Torah · MussarMussar193. שומע כעונה בד״תTzidkat HaTzadikPart 193Rabbi Uri Nahum · May 7, 2023−15Play+30Position0:009:38Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat HaTzadik, Ot Kuf Tzadik Gimel, 193.0:04A very short piece today,0:06one that we didn't have in a very long time.0:09And there are a lot of brackets,0:11so we usually skip the brackets,0:13the nice side points,0:14but I'm going to skip them0:16just that we shouldn't lose focus0:17and we'll see if we come back to it or not.0:20So we talk about0:22dibur in Torah.0:24We talk about speaking divrei Torah0:25from the pieces beforehand,0:27how Torah needs a certain kind of level0:29of fear0:32of, you know,0:33like basically the Gemara says in Berachot0:36that the Torah was given0:38at0:40Har Sinai, and the way it was given,0:41that's the way it's supposed to be0:42learned. And when it was given, there was thunder and lightning,0:45and there was a certain amount of yirah and fear.0:48So the Torah also says0:50that originally when they were0:52metaken tevilat0:53Ezra for people who have baal0:54keri, meaning that baal keri doesn't really have the fear.0:57It's kind of more of a relaxed1:00position1:02or level that a person gets to.1:04So therefore such a person1:06doesn't have that1:08proper1:10yirah, that fear for learning Torah,1:12and that's1:14why they metaken the tevilah for baal keri.1:16Now on this point, he's still continuing on the1:19Gemara. So he says1:19it starts with the side point, but it comes back to the same theme as before.1:23Gam b'divrei Torah,1:26shomea k'oneh. Also by divrei Torah we find the concept of1:29shomea k'oneh. That means if I'm learning right now,1:31everybody who's listening to this recording,1:33is that called that you're learning Torah?1:36Because really Torah is supposed to read it,1:38with the barta bam,1:39you're supposed to read it out loud,1:41not just read with your eyes.1:44Yes, there's a concept of understanding1:46and gaining information, but Torah,1:48the study of Torah is also,1:49it's a dibur,1:50and many, many1:52Chazal that speak about this.1:53But we do find that let's say you're learning with1:56a chavruta, you're learning in a shiur, it's still called learning1:58because1:59shomea k'oneh. A person who's listening is2:02considered like a person who's speaking. For example,2:04I can make a berachah for you.2:06When you're2:07chayav and Yehud is here and you're2:09yotzei, that's what we do by Kiddush and2:11Havdalah. One person speaks the words and everybody else is listening2:14is2:15yotzei, they're chovah, because we answer amen,2:17the answer is no.2:18You're supposed to answer amen, but if let's say a person didn't answer amen,2:20he's still2:21yotzei the chovah. So we find this concept called2:24shomea k'oneh. The person who's listening is like the person2:27who's speaking. So in the Torah,2:28in the words of Torah, it's the same concept.2:34Tosafot writes this in the Gemara.2:36The Gemara says, just like we have to learn2:39by Har2:40Sinai—excuse me, we just spoke about2:42tevilah, right? We have to2:44dip, the original takanah of dipping2:46tevilat2:48Ezra was—the Gemara says because of Har Sinai.2:50Hashem told them to separate from2:52their spouses for three days,2:54men have to separate from their wives for three days.2:56So it says over there,2:58just like we found by Torah that it has to be3:00given with the same manner level,3:02says Tosafot. Now3:03what does that mean?3:05It says by Har Sinai we found that people3:09were basically3:10not3:12baal keri. We had to make sure they didn't have that3:13tumah of3:15baal keri. So you might ask,3:17how does that fit with the takanah over here?3:19The takanah over here is that people should not learn Torah,3:21should not speak the words of Torah by Har Sinai.3:23They weren't speaking Torah, they were just listening3:25to Torah.3:27So how can the Gemara say, like we find by Har Sinai?3:30Tosafot comes and explains3:31that you see that it's3:34what? That the person3:36by Har Sinai,3:37when Moshe Rabbeinu was speaking,3:39or Hashem was speaking through Moshe3:41Rabbeinu—first Hashem, then Moshe3:43Rabbeinu—and Bnei Yisrael were just listening,3:45that's also considered like they're also3:47speaking the words of Torah.3:48So that's what we find from3:50Tosafot. He says, based on that,3:55v'tzarich lezeh ma'avirah. Therefore, if speaking,3:57if listening to Torah3:58is the same thing as speaking4:01divrei Torah, so therefore, just like the condition4:03that the Gemara says by a person4:05who is speaking4:06divrei Torah, which is like you're receiving from4:08Har Sinai, it needs to be with4:10fear and trepidation,4:11so too when you're4:14thinking of Torah, it has to be the same thing.4:17Like we find a person who is himself is learning4:20Torah.4:22Now, one second.4:24If a person is meharher by himself, though,4:26this is all talking about4:28when somebody else is talking to you4:29and you're listening to him.4:31However, if you yourself are just meharher,4:33if you yourself are just looking4:35and what we call reading with your eyes,4:39now over there the Gemara says4:41that he doesn't need4:43tevilah. The tevilah is only for people that are actually speaking the words of Torah,4:45but meharher he could.4:47Why? Because we find about Keri,4:50when it comes to4:51Keriat Shema, which the4:52Torah, they allowed him to be meharher.4:55And how could they allow him to be meharher?4:58And the answer is4:59because hirhur is not5:01like dibur.5:09So Gemara says, as Tosafot says,5:11as Tosafot says, Baal keri is allowed to be meharher5:13b'divrei Torah. So5:15he's like—what do you mean? I thought thinking5:16is like speaking.5:18So the answer is no. Hearing is like5:20speaking. Thinking, it's like speaking, but it's not actually speaking.5:23It's like speaking5:25because5:27he's yotzei de chovah. The baal keri could be yotzei de chovah by just thinking of the words,5:29meaning what we call reading with your eyes.5:31But it's not like speaking, because5:33if he would be speaking, that would be asur,5:35to speak the words of5:36Torah. So it's kind of like in between.5:44V'hainu dehirhur aleh divrei Torah, hainu shemahu medaber, ma she'eino raui, uvalev mutar hakol. It means to say5:45that when we talk about5:47yira, yira in divrei Torah is5:49that only when you speak,5:50because maybe when you bring it out into the world,5:53that might not be the proper thing.5:55So therefore, you need a certain amount of5:57yira that you should be saying5:59the words properly,6:01meaning to say they should be saying the correct6:04concepts in the Torah.6:05But if a person is not— Thinking is, I mean, it's not6:08speaking it out,6:09it's not bringing it out at all. It's just thinking about it,6:11okay? And thinking, you have more flexibility6:14to think.6:14Thinking is kind of like the level what we call6:17in learning called the havah amina.6:19Havah amina means what you thought to say.6:21Not everything that you thought to say6:23is necessarily supposed to be said or is it correct.6:25So that's why thinking doesn't have to be6:28on that level.6:31U'matzinu, David HaMelech alav ha-shalom amar. We find that there's a6:33pasuk in Tehillim that says,6:38Ashrei tivchar v'tekarev, yishkon chatzeirecha. Fortunate is the person,6:39Hashem, that you select and you bring him6:42close to live in your6:43chatzer. And the Midrash says6:46in Bamidbar Rabbah, who is that referring to?6:48That's Aharon6:50HaKohen.6:50And what does that mean? What was David saying about Aharon?6:53Why is he saying fortunate?6:55And it says,6:59V'haya chomed me'avel l'hakriv korbanot. David himself7:00wanted also to bring7:02korbanot. David came from7:04Shevet Yehudah. Only people that are Kohanim7:05are allowed to bring the7:06korbanot. They're the ones who work in the7:08Beit HaMikdash. But yet David wanted that.7:11Af al pi shekvar ne'emar, v'azar hakarev yumat. But wait a second, isn't there a warning?7:14The Torah says clearly7:15anybody who's not7:17a descendant of Aharon HaKohen7:19says he's called a zar,7:20and any zar who gets close7:22to do the7:24avodah is chayav mitah. So what was David thinking?7:27Rak mekom makom, b'libo shei lachshov. So that's like we said before.7:30Speaking7:31is one thing.7:32To do a thing in the maaseh,7:34it's one thing. But to feel something,7:37that's a little bit different.7:38Therefore, to have7:40the feelings of7:42trying to do mitzvah, that's really beyond7:44your limitation, that's fine.7:50So too, any thoughts in Torah7:54that's only7:55machshavah, you're allowed to, even though it's beyond7:57your capability, you're allowed to think about it.8:00But lemaaseh, you have to know what you're allowed to do, what you're not allowed to do.8:05But when you're speaking, adivrei Torah has to be done8:11b'ema uvyirah. Really, we're done with the piece. Like we said, there's a lot of brackets here, and that could take much longer.8:16So I want to tell you one idea outside. He says over here8:19is that the Midrash says that he desired to bring a korban, right? David really wanted to bring a8:25korban. So we have this concept is that when you have thoughts or you think about something,8:32eventually you end up doing them. So we find that David HaMelech, on a certain level, also did this thing,8:38which is one: when he was running away from Shaul and he was in Sekhena, he was out of food.8:43He went to the Mishkan, and he asked from the Kohen Gadol, Achimelech at the time,8:49that he, you know, he needed something. You know, he was on a special mission, and he needed food, emergency.8:55So the only food that Achimelech, the Kohen Gadol, tells him that we have,9:00he said the only food is lechem hapanim, and David takes it and he eats it because he was in9:05sekhena. And when it comes to a person's life, when it's in danger, he's allowed to break every9:12aveirah in Torah except for the three: giluy arayot, shefichut damim, and9:14avodah zarah. So that's why he was able to eat it. But in any case, you see from here that9:21he was, you know, something that he really desired, he did on a certain level, because9:25lechem hapanim can only be eaten by the Kohanim. It's also considered a korban.9:29So that's one side point that he brings. He brings a few other points,9:32but I think we got the point just to it, you know, keep it short.