Torah · MussarMussar176. A New Shul and Bet MidrashTzidkat HaTzadikPart 176Rabbi Uri Nahum · February 22, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0021:44Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzaddik, אות קוף עין וav, 176.0:05Very interesting thing, and it's connected to the times.0:08We're recording this now. We just got into the month of Adar, Mishenichnas Adar,0:15marbim b'simcha. I'll tell you a nice piece from the Or Gedalyahu before we talk about this piece,0:19just to show you that the connection of what we're learning,0:23how it's connecting with the season of when we're learning it.0:26Now you might hear this on the recording much later on,0:29but those who are following and hearing it fresh, you'll see the connection,0:34and why it's important to see that it connects with the times.0:37There's a Chasam Sofer that says that whenever you're learning something,0:43and you're going on a, you know, either you're learning on a certain schedule,0:47like let's say a daf yomi or0:49parashat hashavua, and then all of a sudden you come across a subject0:52in a different area that's connected to another area where you're learning.0:57Like for example, let's say you're learning something in your daf yomi,1:00and all of a sudden you come across a pasuk that happens to be that week's1:05parasha, and even more so if the daf is on Shabbat and that's what you're reading that day in Shabbat.1:10In our case, we're learning something and it comes up with the season1:13because now we're in the month of Adar.1:16So then it's beautiful.1:17It's a siman from Shamayim that they're learning your Torah also,1:22that they like what you're learning as well,1:25and what you're learning is l'shem Shamayim.1:26It's a beautiful idea from the Chasam Sofer.1:29So this is why I would like to begin with the intro1:32that Rav Tzadok doesn't say over here, but it's a nice intro.1:35Mishenichnas Adar marbim b'simcha, it's a Mishnah, Masechet1:37Ta'anit, that when Adar, the month of Adar, comes in, we have to increase happiness.1:41And really, it leaves this statement in the Mishnah, leaves us hanging1:44because it doesn't tell us. How and what we need to do in order to increase1:51simcha. Now, the same Mishnah says,1:56Mishenichnas Av, mema'atin b'simcha. When the month of Av comes in, we have to minimize1:59simcha, and there we have2:01halachot. For example, a person cannot build a house of wedding,2:07beit chatanut libno. Cannot prepare things that have to do with wedding.2:09And the Gemara talks about what he is allowed to do, what he is not allowed to do in the nine days of2:15Av. But Mishnah leaves us hanging for the month of Adar.2:18How do you increase2:20simcha? So the Ohr Gedalyahu says a beautiful idea,2:23and he says, Well, the fact that the Mishnah compared these two pieces to each other by saying,2:29Look, just like when Av comes in, we minimize2:32simcha, and when Adar comes in, we increase2:34simcha, so it must be the simcha here is for the same reason on both ends.2:42Meaning, why do we decrease simcha in the month of2:46Av? Because Beit HaMikdash was destroyed.2:49So when it talks about in Adar that we have to increase2:54simcha, must be has to do with the building of the2:58Beit HaMikdash. In fact, in the month of Adar is the time when we prepare ourselves for the building,3:03because in the month of Adar we have to give machatzit hashekel, zecher3:08to what they did in Beit HaMikdash to prepare ourselves to bring the korbanot,3:10which is the main part of the Beit HaMikdash, the service of the Beit HaMikdash, the korbanot.3:15In the month of Adar we start to read the parashiyot of Terumah, Tetzaveh,3:23Ki Tisa, Vayakhel, Pekudei. These are the parashiyot that deal with the building of the Mishkan.3:26In the month of Adar we have the holiday of Purim, which was, after the holiday of Purim,3:35the Jewish people got to rebuild, to continue rebuilding the second3:40Beit HaMikdash. This is the month of Adar. In fact, it's hinted in the word Adar: Aleph, dar.3:44Aleph referring to Hashem, Elokim; dar comes to live with us.3:48So the month of Adar, the increasing of happiness in the month of Adar3:54is because we are getting ready to build3:58Beit HaMikdash. Now, in this piece, we talk about— Building a shul or beit midrash,4:04which is, you know, the subject at hand, the mevin yavin.4:09So, because it's also connected to the month of Adar, it's a beautiful idea to see that4:17Mash comes in the right time, and, Baruch Hashem, ... it's coming out in the right time.4:22They like what we're learning in4:24Shamayim. So he said, and now, what does building a shul have to do with a beit midrash?4:27Chazal tell us that the shuls and the beit midrashot are considered a mikdash4:33me'at, a miniature Beit HaMikdash.4:36So let's see what he says over here.4:44Keshe bonim o meyasedim beit knesset o beit midrash chadash, b'eizeh makom, when people are building or establishing a new shul or a new beit midrash,4:50wherever it may be,4:55na'aseh kodem sham mechiyat Amalek b'oto makom. That place where they're doing it, first has to be that they're wiping out the memory of Amalek in that place.5:02Why?5:03Because we find that this is an important step before the building of Beit HaMikdash.5:12Detecheifah acham mechiyat Amalek, bakedushat hamakom. We find that right after we wipe out Amalek, the kedushah of a makom is established.5:21Kemo she'amru zal, like Chazal tell us, shalosh mitzvot nitztavu bichnisatan laaretz, that the Jewish people were commanded three commands when they entered5:31Eretz Yisrael. What are they?5:32Appointing a king,5:34that's number one.5:35Number two is mechiyat Amalek, erasing Amalek.5:38Ve'achar kach, then afterwards, binyan Beit HaMikdash, the building of the Beit HaMikdash.5:43So you see that a catalyst to the building of Beit HaMikdash is erasing Amalek.5:49So it works backwards. If we're establishing a new beit midrash...5:54If we're setting up a new Beit HaMidrash,5:56kavachomer also building, not kavachomer, but also building a new Beit HaMidrash, that is because there was a mechiyat Amalek first.6:05He says also,6:09lachen kavu Chazal berek Bnei Ayir mikedushat Beit HaKnesset, Beit HaMidrash. That's why6:11in Masechet Megillah, this is why6:13the Gemarot that deal with the kedushah of the Beit HaMidrash and Beit6:18HaKnesset, there's halachot. If you look up in Shulchan Aruch,6:21there's halachot beginning, I believe, kuf nun aleph,6:26siman kuf nun aleph in Shulchan Aruch,6:29and a few simanim over there6:30that deal with how to treat, how a person should conduct himself in the shul,6:35the things that have kedushah in the shul itself,6:38kuf nun gimmel, that a person cannot eat in the shul.6:41There's all of these6:43halachot kedushah. Where's the Gemara of all these6:46halachot? It's found in Masechet Megillah,6:49perek Bnei Ayir. Why was it set up in Masechet Megillah?6:50What does it have to do with the reading of Megillah?6:52And the answer is because in the first perek, what do we read about?6:56We read about the story of the Megillah.6:58And since we read about the story of the Megillah, what is the story of the Megillah?7:01The story tells us about erasing Amalek, who is Haman.7:06Haman came from Amalek.7:07So that's why in the same Gemara, after we erase Amalek,7:11therefore the kedushah makom comes in.7:12And yes, you guessed it right.7:14Where is the Gemara that talks about that in the future7:18all the shuls will be moved to Eretz Yisrael,7:20the holiness of the shuls that we have will all be moved and transferred to Eretz Yisrael?7:27Where is that Gemara? Masechet Megillah.7:29Why?7:29He says,7:33V'kitechev lechol karnei resha'im agadea, teromamna karno tzaddik. There's a pasuk that says,7:39V'chol karnei resha'im agadea, teromamna karno tzaddik. Let's translate the pasuk.7:42All the might, although the word keren means horns, but means the might.7:46All the might of the wicked I'll cut off,7:50and the might of the righteous will be standing, will be uplifted.7:56So you see the pasuk puts it right after each other.7:58When you get rid of the—8:06The tzaddikim come out. Ve'amru zal, v'hecha mitromemet karnam? Now, what does that have to do with the building of the shul? And the answer is, Chazal tell us, where do we find, again, masechet Megillah, where do we find that the tzaddikim are able to be mitromem, that their might, their power8:18comes out?8:19Says the Gemara, where?8:28Birushalayim. D'hainu, hadeha l'matkei se'el, hi metzumemet b'makom mekudash, levad b'Eretz Yisrael. The kedusha, or the might of the Jewish people, is limited to a specific place, and that place is a holy8:35place, and that is our holy land,8:41Eretz Yisrael. V'lo bitpashtut hagorem btul. Why8:42דווקא Eretz Yisrael? Because it's not spread out throughout the whole world.8:45Because the kedusha of the Jewish people is specifically in Eretz Yisrael. That's where8:48it's going to flourish and continue,8:51not anywhere else in the world.8:52Anywhere else in the world, it has a certain limitation, like we saw in our long history.8:58Look back at our history.9:00We've had kedusha wherever we went.9:03We've had talmidei chachamim, we've had yeshivot. We've produced unbelievable people in our nation.9:08But time came and we were kicked out and we had to leave, for whatever reason it was.9:13We left that place and the kedusha stopped from those places.9:16You go now, you visit Spain. What's in Spain?9:19What was in Spain?9:21That's where all the talmidei chachamim were. Ramban, Rambam for a certain amount of time9:27also, Rabbi Shmuel HaNagid, the Rashba, the Rosh at a certain time, the Tur, all these9:33Rishonim, they all came from Spain.9:34What's Spain today?9:35Nothing.9:36Go to Germany.9:37You know what was in Germany?9:37The Rosh used to live in Germany.9:39The Maharam Rothenburg was from Germany.9:41Go, all the Rishonim, they came from Germany and France.9:44Today,9:46ma yesh shamma? I don't want to take away from any talmidei chachamim that are living there now, but obviously9:49nothing compared to what it used to be.9:52So. That's the difference between the kedushah that the Jewish people bring to outside of9:58Eretz Yisrael, as opposed to the kedushah that's in Eretz10:02Yisrael. Now, but Batei nesot and batei midrashot in kedushat Eretz10:05Yisrael. The shuls and the batei midrash of the Jewish people, wherever they may be in the world, that in10:10itself has a kedushah of Eretz Yisrael, kemo she'amru Chazal, as10:15Chazal tell us, that the shuls will eventually be transported to Eretz Yisrael and be established10:20there.10:22And the three mitzvot, which is appointing a king, then erasing Amalek, and then establishing10:28the Beit HaMikdash, are all right after each other.10:40And just like we told you that if there's a building and an establishment of a makom, of a place10:46of Torah, there must have been the eradication of10:52Amalek. So there also must be that one Jewish person will now be elevated, and neshamah of a certain10:59Jewish person will be elevated as this is happening.11:03Why? Similar to appointing a king.11:05When you appoint a king, he was a regular person, all of a sudden became somebody11:09on a very high level, like we find by the first Jewish king, Shaul11:13HaMelech. When he was chosen and selected as a king, beforehand he was just a regular person.11:17Keep in mind, he was a tremendous tzaddik. Hashem didn't choose a random guy.11:22He was a tremendous11:24tzaddik. Nobody reached11:26mishichmo u'ma'alah. That doesn't mean only in height that he was taller than everybody else.11:30Also, in his righteousness, he was head and shoulders above everybody else.11:34Let's keep that clear, about11:36Shaul HaMelech was a tremendous tzaddik, but he was not known to anybody.11:42And then Shmuel Hanavi tells him, You are the new king.11:44And when he became a king, all of a sudden he got a very special spirit.11:49There was a certain point that he was even able to prophesize.11:52And that same thing happened with David HaMelech as well.11:56He was just a shepherd boy, and all of a sudden he was elevated.12:00From that point on, when he was selected to be the new Jewish king,12:03he became the person who killed Goliath.12:06He became the top general in Shaul's army,12:08and eventually he became the ruler of the whole entire nation.12:11And all that happened because when you're appointed to be a king,12:16the nefesh is elevated.12:17And he says over here that's what happens also12:20with the establishment of a new Beit HaMikdash and Beit Knesset.12:28Now, the only difference was that when we entered Eretz Israel,12:32that all happened before erasing12:35Amalek, as we see, that first Shaul was chosen as a king,12:39and then after Shaul was chosen as a king,12:41then he was given the command to eradicate12:45Amalek. However, that was how it was.12:49But in the future, how it's going to12:51be—this is a side point a little12:52bit—but in the future, he brings over here,12:54in the future how is it going to be?12:55He says it's going to be different,12:56like the way13:00Chazal tell us, Masechet Pesachim. To understand, here over here he doesn't quote the full Gemara.13:03To understand what the Gemara is talking about,13:05the Gemara says,13:06In the zechut of three13:09rishons—that means the Torah says the word rishon in three different13:12places—in the zechut of the Jewish people13:14keeping those three rishons,13:15for example, talking about the13:18holiday, right, the rishon of the holiday of Pesach,13:20the rishon of the holiday of Sukkot,13:22all those are called rishon.13:24What it says,13:25the Jewish people will be zocheh to three things13:28are also called rishon.13:30What are these three things?13:32There. The Gemara says the following.13:35Listen to the Gemara13:36so you can see the order.13:37Pay attention to the order,13:39because that's what he's going to pick on.13:41Let's read the Gemara.13:43The Gemara says,13:46Detana d'vei Rabbi Yishmael. It was taught in the yeshiva13:48of Rabbi Yishmael: B'schar shlosha rishon,13:50in the zechut of three rishons that are mentioned.13:53Let me tell you what these rishons are.13:55The pasuk says by Korban Pesach,13:57it says,13:58Barishon, b'arba'asar yom lachodesh,14:01on the first,14:02on the fourteenth day of the month.14:05Ba'erev, talking about, so not evening, in motza, so it's Pesach.14:07Also says rishon14:09by the mitzvah of lulav,14:11as it says,14:11U'lekachtem lachem14:19bayom harishon, pri etz hadar, kapot temarim, v'anaf etz avot, v'arvei nachal. On the first day14:20you shall take for yourself14:20the14:21arba'at haminim, the lulav,14:22etrog, and everything else.14:24And also says it by Sukkot,14:26says by Sukkot,14:27Ach b'chamishah asar yom lachodesh14:28ha'shevi'i, on the14:29fifteenth of the seventh month,14:30which is14:33Tishrei, b'ospechem et14:35תבואת הארץ, when you gather14:36the produce of the land,14:42tachogu, the Chag HaSukkot, shiv'at yamim. Bayom harishon shabbaton, bayom ha'shemini shabbaton. On the first day14:43you should cease from any work.14:44So those,14:45in the zechut of keeping14:46these three mitzvot,14:47says the14:48Gemara, zachu l'shloshah rishon.14:49The Jewish people14:50were zocheh to three14:51rishons. What are they?14:52Listen to the order.14:53Number one is14:56lehachrid zaro shel Esav, to cut off the descendants of14:59Esav, which is like mechiyat Amalek,15:02livniyat Beit HaMikdash, the building of the15:05Beit HaMikdash, v'lishmo shel Mashiach,15:07and to the name of Mashiach.15:08And then the Gemara goes on15:09to bring a proof15:12to each one of these concepts.15:14Why? Why it's called rishon15:15and everything else.15:16So now, look at the order.15:18We said first15:19to wipe out the offspring of15:22Esav, which is Amalek,15:23then15:24Beit HaMikdash, they come back to back,15:25and then the name of Mashiach,15:27which is referring to a king,15:29because Mashiach is really15:30just a descendant of15:32David HaMelech who will be the future king.15:33That's what Mashiach is,15:34of course, with much more15:35that comes with it.15:36In any case,15:37he says15:39over here, v'hashib shemosha Mashiach basof, and it counts the name of Mashiach15:42at the end,15:44as opposed to the three15:45mitzvot that the Jewish people commanded15:47when we first entered15:48Eretz Yisrael, which is first having a king,15:50then wiping out Amalek,15:52and then building15:54Beit HaMikdash. And that,15:55you see, the order is reversed.15:57It's not reversed;15:57it's just out of order15:58when it's talking about in the future.16:00So now, remember, there are three rishonim that we keep, and in that merit we get to be zocheh to get the16:08other three things that are also called rishon. What are they?16:12Pesach,16:13lulav, and Sukkot. So he says, the shmo shel Mashiach hu neged rishon16:21de-Pesach. This corresponds to the mitzvah of Pesach that's called rishon.16:28De-bNisan atidin liga'el. What's the connection? Because Mashiach is the redemption of the Jewish people, and since Nisan is16:35also what Chazal told us, in the month of Nisan we will be redeemed, that's what matches it itself.16:40Lulav veSukkah hem yachad. Now, lulav and sukkah are also called rishon; each of them called rishon.16:46They are actually connected together.16:49Number one is that these two mitzvot come16:52at the same time. The mitzvah of lulav and the mitzvah of sukkah come at the same time.16:57Why is that so? Because these two mitzvot, lulav and sukkah,17:00correspond to the other two things that are mentioned in the Gemara,17:03which is wiping out Amalek and the building of the Beit HaMikdash. And these two also come together all the time.17:09Keritat zera Amalek hu neged lulav. Now, how do these two mitzvot match the two17:15rishonim? So he says,17:18wiping out the offspring of Esav, which is Amalek, that corresponds to lulav. How is that17:23so? Chazal tell us in the Midrash, in Vayikra Rabbah, that the lulav17:29moreh al nitzuach, shows that we won. Chazal tell us that on Yom17:33Kippur it's like there was a battle between the Jewish people and the goyim.17:36We don't know who won,17:37but when we see the Jewish people walking on the Hallel of Sukkot with the lulav in their hands,17:42then we know that they won. So you see that lulav represents a17:47battle. So if there's a battle from the list of three things, where do we see a battle? The answer is fighting against Amalek.17:54Therefore, that leaves the last thing, which is sukkah.17:57Sukkah corresponds to building a Beit HaMikdash, and that fits very well,18:00because sukkah is the kedushah of a place, and the building of Beit HaMikdash is also kedushah of a place.18:06And he says it over here for a different reason:18:08Uvinyan Beit HaMikdash, and the building of Beit HaMikdash,18:12we know that Sukkat Shalom, ufros aleinu sukkat shlomecha, referring to Beit HaMikdash,18:17spread upon us the sukkah of peace. That is the Beit HaMikdash.18:25Ulolam mechiyat Amalek kodemet, and all the time between these two,18:28building the Beit HaMikdash and erasing Amalek, mechiyat Amalek always comes first.18:33Ukedushat hamakom lo paskah. This is why we find, the Chazal tell us, and that's how it's18:39nifsak halachah, although it's a machloket Tana'im, that their original kedushah of Eretz Yisrael, when the Jewish people walked in with18:45Yehoshua, that kedushah—and specifically we talk about when Shlomo built the Beit18:49HaMikdash—what happened when the Beit HaMikdash got destroyed? What happens to the kedushah in Har HaBayit,18:55over there in that area? What happened to that?18:57So we hold that kedushah never stopped.19:01The kedushah rishonah kedushah l'sha'atah v'kedushah l'atid lavo, words in the Gemara. The kedushah of the Beit HaMikdash,19:05it was kadosh for the time when the Beit HaMikdash was there, and the kedushah remained there even after the Beit HaMikdash was destroyed.19:11Af al pi she'ein shomemim, as Chazal tell us. Guess where? In19:15Masechet Megillah. That even when the Beit HaMikdash was destroyed, the place remained in its kedushah.19:21Ma she'ein ken, however, Malchut Beit David is not like that.19:24Paskah lefi sha'ah. We see there was an interruption in the kingdom of David.19:29We don't see today kings. What happened? And the answer is, there's an interruption.19:34We'll come back in the times of Mashiach, because that Mashiach will be the descendant of David HaMelech. Why is that so?19:39Lefi shehayta אז kodemet mechiyat Amalek. You know why?19:42Because the appointment of a king back then was done before the eradication of19:48Amalek. So, binyan was before the eradication of Amalek, so therefore19:53it never remained forever, as opposed to the kedushat hamakom of the Beit HaMikdash,19:59which took place after the eradication of Amalek, that remained forever and ever.20:06But however, in the future, shemot Mashiach, ein lo hefsek lefishi, ba'achar kach, we find that Mashiach is listed at the end,20:14which represents the kingdom of the Jewish people led by Mashiach.20:19He is listed at the end, which means that that will have no more interruption.20:23Mashiach and all of his offspring will be kings forever and ever.20:32So too, also, let's connect it back. When the building of a Beit Midrash20:39or a shul is happening, that person who is elevated also20:46should be20:49golah. So too, when we build a shul in20:57galut. So too, if the building comes before the hitnasut of the person,21:05so that means the kedushat of the person who is elevated comes afterwards,21:10then it means that he will not have a hefsek either; it will continue as one.21:15Again, connecting the beautiful three pieces together,21:19I could definitely sit and talk a little bit more,21:21but let you do your own homework of how practical does it become.21:26What is Mechiyat Amalek in our days, that we need that before the building of the shul?21:31We'll just give you a quick idea, a quick21:33remez. We know that Amalek represents cooling down and creating doubts.21:39That is something that has to be eradicated before establishing a Beit Midrash.