Torah · MussarMussar185A. Levels in Learning TorahTzidkat HaTzadikPart 185Rabbi Uri Nahum · March 26, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0015:17Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat Tzadik, ot kuf peh hei, 185.0:05The pieces in Tzedkat Tzadik I don't know if we mentioned them earlier, but they're starting to get much, much bigger.0:10I don't know if one recording will be enough for each piece.0:14I'm hoping that even two recordings will be enough. Let's see,0:17especially there's a lot of background.0:19In the following piece, it's basically the next couple of pieces deal with learning Torah and levels in learning Torah.0:27So let's just re-quote, or let's bring back a statement that we said in previous recordings.0:34The Gemara says that one of the Amoraim says,0:38Harbeh lamadti me'rabotai. I learned a lot from my rabbis.0:42Ve'yoter u'mechaverai yoter mehem, and from my friends I learned even more.0:52U'mitalmidai yoter mikulam, I learned even more than anybody else.0:56Okay, that's one Gemara that we need to know.1:00It's Masechet Taanit. Another Chazal that we need to know before we get to the piece is two more.1:05There's two Mishnayot in Masechet1:08Avot, in Pirkei Avot. In one place it says,1:10Aseh lecha rav, u'kneh lecha chaver, vehevei dan et kol adam1:16lechaf zechut. Make for yourself a rabbi,1:18buy for yourself a1:20friend, and then you should judge everybody1:25lechaf zechut, basically translate it loosely as judge everybody favorably.1:29Okay. Another place it says,1:31Az nidberu yirei Hashem1:34ish el achiv, and then the yirei Hashem, the God-fearing people, spoke to each other,1:38and Hashem was there listening.1:40Those are the three pieces of information.1:42If you're familiar with the Gemara, it makes it much easier.1:44If you're not, even just hearing it, just listening, just knowing it,1:49it's good enough. We just want to get the basic translation in1:53and the basic idea in, and then we'll see how Rav Tzadok,1:56bezrat Hashem. We'll explain it. We'll expound upon it.1:59So he says like this:2:00Shalosh2:02madrigot letalmid chachamim. A talmid chacham really goes through three stages:2:08rav, vechaver, vetalmid. He is, I guess this is working, I guess, backwards.2:12He's a rabbi, where he is giving over Torah.2:16He's a chaver. He's on the same level.2:18He goes where basically he's2:21a talmid chacham, he has friends, and in2:23Chazal the talmidei chachamim are referred to as2:26chaverim. And he's also a talmid.2:28He also goes through a stage, obviously in the beginning, as a student.2:31And he brings this based on the Gemara2:34that we started quoting in the beginning of the recording.2:36As it says in the Gemara,2:40Masechet Taanit: ... Those are the three levels that a person goes through,2:44and really each one in his time.2:45A person begins first as a talmid.2:47He's a student. He's learning from a rabbi.2:49Then eventually he himself will get to a2:53stage where he has other people that are also learning,2:55and he's on a level with them that he learns with them,2:58like chavruta, or he's part of a3:01chabura, he's part of a group, or a study partner,3:03and he's in yeshiva, or studying with others on the same level.3:07And then the higher level than all those3:10is when he gives over Torah to other people.3:12So he says,3:16Ushtayim rishonot hem beyado, and the first two levels, which is being a student3:20and being a3:21chaver, having a study partner3:23or learning with people on your level,3:25that's really in the person's control.3:27He can control that.3:28That means you choose if you want to go to a class.3:31You choose if you want to listen to a3:34shiur. You choose to have a rabbi to learn from.3:37That's up to you.3:37Or you could choose to go on your phone,3:40or to watch the sports game,3:42or to watch a movie.3:43You choose whatever you like,3:45or choose not to do anything, whatever you like.3:47But you choose basically to learn.3:49You also choose to study with others.3:51You also choose to learn with others.3:53Although it's always good to learn,3:55and people, in a way, prefer to learn3:57in a silent, quiet thing,3:59but when you learn with others,4:02especially people on your level.4:04There's that, what the Gemara calls4:06like a sharpening of a knife.4:07When you take two metals against each other4:09and you, you know, you put them against each other,4:13you rub them against each other,4:14then they become sharper.4:15So too, when you have people learning4:17on the same level with each other4:19and they challenge each other,4:20they actually will grow from that4:22and they learn much better.4:23As anybody who's been to a yeshiva system4:25will tell you, when you learn b'chavruta, it's much different. When you learn from the rabbi4:28and you're hearing everything crystal clear,4:31you start thinking that you really know4:33how to learn on your own.4:34You can do this also on your own.4:36It's only when you open the book by yourself4:39and you read it with a study partner,4:40because if you read it to yourself,4:42you could fool yourself4:42and you think you really got it.4:44But now that you're sitting with a study partner4:46and he says, Okay, let's go, let's learn,4:48you start to say something,4:49he says, That's not what the rabbi said.4:50So what do you mean? Of course he didn't. And you start to discuss it,4:52and you have to kind of force yourself4:54to bring out the truth of the matter,4:56the truth of the words,4:58and to really, you know, stand up to your words.5:00You know, whatever he's saying,5:02you have to prove it.5:03So that makes your learning much sharper than that.5:06Now, he says5:09those two levels are in your control.5:10The next level, however,5:12ma she'ein ken talmid,5:14having students is not in your control.5:16And he says,5:18Ayen sham b'Tosafot Yom Tov.5:20One of the commentaries,5:21early commentaries on the Mishnayot,5:23is known as the Tosafot Yom Tov,5:24a really beautiful commentary.5:26And he says5:28on Pirkei Avot over there, on that5:29Mishnah, he says, Hey, you notice,5:36why does he say, 'aseh lecha rav'? I mean, excuse me, it says, why does it say, 'aseh lecha talmidim'? Why doesn't it say also make for yourself a student?5:38It says make yourself a rabbi,5:40buy a friend.5:41What about having students?5:42Students, you learn much more from students5:45than anybody else.5:46Like it says in Gemara5:47in Ta'anit that we just quoted, the rabbi said,5:49I learn from my students more than anybody else.5:50The logic of that is5:53when I'm studying with a study partner5:55and I go back and forth,5:56I, you know, he doesn't know as much.5:59And therefore, we could study back and forth.6:01I could say, you know, but he's going to hold me6:03to my words,6:04and he's going to sharpen me.6:05I'm going to have to teach it over to somebody else,6:08and I have that responsibility.6:10I have to know it very clear to give it over to6:12him because he's completely relying on me,6:14and he's going to ask all type of questions from me6:17because, you know, he thinks I know everything.6:19So a rabbi really,6:21and you speak to any rabbi, they'll tell you that6:22really that is very, very true.6:25From the questions that the students give6:27and they present to you,6:29you learn so much more.6:31And the question that6:33the Tosfot Yom Tov asks on the Mishnah,6:35it says,6:37עשה לך רב וקנה לך חבר, but it doesn't say anything6:39about making students.6:40And we know making students is very important.6:42So he brings a few answers over there.6:44He brings an answer from his rabbi,6:46the Maharal, who says that6:48that's not, you know, it's not something we could command you,6:51go make students,6:53because you're not supposed to be.6:54It says, שמאל דוחה וימין מקרבת. No, you shouldn't be6:57in love to be in that person, in that position,6:59that I'm going to make students7:01and I'm going to take kavod myself.7:03That's why the rabbi didn't command you.7:05He brings other answers7:06also, that's not in your control7:09if Hashem decides that you should have7:10students or not. That's in Hashem's7:13decision, but it's not something that you7:14could control,7:16right? Some people have thousands of students,7:18some people don't have.7:20But the Mishnah concludes,7:23at the third level,7:24the third statement in that Mishnah,7:26it says,7:30ווהוי דן את כל האדם לכף זכות. What does that mean?7:31Says Rav Tzadok,7:33what's the connection?7:35It seems to be talking about stages of learning.7:37Learn from a rabbi,7:39have a friend to learn with,7:40and then judge everybody favorably.7:42What's going on?7:45So he says, Rav Tzadok, נראה דזהו כלפי התלמידים. This is talking about7:47the students7:48that you're going to have.7:50It is discussing students.7:52The students are a person eventually have.7:54Meaning,7:55we find7:57the Gemara Masechet Berachot, before he, you know, he brings here in very short, but let's—8:00Say it outside. There was a nasi at the time of that specific incident in the Gemara, known as Rabban8:07Gamliel. Rabban Gamliel had a policy. His policy was that not everybody is allowed to come to the Beit Midrash to learn.8:14Students who want to learn, not everybody could enter. What was the charge?8:18The charge was there was a guard, actually, who would know who the people are.8:23He says if a person wants to learn, we have to see, is he really fit to learn?8:29If his, the Gemara's words, if tocho lo kebaro, if his inside is not like his outside.8:35On the outside, a lot of people could look like tzaddikim or look like they're interested to grow.8:40But on the inside, are they really fit to grow?8:43And therefore, he put a special guard by the entrance of the Beit Midrash,8:47and he would not let anybody who he felt didn't qualify or wasn't fit to learn.8:52And therefore, the amount of students that learned while Rabban Gamliel was the nasi,8:57while Rabban Gamliel was in charge, was the head of the community, was very, very limited,9:04because most people did not qualify.9:06There was an incident, and they had to replace Rabban Gamliel with another nasi, and that was Rabbi Elazar ben Azariah.9:12Now that's Pesach coming up, when it says Rabbi Elazar ben Azariah says,9:16you know, I feel like I'm, you know, I'm like 70 years old, and we know he wasn't really 70 years old.9:20So in that over there, what happened when he took over, it says in the Gemara that when he took over,9:28then they removed that guard, and they said, Whoever wants to learn, come in, don't worry about it.9:31And the place filled up. The place filled up.9:35There were no rooms. They had to add benches, and they had to add, according to the Gemara, they had to add 300 benches.9:40People were, you know, piling up to learn Torah.9:44So it says of tzaddok, clearly from the Gemara we know, seems that that way, that system was better,9:52that it's open up to everybody.9:55That when it says,9:59הוו דן כל אדם לכף זכות, the Tanna is talking to the rabbis of how they should view their students.10:08Not like Rabban Gamliel who says10:10that if your inside is not like your outside,10:13if you're not really a tzaddik through and through, don't come into10:17the midrash. No, the Tanna is coming to negate that opinion.10:21Judge everybody favorably. Even if the guy doesn't look like he's such a tzaddik, it's okay.10:25Let him come in.10:30Because having students is not in your control.10:34That's not in your control10:34if people come to your class or not. You could try, you could advertise,10:38you could try to pull people,10:41but it's not so much in control if people are going to come or not,10:44or they're going to stay.10:46So therefore, there's no—you can't warn, you can't command.10:49The Tanna cannot say, Go ahead and make, even though—you're going to tell me what it says10:54in the beginning of10:57Pirkei Avot, והעמידו תלמידים הרבה, and the Tosafot Yom Tov brings that.11:00He says, Look, there's a command to make a lot of students.11:02So the explanation is that those over there, in general, to make students,11:05but to have for you specific students,11:09you don't have that command to go ahead and make specific students.11:13If you see that there's no people that are learning Torah,11:15of course you should go and try to make effort that people should learn Torah.11:19In any case, we come back over here.11:21It says, you don't have a command for you on your students.11:29This happens on its own.11:30If you zocheh that you learn from your rabbis,11:33if you zocheh that you learn from people, from your11:37rabbis—excuse me,11:39not you zocheh—if you make the effort that you learn from rabbis,11:42and if you make the effort to have11:44chavruta and to always run ideas,11:46don't just rely on your opinion.11:48Run ideas by chaverim and see,11:49am I right? Am I doing it right? Am I not doing it right?11:51Then you zocheh, on your own,11:53that Hashem sends you12:00talmidim. And corresponding to what Shekeneset HaGedolah said,12:05that12:06Shekeneset HaGedolah warned—that's the first Mishnah12:11in Pirkei Avot—העמידו תלמידים הרבה. Make a lot of students.12:12He came and he said in his own way,12:14he says, And you should judge everybody favorably.12:19Degam ken al yedei zeh yihyu harbeh, because when you judge them favorably,12:22and yes, every person has a little bit of a fault.12:26You know, sometimes you hear people12:27and they say, Ah, these yeshiva bachurim, look at him.12:29He sleeps too much.12:31He doesn't wake up to Shacharit on time.12:33He's bumming out.12:34Look, I see him during the break12:36and he's doing this and that.12:38Yeah, yeah, yeah, we all know their problems.12:40Everybody has problems.12:41Dan12:43l'kaf zechut. Be patient.12:45It's bezrat Hashem, you'll see great things coming out of these people.12:48Nobody starts out as an angel.12:50You have to be dan12:51l'kaf zechut. And even people that are not in yeshiva necessarily,12:54people that come to class and you say,12:55That guy's coming to class.12:56You know what he does at work,12:57you know how he is at home.12:58Yes, yes, yes, yes,13:00we know there are problems.13:01Everybody has problems.13:01We all have problems.13:03Some are worse, you're right.13:04Some of our problems might not be so bad as that guy,13:06but judge him favorably.13:08You'll see eventually there's potential,13:11and that's what he's saying over here.13:12Meaning, there's Rabbi13:15Yehoshua ben Perachya, haya yotzet mirchobotav13:19boto talmid. Meaning, there's Rabbi13:21Yehoshua ben Perachya. The Gemara tells us about that13:23oto talmid. Some say it was Yeshu that, you13:25know, he went off the derech,13:26and the Gemara says13:29in Masechet Berachot over there13:31that basically it's based on a pasuk,13:33the Gemara bases on a pasuk,13:35that there's a prayer, basically,13:37that rabbis are praying that13:38they hope that their students13:40don't come out to be13:43like the students of13:44Rabbi Yehoshua ben Perachya who went off the derech13:46and caused tremendous chilul Hashem.13:49So even having students13:50has its own responsibilities13:52and own risks, if you want to say.13:55And therefore he says like this,13:59You might have thought to say,14:00look, if you... Create too many students,14:02and some of your students14:03will come out to be bad,14:05like the way we find by,14:07you know, like some of these Tanaim,14:09they had some students14:10that went off the derech,14:11and they caused tremendous chilul Hashem.14:13So you might have thought to say,14:15you know14:15what, why do I need14:16this headache? Let me learn my Torah.14:17I don't need any students.14:19Comes the pircha, amar14:22בלשון זה, לומר שאין לחוש לכך. That's why the Tanna comes and says,14:27בפרקי אבות, והדן את כל האדם לכף זכות. Judge them favorably.14:28You don't have to worry about this.14:32ואתה ודן. שכל מעשיו סתומים. You judge everybody favorably.14:34You just teach your Torah14:35l'shem Shamayim,14:39ובהדי כבשא דרחמנא למה לי. And if something eventually14:40in the long term14:41this guy goes off or whatever,14:43that's not your arena.14:46You did what you can14:47to try to put the student on the right path,14:49and if he chooses to go14:50wherever he wants to go,14:52that's between him and Hashem,14:54HaKadosh Baruch Hu,14:55and that's the mysteries of God,14:56and you should not get involved.14:58There's still14:59another—what we just did15:00basically, we just did two paragraphs.15:02Believe it or15:02not, even15:03actually we just did only one paragraph.15:05We still have15:06two, three, four, five, six,15:09about six or seven more paragraphs left,15:11and already I see it's 15 minutes.15:12We're going to call this part one,15:14בעזרת השם, and we go to part two15:15in a new recording.