Torah · MussarMussar171A. Things and Their OppositesTzidkat HaTzadikPart 171Rabbi Uri Nahum · February 9, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0018:13Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat HaTzadik, ot kuf ayin alef. Today's piece is very deep.0:05Let me give a little introduction. We probably have to split it up like we did with the last0:10ot, in kuf ayin alef, and 171 probably has to be also two parts, so look out for part two. Let's begin0:17with a little bit of background. It comes from Sefer Yetzirah. For those who are not familiar,0:22Sefer Yetzirah is a book that's attributed to Abraham Avinu, one of the oldest books that we0:28have, and it's a very, very deep, deep, deep book. You want to call it Kabbalistic, call it whatever you0:33want. It's definitely along the lines of what we call Kabbalah. In any case, over there,0:38he brings a very important concept. This concept is something that all the Sifrei Chassidim use0:46constantly, and it's a very, very important concept, and it repeats itself in Sifrei Chassidim a lot.0:53This concept is understood by the acronym by the Rashei Teivot, AShaN.1:00AShaN, ayin, shin, nun, stands for olam, shanah, and nefesh, which basically the concept of AShaN is,1:08is that anything that exists in the world exists in three realms. That's maybe the best way1:15we could word it. The three realms are in the olam, in the world, in the physical world;1:22in the shanah, in time. Shanah is a year, means in time; and in nefesh, and in people. Let's give1:30you an example of this. There's a concept of kedushah. Now, in order to understand what1:35holiness is, holiness is really in comparison to mundane, to regular. So if there's holiness1:42as opposed to chol, kedushah as opposed to chol, you find that kedushah and chol... Exist in three realms.1:49They exist in ashan. In the physical world, we find places are kadosh as opposed to places that are not.1:55We find in time that times are holy and that times are not, and we find people that people2:01are holy and that people are not. The examples of all this is in the world,2:06olam, Eretz Yisrael is holy as opposed to the rest of the world that's not. Yerushalayim is holier.2:13Even within Eretz Yisrael, it's holier, and Har Habayit is holier, and Beit Hamikdash is holier,2:18and Kodesh HaKodashim is holier, right? So we find this concept of kedusha that exists in the world,2:24as opposed to, you know, chol. And we also find that within the kedusha we have many levels.2:32Now, if this concept of kedusha exists, and you find it in the world, it must exist also2:38in time and by people. How is this in time? Well, we have the holidays as opposed to the regular2:46days, and within the holidays we have days that are holier. We have Yom Kippur. We have within2:53Yom Kippur a special time that's holier than the rest of the time of Yom Kippur. And of2:59course Shabbat, for those who say that Shabbat is the highest of the high. In people also we have the same concept.3:05We have Jews versus non-Jews, holy and mundane. And even amongst the holy we find people that are holier,3:10that's Shevet Levi. And even among Shevet Levi we find people also holier, and that's3:16the Kohanim. Even amongst the Kohanim we find the holiest is considered the Kohen Gadol. So you see3:22again this concept, ashan, olam, shanah, nefesh, whatever exists, any concept that exists will3:27exist in the three realms. This is the background information that you need for this piece 171,3:33and it's also going to be needed for 172 as well. But by the time you get to that, you might forget3:38this. But it's an important introduction. We're not going to repeat it. We'll always refer to,3:43you know, 171 or Kuf Ayin Aleph to go back to this concept. Now that we have this background,3:49let's come back to see Rav Tzadok and what he says. A very, very deep concept. He says,3:57Yesh makom mukhan l'tzaar, chas v'shalom. There are places that are prepared for suffering,4:02chas v'shalom. Where do you find this?4:06Kemo she'amru Chazal b'chelek b'Shechem, makom mukhan l'pra'aniyut. For example, Chazal tell us, Masechet Sanhedrin, about the city of Shechem. Chazal tell us that the city of4:12Shechem is a place that's, loosely translated, is a place that basically a hub for problems.4:21That's where they sold David. Actually, that's where they sold Yosef, in Shechem. That's where Dinah was raped, in Shechem.4:30That's where the, what's it called, the malchut of Beit David, the kingdom of the house of4:36David, was split, and that's when they, from the city of Shechem, that's when they decide to split and go4:41and make the ten tribes, which we know eventually led to the churban by Beit HaMikdash. That's Shechem.4:49V'chen zman, we also find that there are times that are basically prepared or waiting for bad, for problems.4:58Like it says in the Gemara. Also, there's a, there are certain times which are5:02mukhan l'pra'aniyut. V'kemo she'amru also, like it says, for example, Chazal tell us, a famous5:08Gemara, that's actually halacha, but it said,5:12It lei dina b'hai akum. He should avoid the month of Av. If you have to go to court against a goy,5:17avoid the month of Av because it's not a good month for the Jewish people. So you see that5:21there's times that are also kind of like prepared for problems. Chemin nefesh. We also find there are people5:31like that. K'dei she'amru, like you look in Masechet Ta'anit about5:35Rabbi Elazar ben Pedat, b'tuva, many people like him. People just don't have mazal. Chazal tell us, and the story of5:41Rabbi Elazar ben Pedat was so poor. That Hashem doesn't feel one understand why you're so poor,5:47you have to redo the whole world from way back from creation. It's just, that's his mazal.5:53He's going to be so poor or he's going to have problems. So he asks,6:01Ve'ech yitzuyar zeh shemuchan mitchilat briato lera'a, chas v'shalom? How could it be? How could such a thing be, that the guy is just born to such a thing,6:05that beginning of creation this place is bad, from beginning of creation this time is bad,6:10from beginning of creation this person has bad, he's prepared for bad?6:18How could that be? V'lo pi'alyonot ye'tze ra'ot. The pasuk says in Megillat Eicha, from Hashem no bad comes out. But here you're telling me this thing is set up from the beginning to be6:24a place of bad. So he says, the answer to that:6:31אבל באמת לשון חכמים מרפא. But really, the words of the Chachamim are known to be so precise, and they contain really the answers6:40to everything. So that means, look at the words the Chazal use. We're translating into English, and6:46our English, we hope we get the right translation, because we're trying to express the idea hopefully6:51in the right way. But you have to know the Hebrew. You have to go back to the lashon,6:56to the language that the rabbis use. שאמרו חזל didn't say that there's ra. What did they7:02say? מוכן לפורעניות. There are places, there are time, and there are people that7:12are muchan lepuraniyut. What does this mean? Lashon פרעון. פרעון means paying back. That's what the word פרעון means,7:18to pay back. Ra, so meaning to say, so that's what Chazal said. The simple understanding of it, or the loose7:27translation of muchan lepuraniyut we always understand is that, oh, this place is waiting for a7:32disaster. This time is waiting for disaster, the month of Av, that's a time of problems. But really,7:37Chazal said muchan lepuraniyut. It's muchan for paying back. What does that mean, paying back? That means Hashem is7:47paying back people something. The only thing is, Chazal told us, Masechet Kiddushin, דשכר מצוה בהאי עלמא ליכא, that there is no reward for a mitzvah in this world,7:58רק בעולם הבא. The only thing...8:00That there is, Hashem pays back in this world is when you do a sin, so Hashem pays you back in this world for it.8:06You get punished for it. However, you want to know, when a person does taste from the mitzvot, from the good deeds that8:15we do, we don't get reward for it. But there are times that a person is zocheh to certain levels where8:23he tastes from the good deeds. That's in two examples. Chazal tell us, for example, a person8:29is zocheh to taste from the fruits of his actions, not the actual reward, but the fruits.8:35And there are certain mitzvot that Chazal tell us, those who read this in the morning,8:40that Adam ochel otam ba'olam hazeh, hakeren kayemet lo l'olam haba, and the peirot, hakeren kayemet l'olam haba, vepeirot are for olam hazeh.8:50These are things that people will benefit from in olam hazeh, but the actual reward is over there.8:55The real reward for every mitzvah, it's called the keren. Keren is like the base, you could say.9:01And then there's sometimes a little bit of an overflow. That overflow comes in this world.9:06There are certain categories of mitzvot like that, like Talmud Torah, like learning Torah,9:10bringing peace between people, between husband and wife, bringing peace between husband and wife.9:15All that is something that you benefit from in this world. But almost everything else,9:23all the other mitzvot, Hashem doesn't give you in this world.9:31Now, ve'oto hazman, makom venefesh hu muchan lekabel pera'on, ma shenistaker. And that special time that's prepared for pera'aniut, or that special place, or that person9:39who's prepared for this pera'on, is ready to get the pera'on, which means he's ready to get9:43the payback for what he has earned.9:48And what's the reason why Hashem doesn't pay back people for their mitzvot in this world?9:55Because Hashem pays a full load,10:00veyifra olam hazeh lekabel, and that full load that's really deserving of the mitzvah he did, he can't get it in this world.10:05This world is not meant for it. He just won't be able to be enough to receive the full reward.10:20Therefore, באותו מקום וזמן ונפש, נשפע פרעון ושכרו של השם יתברך מצד ריבוי השפע. Therefore, when there's so much of an overflow, when Hashem has to give back10:26and has to pay back the person, na'asa hashpa'ah shefa praniut lara. Then actually, because there's an overflow of paying back,10:35it actually turns into something bad.10:42כידוע, בסוד שבירתן של כלים, זו היא מתנתן על ידי ריבוי האור, as what the Sifrei Kabbalah bring down, something called shevirat kelim.10:47What is shevirat kelim? Let's give you the translation in10:52a mashal, and then we'll take this translation and bring out the concept.10:58If I would tell you, you know, there's somebody who is giving out gold coins.11:04Nice gold coins, yeah? So go and take whatever you can.11:09He's giving out whatever you can take. But the only thing is, you only get to come once.11:13Whatever you come, he'll fill up whatever you bring him, and that's it.11:17So you're gonna go, you're gonna look inside your house and you're gonna look for bags,11:22look for a bag, and then all of a sudden you get a bag and you say,11:24Oh, this bag is good enough. It's big. I can fill up a lot of gold coins in it.11:29Now, right before you walk out, he says, No, no, no, no, no. Bag,11:32it's not good. It's gonna might rip. I'm gonna get a box.11:36So you go, you go get one of those supermarket boxes,11:40like a Moishy's box or Bingo box, and you take this box and you line up on the line,11:46and this guy is giving out gold coins. And you come and you say, Okay, I got a box.11:50So, okay, he tells his men, Load him up with gold coins. He fills up the gold coins. Great.11:56Now it's in your box. You tape the box. You come to pick up the box, but12:01you have to know that the box is meant to hold, you know, groceries, some plastic cups,12:09some food, some lettuce, maybe sometimes potatoes and some soft drinks, sodas.12:15But gold and coins are very heavy, and the box is not able to last.12:18So you're walking, you're walking, all of a sudden,12:21the box bursts open and all the gold and coins just flow out. Why? Because the keli that you chose,12:27the box, is unable to hold the gold and coins. It comes out that your blessing was actually12:33what broke your box. The fact that you got so much coins was actually your problem.12:38You tried to stuff too much in the box and therefore broke the box.12:41This is known as shvirat kelim. Shvirat kelim is when there's so much and12:48you're unable to handle it that it breaks your quote-unquote utensils.12:52This is a concept that's brought down in sefarim, or of Sifrei Kabbalah specifically,12:58of shvirat kelim, is when Hashem gives somebody something beyond his capability.13:04They can't handle it and actually destroys them. This is called13:14shvirat kelim. וכן אמרו זל על הפסוק לא יראני האדם וחי. Chazal say on the pasuk when Hashem tells Moshe Rabbeinu, as long as a person is alive, he's unable to see Me.13:21Chazal say, however, when they die, they could see. Because to be able to see Hashem is to understand a13:27certain level and to connect to Hashem on a very high level. And such a high level,13:34when a person tries to do in this world, it will break his keli. It will destroy him.13:41But when he dies, therefore he's not limited to the keli, which is called the13:45guf, which is the body, then he's able to see. So that's what the Pharaoh. Those times and places13:53and people that are muchan l'Pharahiyut are the people who are basically getting a tremendous13:58shefa, but it's beyond their ability.14:05ולכן אמרו זל. Now this is a deeper concept. He goes a little deeper. He says,14:10Gemara tells us in Masechet Yoma, when the goyim came to destroy Beit HaMikdash in the Second Beit HaMikdash, they walked inside of14:17the Beit HaMikdash, in the building, and there was a parochet. The parochet originally had on it14:22the keruvim, the images of the keruvim. These keruvim were like angels, basically, what we call,14:29but really it was images of a boy with wings and a girl with wings. The boy represented Hashem,14:34and the girl—it's a little child, basically—a boy and a young girl, and the girl represented14:41the Jewish people. And Chazal tell us that miraculously, whenever the Jewish people would do14:47what they're supposed to do, the keruvim, the male and the female, would face each other,14:53representing the closeness between Jews and Hashem. And when the Jewish people are not doing what14:57they're supposed to be doing, miraculously the keruvim that are sewn into the parochet would face15:02away from each other. When the Beit HaMikdash was destroyed, the goyim went in, and they discovered15:09that on this parochet, where the keruvim are sewn, matz'u keruvim me'urin. They saw them actually hugging each other.15:17One second, when did this tragedy take place? It took place during the times of the greatest15:25tragedy, the destruction of Beit HaMikdash. At the time of the destruction of Beit HaMikdash,15:29the Jewish people were clearly not doing what they're supposed to be doing, yet they saw them15:34hugging each other. What's going on? How could it be? So he explains, this is what we're explaining:15:42כי אז היה תוקף ריבוי שפע האור, because the flow that Hashem was giving was so much, which actually ended up breaking the Jewish15:50people. Right, that's what brought about the destruction. There was a lot of15:55or. Not that Hashem punishes, but He gives this tremendous amount of or, and when they—16:00They can't handle the destructions. And that's why it wasn't just that the keruvim faced16:04each other; they were hugging each other. I mean, there was a tremendous flow that16:08was coming down, and that's what actually, how translated in this world, is that we16:14saw it destroyed.16:15If you look at Sefer Yechezkel, right in the16:19beginning, in perek rishon, he speaks about a nevuah that we read as a haftarah16:25on Shavuot. It basically describes in detail how he saw the merkavah, the heavenly chariot,16:33which is basically how the whole world runs. Very, very deep and mystical. He was16:39zocheh to such a high level of nevuah when, at that same time, as the Beit HaMikdash was being destroyed.16:43How could it be? We were at the lowest point. We were so distanced from Hashem. And16:49the answer is no, because the punishment came from the tremendous flow, but that it broke the kelim of others. But for16:57some, they actually got the good from it.17:00But a person who is really zocheh, he actually17:05receives the good at that time.17:07And that's the same concept17:10the Chazal tell us. The Chazal tell us in the Midrash, when was Mashiach soul born?17:16On Tisha B'Av. There are many ways to explain this, but in the theme that Reb Tzadok is talking about17:22over here, what he's saying is, is that the flow that came down during the17:30Tisha B'Av, which destroyed Beit HaMikdash, for those Jews that suffered this because they got it17:38in the shevirat kelim form. But the tzaddikim, they were able to get it in the positive way.17:44Like, for example, Yechezkel got this level of nevuah, and also was able to produce the highest17:50neshama from the Jewish people, which is the neshama of Mashiach. It had to be born right17:55then because of the tremendous flow that came into the world.18:00Now, there's a lot more. I'm even in the middle of a paragraph. I'm looking at the time,18:04and it's already way above our time. We're going to pause over here,18:08be'ezrat Hashem. We'll come back in the next piece, review this concept very shortly, and continue.