Torah · MussarMussar148. What Defines a True Talmid HachamTzidkat HaTzadikPart 148Rabbi Uri Nahum · January 1, 2023−15Play+30Position0:0018:55Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat Tzadik, kuf mem-chet, 148.0:05Very nice, interesting piece over here.0:08Says,0:14יש תלמיד חכם שזוכה דשמעתתיה מבדרין בעלמא. There are talmidei chachamim that have the zechut and the privilege0:18that their Torah, their teachings, are spread in the world.0:25ויש שאינו זוכה לכך. And there are other talmidei chachamim that may not be on any lower level0:31than the first talmid chacham that was just mentioned,0:34but they're not zocheh that their limud is spread in the world.0:38Now he asks most people, Who's a greater rabbi?0:42Who's greater? Everybody will say, What do you mean?0:44Look at this guy, he has zechut, Rabbi, his Torah is everywhere.0:47So listen to what he says, an amazing thing.0:49And he says,0:53ואין זה ראיה שזה גדול מזה. This is not a proof at all that the first talmid chacham,0:58who has his teachings spread throughout the world,1:00that everybody is listening to him and reading his sefarim and learning from him,1:04this doesn't prove that he's greater than the second talmid chacham1:07that perhaps most people have never heard of.1:13שלפעמים יש בבית תורה יקרים, בפי מישהו. Because sometimes the words of the Torah happen to be found,1:19the special words that happen to be found by someone, by any random person,1:24and now he's going to prove it.1:29וכמו שאנו רואים בבלעם. Where does he prove it from?1:35Bilam. שאמר פרשה שלמה בתורה שבכתב. A full parashah in the Torah is dedicated to the story of1:40Bilam, and in fact, what he said himself,1:43the conversation that he said.1:46And the brachot that were supposed to be called1:48the brachot that he said1:50were all said by1:52Bilam. We're learning1:55Torat Bilam, a full parashah in the Torah1:57shebichtav. And not only that, he brings in brackets,2:03וליודעים הם כי גם כל הדיבורים מפרעה ואבימלך ועשיו שנזכר בתורה. He's not the only one who is not worthy2:08that's mentioned in the Torah.2:10We find Paro spoke in the Torah,2:12and we learn from him.2:15Bilam spoke in the— I mean, Esav spoke in the Torah.2:17Avimelech. All these people were2:20resha'im, and yet their words are found in the Torah.2:23And if you read those words,2:25you will get sachar, you get reward as learning Torah.2:31והיה זה אצלם, ועל ידי דיבורם נתגלה לנו. But their words, whatever words were,2:34were by them,2:35and that's how it was revealed to us.2:37The whole story of Avimelech, we learn from there2:39that if a person prays for somebody else,2:42then he gets answered first.2:44You know, we learn that from2:45Avimelech, and if it wasn't for Avimelech doing his2:47reshaut, we wouldn't learn it.2:50He's not going to tell me Avimelech was a big tzaddik,2:53and the words that were said by2:57Esav, just because everybody's learning it,2:59are you going to say,3:00Whoa, what a reward Esav must be getting.3:03His divrei Torah is spread throughout the whole land,3:06everywhere, throughout all the generations.3:08Apparently not, right?3:11וכן אמרו בפרק חלק. Listen to this.3:13It brings a beautiful, another beautiful proof.3:15We know that David HaMelech prayed for certain people3:18that were big3:20resha'im, and these people were listed in the3:22Mishnah as not having a portion3:25in Olam Haba. Two individuals were Doeg and3:29Achitofel. Doeg, who was known as Doeg HaAdomi, and3:32Achitofel. Now you should just know about3:33Doeg, because when we speak about him in for a second,3:35Doeg HaAdomi was— The head of the Sanhedrin,3:39the Gemara says,3:40he was the head of the Sanhedrin.3:42Yet he was the one who was responsible3:46for carrying out the killing3:49and really responsible3:52for giving the psak din3:54against the killing of,3:56or for the killing of, the Kohanim3:59in the city of Nov.4:01An entire city.4:02I mean, even an entire city of Kohanim,4:04that they were living in the city called Nov.4:07The whole city was wiped out,4:10all because of4:12Nov, all because of Doeg. He's the one who reported4:15false testimony4:16that they were siding with4:18David. He's the one that instigated4:19the whole fight between David and4:21Shaul, and he's the one who kept it alive,4:23and he is also the one that went out4:24and actually killed out the people in Nov.4:28Okay? This is Doeg Edomi,4:29and he was the head of the Sanhedrin.4:32Now, he is one of those people4:34that...4:36So now, the Gemara says4:39in Masechet Sanhedrin that4:41David, when he prayed against4:42Doeg, he said like this:4:47First, Chazal tell us4:49that David prayed4:50that Doeg should not be4:51zocheh to get4:53Olam Haba, and as the Mishnah says,4:54he did not get4:56Olam Haba. He's one of the people4:57that4:58are listed that ein lahem chelek l'Olam Haba, that don't have a share5:00when it comes to5:02Olam Haba. Fine.5:03V'achar kach, and then David prayed,5:08that his teachings,5:10his5:12halachot—and he knew a lot of5:14halachot, he knew a lot of Torah.5:15In fact, the Gemara says5:16that David knew the precise location5:19of the Beit HaMikdash.5:20Keep in mind,5:21it was only Shlomo5:22who built the Beit HaMikdash.5:23Today we know exactly5:24where the Beit HaMikdash was5:25and is supposed to be.5:27Back then, nobody knew.5:29They knew it was supposed to5:30be in5:31Yerushalayim. Who knew?5:32Shmuel Hanavi taught5:33David5:34HaMelech. How did Shmuel5:35Hanavi know? Well, he was a navi,5:36and he was5:37zocheh that he got a5:38nevuah to know exactly5:40the precise location5:41of the Beit HaMikdash.5:42And he taught it to5:43David, and the Gemara says5:44in Masechet Zevachim, I believe,5:46that he taught it to5:49him based on the5:50pesukim. They were able to analyze the5:51pesukim and to fit it with the5:53nevuah for the precise location5:54of Beit HaMikdash.5:56There was an unbelievable level,5:58the Gemara says,5:58for a person to know6:00the precise location6:01of Beit HaMikdash.6:02Now, as amazing as that sounds,6:06and you can see6:06what kind of level David was on,6:08that he knew the precise location,6:09the Gemara says6:10there was another person6:10that also knew.6:11And who was that?6:12Doeg6:13HaEdomi. Doeg HaEdomi was such a6:15genius in Torah6:16that he also was able6:17to figure it out on his own.6:19In fact, that's what really6:20bothered Doeg HaEdomi about David,6:22is that Doeg6:23HaEdomi figured out—he thought6:24he was the gadol hador,6:26you know, like he figured it6:27out—and now all of6:28a sudden David, who was much younger than him,6:30comes along,6:31and he also6:32is a big talmid chacham like that,6:34so he felt that little competition,6:35based on the Gemara,6:37and whatever.6:38In any case,6:38he was clearly6:39not such a good person.6:41So Doeg6:43HaEdomi really had a lot of Torah,6:45and people were saying6:45divrei Torah in his name.6:47And he says,6:48Rav Tzadok,6:49the Gemara tells us clearly6:50that first David prayed6:52that Doeg should not have6:53the share to Olam Haba,6:54and then he prayed6:55that people should not say6:57his teachings in the Beit7:00Midrash. Comes Rav Tzadok and says,7:06Harei de'efshar sheyomru shemata mishmei, af al pi she'eino chelek l'Olam Haba. You see from here7:07a clear proof.7:08People were saying7:10divrei Torah in the name of Doeg7:11before David prayed7:12that they shouldn't say7:13his divrei Torah.7:15But at that point,7:16David already prayed,7:17and it was accepted that7:19Doeg should not be7:21zocheh to Olam Haba.7:23So imagine living in that period of7:25time, in between the two prayers of David.7:27People are saying7:28that Divrei Torah of a murderer,7:32of a wicked person,7:33that at the time7:34people didn't know that.7:35At the time,7:37Doeg was viewed7:39as the7:41gadol hador, was viewed as7:42the head of the Sanhedrin,7:43the genius of the generation.7:45And people were saying7:46his divrei Torah,7:47and people were learning it,7:49and the Beit7:50Midrash would say,7:51But Doeg,7:52Chacham Doeg says this,7:54and Rav Doeg says this,7:55and Rabbi7:56Adomi—I don't know if his last name7:57was Adomi—but Doeg7:59Adomi, and they would...8:00Go back and forth. What are you talking about?8:03And you're saying it in the name of a person that doesn't even have a share in Olam Haba.8:07This is what Rav Tzadok is coming to prove in his trying to say.8:11So you see that even though there are people that have their divrei Torah spread8:16and people are dealing with their divrei Torah, it doesn't prove anything.8:21It doesn't prove anything.8:23I don't know if they were also discussing David HaMelech's Torah back then.8:26I can imagine the times of Shaul HaMelech, or when things got sour between Shaul and David.8:33I don't believe they were saying divrei Torah in the name of David HaMelech.8:38I don't believe. I don't know. I'm not sure. I'm not saying for sure. I'm not saying that.8:42But if you think about it for a second, if David8:47HaMelech—if somebody comes into the beit midrash and says, David HaMelech says so,8:50say, Ah, get that guy out of here. Are you kidding me?8:53The Rodef? Who's that guy?8:56And Doeg would say, You're speaking about8:59an apikores. How did he bring him into the beit midrash?9:00When it was exactly the opposite.9:03Doeg is the person that doesn't have a chelek l'Olam Haba, and David does.9:08Not only does he have a chelek l'Olam Haba, he is even able to ask Hashem9:14who should get a chelek l'Olam Haba or not.9:17David was the real9:18chassid. So that proves the point of Tzadok wanted to say from the beginning,9:23that just because a person's divrei Torah,9:27which we know is like really the barometer of the success of a person,9:31his divrei Torah, just because a person's divrei Torah is being taught and spread everywhere,9:38it doesn't mean that he's necessarily greater than the other guy.9:40V'chein, here's another proof.9:42Be'acher. Who's9:45Acher? When it talks about Acher, it's Shabbtai ben Avuya, who is really one of the9:50Tannaim. In fact, the Gemara Masechet Chagigah says there were four people that were zocheh to enter the Pardes.9:55Pardes is like the spiritual realm that was very, very difficult to enter there.10:00Rabbi Akiva was one of them, and Elisha ben Avuya was also one of them.10:03However, after entering such a high level...10:07Those who were not on the level, unfortunately, four people that10:09entered, all three out of the four had problems.10:13One of them died, one of them went crazy.10:17Elisha ben Avuyah, who entered such a level, when he came out,10:21he became complete apikorus. He became a10:25non-believer. And only Rabbi Akiva was able to enter and get out of there in peace,10:29and it didn't affect him.10:32Now this Elisha ben Avuyah, when he came out,10:34remember he was this huge, huge10:36talmid chacham. In fact, as we can soon see, he was also the rabbi of Rabbi Meir Baal HaNes.10:41Rabbi Meir Baal HaNes would walk with him, and he would learn from him,10:43and then he would say things in his name.10:45This Acher, this person, excuse me, Elisha ben Avuyah was nicknamed10:50Acher because after he went off, they nicknamed him10:53Acher. So, וכן באחר, he says,11:00Hazal tell us that in the beginning, his punishment was,11:06because he went so off after being such a big tzaddik,11:10is that he is not zocheh to come to11:15Olam Haba. ואפילו הכי אמר רבי מאיר שמועת מפיו. And even though he didn't have a portion11:18to Olam Haba, that was the din in Shamayim about him.11:19In fact, even Acher heard that.11:21He said, I heard it. I heard them say,11:25שובו בנים שובבים ולא אחר. Do teshuva, everybody, even those who went way off, do11:28teshuva, but not you, Acher. You cannot do11:29teshuva. That means he knew. He heard that he has no11:33chelek in Olam Haba. And still, Rabbi Meir was saying divrei Torah in his name.11:39וכמו שאמרו הקדמונים, בכל מקום אחרים היינו מה שלמד מאחר. He said the Sefarim bring down11:42that whenever—we know that Rabbi Meir was called Acherim based on a certain11:47incident—and whenever Chazal bring a halacha in the name of11:50Aharim, which we know is Rabbi11:51Meir, it's that the Torah that he happened to have learned from11:54Acher. It's a very interesting idea.11:56In any case. He says,11:58v'chein. So you see that Rabbi Meir was still saying things in the name of12:02Acher, even though he had no portion12:03in Olam Haba. Now the story continues with him.12:08V'chen, achar kach adayin haya b'Gehinam ad zman Rabbi Yochanan. In the Itim b'Hagahah, the Gemara continues and says12:10that after Rabbi Meir passed away,12:14he says, I'm going to get him somewhere.12:16He pushed him at least into12:18Gehinam, because Gehinam is the first step before entering12:22Olam Haba. And when he was still in Gehinam, right,12:25until Rabbi Yochanan came,12:27and Rabbi Yochanan says, I'm going to get him out of12:33Gehinam. So one second.12:35Rabbi Yochanan—look back in the history for a second.12:38Rabbi Meir passed away12:40when Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi,12:42who is the one who put the Mishnayot together,12:44was still a young man.12:46Rabbi Yochanan was a student of Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi.12:52You got the lineage a little bit?12:54One more time.12:54The Gemara tells us12:56Rabbi Akiva was also the rabbi of Rabbi Meir Baal12:59Hanes, and Rabbi Akiva and Elisha ben Avuyah were contemporaries.13:02They lived at the same time.13:04Rabbi Meir learned from both of them,13:05although his primary rabbi would probably be Rabbi13:09Akiva, but he still also learned from Elisha13:12ben Avuyah. Now, the day—the Gemara tells13:15us—the day Rabbi Akiva passed away13:17is the day that Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi was born.13:19And Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi says,13:21I was never zocheh to actually see Rabbi13:22Meir, but I saw the back of Rabbi13:24Meir, and that's really the reason why I'm so great,13:27is because I saw just the back of Rabbi13:28Meir. So clearly Rabbi Meir was13:31alive—excuse me, Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi,13:34who organized the Mishnayot and put them together,13:36he was alive at the time of Rabbi13:39Meir, although for a short while.13:40I would say maybe three years old, four years old,13:43whatever. Maybe he was able to remember the back of Rabbi13:47Meir. Then, after what we see later on,13:49Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi got older.13:52He put together all the13:54Mishnayot, including13:55Masechet Avot, Pirkei Avot, which we know as13:57Pirkei Avot, and in there there is a teaching13:59in the name of Elisha14:01ben Avuyah. Now, at that moment, at that time,14:04Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi put this together,14:07where was Elisha14:10ben Avuyah? Well, after the death of Rabbi14:11Meir, Rabbi Meir was able to push him from nowhere14:13to put him into Gehenna,14:16until Rabbi Yochanan passed away,14:18who was able to take him out of Gehenna.14:20And Rabbi Yochanan was a student of Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi,14:22who died way after Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi.14:25So says Rav Tzadok, you see14:27that even though he was in Gehenna,14:30still Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi came14:32and put a teaching of Elisha14:35ben Avuyah in14:38Pirkei Avot. Why?14:40Lefi sheshimu'otav hem Torat emet, vedivrei Torah mamash. So even though the person is not worthy14:44of entering Olam Haba, he's in Gehenna,14:46but his teaching was something chashuv that we needed,14:50and therefore we entered it,14:51we placed it in14:53Pirkei Avot. Now, rabotai, nobody could come now and say14:57he's a rasha, chas v'shalom. He got his din, and he's in15:00an amazing place in Olam Haba, I'm sure.15:02But at the time,15:04that's what Rav Tzadok is trying to prove.15:05At the time when people were learning his Torah,15:08it doesn't really reflect15:09on who the person really is.15:15So now,15:16comes back to,15:17if that's not the barometer,15:19a person is teaching Torah,15:20and how does he know that he's really doing the right thing?15:22So he says a person really needs15:24a tremendous amount of mercy from HaKadosh Baruch Hu15:26and compassion, that whatever he's learning15:27should actually be part of him,15:30shehukach, that what you're learning15:32should be, that you should be exactly what15:36you're learning,15:39like the divrei Torah that he's learning,15:40that he's expressing.15:41It should not be just lip service.15:43It should not just be ideas.15:45That's the difference between15:46the Oreganomi and everybody else.15:48The Oreganomi, of course, knew a lot of Torah,15:49but it wasn't him.15:51I don't live it.15:52Torah says,15:55Deracheha darchei noam v'chol netivoteha shalom. Its ways are ways of peace.15:57If you're a person that's making fights because of the Torah.16:00You're doing something wrong. If you're a person that's not pleasant, then something's wrong.16:04If you're not happy, if you're not happy, pikudei Hashem yesharim mesamchei lev. You have to be happy.16:12Not because you have to be happy, but it should be a natural consequence of learning Torah.16:19When you learn Torah, you are a happy person. If you're not happy, you're doing something wrong.16:24And therefore, you need to pray. You need to ... that Hashem should help you16:29that whatever you're learning should be internalized and become part of you.16:35Like Chazal tell us that the Torah of Doeg, which, like we saw already, was a lot.16:40He knew a lot of Torah, was only from what we call lip service, only from the lips and out.16:45It was external.16:48It wasn't absorbed inside of him. It wasn't part of him.16:52It wasn't part of his heart that he should be what he's learning.16:55Like it says over there in the Gemara,17:00... Hashem wants a person's heart, but if his heart is empty of Torah, so what is he getting?17:08... says if a person has still questions and doubts in his heart about what he is learning,17:16then he hasn't really internalized what he's learning yet.17:20There can be questions that you don't know the answer to, but it doesn't mean that you have doubts.17:25A person can't have doubts. If you have doubts, you're doing something wrong.17:29And therefore, you should have a natural consequence of learning and enjoying and living a life of Torah.17:35And when it's not that way, it could be something external. And that type of Torah,17:40although, again, a person may be the biggest, you know, spreader of the Torah,17:45that doesn't mean anything. It could be just external,17:48and it just happens to be he happens to be in possession of words that everybody needs to hear right now.17:53I would like to also add, ... this doesn't mean that if you see people that are zoche, Baruch Hashem,18:00that their shiurim are everywhere and their sefarim are everywhere, it doesn't mean that they're18:04off. It doesn't mean that18:06they don't have a chelek l'Olam Haba. It doesn't mean that at all,18:09chas v'shalom. What we're saying is it just doesn't prove it, that's all.18:12But not to take away, chas v'shalom, from the people that are, Baruch Hashem,18:15a lot of people today in Klal Yisrael that are spreading Torah.18:19They have a lot of shiurim and sefarim, and people are learning their Torah,18:23and Baruch Hashem, they're doing tremendous things,18:26and they have some sort of zechut.18:28Again, it doesn't define it.18:31You know, most people probably heard of, you know, the famous speakers on the internet and everything else,18:37and they've never heard of the big, you know, some people like Rav Chaim18:41Kanievsky. Only recently people have heard of him,18:42and they never heard of his sefarim ten years ago.18:44This is already—he's already gives blessings. They never heard of his Torah.18:46Meanwhile, he's a tremendous18:49talmid chacham, but it's not defined on popularity.18:51That's all. Popularity is not what defines it.