Torah · MussarMussar175. Be Very Careful Not to Cause Pain to OthersTzidkat HaTzadikPart 175Rabbi Uri Nahum · February 19, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0012:47Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkas haTzadik, ot kuf ayin hei. Another beautiful piece, as usual.0:08175. Tzarich lizaher min0:13ligrom tzaar leshum beriyah, afilu ltzorech mitzvah. A person has to be very, very careful not to cause pain to any creature.0:20As he's going to say later on, especially tzaddikim, but anybody. You cannot cause pain to0:25anybody, even when you're doing it for the sake of a0:28mitzvah. What do you have to do a mitzvah? What does that mean? He says, yeah, you have to be careful.0:33Kemo she'amru, like the pasuk says, like it says in the Gemara, excuse me,0:41Al kol lochatzav, afilu gabai tzedakah. The pasuk says, al kol lachatzav, on all those who put pressure, even gabai tzedakah, who put pressure0:47on people to do mitzvah, to give tzedakah, that's also, you have to be careful not to cause that pain.0:52You got to be careful, especially a side point. Sometimes people try to collect0:56tzedakah, you can put people under pressure that they don't have, and then they can feel a lot of pressure.0:59That's not a good thing. You have to be very careful with it. You suggest, you can ask,1:04you try to convince. If they're giving anyway, you got to be careful not to put too much pressure1:08that they shouldn't give what they cannot do. Now, look at this amazing thing that he brings1:13over here. But first of all, what does he prove from this point? He says, pasuk calls1:17lochatzav even the gabai tzedakah. What do you mean? The guy is doing a mitzvah. He's collecting1:21tzedakah. It's still, the pasuk is criticizing and calling them lochatzav. Then he brings something very interesting.1:29The pasuk in Sefer Melachim Aleph lists the cabinet of Shlomo HaMelech, who they were and what1:36their jobs were. And it says over there there was a person called Adoniram. And it says in there1:40that Adoniram, al hamas, this Shlomo HaMelech, alav hashalom, that Adoniram, this man Adoniram, was in charge of the mas. Mas usually means the taxes. Now we're speaking taxes.1:53If you live in the U.S., that is, taxes are all in the, you know, dollars, in money. You have to pay 10%,2:0120%, 30% if you're richer, and if you live in, you know, the progressive America,2:07you're gonna have to pay 70% if you make a lot of money. In any case, that's what we know as2:11mas. But mas, although taxes could technically be money, it could also be anything else,2:18right? So let's just simply translate the word mas as taxes, because when you see later on what2:22he's, what Rav Tzadok is going to explain, he says, Adonayim was in charge of which taxes?2:28Lachtzov avanim l'vinyan Beit HaMikdash. He was in charge of people who have to chop the stones for the building of Beit HaMikdash. As we2:37know, Beit HaMikdash in times of Shlomo HaMelech was made out of stone. A lot of it was made out of stone, and that stone had to come from the mountains, and everything2:41had to be done there. Who was the person assigned to this task? It was a person called Adoniram.2:46Now, isn't that a great mitzvah? There's no greater mitzvah than the building of the actual2:53Beit HaMikdash, the first Beit HaMikdash, if this guy was in charge of it. Still, Chazal tell us,3:07how did Adoniram die? He died by getting stoned. Whoa. Not that he was stoned because he committed an aveirah, but there was an incident over there that3:12they were throwing stones, and he got hit with a stone, and he got killed with it.3:17How could that be? And it says, Midah keneged midah. You force people, you put pressure on people to give stones,3:24therefore, midah keneged midah, his death came through stones. What do you mean the guy's supposed to do the job of3:35the Beit HaMikdash? That's what we say, you got to be careful. You got to be careful not to put pressure on people, even for the sake of a mitzvah. He explains now why that's so.3:43והיינו דמס נקרא מה שיותר לפי הכוח. Why is—did he do the right thing? And it seems like there's a little bit of a3:48ta'ana against Adoniram, because the word mas usually refers to something beyond a person's ability.3:55Kemo shene'emar, like Chazal tell us, that Shlomo HaMelech taxed the people too much. Because after the4:03death of Shlomo HaMelech, when Rechavam, the son of Shlomo, ruled,4:09the people came to him and they told Rechavam, the king, says, Avicha hichbid, your father was too4:15heavy on us. So we know that Shlomo put a tax on the Jewish people, but it seems4:20to be it was too much, it was too heavy on the Jewish people. And Chazal tell us another place4:24that the word mas refers to also that's too much, because it says by Achaz ben Rosh—when the Gemara is doresh on the4:33word Achaz ben Rosh—that, Hakol na'asu rashim, everyone became poor in his days, shene'emar, vayasem mas, and the Gemara proves it because he put a mas, and pashut pshat, he put taxes.4:40People tax all the time. When he put too much of a heavy tax, then it was beyond their ability.4:48Vu mikra d'sarei misim, and it's actually a pasuk that the word mas refers to something beyond a person's ability,4:53too much, because the pasuk says in Mitzrayim that Hashem put sarei misim, the ministers of taxes, and the pasuk says,5:03lemaan anoto, in order to make them suffer. So you see that the word mas is something beyond the person's5:08capability. Dera'at mas hainu k'shu bechbada le'anot nefesh, because the word mas refers to something that's too much on a person5:15to inflict pain. V'azei na'anishim kemo shehu l'mitzvah, and therefore, because a person is causing pain to another creature,5:23they get punished for this, even when it's being done for a mitzvah.5:34V'amru zeh b'Tanad d'Bei Eliyahu, and he brings a Midrash now, afilu eved sheniskal v'eved nisraf, atid liten din. Amazing Chazal. A person who is chayav mitah, let's say for example, a person is chayav sekilah5:40because he was mechalel Shabbat, so we do sekilah. We throw him off what we call, let's say,5:45a second floor, and if he doesn't die with that, then we take a stone and we throw on top of5:48him to kill him. And a person then, after that, after he's dead, is supposed to be hung for5:56a few seconds before death, not from his neck, but hung by his arms after he dies. So that's6:02called teliyah. So the Midrash says even this stone that was used to kill a person was6:07chayav mita bedin, and even that wood that was used to hang the person, that stone would will eventually pay6:13their punishment, Hashem will exact punishment from them, will take out His revenge against them.6:21V'hainu, afilu b'mechayeh bedin, says Rav Tzadok, even people who are chayav mita bedin are going to be subject to such a thing.6:33That's a Sanhedrin fasted the day that they had to give a psak when a person was6:41chayav mita. Why? As the Gemara says, l'chaper al nafshotam, because they had to get6:49kaparah. As Chazal tell us in Masechet Makot, Sanhedrin ha-horeget echad b'sheva shanim nikrachah blanit; it's called a damaging6:57bedin. Aval pishu bedin, obviously Sanhedrin are the greatest talmidei chachamim, and the 23 judges all came out, this is a psak halachah, they obviously understood7:02that this is how it's supposed to be. They're obviously not, you know, trying to get anybody. Still,7:11din nehnash, gam kol shechavero nehnash al yado. They're still going to be punished because you're causing pain to another Jew.7:14As Chazal tell us, any time, even if a person gets punished because of you,7:18that means they did something wrong to you and they're going to get punished because of you,7:22you're also going to be held accountable for that.7:27V'horeg shogeg chayav galut, and another proof we find that a person who kills by accident is chayav to go into exile,7:35ta'arog miklat. Now, Chazal tell us the person who got killed in such an accidental way,7:41af al pi shehalah mechayav mita, he was chayav mita anyway,7:50kemo shar muzharim, zeh zakai v'chovah al yedei chayav. That person who got killed by accident is no accident; Hashem wanted him to die. But still, the person who causes death will pay punishment.7:54Why is that so? Because again, tzaar was caused to another person.8:00Even though it's a mitzvah for that person to be killed. Just to give you a background information, those who are not familiar, the Gemara says,8:08don't think that there's, you know, people are dying by accident.8:11You know, it talks about a person who, let's say, was going down the ladder and he slips and he falls on top of another person,8:17and that person he fell on died.8:19So the person who killed didn't kill him on purpose; he was walking down the ladder, it was an accident.8:23So he has to run away to arei miklat. The8:26Gemara says you should know how Hashem works.8:31Meaning that what happened really is the guy who died8:34committed murder somewhere else, but nobody saw him. There were no witnesses, so you can't execute him.8:39What does Hashem do? Hashem makes it that this guy who killed8:43on purpose will be walking under a ladder one day, and the guy on top will slip and fall on him.8:48So you see, the guy who slipped anyway killed the guy who was חייב מיתה anyway.8:51Why does he have to go to galut?8:53And8:59then, his מקום, הרי גורם, צער לשמים, because9:01Chazal tell us even by9:05resha'im, אין הקדוש ברוך הוא שמח במפלתן של רשעים. Hashem is not happy when the resha'im fall.9:09And another9:10Chazal in Maseches Sanhedrin, this Shechinah—what does the Shechinah say when it's rasha is being executed, when a rasha is—even a rasha that's suffering?9:20The Gemara says, Shechinah מה אומרת? Oy. It says that the Shechinah says9:24that my head is too heavy,9:30קלני מראשי, קלני מזרועתי. My head is9:32too—he has basically a tremendous amount of pain, Hashem, even for the9:37resha'im. ואם כן בצערן של צדיקים, this is how Hashem feels when the tzaddikim are suffering.9:41How much more so when the tzaddikim is suffering.9:45Even if you're trying to force him to do דבר מצוה, we have to be very careful not to cause pain to somebody else.9:51Sometimes it may not be worth it. Now this is where the piece finishes. He has in brackets something else.9:56I would like to say that outside, but before I say that, I'd like to just bring another10:01proof to what Rav Tzadok is saying, not that he needs my proof, but we find that, you know,10:06the obvious Chazal tell us that10:09Elkanah, the father of Shmuel Hanavi, had two wives:10:12Hannah, the famous Hannah of Tefillat Hannah, the mother of Shmuel, and there was another wife called10:18Penina. Before Hannah had her child, Shmuel,10:20she had no children. She was barren, and for many years she tried having children. And her10:27co-wife, you could say,10:29Penina, it says that she would taunt her.10:31But she did it really just because she knew that Hannah has the power of tefillah, and if Hannah would be10:37hurt, she would pray from the depth of her heart and would have children. Chazal tell us, although Penina meant it10:43l'shem shamayim, but still her words caused pain to Penina, and unfortunately Penina's kids died.10:58Where did that come from? It says every time Hannah would have a child, another11:04few kids from Penina would die. Why did that happen? Chazal tell us because she caused pain to11:12Hannah.11:13Because she caused pain, this happened, even though she meant11:16it l'shem shamayim, and even though at the end11:17Hannah actually prayed and got the child. A person has to be very careful not to cause pain to another person, another Jew especially,11:24and a tzaddik especially, even if it's l'dvar mitzvah.11:27Ad kan. This is the piece. In brackets he brings something very interesting.11:31He says, however, people who are on the level of a king, in the midah of malchut,11:38they work differently. It's the opposite, actually,11:41because by them it says that they have to be a little tougher. We find that Shaul, who was a king,11:47he was kicked out because he was too soft. On11:51the people that were cruel, right? He should have been much more cruel to—he should have been very cruel to Agag, the11:58father—I mean, not father, the king of Amalek.12:01Yet he was not. He felt bad for him, and he lost the kingdom. And David HaMelech was very cruel12:08to the nation of Moab, how he killed them, but he was praised for that.12:13So you see, and not only that, it says about David that he had a red hair like12:19Esav; he had this trait, because malchut is a little bit differently. Even Moshe12:23Rabbeinu, we find that he was criticized by Korach: You're such12:28a—madua titnase'u? Why are you lifting yourselves?12:31Yeah, over, to some extent, a melech has to be a little bit on the harsher side. It's a little bit deep,12:38but obviously needs more talking,12:39but I just wanted to point that out, that there are exceptions when a person is on the level of a king.