Torah · MussarMussar16. Kedusha on a ספקTzidkat HaTzadikPart 16Rabbi Uri Nahum · May 19, 2022−15Play+30Position0:006:31Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:03Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot zayin. In this piece, there are a few parentheses, like we explained that the parentheses or the brackets are side points.0:11The Rav Tzadok brings one idea and he wants to prove it,0:15and some of the proofs come also from a masechet, Berachot, from the beginning.0:19The idea is that when we do something because we're not sure, there's a0:25safek. So we understand that if it's safek d'oraita, l'chumra, which means that if we're not sure about a certain halacha,0:31we try to do, to be of the machmir opinion.0:35Are we really accomplishing anything, or are we just covering ourselves0:38just in case this is what I was supposed to do, right?0:42Kind of like, for example, let's take the safek that he's going to discuss later on as well,0:47like safek of bein hashmashot.0:49What's bein hashmashot?0:50Bein hashmashot, Chazal tell us, and we know the Torah says that Hashem calls the daytime yom.0:57What's the daytime? When the sun is out, that's called yom.1:00And when the sun is gone and the stars are out, that's called night.1:07Now in halacha, we know, and that's the reality of the world, that when the sun sets,1:11that means when the entire ball of the sun is completely below the horizon,1:17until the time that the stars come out, there's a time in between.1:20There's a little bit of time, whatever that time is.1:23The Chazal refer to that time as bein hashmashot.1:27And we're not sure if it's really part of the previous day or part of the following evening.1:34That bein hashmashot period is a time of1:38safek. So Gemara says because it's a safek, we treat it1:42l'chumra. That means on Friday afternoon, when we accept Shabbat, we accept it,1:46we assume that at the beginning of the bein hashmashot period, when the sun sets, it's already Shabbat.1:51And on Shabbat afternoon, when the sun sets, we don't assume that it's already the next evening1:56and we're allowed to do1:57melachot. We assume that it might be still part of the day, and we'll wait until the stars come out2:03to wait till then to be able to do melachot, to make sure that the Shabbat is completely left.2:10So this, b'nesh mashot, we treat it as a2:14safek. Now, when we treat it as a safek, is it because we're worried, we're scared?2:18We don't know; it could be ספק, it could be not Shabbat.2:20So let's assume, in reality, it is Shabbat.2:23It's 100% Shabbat.2:25What does it mean, Shabbat?2:26It means to say it is the following day, the beginning of the sun, when the sun2:30finally—when the sun sets, it's actually the next day.2:32So it comes out that on Shabbat afternoon, when the sun set, we're keeping Shabbat for no reason,2:37just because we're not sure about really2:39this. In reality, right,2:41whatever, you know, seems like only Hashem knows that reality from the Gemara,2:45we're really doing nothing.2:47That's what it seems like.2:49Rav Tzadok wants to prove, no. Even when you do something out of2:53safek that has also a kedushah in it, as if the item itself.2:58Now he's going to prove it. Let's see it.3:05דהמצוה שעושה הוא מפני הספק, חל עליו קדושת השם יתברך בוודאי. Any mitzvah that you're doing it because of a3:08safek, whether the rule is because you have a safek if you did it or not,3:12like, or there's a safek in the opinions, like3:15safek de'oraita l'chumra, or whatever it is,3:18it also has kedushah from Hashem, like a person who is actually doing the mitzvah.3:28Why? Because that's what the halacha decided, that because there's a safek, you have an obligation to do it,3:31so therefore it becomes a mitzvah. Dugma, Yom Tov Sheni.3:34I'll give you a perfect example:3:36second day of Yom Tov.3:38Today we know, and Chazal also knew the calendar,3:42and they knew exactly when the holiday fell out, or falls out.3:46There was a period in time when there was a3:51safek; we weren't sure when the holiday would fall out,3:54so they kept a second day of Yom Tov.3:57That means Yom Tov Sheni, as we all know,4:02it's miderabbanan. Why do we keep it? Because of the4:03safek. Maybe it was supposed to be the first day,4:05maybe it's really a weekday, maybe it's really a holiday,4:08so we keep it out of the4:10safek. Yet we know we make4:13kiddush, we say the bracha, we're using4:15Shem Hashem, Baruch Atah Hashem, mekadesh haShabbat.4:17In fact, we even say Shehecheyanu again.4:19We treat it all with the same kedusha.4:20So you see, even something that's done as a4:24safek, it's not safek kedusha; it's vadai kedusha comes in it.4:28Also, Chazal tell us that in Masechet Shabbat,4:37demevarchin al shekideshanu b'mitzvotav a safek, chutz min demai, deRabbanan me'aserin. Chazal tell us that you make a bracha even on a4:42safek, even on something that's a4:43safek. You still make a4:45bracha, asher kideshanu b'mitzvotav. He brings another proof from the Beit Yosef in Yoreh4:49Deah that something on a safek is4:53chashuv kevadai. The concept4:55over there, he brings4:56in siman chaf-chet, nimtza... I couldn't find it exactly,4:59but again, it's the same concept,5:00that even something that's a5:02safek, we treat it, or when we do it because of a5:07safek, it's treated even in Shamayim as a5:10vadai. And he says that's also,5:13v'chen mukach lashon haGemara, and that's also the way the Gemara in Masechet Berachot5:16uses the words,5:21misha'ah shekidesh hayom b'Erev Shabbat. One of the opinions that when you read Kriat Shema is,5:25when the Gemara says,5:28when you read Kriat Shema, misha'ah shekidesh hayom b'Erev Shabbat, according to one of the opinions.5:29But look at the language that the Gemara uses:5:34kidesh hayom, when the day becomes kadosh on Erev Shabbat. One second,5:37the day becomes kadosh lel Shabbat. Erev Shabbat means the day before Shabbat.5:41Rashi explains, what does he mean, erev Shabbat?5:42Says Rashi,5:44bein hashmashot, and you see5:45it's called kedushat hayom.5:48And again, you see the proof5:50that kedushat Shabbat5:52begins by the beginning of5:55bein hashmashot, because even though it's only a5:57safek, but that's called kedushat Shabbat.6:00And he brings that as a side point.6:01As a side point, he says6:03the whole concept of6:05bein hashmashot, right, of Shabbat,6:06we are6:07mekadesh it, and therefore that has6:10its kedusha. And now he summarizes the point.6:11Because6:14bnei Yisrael machmirim al themselves to do a mitzvah, anytime the Jewish people6:17are machmir on themselves to do a mitzvah6:19because of a6:21safek, that has the status of a mitzvah6:26vadai and also has a6:27kedusha like things that are certain.