Torah · MussarMussar192. Fear vs. DesireTzidkat HaTzadikPart 192Rabbi Uri Nahum · May 3, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0020:16Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzaddik, ot kuf tzadi bet. I found this piece a little bit difficult,0:06trying to understand what Rav Tzadok is trying to tell us. But I found that when I prepare0:12sometimes for things, for pieces in Rav Tzadok, I find that when we come to the recording,0:19it comes out much clearer, and I believe it's a siyata dishmaya we get0:22in the zechut of those who are listening. So at this moment, I want to thank everybody that's0:27listening, because it's in your zechut that we're able to have a little bit of clarity0:33in the words of Rav Tzadok. So thank you. Let's continue now in the piece, kuf tzadi bet. Kuf tzadi bet, excuse me, kuf tzadi bet.0:45Al yedei ha-ta'ava, mistalek ha-yir'ah. Through desire, that actually takes away from fear, as he's going to explain. But before we come0:52to explain, and we see that yir'ah, the trait of yir'ah, the trait of fear, but it's not a bad fear. Fear is always associated with something bad,1:02because people, when they think of fear, they think of anxiety. A guy who is a nervous wreck,1:09yesh lo nervin, you know, they call that in Hebrew. That's what they think about. The guy1:13has yir'ah, he's in there, he's OCD, you know, overcompulsive disorder. That's what they think of yir'ah. Meanwhile, it's the highest1:20level that person can reach. It's called yir'at shamayim, right? The pasuk says in Parashat Eikev, V'ata Yisrael, mah Hashem Elokecha sho'el me'imach ki im l'yir'ah. And the Gemara says, Hakol bidei shamayim chutz miyir'at shamayim.1:34And clearly, if that's a trait, that's all the sefarim, when they discuss the service of1:40Hashem, avodat Hashem, they speak about yir'ah. So if all the sefarim are discussing yir'ah, it's clearly1:45not a bad thing, and definitely it's not something that a person is scared. You know,1:50we used to have a joke in yeshiva for baalei teshuvah, and, you know, when they come in and1:55they're learning, and they, you know, we used to say as a joke, Yir'at shamayim. Every time I look1:59at the sky, I get scared, right? That's a very silly way. So some people look at yir'ah also,2:05when they think of yir'ah, they think OCD, anxiety. That's clearly not the yir'ah we're talking about.2:10Yir'ah that we're talking about. Especially, yirat Hashem is the concept of realizing the2:17importance of, or the value of, listening to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, and that breaking His word is a breaking in our2:26relationship between us and HaKadosh Baruch Hu. It's also a breaking also in just the, you know, the honor of2:34HaKadosh Baruch Hu. So yes, we need yirah. In fact, if you're married and listening to this, you have yirah of your wife,2:40and not the way most of you guys are thinking, you know, like, Oh, she's gonna beat you up,2:44you're whipped. No, no, no. We all have a certain yirah. For example, we don't want to ruin a great2:49relationship. If you've been married five, ten, twenty years, thirty years, you've built a relationship that2:55hopefully is a wonderful relationship. You've built a family. Perhaps you've had grandchildren,3:01and you've built something. And yes, there should be, and you must have a certain fear3:07not to ruin it. And even that means even fear not to ruin it. There's got to be a fear.3:14There's two traits that are always discussed in Chazal, in the sefarim, is3:20yirah and ahavah, yirat and relationship with Hashem, loving Hashem and yirat Hashem. We all feel that we can relate3:26easier to the trait of love. I just do it because I love HaKadosh Baruch Hu.3:31And yirah is something that we feel is away from us. But really, we need both.3:35As much as you love Hashem, sometimes you're just not in the mood. So if you're not in the mood,3:39doesn't mean you just do whatever you want. So that yirah, that fear of3:45doing something wrong, is a very necessary component, and we need that in our lives3:50in every single area. We need it in our relationships. If, Hashem, a person doesn't have that3:55yirah to ruin this relationship, then whatever comes to him, he could do. If one day he's just4:00not in the mood to go home and listen to, you know, his wife tells him, Oh, she had a rough day.4:05Ugh, not today. I'm so tired. I don't want to hear her now, and he just avoids her. He goes to his4:10parents' house. So he doesn't care about the relationship so much; just tries to avoid4:14it. No, you need to have a son you're out. I don't want to lose and ruin the relationship.4:19Elu aleinu could be something worse. There's that pretty woman at work, and it's a very tempting4:25thing, and she's, you know, she's having a rough time with her husband, and she comes to this man4:30and she talks to him about her problems, and all of a sudden feelings start to, you know, come up.4:37And if the guy doesn't have yirah, if you don't have yirah of God, that this is an eshet ish,4:42there's major problems going to happen. We all need yirah. Can't just do things just because4:46of ahavah. So yirah is a wonderful thing. Now that we explained how wonderful yirah is,4:52how important it is, of course there's much more layers to it,4:57says the tzaddik, what could ruin yirah, what could take away yirah is desire, one's physical desires.5:05Now he's going to prove this. This is where I had a little bit of a challenge5:10to understand, but hopefully we'll understand now, bezrat Hashem. Chazal tell us that there was a point in5:15time when they instituted that a person who's together with his wife, so as a man,5:22keri comes out, and therefore he's called a baal keri. MideOraita, a person only needs to dip5:30if he's going to be handling things that are called kodesh. So, for example, if he's a kohen5:35that's eating terumah, or if he is going to be going to the Beit HaMikdash area when he's allowed to go,5:43or deal with korbanot, so yeah, of course he has to go to the mikveh to purify himself.5:47But if he doesn't deal with these two things, for example, nowadays, unfortunately, we don't5:51have a Beit HaMikdash, and we also don't have terumot. Kohanim are not eating anything that's5:56terumah, and they're not dealing—nobody's really handling anything of holiness. So today, technically,6:03a person doesn't need to go to the mikveh. However, there was a point in time when6:07Chazal, really Ezra HaSofer, instituted that people who are baal keri... Not because it was done on purpose.6:14It was, I mean to say, it was like done b'aveirah. Even in a case where it was done6:18b'mezid, it comes out of his body, he still needs to do a tevilah. Why? So the original reason was,6:24mishum d'divrei Torah tzarich b'eimah u'vira'ah. The Gemara explains over there, Masechet6:30Berachot, because we see when the Torah was given to the Jewish people, as we approach6:33Shavuot, we should be familiar with the Gemara in Masechet Shabbat, that deal with the Torah being6:39given. So the Gemara in Masechet Berachot says the Torah was given, there was thunder and lightning, there was a certain6:48trepidation and fear that was created in the giving of the Torah. And therefore, when you learn Torah, you have to know what you're doing. You're6:52learning the Torah, Torah Hashem. So you need a certain eimah and yirah, basically seriousness. You need to6:59be serious about it, not just, you know, laughing and goofing off, and not, you know, when teenagers7:05or young people, they think they're doing you a favor, they're coming to class and they're just7:08always joking and laughing. No, you need to have a certain eimah and yirah, certain fear.7:14So the Gemara says that's how divrei Torah should be done, and because it should be7:21that, that's how they should be done. Because it has to be that way, so the Gemara says7:24a baal keri is a person who just went through, you know, basically the height of his7:31taavah. He just, you know, reached the height of his taavah. That's why keri comes out.7:36Keri comes out when a person, when a man reaches the climax of his taavah. So you see the fact that7:43the Gemara says that a baal keri needs tevilah in order to bring him back to the level of7:49eimah by learning Torah, you see that what took away that eimah was actually the taavah. תאווה. And that's.8:00Why? He says that the taavah is what takes away yirah. Vatikun lazete bila bamayim, and what did Chazal institute? They instituted that a8:07person should dip. So he says, what does that mean for us? How does that translate for us besides the halacha of it?8:20Sheromzim lemidat hachesed vahavat Hashem yitbarach. Mayim, dipping in water means immersing yourself, completely getting lost into the water.8:25Basically being buried into the water, being batel, batel to the water, being—I forgot the word in English—but part of the water, basically when you go under the water.8:36So what does that—what does water represent? Water always represents the trait of love toward HaKadosh Baruch Hu and chesed,8:43because water has no boundaries. The concept of chesed is that there's no boundaries.8:49Anything that has boundaries and is finite cannot be chesed.8:55For example, if you're an employee and you have certain responsibilities, those responsibilities are your boundaries.9:01When you do beyond your responsibilities, you stay the extra hours, you help out when it's not necessary,9:07you, I don't know, for some reason you forgive part of your salary, all of that is really—there's no boundaries for that.9:18You do whatever you like, you know, but that's what chesed is.9:22But if part of your job is that you should be polite, if part of your job is, besides, let's say, working on9:28a computer, is also to get every single day to get your boss a cup of coffee or to serve your customers a cup of coffee, you're not doing a chesed.9:37So let's say you have a restaurant and you are a waiter, so part of your job is to serve them coffee.9:43You're not doing them a chesed by serving them coffee. That's your job.9:47So anything with boundaries is not called chesed. Chesed is without boundaries.9:51So that's why water really doesn't have boundaries, because water, by definition, doesn't have a shape.9:56It's the physical object in this world that has the least10:02tzurah. It doesn't have any form whatsoever; it just takes the form of everybody else, but in itself it doesn't have a form.10:08So that's why when we tell you to immerse in the water, it's midah midah to the trait of chesed,10:13and love of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, that should be without boundaries,10:17should be באמת, מהות of attachment to Hashem. Because really, deep down, what does every single Jew really desire deep down?10:24And that is HaKadosh Baruch Hu. It's a desire, a deep desire to connect with HaKadosh Baruch Hu.10:31Everything else that we have in life is just a distraction from that.10:37The love deep down in every Jew, there's a deep love between them and HaKadosh Baruch Hu.10:43But again, the yetzer hara gets us busy with everything else, sometimes good stuff.10:49We have, Baruch Hashem, we have a family, we have kids, we have our wives, we have our family members, we have our friends, we have our community.10:55Yes, we get involved. Hashem has given us such a gift, right?11:01But, you know, sometimes it's not such good things.11:04We have love of money, love of gashmiyut, love of desires.11:08All these things also, they get us distracted from the true love which is deep in our hearts, which is the love of Hashem.11:15So therefore, when we immerse ourselves into the water, come batel to water, we're coming back, we're basically dipping back into HaKadosh Baruch11:23Hu. Because really, every type of love and desire is really the opposite of yirah,11:31because they're really two opposites.11:34The only time these two, which is ahavah and yirah, could join powers together is when it is for HaKadosh Baruch Hu.11:42Like we said, there's love of God and there's fear of God.11:45Those are two main things,11:46and these two could combine because they're both coming to serve the same purpose.11:50But if it's not for HaKadosh Baruch Hu, you may have your ahavah Hashem. Like we said, is a basic standard that we all need,11:59but love for anything else will take us away from that.12:02And that is, love for anything else is called12:10ta'avah. ועל זה רומז בטבילה, כי כל כוונה שבלב שיוצאת לפועל במעשה, היא מתחזקת. This is the idea of dipping,12:14because any good intention, or any intention that a person has, where he brings out that12:21idea—any idea, basically, that's not the word intention is not a good12:24word—any idea that a person has on the inside that he thinks about, that he brings it out into action, then it actually becomes stronger.12:32Right? Think about it.12:35If you have an idea, but it remains an idea, it's not so great.12:39When you have an idea that you carry it out, and you translate that, and you converted it into action,12:46so then you've made this idea solid and strong,12:50and becomes much more real.12:53Therefore, במעשה, במים שמכניחים באמת הלכלוך גם כן. And therefore, a person who is dipping in the water, where water also has another characteristic:13:05the water that has the ability to wash away dirt.13:10ושומר מצוות חכמים לטבול, a person who is careful to listen to the decree of the rabbis, or the original13:17decree—Chazal, by the way, batlag is13:20tevilat Ezra—this whole dipping after relations, the rabbis took it away.13:24It's not an obligation, but still wonderful to do.13:27So anybody who's still dipping by listening to the original takanah of the13:36Chachamim, כמו שאמרו, גדר גדרו גדרו, שזה גדר בפני התאוות. Why is the dipping called a fence?13:40Because it's a fence for the desires. Not to go out of control.13:48Shehaotset ta'avato, it's in a way this dipping actually holds a person, controls a person's desire.13:54How so?13:54Well, Chazal, when they had the institution in place, when they instituted this14:01gezeirah that you have to dip every time relations happen,14:05so back then it wasn't so easy to get access to water.14:07So if a person didn't have the water, k'she'ein lo mayim litbol, you can't do your desire.14:15V'nimtza ta'avato rak ki-ratzon Hashem yitbarach. So then you can't do your desire.14:17If you can't do your desire, where would your desire go?14:20It would go to where it's naturally supposed to go, which is to HaKadosh Baruch Hu. V'az hu14:24echad meyira'ah. So then your desire for Hashem is together now, working together with the14:30yirah. That's what chachamim were able to accomplish in14:34the14:38gezeirah. V'Chazal sidru dinei tevilat keri l'inyan Kriat Shema u'tefillah b'Yichud. And when Chazal spoke about this tevilah, this immersing yourself in the water in the mikveh,14:44they specified it by the mitzvah of Kriat Shema and Amidah specifically.14:54Why these two did the Chazal speak about?14:56Why did they mention that the Torah, which is Kriat Shema and the Amidah,15:00a person needs to dip more than any other mitzvah?15:04Shebahem mekareh ha-yirah, because really Kriat Shema and Amidah are the main part of our religion that bring about15:17yirah. Like the Gemara says in Masechet Berachot, Yira'ucha im shamesh, that standing up in the Amidah, we learn that a person should stand in the Amidah when the sun is rising,15:23as it says,15:28Yira'ucha im shamesh. They should have fear of You, Hashem, with the sun, meaning that the yirah, which is referring to Amidah,15:33you see that the main part of a person's yirah is the Amidah.15:37And as the Gemara says, you cannot stand up to the Amidah without Kriat Shema.15:44U'margil shehata'avah mimenu, tzarich tevilah, d'hainu gam ken hit'orerut mimenu, sheyichnas l'toch hamayim u'mshabed kochotav l'maalah. And it's the15:54idea also, the guy who is with this15:58ta'avah, who's dipping in the water.16:00is immersing himself and completely giving himself over,16:04even his desires, he's giving it over when he goes into the water,16:08and now he's basically redirecting his16:11love to HaKadosh Baruch16:15Hu. Now he explains why originally the gezeirah was also that16:18originally it's supposed to be a regular mikveh. Mikveh, minimum has to have16:23arba'im se'ah of water. Se'ah is a certain type of16:25measurement. Why is that so? So Chazal tell us the significance of the measurement of16:30forty se'ah. It's the amount of water that is able to16:34fit inside of an entire human being, his entire body.16:38Because the forty se'ah is16:42an amount of water that could fit an entire person.16:47You know why? Because when one has16:49a desire in his heart, it really takes over his entire body16:53until his entire body is involved in the aveirah, he doesn't stop.16:58Now, that's why Chazal say if a person was,17:01you know, active in bringing out his taavah, again, not for an17:06issur or an aveirah, but he was together with his wife, but he did it willingly.17:09But then there's times when a person sees keri, which is not a choice,17:13it comes out of his body. Sometimes it could be due to certain foods that he17:17eats or certain things that he thought about. Whatever the case is, that's called17:21le'onso. So says Rav Tzadok,17:26something that's not in his control, suddenly wanted to sleep,17:29and it wasn't something that he thought about. Just all of a sudden this came out of his body,17:33so that he didn't really get involved in,17:37you know, this happening to him and this keri coming out of him. It came out in sleep17:42from Shamayim, shelo mida'ato, it's without him.17:47So that again, for that, it's shaar kabin. So it's good enough to just pour over him17:49nine kabin. Kabin is a certain measurement. You just pour over him a17:53certain amount of water. Why?17:57Shamayim noflim alav, d'hainu without. Because the water is falling on top of him from his head all the way around his body,18:01represents this idea of an inspiration from above, the love coming18:05from Shamayim down here.18:12So bring the same18:13idea also, when a person has a certain love for18:17HaKadosh Baruch Hu, he allows it to flow down to the rest of his body.18:23Even though it's not the same18:25as the love that he had when he gets his entire body involved in it,18:29there he needs to dip in the mikveh, his entire body. Here,18:33just a shefa to come down. At the end,18:37we said, as we said in the beginning, at the end Chazal saw that they were not able18:41to handle such a gezeirah, and they canceled it.18:44So18:47he quotes the Gemara: Bitluha l'Rabbi Yehuda ben Beteira. Rabbi Yehuda ben Beteira holds that tevilat gezeirah has been18:52canceled. Why? We don't need it, says Rabbi18:55Yehuda ben Beteira. Pasuk says the whole—well, let's start. The original gezeirah of tevilat Ezra,18:59basically of dipping after seeing keri, was because you need to have19:04yir'ah when you come to learn Torah.19:07Comes Rabbi Yehuda ben Beteira and says, but there's a pasuk that speaks about Torah that says,19:11Halo ko devarai ka'esh, my words are like fire, which means, and the Gemara19:14explains, that fire is not mekabel tumah. Therefore, just like fire is not19:18mekabel tumah, a person is not mekabel tumah when he's learning Torah. He doesn't have to worry about it.19:22If he's tamei, he's not going to be able to affect the Torah. What can we learn from this?19:29Says Rav Tzadok, פירוש שבדברי תורה שורפים כל דבר רע, that we don't need19:30the mikveh because through Torah we can burn all bad desires.19:35If a person has bad desires, the Torah will be able to19:38burn all them.19:44וגם מביאן בברכות, מקיש אהלים לנחלים, ומעצמן דוגמת טבילה. And the Gemara also brings19:47a pasuk from Parashat Balak. Over there, the Gemara19:50compares the ohalim, which is a remez19:54to the tents of the Torah, to the streams of water, to say19:58that just like a stream of water, where a person can immerse himself inside20:02of it and become tahor by dipping in it, so too the ohel of Torah,20:06a person immerses himself in the beit midrash and learns Torah,20:10it can also purify him and serve as a mikveh to burn20:14the evil desires.