Torah · MussarMussar189. 2 Ways to Perceive HashemTzidkat HaTzadikPart 189Rabbi Uri Nahum · April 24, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0015:28Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat Tzadik, ot kuf pe-tet, 189.0:04It's been a while since we had one of those pieces,0:06short and not so complicated and to the point.0:11I hope, be'ezrat Hashem, this piece will refresh in us a little bit.0:15I personally have been struggling with the other pieces,0:18although, Baruch Hashem, they're very nice and deep,0:21but because it's a lot of information, sometimes you can lose focus.0:26In this piece, we come back to the old little bit, you know, shorter pieces,0:32be'ezrat Hashem. Beautiful idea, but very deep concept.0:35So let's begin.0:37Shnei minei hasagot elahut yesh.0:40There's two ways in basically understanding0:45God. Now let me explain what that means.0:47There's no way of understanding0:48God. That's what makes Hashem, Hashem, and we are as humans.0:52So you will not understand0:53Him, but in understanding and getting an understanding of Hashem,0:57there's two approaches to that.1:00There's two approaches.1:05Echad, echad מצד הבריאה, מכיר שיש בורא. One way, one track of getting an understanding of HaKadosh Baruch Hu is from creation itself,1:12that you recognize that there's got to be a Creator to this world.1:17Vezeh nikra ma'aseh Bereishit. This is what's known as1:19Ma'aseh Bereishit. We'll elaborate on this for a1:21second. Rav Miller, Avigdor Miller zatzal, whose yahrzeit was just a few days ago,1:26he used to talk a lot about this,1:29and a lot of sefarim have been written in the same style,1:32where you could look at the world and see the amazing coordination of the world,1:39and you have to say that there's got to be1:41God. It's impossible that there shouldn't be a1:43God, as we'll soon see that was the style also of Abraham1:48Avinu. Right, of a bigdimil, we'll say, for example,1:50you look in nature and you look how Hashem made the apple, and you look how He made the fruit,1:55and it's so colorful, and colors draw, you know, a certain attention from us,1:59and we look at it and it's sweet.2:01And the banana, look how it peels so nicely,2:04so this way you could protect the fruit,2:06and when you're ready to eat it, it's just so easy to take it out and eat it.2:09And one and one and one,2:11detail after detail.2:12If you study science in the right hashkafah, you see that it's an amazing world.2:18It's got to be created to the world in such a case.2:20This is known, this track is known as Maaseh2:23Bereishit. The other track of understanding God is mitzad2:29hanhagah, is how the world is actually running.2:32How, if you would understand, for example, the game of chess.2:36Let's say you're a very, very good chess player,2:38and you'd see how a person is making his moves,2:43and you're just like seeing such a perfect, you know, setup of how the person is setting up his pieces so he can checkmate.2:51And you see it's beautiful. It can't be just random.2:54It's unbelievable how this person is setting up the things,2:56and as the other player is, you know, defending his position and the guy keeps repositioning himself,3:02you see an unbelievable way of how, you know, the person running the world is.3:06So there's another way of perceiving the world,3:09and that is through looking at the world,3:12looking how the world is functioning, how history basically is taking place.3:16V'zeh nikra maaseh3:18merkavah. This is known, maaseh3:22merkavah, איך השם יתברך רוכב על הברואים. Why is it called maaseh3:24merkavah? Merkavah in Hebrew means chariot.3:26Chariot means that there's somebody riding a chariot and guiding it.3:30So too, maaseh merkavah is seeing how the world is not actually running by itself,3:34not just because people happen to want a democracy3:40and therefore they voted a certain individual and he came to power, and because he came to power,3:44certain things happened and it's his fault and it's the fault of the left or the fault of the right or whatever it is.3:52It's not. Maaseh merkavah means Hashem is coordinating things, He's running things.3:56Vehem shtei madregot, and these are actually two different levels that we find in history by the great Jewish people, Jewish characters,4:05which are—these two tracks are also4:08re'iyah v'da. They're also known as re'iyah, seeing, and yediah, which is understanding.4:13These are two levels of4:25shel Avot u'Moshe Rabbeinu alav hashalom, and iskaber Zohar, Parashat Vaera. These are two levels that we find by, or the two different tracks that we find, one by the Avot, Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov, and one by Moshe.4:29If you open up the Chumash in the beginning of Parashat4:32Vaera, as Chazal tell us over there that Hashem was giving a little bit of a, call it tochachah, to Moshe Rabbeinu,4:40He says in the pasuk, right in the beginning, the first first pasuk of the parashah says,4:45Vaera—well, it's not the first pasuk, sorry, it's the second pasuk.4:48The first pasuk is,4:50Vayedaber Elokim el Moshe...4:54Vaera, He tells him, Vaera el Avraham, el Yitzchak, v'el Yaakov b'El Shaddai,4:59shmi5:01Adonai lo נודעתי להם. And I have appeared to Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov with the name El Shaddai.5:06Specifically, the name Shaddai is the name that Hashem used to appear to the Avot.5:10However, my name Yud-Ke-Vav-Ke, that name I did not make known to5:15them. So the Zohar explains that this is because there were two different levels of perception of5:22God. The Avot, they had the perception, they understood Hashem through the creation.5:27That's called maaseh5:30Bereishit. And that's why the name, the appropriate name that they perceived God as, is the name Shaddai.5:36We'll see later on the connection.5:37And you, Moshe, you're going to see Hashem through not creation, but through Hashem's control of events,5:45and that's called maaseh5:47Merkavah, and that's through the name5:49Yud-Ke-Vav-Ke. Here we go.5:56For example, the mashal that Chazal tell us in Midrash, the famous Midrash. What does the Midrash say?6:00The Midrash says that Abraham Avinu walked and he would see a6:07bira. He would see a room, but he would see like a castle, a house, a big house.6:13And then he would see fire going on.6:15He says, It can't be.6:17There's got to be an owner to the6:19bira. It just doesn't make sense.6:20You don't just happen to have a house.6:22It doesn't work like that.6:24There's a house,6:25there's a fire,6:26something is lighting,6:27somebody's inside,6:28somebody's doing it.6:30So that's over here also, what Abraham Avinu, his perception was through nature,6:38v'hinikret re'iyah, and that's called6:40re'iyah, that he's able to perceive it on a level of seeing, which is called giluyah, which is really revealed,6:45which is something exposed that anybody could perceive.6:53V'lachen nizkar oto Hashem etzlahem, sham bakatuv haMoreh sheamar la'olami dai, kedei Chazal. And that's why the name that Hashem uses to— Explain this level is Shaddai.7:02What is Shaddai?7:04Chazal tell us Shaddai is she'amar l'olamo dai, that Hashem, when He created the world,7:08He told His world, enough.7:10What is the connection with that name to the perception of the Jewish people,7:17of the Avot? Rabbeinu Bachya explains that the world kept on expanding and expanding and7:25expanding, and Hashem said, Dai, enough.7:27You don't need to expand more.7:31Meaning, Rabbeinu Bachya explains that Hashem said, Enough.7:36You don't need more than that.7:37Enough.7:38Now you can perceive God through the world.7:41You don't need to develop it more.7:42He has over here brackets, which is a beautiful deep idea.7:47I want to skip it for now.7:49We'll come back to it, be'ezrat Hashem, later on, if we have time.7:53Vidia. Now again, that's one track.7:55That's a track, like we said, that is known as through creation.8:07The track of the Avot, and that track is called, what's it called, Maaseh Bereshit, good. And then there is the other track, the track of Maaseh Merkavah, vida'ahu ben Haga, kemo shene'emar, Hodi'eni na et derachecha. The other track is the track of Moshe Rabbeinu, which is how Hashem conducts the world.8:27As you notice, as you see, that's called the yediah, because Moshe Rabbeinu, when he was praying for the Jewish people after the Chet HaEgel, he saw his ... he's waiting for something from Hashem for a long time.8:36He tells Hashem, Hodi'eni na et derachecha, please show me your ways.8:40Hashem responds to him, Vlo ye'eni adam vachai, nobody can see Me and live.8:44And all the mefarshim get to work, what does that mean?8:49So the Gemara says, What was Moshe asking when he says, Hashem, let me know your ways?8:53He was asking, let me understand why is it that there's a tzaddik that could go through this world and he could suffer,8:59and why should it be that a wicked person should prosper?9:03Famous question of tzaddik vera lo,9:08vrasha vtov lo. And Hashem's response is, Nobody can see Me while he's still alive.9:11As all mefarshim explain, it's basically Moshe Rabbeinu was questioning the way things are running.9:17If you're a tzaddik, you're supposed to get good,9:20and you're a wicked person, you're supposed to get punished.9:22Why do we see that sometimes it's not that way?9:26And Hashem tells him, No, no, you can't see that while you're still alive.9:30And this is the same idea.9:31This is what Maaseh Merkavah is.9:33Maaseh Merkavah is the way Hashem conducts the world.9:35We don't always understand how Hashem is running the world,9:40and that's called lo9:43itgalya. Remember, the world of the Avot is something that's called9:45itgalya, that's revealed.9:46Not so the track of Moshe Rabbeinu,9:50vlo hodio.9:51And Hashem never notified him.9:53Rak, however, there was a certain level of understanding by Moshe.9:55We know that He told him,9:57what did He tell him in the pasuk that we quoted before from Parashat10:03Vaera, ושמי ה' לא נודעתי להם, the name of10:04Yud-Kei-Vav-Kei, I never exposed myself to them in such a way, but to you I did.10:08And through the makot, Hashem repeats that,10:11now you'll see10:20כי אני ה', right? Rak ידע דשמו הוויה, ומהווה הכל, והיה הוה ויהיה. He knew about this name10:22Yud-Kei-Vav-Kei, which means that He was, He is, and He will always be.10:25That he knew.10:31דהיינו, אשר לא נברא עולם, כי אין עכשיו, וזה אי אפשר להיות מחשבת אפיסה. Basically, to understand what Hashem was means that's before the world was created,10:37and now as the world is running,10:40and for the future, even after the world will be destroyed,10:42which is something beyond human comprehension.10:49וזהו הדעת מדת משה רבינו עליו השלום. This level is known as level of10:51daat. Those who understand the ten sefirot, there's the sefirah of10:56daat, שהוא כולל כל לבושות מן החכמים. Now, Moshe Rabbeinu's understanding of that level of11:00daat, again it was,11:03Chazal say, ותחסרהו מעט מאלוהים, he was lacking a little bit from that level,11:08but still Moshe Rabbeinu, his neshama actually11:13included all the neshamot of all the future talmidei chachamim that can come from the Jewish people.11:18Therefore, this level, this track called11:22maaseh Merkavah, it's impossible for everybody to understand.11:25It's only limited to those who are11:29talmidei chachamim. However, the level, the track of perceiving God through creation,11:35through maaseh bereshit, known as11:38re'iyah, that level of the avot,11:41שהם כוללים כל הנשמות כולם מישראל, the avot neshama include all future neshamot of the Jewish people,11:48זה אפשר לכל אחד. Not everybody could tap into.11:52Even if a person is not a talmid chacham, just the fact that you are a descendant of Abraham, Yitzchak, and11:57Yaakov gives you that privilege.12:04This level is something that everybody is zocheh to.12:09From the, basically, we have the zechut, the fact that we are— What12:14we are children of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, of Abraham, Yitzchak, and12:18Yaakov, we get that privilege.12:24V'dor hamidbar, the dor12:25hamidbar, ... This is in brackets, but it's good to do this piece.12:28Dor12:30hamidbar, they would also know that generation of Moshe Rabbeinu was known as dor12:33de'ah. Remember, the level of Moshe Rabbeinu was called dor12:36de'ah. Over there we find, Chazal tell us,12:41... shifchah yamah shelo ra'ah Yechezkel ben Buzi. Even the shifchah was able to perceive something12:43that even Yechezkel ben Buzi couldn't understand.12:45Now, and Yechezkel ben Buzi, what was he looking at? As we know,12:47the first perek in Sefer12:50Yechezkel, which is what the Chazal are talking about,12:53that's also what we can read in12:56Shavuot. That first perek talks about13:00Maaseh Merkavah. Maaseh Merkavah is something that Yechezkel ben Buzi saw,13:05although he didn't fully understand.13:06This shifchah, after Kriat Yam Suf by the Jewish people,13:10was able to understand.13:14Why?13:14Because they were all under the leadership of Moshe Rabbeinu.13:20And since Moshe Rabbeinu's level is13:23da'at, they were all tafel to him,13:24they were all secondary to13:26him, and they were able to perceive like him on that level.13:34And even Talmid Chacham was really able to13:37perceive from the way the world is running.13:40He could perceive God that way.13:42But sometimes we don't understand13:46why Hashem is doing certain things.13:47We don't understand how Hashem is moving the chess pieces.13:51It says in those times when it's dark and not clear13:54why Hashem is doing what He's doing,13:56then at least we could perceive God through nature.14:01This is something that we're zocheh to it14:04from our ancestors,14:05from Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov. As the Rambam brings down14:08in14:12Hilchot Yesodei HaTorah, how does one fulfill the mitzvah of Ahavat Hashem and Yirat Hashem?14:16And it says,14:17Rambam, כשישים האדם אל לבו... pays attention to all of nature,14:20that's how he perceives it.14:22So it comes out14:23that the two tracks,14:25known as14:28re'iyah and14:28yediah. Re'iyah is the level of the avot,14:31seeing God through nature,14:33known as14:34ma'aseh Bereishit. And then there's14:35yediah, the level of the14:38talmidei chachamim, understanding God from the way things are14:41running. It's interesting,14:41you know, many rabbis,14:44real14:45talmidei chachamim, when they see world events,14:46they are able to connect it to the14:49parashah and to talk about it14:50and to bring out an understanding of what's going on.14:53In fact, when things are happening in the world,14:54we're always turning to our14:56gedolim to tell us what are we supposed to learn from it,15:00because that level is really reserved for15:03talmidei chachamim, not for any person to come along and say,15:06Oh, this is what it means.15:07But any person who wants15:09can look at nature,15:10can study the science,15:12and come out with a certain understanding,15:14and that will be okay.15:15That could be done.15:17The other one is reserved for15:18talmidei chachamim. Anyway, I hope you enjoyed this piece15:20as much as I did,15:21really. Baruch Hashem, we're back to, you know, something15:24a little bit more that's attainable.