:40of who?14:41Of Hashem. What do you mean,14:42throne of Hashem?14:44Hashem sits on His throne.14:51And the answer is, love attaches one to what he loves. One who loves14:54the Torah, v'Yisrael, davuk bahem. A person who loves the Torah and loves the Jewish people14:59is attached to them.15:07But one who loves HaKadosh Baruch Hu, as we know,15:10that Shlomo HaMelech, the whole Sefer Shir HaShirim15:12is about love15:16of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, and davuk bo ad kibyachol, vayehu levasar echad, then he is attached to Hashem15:19as if they become one.15:21We know that love,15:21the greatest love, is between husband and15:23wife, and the pasuk says15:25vayehu levasar echad, and that's how it was with Shlomo15:27HaMelech. The love they had for HaKadosh Baruch Hu15:29made him one with Hashem,15:31that when he sat on his own throne,15:33Shlomo was considered like he sat on the throne15:35of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.