Torah · MussarMussar188. 4 Styles in LearningTzidkat HaTzadikPart 188Rabbi Uri Nahum · April 21, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0024:26Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkas HaTzadik, of Ot Kuf Pei Chet, 188.0:04This is one of those pieces that, in order to really understand every single line0:10of Rav Tzadok is saying, you need to know a lot of different Gemarot and how he puts them together.0:17But mainly, we're going to have to, we're going to focus on one specific Gemara,0:22and the reason for that is because otherwise we'd really spend a lot of time just giving0:26background information, and sometimes even fall in line. So when I feel that something very,0:31very minute, very small, I'm just going to give you a reference, and if you would like to look0:36into it, you look into it. Most people that are listening to this, especially as they're driving,0:40I don't think they're going to want to look into it, but if you want to look into it,0:43go and look into it, especially if you'd like to learn this book inside.0:47So the Gemara is on Daf Samech Gimmel, Masechet Shabbat, 63a, and what Rav Tzadok is going0:53to later on summarize is that there's different levels, four different levels of students. Now0:59we're talking about students, meaning referring to what we've been saying till now, people that1:03learn together, that we call in yeshiva world chavrutot. So the Gemara has different terminologies1:12to, I guess, you know, represent the different levels, as Rav Tzadok calls them. Let's start1:16with one, the first Gemara. The Gemara says, Amar Rabbi Meir, Amar Rabbi Elazar. You can find this by the1:20two dots. Shnei talmidei chachamim hamechadedin zeh1:27lazeh bahalacha, HaKadosh Baruch Hu matzliach lahem. Two talmidei chachamim, two scholars that sharpen each other in halacha, Hashem makes them succeed.1:35That is one Gemara. Obviously the Gemara brings pesukim, which I'm skipping for now because1:41we don't need it for now. Good. Next, the Gemara brings another statement: Amar Rabbi1:48Yirmiyah. Rabbi Meir says in the name of Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish, shnei1:54talmidei chachamim, hanochin zeh lazeh בהלכה, HaKadosh Baruch Hu makshiv lahem. Notice,2:00we're still talking about talmidei chachamim, but now we're referring to—we're using a different2:04terminology, nochin. The regular word of nochin means they are, you know, at ease with each other.2:11But what does nochin mean? Says Rashi, nos'in v'nosnin ba2:21benachat, ruach, mitaskin kedei sheyilmedu zeh mizeh. They learn with each other, and they are very at ease with each other. That means,2:27as Rashi says, benachat ruach. They're very interested in each other's wisdom2:31so they can learn from each other. So the Gemara says about this other—this type of learning,2:38which is called hanochin zeh lazeh בהלכה, HaKadosh Baruch Hu makshiv lahem, Hashem2:44listens to them. So as opposed to the first one, which is—what the first one is,2:50mechadedin, it says over there Hashem matzliach lahem, Hashem makes them succeed.2:57I forgot to mention also that the Gemara also says also, vela od ela3:02she'olin לגדולה. Also they get to greatness, and of course with the condition,3:07l'Hashem shamayim, and they're also zochin to the Torah. I didn't mention all that. I figured everybody would3:13look at it, but they're zocheh to the Torah, they're zocheh, which is also for oshvei chavod. The Gemara brings a3:18whole bunch of things. Good. Nochin zeh lazeh also says is that HaKadosh Baruch Hu listens to them.3:25Third topic, third Gemara says, Amar3:29רבי אבא אמר רבי שמעון בן לקיש, שני תלמידי חכמים המקשיבים זה לזה בהלכה. Two talmidei chachamim that are3:35listening to each other in the halacha, says3:40Rashi, makshivim zeh lazeh, melamdim זה את זה מבינים זה מזה בלשון דקה נקט. They're just—he's just borrowing the term,3:45the Gemara is borrowing the term from a pasuk. Makshivim means that they are teaching each other3:51and understanding from each other, as opposed to the first—the level before that,3:56hanochin, was that they're learning in order that they should learn from each other.4:01In this case, the Gemara says,4:06HaKadosh Baruch Hu שומע לכולן, Hashem listens to their— Sound to the voices. And finally, Rabbi Abba4:12... again, same rabbis said all those four statements says,4:15Shnei talmidei chachamim hamadgilin ze laze bahalacha. Two4:22talmidei chachamim that are madgilin ze laze bahalacha, HaKadosh Baruch Hu ohavan. Hashem loves them. What is madgilin? Here Rashi says4:28it's a little very different. Hameasfin ze et ze v'omrim bo venilmod. The word madgilin,4:34Rashi learns it is that they get together. Measfim, they gather each other. They gather4:41each other and they say, Let's learn together, venavin bein sheneinu, and we should understand4:46between each other. Now the Gemara says over here, Hashem loves them.4:52But on this you need to know, the Gemara brings two conditions. It says,4:56on a condition that they know tzurata d'shmaata. They know at least the source of what they learned.5:04And condition number two is that they don't have a rabbi around them. But had they had a5:09rabbi around them that can teach them, they should learn by him. But if they don't have, then5:14HaKadosh Baruch Hu just loves them, even though they may not fully understand what they're learning,5:19but they understand a little bit of the structure of what they're learning, and the other5:24condition is that their rabbi is not around. So it comes out that there are four different types of talmidim5:29that Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish spoke about. So now we get to Rav Sadok. This is a little bit of a background.5:35If you want one more thing, which I was thinking as a side point, one more thing that if you want5:38to know on this last point, this last level, there's a Tosafot in5:44Masechet Avodah Zarah that Rav Sadok points out, and over there in dibur hamatchil Regla b'chabrei yada, over there Tosafot5:51disagrees with Rashi over here. It says that ha-madgilin, Rashi says over here, is that,5:59mesiva zeh ve'omrim bo v'nilmad. Tosafot over there disagrees with them,6:03and they say over there that no, it means that they, what's it called, that they don't understand6:12what they're learning. They contradict each other in their learning, and they don't understand what6:16they're saying. It's a little bit of a machloket between Tosafot and Rashi. Okay, in any case,6:20you'll look it up if you want to, but that's a side point. Let's go now to Rav Tzadok, and hopefully6:25with this little bit of a background, we'll be able to appreciate the pieces of Rav Tzadok. We6:29might have to split it up in two, we'll see. Arba madregot ba-chaverim, says Rav Tzadok, there are four levels6:35when it comes to people that are learning together. Kemo she'amru, like it says in Masechet Shabbat,6:41and they are called mechaddedin, they sharpen each—level one is mechadden; v'nochim is, like we said,6:47is that they listen, they learn at ease with each other; makshibim is that they come to learn from6:54each other; madgilin is that even they just get together to learn, even though they don't really7:00fully understand. Lefi פירוש רשי, שאין בידם אלא אסיפה לבד. According to Rashi, he says, is that all they7:05have is the fact that they're coming together to learn. V'ka'inyan, similar to what we find in7:11Masechet Berachot. Over there the Gemara says, Igra d'pirka, rihata. The reward, the most reward that a person7:19gets when he's going to shiur is the fact that he runs to shiur. V'dekalad hu hacha, and it7:24says over there, in those days called yarchei kallah, it used to be a minhag amongst all7:30Klal Yisrael that everybody would learn Torah when they were younger, but as they get older, they would have to go to work.7:37So when they went to work, their life wasn't all about work, as we see some people's lives are7:45in certain generations. Their life was about Torah, but of course you have to work.7:49But once one month at least a year, perhaps sometimes another month, everybody would come7:54back. It's kind of like miluim, those who know in the Israeli army.8:00It goes to the army, and8:29then after you go to the army, then you have to kind of serve a month or two every few years, or jury duty in America, something like that. But over here, once a year, one month, everybody comes. That would be called Yarchei Kallah. And Yarchei Kallah, there's so many people there. And over there, the Gemara says, What's the sachar? What's the greatest reward a person gets when it comes to Yarchei Kallah and those times? It's a dochaka. It's that, you know, it gets packed, and there's so many people there that, you know, it's so tight. Your reward is for the fact that you're able to stand there even though it's so tight.8:36And Rashi explains,8:39Why is that the reward? You're coming to shiur, you're telling me the reward is for the fact that you're able to still remain there even though it's so tight?8:47Rashi explains because they don't really fully understand.8:51So the reward is for the fact that they came; they also get rewarded.8:54So says Rav... So this last level that we said, which is called Madgilin,9:02we said that Hashem loves them; they get rewarded also.9:05It's similar to the people who used to come in the months of, or in9:11Yarchei Kallah, and they would get rewarded, the Gemara said, just for being there in a tight place. Why?9:14Because even though they don't really understand, there's so many people there,9:18and they can get very distracted, the fact that they're coming, they get9:22rewarded. Then he brings, like we said, what we're calling a side point.9:25I'm just reading it, so we read it.9:27But like I said, it's a side point. I don't get into it.9:29He says,9:32And we told you before that Tosafot disagrees on how to explain Madgilin.9:52So... Tosafot basically disagrees with Rashi's understanding of what's that last level.9:57He says, of course, if they're learning and they understand the hashibut of the Torah,10:03of course, the Hashem loves them.10:06Why is the Gemara have to tell me?10:08Tosafot's chiddush is, Rabbeinu Tam's chiddush is,10:10magilin doesn't mean that they understand.10:14Magilin means they don't understand. They contradict each other.10:16They don't even realize what they're saying.10:18Still,10:19Hashem—that's the chiddush the Gemara has to tell you—that still Hashem loves them on a condition.10:23What do you mean?10:25So how do you know, on a condition that they value the Torah.10:28They're not just making fun;10:28they value the Torah that they have in front of them.10:36As opposed to the other levels that the Gemara says,10:43that talmidei chachamim, on a higher level,10:45if they don't do it l'shem shamayim, the Gemara says,10:48then it could be sam hamavet.10:50However, for these people, it doesn't say they have to do10:53it l'shem shamayim, because the fact that they're volunteering,10:55they come and they know they don't know so much,10:58but they value it.10:59They value Torah.11:01That alone creates love for them by HaKadosh Baruch Hu.11:06Now says Rav Tzadok now,11:09now that we explained the lowest level,11:11let's go back to now the third level,11:13what's called11:15makshibim. What is11:16makshibim? Says Rav Tzadok,11:18means that each person has some sort of wisdom,11:25and his friend is ready to accept from him what he knows.11:29What does it mean to be11:31makshib, which we know is to listen?11:33He says,11:35פירוש קבלה. Hakshaba means to not just listen,11:37but to also accept,11:39ma she'ein ken shmi'ah, which is different from shmi'ah, which is just hearing.11:42Hearing is, I hear you.11:43Do I accept it?11:44Not really, I hear.11:46Makshiv means I hear and I accept.11:54Aval ein chidushim, dehainu bina nolad beineihem. But over here,11:55in this interaction between these two people,11:56where they're just learning from each other,11:58there's no chidush that comes out.12:00They're just, each person is giving what they know to the other person,12:04but there's nothing that they are, you12:08know, discovering or creating from here.12:16Basically, the Gemara says about Rabbi Chiya b'Bamidbar, Abina d'lo nishkach Torah miYisrael, shekol echad yigmar l'chavero sidro. Basically, the statement where Rabbi Chiya says in12:20Masechet Bava Metzia, is that I make sure to guarantee that Torah doesn't get forgotten,12:23is that everybody basically learns what they're supposed to be learning.12:28And the Gemara says about the12:30makshivim that Hashem also listens to them,12:34shemitkayem bidehem, that Hashem allows them to do what they want to do.12:40Shezeh peirush shmi'at HaKadosh Baruch Hu l'kulan. This is what it says in the Gemara,12:41that Hashem listens to their voices,12:43is that what?12:45Is that what they want to do, they're able to do.12:54Ki einz Hashem yitbarach, lo sheyesh zman lo ma she'az shomea v'achar kach eino shomea. Rak shehu shomea l'olam. By Hashem, there's no time when He listens, time when He doesn't listen.12:58Time is a physical thing that we're bound to, not for Hashem.13:01Hashem is always listening.13:05V'hainu ki kolan kabua v'kayama, which means that a person who learns Torah,13:08that sound of Torah is constantly ringing there.13:11Here, you spoke at 1113:15o'clock and you stopped speaking at13:1711:05. That's it. The voice stops.13:20In Shamayim, there's no time.13:21If you spoke Torah, words of Torah, always constantly being spoken.13:26Like the Zohar says,13:31dekalin d'oraita v'tefilta lo abidu l'almin. The sounds of the Torah and the prayer, says the Zohar,13:35are never, ever, are never lost.13:39They're always around.13:41V'hainu d'lo tishtakach. That's the meaning of Rabbi Chiya says on this level,13:45is that I will guarantee that will never be forgotten.13:47What does it mean will never be forgotten?13:49What does it mean when Rabbi Chiya says,13:51I'll guarantee that Torah was never forgotten?13:52That means, and the Gemara over there13:54describes Rabbi13:55Chiya that he just takes the skin of a deer13:57and he writes on it13:58Sifrei Torah and he teaches kids.14:00How does that work?14:02So there are, of course, there's a simple meaning14:03of Talmud is explaining,14:05is that the fact that I give them just to read and to learn,14:08they spoke words of14:10Torah. Those words of Torah14:11will never be forgotten14:12because it'll always be ringing in14:24shamayim. And here the Gemara gives a condition14:26by this level.14:27Although it's a third level,14:28still the Gemara does give a condition,14:30and the Gemara says14:33by this condition14:35is that14:37it will, if they don't do it14:38l'shem shamayim, which, chas v'shalom, which means14:41if you don't learn it,14:42then the sound will not be around14:45and will not be continuous.14:56And this level is what we called in previous pieces,15:01b'ti.15:01Remember we said that there are different levels15:03that HaKadosh Baruch Hu calls the people that learn Torah.15:05One is b'ti,15:08then it says15:09achoti, then15:10imi. It says this level is still a b'ti,15:13still basically on the lower level.15:15So we got the lowest, lowest level,15:18which is called15:19medyelin. We got the level above it,15:21which15:22calls makshibin. There are people that just give information15:24without15:25chiddushim, and that's still,15:27in comparison to the overall picture,15:29one of the lower levels.15:31However, now we get to the highest two15:33levels, which we're working again from lowest to highest.15:41So he says, The two other levels are mentioned here in the Gemara15:45are levels that... A person actually comes out with a chiddush in Torah.15:50He comes out with novel ideas,15:52new explanations15:54and new levels of understanding15:57in what he's learning.16:00And on that, remember we told you in the Gemara, we skipped the pasuk on that.16:05He says, V'az nikra16:08yir'ei Hashem. There the Gemara calls them,16:09az16:12nidberu yir'ei Hashem, ish el re'ehu. Pasuk calls them the God-fearing people.16:15V'hem shetei madregot: the Noam,16:20v'chovlin, and these two levels are really the same two16:23levels the Gemara mentions16:25in Masechet Sanhedrin that explains the difference between the style of learning in16:28Bavel to the style of learning in16:31Eretz Yisrael. In Eretz Yisrael, the style of learning was much more16:37b'naimut, b'nochim b'halacha, like it says over here.16:38They're at ease with each other with16:41halacha. They speak politely, they speak nicely,16:43they're not knocking each other.16:45Each one is giving the chadesh, they're16:48discussing, as opposed to Torah in Bavel. The Gemara says in16:50Bavel they're called16:52chovlin. Why? Because they're always knocking and, you know, challenging each other.16:57Those who are zocheh to learn Yerushalmi17:00and learn Bavli, obviously, because you learn Yerushalmi, you learn Bavli as well,17:03you see the difference in the two styles.17:06Bavli is always a17:07challenge. Every single thing that's said, a challenge17:09until finally you come out with a halacha,17:12right? The Yerushalmi can just say statements.17:13There are a lot of different statements.17:14There can be challenges here and17:16there, but it's more noah.17:17And that the Gemara discusses that in17:20Masechet Sanhedrin, the difference between Talmud Eretz Yisrael and17:22Talmud Bavel. V'nochin ze17:25noam. The nochin that are mentioned in our Gemara, Masechet Shabbat,17:28is the level of noam, of pleasantness.17:30V'eilu shneihem nikru yir'ei Hashem.17:32But you should know, both levels are called yir'ei Hashem.17:36She'einam shnei hafachim. It's not that they're two opposites.17:39V'HaKadosh Baruch Hu mekabel mah shehem gozrim,17:41and Hashem listens to what they say,17:42means that Hashem accepts what they're gozer.17:45This is called achoti.17:46Now they got to the level, like we explained in previous pieces,17:50on the level of achoti means that they're like HaKadosh Baruch Hu.17:53Just like Hashem is gozer, they're also gozer.17:56She'achdoshim shelahem mekubalim17:58u'sgemim lemaalah, mipnei shehu shenehem yir'ei Hashem.18:00It means that just like Hashem is mechadesh18:05the Torah, so too these people are zocheh to get to that level,18:07like HaKadosh Baruch Hu,18:08to be also mechadesh Torah.18:09And of course, with the condition that they're God-fearing people.18:13Of course, we find the Gemara in Maseches, and here telling us18:16about Menashe that would come and be doresh18:19the Torah, mechadesh18:20chidushim, but was there to, you know, twist the real meaning of18:23the Torah. It wasn't done with fear of God.18:27I know I'm a little bit over time,18:29but I just have one more18:31paragraph, and I'm going to finish it here in this recording.18:33And then he says,18:39The Gemara explains that what produced the most amount of Torah and students18:44was really in18:46Bavel. Like the Gemara says,18:49Maseches, daf kuf vav amud aleph. Why?18:53Because in order to increase students, it's only through sharpness,18:56through sharpening their minds,18:58through aiyedeihem machloket, which comes through disagreements19:03and opposites.19:08This is what the Gemara means in Maseches Shabbat19:09that we started off with.19:11It says...19:14Two people, two talmidei chachamim, that are mechaded each zeh lazeh bahalacha, each other19:19in19:21halacha, they sharpen each other in halacha, Hashem makes them succeed.19:23And what does He say?19:24He also makes them19:27oleh legdulah. You know what the oleh legdulah means?19:29It means that they are able to produce students.19:34Why is that so?19:36Because two opposites need a19:38middle. When you have two people learning, two talmidei chachamim learning,19:41and they're sharpening each other,19:43they're arguing back and forth with each other,19:45they need that,19:47you know, in the rules of two opposites,19:50there's always a middle.19:52V'daat hamechaber, and there's that middle person that connects the two opposites.20:01V'zeh nikra v'haderech, k'dechsiv, Talmidei chachamim shebBavel rotzim setzin ufrachim laTorah. This is what the Gemara refers to20:04in a different section, Masechet Shabbat,20:06that the talmidei chachamim in20:09Bavel have made flowers and buds out of the Torah,20:13meaning they produced,20:15they produced a lot more to the Torah.20:20UvZohar nikra pilpula talmud kishutei kallah, and the Zohar refers to the sharpening of the Gemara20:25as the adornments that one places on the bride.20:29Shezehu hahadar bemet, this is the real beauty of the Torah.20:34V'kach Talmidei chachamim shebBavel metzuyanim, that's why the Gemara says about Talmidei chachamim in20:36Bavel, another statement says that they are20:39metzuyanim, they walked with a certain look,20:41they stuck out,20:45k'deita uferush, sheeinam binei mekomam, shehaYehudim metzuyim bmekoman. The Gemara explains20:48why is that so?20:49The Gemara says because they don't really, that's not really their home.20:52Their home is really20:53Eretz Yisrael, and that's not their home, meaning.20:55It's the fact that they sharpen each other,20:58they don't have a20:59makom. They're spiritual;21:00they're above from their21:04makom. Ki nochin, yeshuv hadaat, because the tamud of Eretz Yisrael,21:06we said, was called21:07nochin. That was done21:09b'yeshuv hadaat, with calmness,21:12right? And21:13yeshuv is settlement, also, same word as settlement.21:16Right,21:17as the Gemara says,21:18people who live at peace all21:20times, when something small came,21:21it just threw them out.21:22Because when people don't move from their place,21:26right,21:27they're called shanan, they're very chilled out.21:32But the sharpness actually21:34widens up21:36the derashot u'marchiko, and like the21:38definition of a drash,21:40that it's not, you know, you talk about one word21:41and all of a sudden you end up somewhere else.21:43That's what drash is.21:44You're distant, you're far from your place.21:46And that's why דווקא the people who were in21:48Bavel, that were far from their source,21:50which is Eretz21:51Yisrael, that's why there was21:54zocheh to the derashan to be able to expound upon the Gemara,21:57right?22:00And this is why they were22:02mitzuyanim. However, this could be dangerous22:04because this could cause a person to become22:06baal gaavah when he sees he's producing so much22:08chidushim, or when he sees that he is,22:12what's it called,22:13succeeding in developing the Torah,22:15it could cause a person to do22:18a shelo l'shem Shamayim. For example,22:20he would want to learn22:22in order that he should get titles,22:26kedei to be nedarim, lachen amru b'kedushin, v'gasu lebavel nachit. That's why the Gemara says,22:28based on the pasuk in Zechariah,22:30that22:32gaavah landed in22:35Bavel. Lachen itnu b'zeh al devar emet v'tzedek. That's what the Gemara says22:37in the beginning.22:39Hamechadedin zeh lahalachah. Read the Gemara over there.22:40Give a few conditions.22:41It says on the condition that they do it.22:44To find out the truth,22:45which is22:48l'shem Shamayim, v'anavah tzedek, and with humility.22:49Why with humility?22:51Because there's a danger that it could22:53produce22:55gaavah. As22:57zochin l'minatan, the Gemara says over there,22:58as a result,22:59the zocheh to receive the Torah that was given23:01in the right of Hashem's hand.23:06This is purely another,23:08completely another level,23:10and this is the goal of the whole Torah,23:12that it makes him reach greatness.23:16Bechol arba madregot hem, bechol talmid. You should know all these four levels23:18are not talking about just four different people.23:20They actually are discussing23:22the same person,23:24the same person23:25on four stages in his life.23:28Mina d'leit rabba, from the beginning,23:29when a person doesn't even have a23:31rabbi, doesn't have a rabbi to learn from,23:33he just comes and he wants to learn.23:36So he picks up a sefer nowadays. You can just pick up a book,23:37you pick up an art23:38scroll, you pick up an English book,23:39you just want to learn.23:40You may not even understand what you're actually reading.23:43And then there's the next level,23:46right,23:47when a person gets on a higher level,23:48then he's just learning.23:50Now he's understanding, but he's just learning.23:51He picks up books and he's understanding what he's learning.23:54Then he goes on a higher level,23:55and then he's discussing his halachot with other people23:58that's nochin.24:00And then he's so convinced of what he knows that when people challenge him, he comes and challenges back,24:06and he creates. He's able to create many more talmidei chachamim, and he's able to have talmidim that they disagree with him.24:13Right? He says that's what it is.24:15It can all be in the same person. From the Tanna, he doesn't have a rabbi in the city24:20until he himself becomes his own rabbi.