Torah · MussarMussar184. Stages in Learning TorahTzidkat HaTzadikPart 184Rabbi Uri Nahum · March 20, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0021:43Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:01Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot kuf peh dalet, 184. Today's piece is an entire page in0:08Tzidkat HaTzadik. It might take us two recordings. We'll see what we could do.0:12We'll start, be'ezrat Hashem, try to squeeze it into one. Here we go.0:16Hatchala ledivrei Torah hu0:18hacheshek. So if you were listening till now, if you're following us till now,0:22in the previous letter, previous ot, and in the next coming up letters, this one and a few of them,0:28we're going to be discussing the subject of Talmud Torah.0:31So now he's talking about the concept of learning, a person getting into learning, how does it work,0:39basically the stages of a person's involvement in learning Torah.0:44Let's begin. Hatchala ledivrei Torah hu0:47hacheshek. The beginning of a person entering or getting involved in learning Torah is a desire,0:57כמו שנאמר, כי אם בתורת ה' חפצו. Pasuk says in Tehillim, his chefetz, his desire, is in the Torah of Hashem.1:03It's got to be a desire. It's got to be an interest.1:06Nobody is coming into getting into learning because he has to, because it's an interest.1:10You go to a class, you hear an inspiring idea,1:14but after a person gets involved,1:18ואז נקרא תורת ה'. But in the beginning, it's still not your1:20Torah. It's still called the Torah of Hashem,1:22כמו שאמרו בעבודה זרה. Like it says in Gemara, Avodah Zarah. In that same perek, it begins by saying,1:30כי בתורת ה' חפצו, תורתו יהגה יומם ולילה. Immediately afterwards, it turns from Torat Hashem to his own Torah.1:36Chazal say that in the beginning it's called Torat Hashem,1:38but afterwards it becomes his own Torah.1:41And that's what he says over here. When does that happen?1:46ואחר כך ההשגה שנקרא תורתו יהגה. But then afterwards, when a person gets it, when a person understands it,1:51it's not just a desire, but he's grasping, he's understanding clear what the concepts are,1:58then it becomes his own Torah.2:01והחשק גדול יותר. And then the desire is even more.2:04The desire to want to learn is even greater.2:13כמו ששמעתי על פסוק טוב שם משמן טוב, ועל מה חזל גדולה שמושה יותר מלימודה. He says he heard, I'm not sure exactly what he heard,2:16but he heard some sort of explanation on the2:19pasuk that a good name is better than good oil,2:22and Chazal say that— Serving the Torah, serving the2:27talmidei chachamim, which is serving the Torah, is greater than the actual learning of the Torah.2:31I'm not sure exactly what he heard,2:32but it seems to be that he's connecting it to these two stages of learning:2:37the beginner stage, and later on, where a person accomplishes2:41and he understands and he becomes...2:45However, the beginning is a person is with excitement.2:52A person in the beginning, everything is—when a person is young,2:56we all know, desire is very, very strong.2:59Not only just for physical things,3:00but anything in the beginning is always super exciting,3:04very, very excited to do it.3:09And that's what Chazal say in Masechet Shabbat,3:12that the childhood is basically the beauty of the flower,3:16meaning to say—he tells you, don't have to say—he says,3:22Ayen sham, shevach ha-yaldut. Look over there how Chazal speak and praise the younger days,3:28the young days, the good young days.3:34And how Chazal tell us, you know, what unfortunately happens as we get older3:39and, you know, we lose desire.3:42You ever notice that, you know, they call3:44graggy? People get older, they become less interested in everything,3:48because that's how life is. That's how we are created.3:51So that's what he says: the beginning of the Torah is always exciting.3:54The person who is a newcomer to the religion is always super excited.3:58Then you get older, okay, we've been there, done that, you know.4:03However, don't think that the older you get,4:06it's like, you know, going downhill. That's not true.4:09We do find that Chazal speak very positively also about aging in Talmud Torah.4:16In fact, Ziknei Talmidei Chachamim, like it says over here, brings from4:22Masechet Kinnim, perek gimmel, halachah vav. Ziknei Talmidei Chachamim—Chazal tell us the elders, the Talmidei Chachamim that are older, the older they get...4:27The wiser they become,4:30v'chein b'kama mekomot, huzekenim. And like we find in a few places, he just lists them,4:33if you want to look them up, you can look them up. For example,4:36Midrash in Shemot Rabbah and Vayikra Rabbah,4:39and in Gemara Masechet Ta'anit as well.4:41Like it says over there,4:46Harbeh lamadti me'rabotai, u'me'talmidai yoter mikulam. And from my students more than everybody.4:48What does that mean, from my students more than everybody?4:51So, it means that a person already became a rabbi in his older age,4:54but also from my students, because by the students—4:58excuse me,5:00u'me'rabotai hainu hischalat haheshek, and rabotai, you know, the Gemara— okay,5:03I'm sorry, let me pause for a second.5:06Let me clarify the Gemara.5:07I'm speaking about the Gemara as if it's a known Gemara.5:10Let me say the Gemara.5:12The Gemara says,5:15Harbeh lamadti me'rabotai. I've learned a lot from my rabbis.5:21V'yoter me'chaverai, but I learned more from my friends.5:24U'me'talmidai yoter mikulam, but from my students I learned more than anybody else.5:27So there are three stages that the rabbi is mentioning over there5:30of how much he learned.5:32The first stage is he learned a lot from his rabbis.5:35Baruch Hashem, he was blessed with good rabbis.5:37But he says, but from my friends5:38I learned even more than I learned from my rabbis.5:40This is what we call5:44pilpulei5:45chaverim. It's when friends discuss something,5:48yachabruta. You learn much more from5:48your chavruta than you learn from the rabbi that you hear his class5:50for one hour and you're sitting with5:52the chavruta for a bunch of hours every day.5:54And then when you get to the stage of teaching Torah,5:58then he says, I learned even more than that6:00from my own students,6:01because your students sharpen you.6:03So it comes out that when I learn from my rabbis,6:06that's the beginning stage.6:08That's when a person is a beginner.6:10And that's what he says over here,6:13me'rabotai hainu hatchala v'heshek. From my rabbis means6:14not just, yes, in the actual stage6:17that a person actually goes through,6:19but it means in the beginning6:20when a person enters the world of Torah,6:24it starts with excitement,6:26and then it goes on and on6:28as you continue.6:29So again, this is what he's trying to say from beforehand,6:32is that there's a praise to getting older,6:35is that you become wiser and wiser.6:39V'achar pei torah, talmud k'rato. Now we said you start out,6:41the Torah starts out by being called6:45Torat Hashem. After a person's rabbi— Passes away,6:48which means his source of,6:50you know, of his primary source actually6:53of learning,6:54then the Torah becomes his own Torah.6:56Why?6:58Because now you get to the next stage.7:00You see, throughout life7:02we're always going through different stages.7:03As a learner,7:05we have rabbis to teach us.7:07Then you get to the stage where you yourself7:10become the distributor.7:12Then you actually learn,7:15you7:16toil hard so you can give it over to others.7:21אז המוסיף חכמה. Then you need to learn more.7:23There's one level of coming to class and learning.7:26Another level is that7:28if you yourself have to prepare a7:30class to give it over.7:33רק שהשגה הוא מהשם יתברך. But to be able to grasp the ideas7:35and to be able to get it,7:36actually that's a gift from Hashem.7:41כי ה' יתן חכמה, because wisdom is given from Hashem,7:43like the pasuk says.7:44And therefore, for a person to be able to grasp,7:47and he's on that level to grasp,7:48be able to give it to students,7:49that's a gift from Hashem.7:52And it says it,7:56Chazal tell us, הכל בידי שמים חוץ מיראת שמים. Everything is in the hands of7:58Shamayim except for7:58yirat Shamayim. Wisdom.8:01This from HaKadosh Baruch Hu. He explains this, the following two lines are a little bit Kabbalam; only reading it because it's mentioned here. I don't want to skip it.8:08He explains what that means:8:14Why is your Atzamayim considered in the control of a human being as opposed to everything else?8:21Because your Atzamayim represents the female.8:24The female is connected to Olam Hazeh, which is connected to det aruta d'letata, which means the inspiration or the effort that a person has to do here in this world,8:34and that is the desire.8:36The desire and the ratzon, that's all in the hands of the person.8:46However, Hashem makes it from His Torah; He turns it into the Torah of the8:56person. The pasuk says, Shegam zeh shelo, that what the pasuk is telling us is that this Torah becomes also yours,9:07and you become the person who now comes up with chiddushim, who now brings in novel new ideas to the Torah.9:18That's a very high level.9:22Similar to what Chazal say: In the future, the tzaddikim will be called the name of Hashem.9:27What does that mean,9:28in the future the tzaddikim will be called the name of Hashem?9:30This beautiful explanation:9:34Ki haTorah kulah shemotav shel HaKadosh Baruch Hu, because all of the Torah is the names of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.9:38And when you are mechadesh chiddushim in the Torah and you become the source of that9:43chiddush, you are basically—you know, somebody says, Wow, that's a beautiful idea. Where'd you hear it from?9:46You know, it's brought down in the sefer, or this rabbi said it.9:50This rabbi is called on the name. Right,9:53this rabbi is called on that piece of Torah.9:54He's known for this chidush, and because he's known for this chidush, he's really, in a way, called the name of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.10:03V'zehu mitzat Torat Hashem. That's because it's also the Torah of Hashem.10:08V'gam shemot haanashim Yisrael ken noda. We also know that the Torah, besides being also the name of10:13Hashem—the whole Torah, Chazal tell us, it's all the names of10:16Hashem—we also know that the Torah also the names of the Jewish people,10:19as Chazal tell us, that Yisrael, the word Yisrael is an acronym,10:25tzrufei teivot of10:34Yesh Shishim Ribo Otiot LaTorah, as he brings over here.10:37V'zehu tzad Torato,10:39and that comes from the10:40Torah. So on one hand, we have the Torah. We know the famous10:45Chazal tells us, Kudsha Brich Hu v'Orayta v'Yisrael chad hu. Hashem,10:49the Torah, and the Jewish people are all one.10:52On one hand, the Jewish people have a connection to the Torah,10:56and on another hand, the Torah is connected really to HaKadosh Baruch Hu,11:00and that's the two levels.11:01The first level is called Torat Hashem.11:03The second level, when a person, when the tzaddikim or11:08the talmid chacham is osek baTorah and it becomes his Torah, that's called11:12Torato, and that's the flip side, or the other side of Torat Hashem.11:20V'lakach bitichat Sefer Shemot, Sefer Matan Torah, v'eleh shemot Bnei Yisrael. And now you can understand why Sefer Shemot, which has in it the parashat Yitro,11:26which talks about the giving of the Torah to the Jewish people,11:29how does the book begin?11:31It begins with the names of the Jewish people, because it's all one11:33and the same. Question: Ma taam ki ptichat kol sefer uparashah hu tzurta dishmata shel oto sefer?11:38As you heard, and it's brought down actually in sefarim, we've heard this also,11:42is that the beginning of every sefer and the beginning of every11:45parashah is actually the summary or encompasses in it the entire theme of the entire sefer.11:52So the beginning of Sefer Bereishit, that first pasuk11:56encompasses in it the entire Sefer11:58Bereishit. And so too, the first pasuk of Sefer Shemot encompasses in it the entire sefer.12:03You're going to say, what in the world do the names of the Jewish people have to do12:07with the entire story of— Of Sefer Shemot,12:12the main thing is giving the Torah, right?12:14And the Mishkan is really just another level of Torah that we kind of lost by12:19Chet HaEgel, and we had to bring back through the Mishkan.12:21So what I'm telling you is that the Jewish people are really,12:24the names of the Jewish people are also the part of the Torah.12:27That is when it becomes12:31Torato. Now, he says,12:38V'kach kriat shem haSefer Shemot al shem shemot Bnei Yisrael, shehu kelalut haTorah, ki hashem hu yesod hadavar. Basically, it's saying the same exact thing that we just said now.12:41Next thing he says,12:45V'lekach adam harishon kara shemot, v'malachim lo yad'u. And we find also Chazal tell us12:47that Adam HaRishon gave names to all parts of the creation, like animals and things.12:52And angels didn't know how to do that. Like Chazal tell us,12:57Malachim ein lahem shem. Chazal tell us that angels don't really have a name.13:00What do you mean? What about13:02Gavriel, Rafael? No, no, no, let me explain.13:05D'lefi shlichutam nikra, Chazal explain. The name of an angel is only given based upon his doing.13:08So let's say you take a person, you don't really know his name,13:11but you know he's your mailman.13:13Good, he's your mailman.13:15A few years later, you find him that he becomes now the police officer that's involved,13:23that's patrolling your neighborhood.13:24So now he's a police officer.13:27You don't know his name,13:28and his name is not so important because he's a serviceman.13:30He works for the city.13:32One time he's a mailman, one time he's a police officer,13:35and next time he'll be a fire guard.13:37It doesn't make a difference.13:39But he's called on what he's doing.13:43The angels have the same way.13:45Angels, Rafael is not because that's his name.13:47Rafael is because he's healing,13:50so he's given the title of13:59Rafael. What does this mean, that Adam HaRishon gave names?14:04So he says that it used to be, he says it's brought down in Sefarim, old Sefarim, is that the old custom was that14:12masters would call their servants names.14:14They would give them a name.14:15Why?14:15To show that you have no power within yourself.14:19I give you a title.14:20I describe what kind of person you are,14:22meaning that I have complete rulership all over you.14:31And how much do the angels... How much could they grasp from this world?14:39Well, angels don't have a choice,14:42and therefore, because as much as the fact that they don't have a choice,14:45that's also in how much they grasp in creation.14:53When weisha amar, Hashem vidalek, ... for the angels, it doesn't make sense that there should be a difference between oil and between vinegar.15:02Why? Because, I mean, Hashem is the Creator of the whole world.15:05Hashem controls everything.15:06So what's the difference what I call it?15:08We today cannot use vinegar to light;15:12we need to use oil.15:13So for us, it makes a difference if it's called oil or vinegar.15:15For angels, they couldn't give names because angels have such a clarity in how the world runs.15:22For them, it makes no difference if it's oil or if it's vinegar.15:26I mean, vinegar doesn't light.15:28Well, who gave the power? For them, oil also doesn't light.15:30Oil only lights because Hashem said so.15:33So for them also, the oil and the vinegar is exactly the same.15:37Just Hashem decided this should work this way.15:39But they have such clarity.15:40That's why they can understand humans, and they can't give them really a name.15:49Only person who can understand and perceive and see the difference in creation between different items is15:57a human, because he has a choice, and therefore with that.16:00That freedom of choice, that he's able to choose between believing and knowing that16:07Hashem runs the world and not, he's able to perceive the nature of each item.16:17It's because we as human beings, Hashem has given us the ability to choose.16:22Now, the ability to choose is really a blindside, believe it or not.16:25It's a weakness, that ability to choose, if you think about it,16:29because ability to choose means I have another choice.16:32What does that mean, I have another choice?16:34Imagine a person is married.16:36A person is married, we all could agree that this is the most wonderful gift that Hashem16:38has given to a human being.16:40A person is married, he has a wife, they're dedicated to each other, and they really have16:43true love.16:44I'm not talking about marriages that people complain about their wives. I'm talking about16:46people that really have true unity between each other.16:49To other people, people goyim and secular people that don't understand16:54the beauty of marriage, they look at a person who's married and say, Oh, poor guy, he's17:01locked in, man. Yo, bro, this guy is locked up. He's in jail. He has no choice. He's stuck,17:09right?17:10That's what, he's stuck. He has no choice.17:12What do you mean?17:12That's what you chose, to have no choice.17:14That's the most wonderful thing.17:16The fact that a person can be married and feel that he has a choice is a weakness. It's17:22a17:22problem. It's not a good thing. It's a problem that you feel that you have a choice.17:26So you clearly don't have a true concept of the goodness of this world.17:31And that's what we're saying. The same thing is happening also with this person, or this17:36person called the human being, that has a choice in comparison to the angels.17:40The angels look at us and say, Yo, man, this guy's got it all messed up.17:44He thinks that there's a difference between oil and vinegar.17:51That's why he gives them a different name.17:54So the ability to give names is because we see a difference in their capability.18:00And the fact that we can see a difference in their capability, it's because we give a certain18:05amount of power to the item itself, and that's why we give it a different name.18:14So that's what he's saying over here, that Adam HaRishon was able to give names because18:19of that ability to see the difference in their power.18:23So now he says,18:29That's why when a person first comes to learn Torah, it's because of his choice.18:34That's the idea.18:35That's why the sefer, when it talks about Sefer Torah, of the giving of the Torah, it begins with18:41Elish,18:42... It's the ability to give names.18:44It's the ability to see something different.18:45A guy who comes to learn Torah, it's because he thinks he's choosing, because I could have18:51went to a club, I could have watched the football game, I could have been on my phone, I could18:55have relaxed, but I'm choosing to come and learn.18:58I could have went to a life of working, but I'm choosing to sit and learn.19:02So it's because he feels that he's choosing, right?19:05It's actually, it's a blindside, like we said.19:07But HaKadosh Baruch Hu אומר להיפך. בתחילה תורת ה' ... says that it's the opposite.19:10In the beginning it's called19:20תורת ה'. ... קודם ברכה. And like we find the same idea when it talks about saying a19:25beracha. It says in the pasuk, Gemara19:27says berachot, it says before you eat, the pasuk says, לה' הארץ ומלואה. Before you eat and before19:34you make a beracha, everything belongs to19:37Hashem. Why?19:40... because a person thinks, hey, because I have the freedom to choose, this is not mine, this19:46really belongs to19:48Hashem, ואחר ברכה. And then the Gemara says, but after you make the beracha, it becomes yours.19:52And the pasuk says, וְאָסַפְתָּ דְגָנֶךָ. What does that mean, after the19:56beracha? Says Rav Tzadok, you know what it means? After you make a beracha, it becomes yours.20:01שמכיר שהכול שלו. It's not that you said the beracha and it's like, oh, you know, you paid for it.20:05No.20:06After the beracha, if you said the beracha and you truly understand what a beracha is,20:10which means a recognition, Baruch Atah Hashem, בורא פרי האדמה, that this whole world is yours. Then, oh, okay. Then you have20:17permission to eat20:19because you came to that recognition that everything belongs to20:22Hashem. V'chen kan. And so too comes to the Torah as well.20:25In the beginning, you have to have a recognition that it's all20:28Torat Hashem. V'chen, as nikra Torato, but then after you learn and you recognize that it's not a choice I'm giving to Hashem, but it's really20:36everything is part of Hashem, then becomes your own Torah.20:45And the tzaddikim themselves are called the names of Hashem, which is from the Torah, because20:50that's what we're saying. It's all one and the same.20:52The shemot of Hashem is the Torah. It's also the shemot of the tzaddikim, and that's why20:57the zekenim, the zikneitem, the chachamim, are more praised because they actually attain21:02that level of the shemot of the Torah.21:11However, being that human beings are praised for the ability to choose, so therefore, yes,21:17that's why we find also that there's a praise for people who are younger.21:22A very deep concept, Rabbeinu, we tried to explain by just translating, but really21:27what he's saying is levels in understanding Torah, and then he just connects it to different21:33concepts, and, zat Hashem, hopefully we cleared it up as much as possible.21:38It was a little bit longer, but we squeezed it into one recording.