Torah · MussarMussar167. When Fear Is GoodTzidkat HaTzadikPart 167Rabbi Uri Nahum · January 29, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0020:42Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot kuf samech zayin, 167.0:05Today's piece, there's a lot of information that we need as background information to understand the piece,0:11and I was debating if I should say in the beginning, or maybe as we go along.0:15I decided that maybe it'll be better if we start reading from0:19Rav Tzadok and we interject a little bit of some of the information that we'll need to understand each piece.0:25So he says like this:0:27Bedivrei Torah mutar adam0:29lefchod. When it comes to Torah, you're allowed to get scared.0:33Pause for a second.0:35What does that mean?0:36Why is he bringing this? You're allowed to get scared.0:38What does that mean? Can I get scared of anything?0:39I can't get scared of a movie. I can't get scared of the news. I can't get scared of my financial situation.0:43The answer is no,0:45because the Gemara says0:48in Masechet Gittin that one time somebody was seen scared,0:51and he was told, based on a pasuk in0:56Eicha, that the fact that he's scared, he's a sinner.0:59So he responded, he said, One second, doesn't it say in the pasuk,1:02Ashrei adam1:04mefached tamid, fortunate is the person who is always scared?1:07The response was, Hahu bedivrei Torah.1:09That pasuk that says a person who is always scared is praiseworthy,1:13that's only when it comes to divrei Torah.1:15But in matters of olam hazeh, anything else,1:19it's assur to be scared.1:21If you're scared, it's a sign that you have1:25sin. And I believe that's based on another1:27Gemara, Masechet Berachot. The Gemara says1:29in Masechet Berachot, once there was a certain creature1:31which seems to be like this poisonous snake,1:33pashut pshat is this very, very poisonous snake,1:36and that was killing people.1:38And they came and they told1:40Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa, and Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa asked where the snake is,1:43and he went to the hole where the snake was coming out from.1:46He put his foot right by the1:47hole, and the snake came out and bit him.1:49And when the snake bit him, the snake died.1:53Rabbi Yochanan ben Dosa proceeded to take the snake.1:56He carried it. He went to the city. He said,1:58I just did this to show everybody.2:01It's not the snake that kills;2:03it's the sin that kills people.2:06Meaning, we're always scared of what's going to happen to us.2:09But as Rabbi Yochanan ben Dosa demonstrated with the snake,2:13it's not the snake.2:14It's not the news.2:16It's not the whatever things are happening.2:19It's not the loss in the market.2:20It's not the price jack in gas2:23that's making our economy worse.2:25It's the fact that we're scared and we're nervous,2:28and we have a sin2:29that's our nervous that we're going to be affected2:33by the snake or by whatever it is in the2:36olam hazeh. But really, if a person doesn't have2:38sin, there's nothing to worry about,2:39and therefore it's assur to get scared.2:42But when it comes to divrei Torah,2:44he writes,2:47Mutar l'adam lifchod. You're allowed to get scared. Now, what does that mean, to get scared of Torah? Who says the Torah2:50something you get scared? What does that mean?2:55כמו שאמרו זכרונם לברכה, היינו שיפחד שמא הוא חס ושלום שם המוות. What to be scared is that2:57maybe the Torah that I'm learning2:59is sam3:00hamavet. So again, we need to interject a little3:02another background.3:03The Gemara says3:09that עץ חיים היא למחזיקים בה, and we know that the Torah is considered a tree of life.3:12It says,3:20מימינה... אורך ימים בימינה, בשמאלה עושר וכבוד. In the right hand of the Torah,3:23it's אורך ימים, long life,3:25and בשמאלה עושר וכבוד, says the Gemara. It's חיים. The Torah is3:26considered חיים for לימינים בה, and for משמאילים בה, it3:33could be sam hamavet. That means3:35if a person learns Torah in a certain way3:37that's not3:39לשם שמים, it could actually become like poison.3:41It could actually kill the person.3:42How could that be?3:44Torah is considered3:45עץ החיים, and the answer is, I guess,3:46is how you manipulate.3:48A guy who doesn't know any3:49Torah and3:50is עם הארץ, and he does, you know, does things that are not so good,3:52he's3:53עם הארץ. A guy who knows Torah...3:55And manipulates the words of the Torah,3:57using the king's staff3:59for the wrong things,4:01that is going to turn into sam4:03hamavet. And that comes from doing it4:05shelo l'shem shamayim. So he says,4:08a person has to be4:10scared that what,4:11that my Torah4:12might be,4:13chas v'shalom, that the way I'm learning4:15might not be proper.4:16I'm not talking about understanding.4:18I'm talking about in goals4:20in my learning.4:21It could be4:22it's the poison that Chazal refer to.4:26However,4:26by me getting nervous,4:28maybe I'm not really learning properly,4:31that fear itself,4:32the anxiety that I have over it,4:34and again, anxiety that it doesn't4:37make me disabled4:38and I'm not able to function,4:40anxiety just that I'm nervous4:42that maybe I'm not doing the right thing4:43and therefore I'm always4:44going to make sure to do the right thing,4:46that fear4:50mitmatek v'na'aseh mitok shelo lishmah lishmah. That's what converts my learning,4:53even if it had been4:55shelo lishmah, it converts it and makes it4:59l'shem shamayim. Now here's another thing.5:01The Gemara says,5:08לעולם יעסוק אדם בתורה ומצוות אפילו שלא לשמה, שמתוך שלא לשמה בא לשמה. The Gemara says5:10that a person5:11should always learn Torah5:13even if it's5:15shelo l'shem shamayim. Why?5:17What does it mean,5:17shelo lishmah? It means it's not for the right reasons.5:19You're not doing it for the right reasons.5:21Why?5:24Because mitoch shelo lishmah ba lishmah. From doing5:25it lo lishmah, meaning to say5:27not for the right reasons,5:28eventually it'll lead you5:29to doing it5:29for the right reasons.5:30You just start learning,5:31don't worry.5:32Hopefully,5:33now hopefully,5:34it'll eventually lead you5:35to the right reasons.5:36So he's saying over here also,5:38when it's5:39lo lishmah, it could be sam5:41hamavet. How do we turn that into a lishma?5:43The answer is by worrying,5:44by feeling the nervousness5:46that perhaps I'm doing something wrong,5:49you can eventually turn it into5:52that.5:53Not eventually, sorry.5:55The fear itself turns it5:57into a lishma.5:59So he says an interesting thing:6:05Ki hai man de-mabheit, mazalei chazi. Because we find6:06fear is connected to a person's6:09inner world,6:13his neshama.6:14Chazal tell us6:15that even if a person is scared of something6:17and he doesn't know what he's scared of,6:18when he gets that, like, nervousness6:20and like you're nervous,6:22Chazal base it on an incident6:24that happened with Daniel,6:26Chananiah, Mishael, and Azariah, that although one doesn't see it,6:29but still,6:33he hu lo chazi, he doesn't see it, but mazalei chazi. The mazal of the person, meaning to6:35say the spiritual part of the person6:36that's outside of his body6:38that's able to have a6:40vision of what's going on,6:41they could see it,6:42and therefore,6:43since we are connected to our mazal,6:45to our spiritual being6:47that's outside of us,6:48we could also sense6:50something that's scary.6:52So he says,6:53V'hu dugmat chalom. This is very identical to a dream,6:57because when we're in a dream,6:58we're really outside of our body.7:00We see things7:01that may not have happened yet.7:04We could travel7:06outside of our body7:09in space,7:10and we could travel also7:12outside of our body in time.7:14We could go to the future,7:15to a different place,7:16even though we're situated7:18in, let's say for example, Jerusalem7:20in7:21Eretz Yisrael, but we could have a dream7:22of seeing ourselves7:23somewhere in the7:25world, like, I don't know, Brazil,7:27and three years from now.7:29We travel.7:30So that's a dream.7:32That's something outside of your body.7:33That's the same thing7:35as of7:36mazalei chazi, when a person's mazal7:37is able to see something.7:43V'hu dugmat chalom. Now that we connected7:46the7:47fear—excuse me—now that we connected7:48the mazal of the person7:50to the dream,7:51and we said that through fear,7:54it's fear of something7:55that's not seen,7:57but just the nervousness,7:58that alone could...8:00Turn shalosh mantos. How that works, he connects it beautifully. He says, Chazal tell us in Masechet Berachot that when a person has a bad dream, atzibuteh mistayeya. Just the feeling bad about it could be its medicine.8:15That's the way to heal it. Hainu sheba'atzmut atzmo dai. Meaning, what the Gemara is telling us, just the feeling bad alone, that is enough to make the person feel better.8:26Not feel better, but to take away that bad dream, or the gzeirah of the bad dream.8:34Vechein b'inyan haTorah, shelo zachah, chas v'shalom, na'asit lo sam hamavet. As we know, a person who is learning Torah and he's not zocheh to learn it properly, it could turn into8:41sam hamavet. Therefore, same idea. Vadai b'zeh mashu mefached baTorah. It's enough for a person just to be scared that maybe I'm doing something wrong,8:50and that's like the dream that will be also. Just like the dream, the bad feeling is good enough to convert it and to take away the bad gzeirah, to convert it into something positive,9:00so too the feeling of anxiety and fear that maybe I'm doing the wrong thing is good enough also to turn ma shelo lishmah into9:15lishmah. Ufikudei Hashem yesharim mesamchei lev, v'mitzvat Hashem barah me'irat einayim. We find pesukim that speak about turning the mitzvot, turning a person into a happy person and giving strength.9:27Vechein b'shar pesukim shenotenet oz v'chidvah shehu hefuch hapachad. How does that work? What does that mean, the Torah gives us happiness? Well, like we said beforehand, fear comes when a person is nervous,9:34he's scared, he's not sure about things. Simchah is the exact opposite. When a person is happy and excited, there's no fear.9:42I'll give you a very quick example. A person has the wedding of his daughter. Coming up, and he's the one who obviously has to pay for it,9:52but he doesn't have the funds. But he wants his daughter to get married. What about the option? Does she stay single,9:56has v'shalom? No, she got a great chatan, and he knows he's got to come up with the money. He doesn't have fifty thousand dollars to come up with.10:02It's not like, you know, expenses over a year. This is fifty thousand dollars. How is he going to come up with it? Ah, so he's nervous. He's scared.10:10The day that's supposed to be the happiest day for him, where his daughter is getting married, is turning to be a day of anxiety and fear.10:19And all of a sudden, he enters a raffle and he wins a hundred thousand dollars. Not only does he get the fifty thousand to pay, but he has extras as well.10:30Woo! Look at that simcha. Where's the fear? Why is he scared anymore? When you have simcha, you don't have fear.10:41Pikudei Hashem, the mitzvot of Hashem are mesamchei lev. They give a person simcha. Why? When you have that fear and you are nervous, you're doing it for the wrong thing,10:48and it turns now into positive. You become happy in learning Torah.10:52It'll make you naturally happy. It'll automatically take away that fear.10:59Now, next paragraph, he says,11:10What does that mean? This is la'olam, meaning his emphasis is not on what Chazal tell us, that you should be11:16osek shelo lishma ba lishma. His emphasis is, Rabbi Yehuda in the Gemara begins the statement, and he says,11:29Le'olam, always. What does that mean, always? פירוש בתמידות, constantly it's always like this. מה שאין כן הלשמה. The lo lishma is always there. Whenever we're doing things, it's always the lo11:37lishma. But the lishma is not constantly there,11:39because he says11:42the lishma, you have shakla liyot בתמידות דלשמה, היינו דביקות. Because you know what lishma means? It means completely attaching yourself to Hashem, doing it solely for the sake of Hashem without any personal interest at all whatsoever.12:01He says because it's impossible to really attach yourself constantly to this,12:07because the lishma is comparable to what Chazal12:12say. Remember, lishma is a complete attachment. That's12:15daat. That's what they call in the sefirah of daat, the complete attachment to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.12:19And when we know it comes with daat, it's comparable to עונה, to the time when the couples are together.12:25And Chazal12:32tell us a talmid chacham is once a week, a tayalim, those who don't work and they have their life easy, it's once a day. But even then, even the greatest physical unity that comes, the couple could come together,12:41that also only comes in a moment. It's not constant. It's only for a12:46moment. And so too, he says, the lishma, to really, really be lishma is not something possible at all times.12:54Certainly not on our level.12:55But it can happen once a day for certain people, once a week even,13:00but the lo lishma is constantly there.13:01And does that mean we don't do it? No.13:04It's like any responsibility.13:06Are you always in the mood to go to work?13:07Are you always excited to run to work? No.13:10If you're the boss,13:11you know, as the famous saying in Hebrew,13:15יום עשה, יום בטל. They call it a saying in Hebrew. It's an Arabic saying.13:18One day it's honey, one day it's sweet, one day it's like an onion.13:23It's bitter. It's spicy. It's, you know, it's sharp.13:28So that's the same thing also in life.13:31Everything in life that we do,13:33you're in the mood, you're not in the mood,13:34you try to get yourself in the mood.13:35But this is our responsibility. This is what we got to do at the end.13:38Same thing also. He says,13:41in our avodat Hashem,13:43the dvekut, to be completely attached to HaKadosh Baruch Hu,13:50it may be possible for, like, individuals, certain individuals, unique individuals,13:54but for us regular folks, it's impossible that it should be constantly like that.13:59That's what he brings.14:03But b'tmimut hu shelo lishma, rak shemitoch shelo lishma ba lishma. So he says, but most of the time our avodah is14:06shelo lishma, because this is the right thing.14:09We're going to get sachar for it, we're going to get reward for it,14:11and this is our community demands this of us,14:13and we're doing it. That's called14:15shelo lishma. Again, we're doing the right thing,14:16at least shelo lishma is not doing the wrong things,14:18but still14:20shelo lishma. But he says,14:21but from the lo lishma will bring you14:29lishma. פירוש, מתוך הלֹא לשמה עצמו, בתוךו, ... להיות אותו לימוד עצמו לשמה. From the actual lo lishma itself,14:32מתוך — the Gemara says,14:33what do we mean,14:35מתוך? Pashut pshat is, simple translation is14:38that from not learning lishma will lead you to14:40lishma. He says, no, מתוך, from the lo lishma itself,14:43that will lead to14:45lishma. והיינו על ידי הפחד. How is that so?14:46And the answer is,14:47when I think about it and I contemplate and I think,14:49Oy, where am I?14:51Oy, where is my head?14:53I'm only thinking about myself.14:55I'm only thinking about what I want to do,14:57my personal kavod,14:59and my, and me, and me.15:01What about Hashem?15:02That nervousness is what turns it into15:16lishma. ... פירוש על עסקו התמידות, ... because it's ... כלל. He says15:18that's the meaning also15:19what Chazal say on the pasuk,15:22אשר אדם מפחד תמיד. A person is always scared,15:24like we said.15:25The pachad, the fear in the divrei Torah means15:28the worry that maybe I'm not doing15:30it shelo lishma, because on a regular basis15:32the temidut, the regular thing is that we are15:35shelo lishma, and therefore the15:38pachad has to be also constantly.15:40Again, pachad not that it's15:44disabling you from functioning.15:46The pachad that we're talking about over here15:48is that constant worry that,15:49I'm not doing the right thing, maybe,15:51and I'm always thinking I should be doing the right thing.15:54And if you see yourself getting a little carried away15:58and you're not able to function,16:00That's not the right pachad that we're talking about.16:02There's a pachad that actually makes a person actually, you know, do well, you know, work harder.16:09Lemashal, a person who's on guard,16:12a person who's hired to be a security force16:15in, let's say, in Israel. You're defending your own people.16:18You're defending the Jewish people, the holy people, the holy land.16:21You're nervous all the time that maybe there's terrorists that are going to come,16:26but you're excited by the challenge.16:28A guy who enters a tournament in sports, basketball, football, whatever it is,16:33he's nervous of losing all the time. He doesn't want to lose,16:36especially when the game is very close.16:38But that nervousness gets him to work harder16:41and makes him work harder.16:43He doesn't relax.16:44You know how it happens when, let's say, you're playing basketball and you're up by 25 points16:48and it's already the first quarter?16:50You relax. You know, you don't need to put so much effort.16:52But if you know you're playing a very hard team16:56that made dozens of comebacks when they're down by 25,17:00you're always nervous that they might just come back and win the game.17:03So therefore it makes you work harder.17:05It doesn't make you get so nervous you can't shoot the ball.17:08If you're so nervous you can't shoot the ball, they got you.17:11Same thing, the yetzer hara also.17:12We have to be nervous that our learning is perhaps not being done right,17:15and the yetzer hara is going to turn it upside down for us.17:18It's going to make our learning,17:19our mitzvot, go lelo lishma and turn us into bad people.17:23But not that it's disabling us.17:26It's actually empowering us that we want to work harder,17:30and that's how we could turn actually our avodah of shelo lishma into17:35lishma. V'amru זה, one more paragraph. I know of the time, but I just got to finish this.17:42V'amru זה, אשריך בעולם הזה וטוב לך בעולם הבא. On the pasuk17:47in Tehillim, אשריך וטוב לך. Chazal make a drashah: אשריך, you're fortunate in olam hazeh,17:50וטוב לך בעולם הבא. So notice that the word ashreicha, fortunate, is used for17:54dafka in Olam Hazeh.17:57The lashon is shum mishama me'acherim, because ishur says, ... is something that other people give you.18:02You are a fortunate person based on other people's point of view.18:06V'zehu rak b'Olam Hazeh, and that's only שייך in Olam Hazeh.18:10Because in Olam Haba, there's nothing that's dependent on others.18:15Your reward, your place, your enjoyment is not dependent on others' point of view.18:20Each person has his own world and there's nothing to compare it to.18:25U'be'emet lo shayach klal b'Torah shelo lishmah. Really, if you think about it deeper, he says,18:28learning Torah,18:32how can it be lo lishmah? Because in stam, a person who's learning,18:33why is he learning? Obviously,18:36lishmah. Now, same thing when a person brings a korban.18:38Chazal say,18:39the guy's bringing a korban,18:40obviously he's doing18:41it l'shem Shamayim. If, with that thinking, he's obviously bringing it for the sake of the right korban18:45that he's bringing it.18:50So how does the lo lishmah get created by Torah?18:53The answer is because Torah is through words,18:57and when you speak words,18:59that actually empowers the ability of words in this world.19:06Being that in this world it's a world which has evil in it,19:09and specifically the evil in speech, which is called19:17lashon hara, therefore right away by learning Torah19:18you increase the power of speech in the world.19:20And the power of speech means automatically19:23you're watering and you're giving power also19:25to the ability to speak lashon hara as well.19:32Therefore, ... the ... hed shachut leshonam alav. Therefore, you could have now19:34in Shamayim the malachim could also speak against you,19:39and that's why the advice to get these angels,19:44these prosecuting angels, off of your back19:46is to be19:53... and ... and the solution to this is by getting nervous,19:57by getting this pachad, by getting this fear that maybe I'm not doing it20:02l'shem Shamayim. That pachad, as we know, fear automatically shrinks and holds back.20:08Think about it:20:08you're walking or you're running and something just runs in front of you,20:12you stop, you jump back.20:14Fear always is what we call tzimtzum.20:18You know, it minimizes something.20:21It minimizes your steps, your walks.20:23It shrivels it.20:24It puts it smaller.20:25So therefore, when you do that,20:27when you have pachad,20:28they also don't allow the powers to be extended to those angels20:34that have the ability to prosecute you,20:36and therefore you get the yishur in Olam Hazeh as well.