Torah · MussarMussar185B. Levels in Learning TorahTzidkat HaTzadikPart 185Rabbi Uri Nahum · March 28, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0022:05Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot kuf peh bet,0:05185b. Like we said in the beginning of the last recording,0:08this will take us a while because it's a very long piece.0:13So let's do a quick review. We basically spoke about different levels.0:17We spoke about the level of a person when he begins, he begins0:20to learn from a rabbi, and then the next level is after a0:24person learns from the rabbi, then he's on the level of0:28bechavruta, learning from others. And then we spoke about why it is0:33that you can't pray, or,0:37you know, the Tanna doesn't command—not you can't pray, but the Tanna doesn't command a person0:41to go and make students, although that seems to be0:44the highest level. And we, whatever, we discussed0:48at length in the other level. Now let's continue. He says,0:53V'limud me'rabhuat hatchalah. Learning from a rabbi is really the beginning.1:01V'zeh nikra birachot, echad sheyoshev v'osek baTorah, sheShechinah imo. And this is what the Gemara says1:03in Masechet Brachot, that a person who sits alone and he is osek baTorah, the Shechinah is with him.1:07And where does that concept come from? Where does the Gemara learn it from?1:12The Gemara learns it from the pasuk that says,1:16B'chol makom asher azkir et shemi, wherever I mention My name. And the Gemara explains over there1:20that Torah—not over there, but we know that the Torah נקרא שם ה', the Torah1:23is called the Shem Hashem,1:28like it says later in Masechet1:30Brachot, in daf chaf alef, it says,1:34V'azkir, hainu dehu Torat Hashem. And whatever it says that I will mention My name, it's referring to1:39the Torah of Hashem. So when it says,1:42B'chol makom asher azkir et shemi, it means a person who is learning Hashem. V'nikra lHashem, Hashem1:48yitbarach shemo, mazkiru melamed. The reason why the Torah is called the name of1:51God is because we are teaching everybody about God and His ways.1:58U'vezehu b'yachid, and this is referring to a2:00person sheyoshev v'osek. This is about an individual that learns2:03by himself.2:10Kemo she'amru, pirush: ma ein tamidei chachamim metzuyim lihiyot beneihem tamidei chachamim shelo birchu b'Torah techilah. And the Gemara2:11brings a masechet Nedarim, a rather somewhat rather2:16known Gemara,2:17where this says the Gemara, based on2:22pesukim, says, Why is it that talmidei chachamim, we don't find the dead2:26children also come out to2:29be talmidei chachamim? The Gemara answers because they didn't make the brachan haTorah first. What does that mean,2:32they didn't make the brachan on the Torah? So he explains,2:39shemevarech, ki birchat Torah2:41shemevarech hamelamed Torah l'amo Yisrael, because the bracha of2:45the Torah, what does it mean, they didn't make a brachan on the Torah? The bracha of the Torah is what we say,2:50hamelamed Torah l'amo Yisrael, that Hashem teaches the Torah to2:53His nation, meaning, makir sheHaKadosh Baruch Hu melamed.2:58When a person is learning Torah, he understands3:01or he recognizes that it's Hashem who teaches Torah to everybody,3:06that it's Hashem teaching them Torah,3:09והיא תורת ה', as na'aseh Torato l'chaveracha. And when you recognize that, you recognize that the Torah3:13is all from Hashem, even your own chiddushim, your own novel ideas,3:18it's really all from HaKadosh Baruch Hu, then,3:21as the Gemara says, that it begins by saying Torah Hashem, then eventually becomes3:25the Torah of the person. That's what we're saying also over here.3:29It starts out as Torah Hashem. Hashem is the one who teaches3:33everybody, but after you make the bracha, then you3:37zocheh that it becomes yours. Ve'az, then after that level,3:41zochim lebanim talmidei chachamim. Then3:45they zocheh that their children should also be talmidei chachamim. What does that mean,3:48that3:53... dechachamim? דהיינו להיות שניים שיושבים ועוסקים בתורה. That's the next level. Remember, first level is learning, and when you're learning,3:57you're just alone. You're learning from the rabbi. The next level is two people learning4:00together. That's the chaver. The two people learning together is4:05the same idea also as the4:09next generation of,4:12basically the next generation where the kids of the talmidei chachamim are also talmidei chachamim.4:17And that comes, why? The Gemara tells us, when they make4:21the berachah. Now what does it mean to make the berachah on the Torah first?4:25It means to recognize that it all comes from HaKadosh Baruch Hu, because when you recognize it comes from4:28Hashem, then it becomes like your Torah, and you're zocheh that you have4:33now you and somebody else.4:36Now, he brings in brackets4:39a small little line, which we're going to need for the next paragraph, and he says,4:42this next level—remember, the first level is, the Gemara says,4:46b'chol makom asher azkir et shemi. That's a person who's learning alone.4:49The next level is called,4:56זֶה נִקְרָא מִדְרָגַת עַז נִדְבְּרוּ יִרְאֵי ה' אִישׁ אֶל רֵעֵהוּ. That's the next level. The Torah says4:59that when each person—when there are two people learning, the Gemara says,5:02how do I know that the two people that are learning, שכינה is between them?5:06The Gemara quotes a pasuk that says,5:12עַז נִדְבְּרוּ אִישׁ יִרְאֵה ה' אֶל רֵעֵהוּ. The God-fearing people5:15spoke to each other, one to another. And from there the Gemara learns that5:18two people that are osek baTorah, the Shechinah is between them.5:22So Rav Sadok is explaining that next level also corresponds5:26to the next generation, because now you have two people that are osek in the5:29Torah: first generation, the talmidei chachamim, and the next generation, their kids5:34that are also busy in Torah.5:39וְנִקְרָא יִרְאֵה ה' אִישׁ אֶל רֵעֵהוּ מִדְּגַת חָבֵר. This second level is what we called5:41originally chaver. Remember, a person goes through stages. First he's a talmid,5:45then he's a rav, then he's a chaver—excuse me—then he's a rav,5:49and that's the chaver, כי עד שמא. Now why? Is this level,5:53which is called the second level, called yirat Hashem?5:58Ki yirat Shamayim hu bechirah shebidei adam, because6:00yirat Shamayim is something that you could choose. As the famous6:04Chazal, which is based on the pasuk, parashat Eikev, Moshe Rabbeinu tells us,6:11ועתה ישראל, מה ה' אלוקיך שואל מעמך. What does Hashem ask of you?6:14Ki im leyrah. He only asks that you should fear6:16Hashem. And the Gemara, Rashi brings it over there on the pasuk,6:19the Gemara, I believe it's Masechet Berachot, it says,6:30הכל בידי שמים חוץ מיראת שמים. Maybe it's Masechet Megillah. הכל בידי שמים חוץ מיראת שמים. Everything is in the hands of Hashem except for yirat Shamayim.6:34So yirat Shamayim, you see, it's not in the hands of Hashem; it's in your hands.6:38So that's why when it says that the second level, which is the level6:42of the chaver, is yirat Hashem, because that's still in your choice.6:46It's a choice that you can make.6:50ובחירה בעצמה באמת גם כן מאת השם יתברך, יצר האדם בעל בחירה. But if you think about it deeper,6:54as this seems to be a theme that Rav Tzadok keeps repeating,6:58although we have the ability to make a choice,7:00but who gave us the ability? Who created us with such an ability to make a choice?7:05And that is HaKadosh Baruch Hu. So really it's all Hashem,7:08because Hashem put me in the position that I should be able7:12to make a choice. So my choice is really7:15from HaKadosh Baruch Hu, Hashem as well.7:23רק יראת שמים, דהיינו הכרה שבחירה גם כן מאת השם יתברך, זה נקרא יראת שמים. But to go deeper than that,7:27my recognition of this, my recognition that it's Hashem7:31who has created us to make such a choice,7:35that this choice also is7:39the ability that comes from HaKadosh Baruch Hu. That's what yirat Shamayim is.7:44שיראה לב חומרה. Why is it called— God-fearing person,7:47because you're scared to choose the wrong choice, the bad choice,7:51which is still in the hands of a person.7:57And to choose7:58to learn, which we said.8:00That was level one, which is to go to classes and to start learning Torah.8:04That is also a choice in its own.8:12והוא בסוד נעוץ סופן בתחילתן. זה גם כן מאשר מידו ברך, לכן נקרא תורת השם. And he explains that, again, it's this ability for a person8:17to learn and to recognize8:20that it's all that he's learning,8:24the Torah that he's learning, everything else is coming from HaKadosh Baruch8:27Hu. That is really why, on this first level,8:31when the person is still working on his hakarah, on his recognition,8:34it's still called8:37Torat Hashem. Next he goes and he explains,8:50ולא אחר פטירת הרב, ואבדו אשתונותיו, כדרך שאמרו: אל תבטחו בנדיבים, בבן אדם שאין לו תשועה. ביום ההוא. Good. It says in the pasuk in Tehillim, Don't put your trust in the wealthy people, the wealthy people.8:54Now a regular person, on that day, all of a sudden,9:00אבדו אשתונותיו, his effects are all gone.9:02So he explains this to refer to a rabbi.9:05When the person's rabbi ceases, so simply that means,9:10pashut pshat is that his rabbi is no longer in the world to teach him Torah.9:16הוא מתחיל להכיר כי באמת השם יתברך מלמד תורה לעמו ישראל. The person now comes to9:18recognize that it's really, it's all from Hashem,9:20no matter who he learns from, it's all from Hashem.9:23And the pasuk continues, and he sees that,9:27ואשרי, fortunate is the person that makes Hashem as his choice.9:30He puts his trust on Hashem.9:36הקרה זו נקרא יראת שמים. This is also what we call yirat shamayim, ואז יתבררו ישראלו, מבקש לקנות חברים. And he recognizes it all comes from Hashem,9:42so now he wants a group to be part of that same group,9:50כענין שאמרו: קנה לך חבר. As Chazal advised in Pirkei Avot. That when you have9:55chaverim, you will be able to acquire,9:57and if you don't do it, then your friends will do it, and they'll take it away from you.10:07Shehu מצד יראה שמא ישכח חס ושלום. And this is also part of fear,10:09because there's a fear that a person has, a person should have,10:13is that once he learns, there's a fear that he might forget his10:17learning. And that fear that he might forget his learning will always make sure to—he'll always make sure10:21to be around people that are learning,10:23and this way he could be part of what we call a chavurah, part of a group of learners.10:27So this way he's always involved in learning, or otherwise, חס ושלום, he might forget his learning.10:32We find this by Rabbi Elazar ben Arach in10:35Masechet Shabbat. It says that he went to a place10:39where—now, this story is expounded upon in other places in10:42Chazal, I believe in10:44Avot d'Rabbi Natan—and it says that basically from the students of Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, Rabbi Elazar ben Arach was one of the top ones,10:50and all his friends decided to go to live in a certain place,10:54and he decided to go live somewhere else.10:56And because he decided to go live somewhere else, for whatever reason, the midrash gives over there,11:02because he decided to live somewhere else, eventually he forgot his learning.11:06So that's what we're saying, because he's not around the group,11:09he didn't have the knei lecha11:11chaver. He went on his own and he wasn't zocheh.11:14Vehu b'chet haTorah, and this is in the same pattern as a b'chet haTorah.11:20Techilah shezocheh lebanim, talmidei chachamim. In the beginning, you're zocheh—the person is praying that he should be zocheh11:33to children also talmidei chachamim, כמו שנאמר: כי בן יברך גבר ירא ה'. Ve'davar zeh nikra lo kumeh gersa, shemem gemara d'hu siyata dishmaya. And this is what the Gemara calls11:36that a person should have the proper11:38girsa, that he should work on remembering his learning,11:42which is all11:47b'siyata dishmaya. V'lachen amar: אשרי... That's why the pasuk says,11:50it puts in the Chumash, I'm going to read you the full pasuk.11:57Ashrei she-El Yaakov be'ezro, sivro al Adonai Elohav. Fortunate is a person who has for his assistance the God of12:04Yaakov, sivro, and he puts his thinking,12:07all of his trust basically, on Hashem, his God.12:11He says over here,12:18and it says over here, fortunate is a person. It doesn't say in the pasuk in a way of a command.12:24In the beginning, a pasuk before that says,12:27Al tivtechu b'nedivim. Two pesukim before that, it says, Don't trust12:31in nedivim. Sounds like he's commanding you, don't do it.12:33And then afterwards it says, Fortunate is a person that is zocheh to such a level,12:41right? Rak zehu siyata dishmaya, ve'eino bidei adam. To teach you that to get to such a12:44level is12:49only siyata dishmaya. V'lachen amar, az nidberu, v'lo diberu. Rak nidberu, sheraku kach. That's why the second level is really a little bit of12:53a siyata dishmaya. For those who went to yeshiva can relate that,12:55you know, to have a chevruta is tremendous12:59siyata dishmaya. Sometimes you're not zocheh to find that proper study partner13:03that's on your level, that can understand you, that can go your pace.13:06When you want to go fast or slower, it's a very, very difficult thing.13:10In fact, it might be harder than finding a shidduch to get married.13:13You know, some people, they could testify about that. It's a very hard thing to have a study partner13:17that could work with you, the same head and the same things,13:20that you guys could challenge each other and work good together.13:23I've been in yeshiva for many years, and, baruch Hashem, I'm zocheh for many years,13:27and I can testify it's not a simple matter to find13:32a chevruta. So that's what he says: you need13:36siyata dishmaya. And now the Gemara continues over there and13:38says that when two people are learning together, what's the difference between one person learning by himself,13:43when two people are learning together? Their words that they speak are actually being recorded.13:48What does that mean, they're being recorded?13:50They're being recorded in the book of chronicles.13:53What's that book of chronicles that records the conversation between two people learning?13:57It says, hem nafshotan. It means they're being recorded on their souls.14:04As he brings down14:06that he doesn't fully explain over here, but we know when Chazal speak about14:10the books that are opened up on Rosh Hashanah, the books of the wicked, the books of the righteous,14:15explains that the books refer to the souls. The souls are opened up,14:18so the books refer to the neshama of a person.14:21So when it says that their words are being recorded on sefer zichronot, that refers to on their14:26neshamot. It sticks better.14:29That's what we're saying till now,14:31that when it says that their words are being recorded means that when you learn with a study partner, you remember it better,14:38and it stays with them. That should not be forgotten.14:43It can be a cheit, amru demitapshan. As opposed to a person who learns alone.14:46A person who learns alone, the Gemara says that he actually, it's not good.14:49Gemara gives some harsh comments to a person who learns alone.14:53It says because they become more foolish, because you have nobody to challenge you.14:57Whatever you think, you think you're right,14:59and you have nobody that can challenge you and tell you no, you're not saying right,15:04and what we call in learning, ma'amido al15:10ha'emet. So I would have wanted to stop over here, maybe make a third recording,15:14but let me finish. Maybe, say, two and a half paragraphs left,15:18and we'll try to wrestle a bit.15:25Now, even though we said15:26that you need se'ata dishmaya to find a study partner15:30on the level of chaver, we find that the Tanna says,15:35ukne lecha chaver. He commanded you to do it.15:38What do you mean? It's not in my hands. I thought it's all se'ata dishmaya. So he says,15:47really, you have to put the effort in finding one.15:49That's in your control. But to actually find it,15:52that's not in your control.15:56That's the zocheh to it. That's se'ata dishmaya. Like it says by Gemarot Hasimah, kacha zecha, v'ein משום שאמרו...16:01It's kind of like doing chesed. You have to put the effort. You have to give charity. You have to try to give tzedakah.16:09Now, does everybody who gives charity is actually fulfilling the mitzvah? The Gemara says no.16:13Sometimes we find people that give charity and they're not16:20zocheh. How can they not be zocheh? They give the money, and the answer is they're giving it to the wrong people, and you need a special privilege that your money that you're16:27giving should go to the right hands, to the right people.16:35And he says maybe that's a continuation of what the Tanna is saying also.16:39The Tanna is saying after he says, Buy a friend for yourself, he says, and judge everybody favorably.16:44What does that mean?16:47Don't have to worry about this. What if I go put the effort and I don't find the right study partner?16:52So what's going on? And you tell me to even buy it and to spend money on it.16:56What if I don't find? So the Tanna says, Don't worry, judge everybody favorably.17:02Don't think too much about it.17:04Yeah? Why?17:05Even though it's brought down. Now, this is a little bit of a contradiction in the statements.17:19He's bringing now over here from the Zohar, from the Rambam.17:21A person who's learning Torah, learn from any person, right?17:25Even though he's not the best, as long as you're learning pure Torah.17:28However, for a friend who will influence you more, you need to make sure that he's a proper person,17:37and therefore you might get too worried about it and not even put the effort.17:42That's why it comes, the Tanna says,17:50Don't be too picky. Put your trust in Hashem, and Hashem will help you.17:59U'pasuk shel Al Tiftachu B'Nedivim v'Chuli, mesayem, HaShomer emet la'olam. Now this pasuk of Al Tiftachu B'Nedivim, b'ven adam she'ein lo teshuah, all these things, all that statement in that mizmor, it concludes,18:11HaShomer emet18:14la'olam. So as it says, Hashem protects the emet forever.18:20What does that mean?18:24HaKadosh Baruch Hu shomer divrei Torah sheyitkaymu b'yado l'olam, v'oseh mishpat. Now whatever you learn, when you put your effort the right way,18:28you try to get a study partner that's on your level and an appropriate person,18:33Hashem will make sure to protect that Torah forever.18:39U'mazkir kol hachaserim sheHashem yitbarach ozeram. And in that mizmor, pay attention,18:41you'll see that it speaks about all the people that are lacking, Hashem gives them assistance.18:48V'chen ha'Hashem makir b'chesrono. How does this apply to the person who's learning Torah? Well, if a person who's learning Torah recognizes his own lacking,18:55whether it's his weak memory, his weak depth into learning, his ADHD that he can't, you know, he can't focus,19:08echavdor... vadai Hashem yitbarach ya'azrenu v'yishmor Torato l'olam. Then for sure Hashem, He comes to Hashem basically broken and says, Hashem, help me.19:12So we all know, as a human nature, which Hashem has planted into us,19:17that when we are asked— To help others, and we see that they completely depend on us,19:24it actually gives us more of an incentive—not just an incentive,19:29but it makes us feel more responsible to help others.19:32So too, when we come to Hashem, we put our full trust on Him, we completely rely on Him,19:37so He also responds in the same way, and He wants to help us more.19:41And a guy who comes in and says, Hashem, I'm chaser, please help me, complete, let me learn,19:47then Hashem helps him.19:51Another point to keep in mind:19:53when the Tana says,19:55וקנה לך חבר, not say וקנה לך חברים; it says חבר, singular.19:58Also, the pasuk that we said corresponds to this level20:01is, איש אל רעהו, again in the singular form.20:06It didn't say acquire a group.20:12The only thing is that the Gemara mentions that there is a group of people,20:25three people,20:35... דין. Right? So if you look, basically he's quoting the Gemara over there in the Mishnah20:39that talks about the levels of people that are learning Torah.20:42First it starts off, like we said already, that if a person is learning Torah by himself, that's one level.20:46Then the Mishnah says, How do I know that two people?20:49It brings another. How do I know three people?20:50And the Gemara says over there, three people is referring to din.20:53And then how do I know that ten people that are sitting down20:55are engaged in Torah? It connects with them. So that's another level.20:58He explains the level of ten, אבל העשרה זהו אחר כך. The level of ten is referring to the next level.21:04That's after, afterwards, when a person is21:12זוכה, כשאדם מבין תורה בתמידים, ששכר יותר פחות בכתוב, הוא שכר עשרות. A person is זוכה to get the level of disseminating Torah, teaching Torah,21:17then he's—that's the next level, which is what the Mishnah refers to, the level of ten people.21:23As we know, that the people who were put in charge by Moshe in Parashat Yitro21:28to be the judges of the Jewish people, minimum was ten people.21:32Ve'az kadmah Shechinah, and then when you have ten people, we know what Chazal21:36tell us, then the Shechinah comes beforehand.21:40Ve'atiyah shekivan na'aseh gufo, merkavah laShechinah, Torah yitbarach. In that case, when there's ten people learning Torah,21:44oh, the Shechinah comes before you start learning.21:47Then you become like the chariot that's holding Hashem.21:55Af kol ha'osek baTorah, betamah d'gatyahu, siyata dishmaya, shekol she'atan Torah niskar la'el. Then they get to that level of a very high level, which is that siyata minei chachamim tzarich limud, that everything they do is really Torah.