Torah · MussarMussar145. Misvot Without a SoulTzidkat HaTzadikPart 145Rabbi Uri Nahum · December 25, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0019:54Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat HaTzadik, אות קמ״ה, 145.0:04Bechol0:07pe'ulat ha'adam, in every action a person takes, all the actions that person does,0:17hama'aseh hu kemo haguf, vehamachashavah neshamah. The action a person is doing,0:19the act itself, well, let's say, for example, the person is sitting in the sukkah.0:23The act of just sitting in the sukkah and eating in the0:25sukkah, that's like the body, and the kavanah and the thought that he's thinking0:30is like the soul. So halacha tells us, for example, when you sit in the sukkah,0:34it says in the pasuk,0:39Lemaan yed'u doroteichem ki basukkot hoshavti et Bnei Yisrael,0:41and all your future generations should know0:44that I placed the Jewish people in the sukkot, and that's a halacha that when0:48you sit in the sukkah, you're supposed to be thinking0:50of a reminder, just like Hashem made sukkot,0:53or ananei hakavod for the Jewish people when they came out of0:57Mitzrayim, that's what I'm supposed to be thinking now also when I'm sitting in the sukkah.1:00So it comes out that there's every single1:03mitzvah—there's the same way, by the way—every single mitzvah, there is what you're1:07thinking about and what you're doing.1:10Veguvilo deShmaya noklum. And as is brought down,1:13for example, by Piskei deZimra, when1:17Maran says that it's better to read a little bit with1:21kavanah than a lot without kavanah, which means, again, the same idea,1:24because a lot without kavanah, it's like a guf without a neshamah; it's like a1:27body without a soul. When you read so many perakim and you're1:30not thinking, you're thinking about what am I going to do next1:33and what errands I have to run today, so there's a body but there's no soul.1:38It says, Veguvilo deShmaya eino klum. A body without a soul means nothing.1:42Lechach, that's why we find it's actually like that in other areas in halacha.1:46For example, metasek. Mitasek is1:51patur ve'eino k'shogeg. When a person, to give you a little background of this, in halacha1:55we find on Hilchot Shabbat, for example, a person could transgress,1:59could do the same issur in four different ways. Let's assume2:02that putting on a light switch on Shabbat is an issur min haTorah. Let's2:06assume. I'm not going into the nitty-gritty of the details right now,2:09but let's assume. Putting on a light on Shabbat is2:12an issur min haTorah. Good? There's four different ways a person2:15could do this act, and actually the consequences2:17will be different in each situation. Let's go from the worst2:21to the best. I don't know, worst, but basically the2:25harshest punishment to the least punishment.2:28Let's begin. The harshest punishment is a person2:31is about to put on the light, and he's warned by two kosher witnesses,2:34and he's told, What you're about to do is an issur d'oraita. You're breaking2:38Shabbat. If you break Shabbat, you're going to be2:40chayav mitat sekilah, and he does it anyway. He puts on the light switch,2:45then he's2:46chayav mitat sekilah. They take him—we used to have the2:49Sanhedrin—and they execute him. Worst punishment from the2:54arba mitot. Why? He was warned, and he did it anyway. He didn't care.2:57Case number two: a person wakes up, looks around, he sees there's3:02no—Baruch Hashem, last time my neighbor got in trouble for that. He looks around, he knows that3:06Shabbat. He knows that you can't put on the light3:08on Shabbat, and he puts on the light anyway, which means he did it b'mezid, he did it on purpose.3:12However, he was not warned by two witnesses.3:15In that case, the person's consequence is, he's chayav karet.3:19Hashem will take care of it in His own way.3:22Okay, case number three. A person wakes up,3:26and one of two situations makes the following case3:30a shogeg. What does that mean, a shogeg? It means everybody thinks shogeg means3:34mistake. Yes and no. Shogeg means specifically either he3:38woke up, he thought it was Sunday. And he wanted to put on the light. He had3:41intention to put on the light. The only thing is, he thought it was actually3:44Sunday, so he puts on the light, and then somebody says to him, Shabbat shalom,3:47neighbor, and he remembers, oh, it was Shabbat. That3:52scenario, that scenario is called3:54a shogeg. Another form that could also be shogeg is, a person wakes up, he knows it's Shabbat,3:59but he doesn't know that putting on a light is asur.4:03He heard in a class somewhere, he got it mixed up. He thought that putting on a light4:06on Shabbat is not a problem, so he puts on the light. Comes to shul that morning, and the4:12rabbi is giving a class explaining why putting on a light is4:15asur min haTorah. That's also another form of shogeg. In both cases, there was some sort of4:20kavanah. There was kavanah to put on the light, but4:24either he didn't know it was Shabbat, or he didn't know that putting on the4:27light is asur. That's scenario number three. Scenario4:30number four. Scenario number four is a guy is4:33walking, and he trips, and he's trying to catch himself that he shouldn't fall, and he4:40reaches out with his arm, and by accident he ends up4:43putting on the lights. This is called4:48mitasek, where the act of putting on the light came completely as a side point. He4:51wasn't thinking about it. He was involved in something else, like4:54the word mitasek means, and as a side way, the light went on.4:58In mitasek, what's the consequence? And there's nothing.5:02Unlike the shogeg, a guy who did break Shabbat b'shogeg is chayav to bring a5:07korban chatat, and a guy b'mezid is chayav karet, and a guy who did it with5:10warning is chayav sekilah. In mitasek, there's no consequence whatsoever.5:14So he explains, based on what we're saying till now, this is why mitasek is5:21patur, ve'eino k'shogeg, d'ha kol p'nei mitkaven la'aseh. It's not like the guy5:23who's shogeg, who at least has kavanah to do an action,5:25ma she'ein ken mitasek, she'ein shum kavanah machshavah, because mitasek is a body without a5:30soul. There's no soul whatsoever in the act that he did, therefore5:34has no ramification, has no significance whatsoever.5:38Ah, you tell me he broke Shabbat, I'm watching from the outside, he put on the5:42light. It's nothing. The act without a5:45machshavah is zero. Now, that is the same way we're5:50saying also, imagine doing a mitzvah as a mitasek, where there's no5:54machshavah. It's the same idea. However, we do find an exception5:59for the patur of metasek. We do find an exception where a6:03person, we do say that a person, although he's metasek, but he will still be6:07chayav. For example, the Gemara says two exceptions, and that is6:10bechalavim ve'arayot. That means a person6:14ate food, thinking it's all kosher, and there was6:17a fat, one of the forbidden fats known as6:20chelev inside of it. Or a person went to bed thinking that his wife was6:24in bed, and it turns out to be somebody else's wife, and he had no clue.6:29He's thinking, his machshava is that it's his wife the whole time.6:32He's thinking that he's eating a kosher piece of meat, doesn't know that there's6:35chelev in it. There we say he's chayav. Why?6:40Says the Gemara, sheken heneh, because at the end of the day he had6:42benefit from the issur. Unlike the case of a guy who6:45slips and puts on the light, even though it might have been a dark room,6:48but at the end of the day he was metasek. He didn't get hana'ah from the6:54aveirah as it's happening. Here, as the aveirah was happening,6:56he's getting a7:02hana'ah. Uv'hana'at ha'adam אי אפשר שלא יתכוון בה עליהם כלשהו על כל פנים. And when a person is getting an enjoyment, it can't be that there's no7:07intention. Now, he might not, again, he may not know that what he's doing is7:11assur, but there's some sort of kavanah that he's enjoying. Why is that?7:18Because the nature of a person is that he feels7:21any time that he's enjoying himself, even though he doesn't remember exactly how7:26it happened, but he feels it.7:31Veyadua, נשמה שנתת בי טהורה. And we all know what we say in the morning. We say, Hashem, the soul that7:36You've given inside of me is pure.7:40ולכך מחשבה רעה אין הקדוש ברוך הוא מצרפה למעשה. That's why we say, being that we have in7:44neshama that is pure, we have a rule, and that is that if a person—7:50Planned on doing something evil, planned on doing7:54an aveira, but he didn't end up doing the aveira. So his machshava, now we said7:58beforehand that machshava is everything.8:00So if so, if there's in the neshama without a guf, it should also be something.8:05Meaning, if a person planned to do an aveira, he was planning to go to a non-kosher restaurant on Yom Kippur.8:11Says, No, I can't stand this anymore. Get out of here already. If I'm going to eat, let me enjoy myself.8:16I'm going to go on Yom Kippur. All the restaurants are closed. Everybody's in shul. Nobody will see me.8:21I'm going to go, and I'm going to go eat, you know, the non-kosher food.8:26He didn't realize that the restaurant was closed. So he gets to the place. He walks for a mile or two.8:33He gets to the restaurant. The restaurant was closed. It's under renovation. They moved, whatever. It's not there.8:38Does he get the sin for eating on Yom Kippur? If the machshava has everything, that should be so.8:43And he says, No, that's a halacha. The halacha is, machshava ra'ah, Hashem does not consider like an action if there was no action.8:52Why is that so? Isn't everything about the machshava? And the answer is that we said, because the neshama, in its essence, it's pure.9:02The answer is that really the soul is pure, and if there's a plan to do an aveira, it's because of some foolishness that came into the person,9:14as Chazal tell us, Ein adam over aveira ela im ken nichnas bo ruach shtut. A person does not do an aveira unless there is a spirit of foolishness that enters him.9:26What is that? Shehu dimyon ha-medameh le-chochma ke-kof bifnei adam, ke-yadua. Because the shtut, the foolishness, if you think about it, it's basically like a monkey.9:41Monkey looks like he's intellectual, you know. Somebody sent me a video. Unbelievable.9:46Once went on a vacation, and... I guess there's monkeys just roaming around. I don't know what these places are, these islands, whatever.9:53The monkey's just rolling around, and there was a person who had no clue that there was a monkey being following, that the monkey following them.10:01And the person, whatever he's doing, the monkey behind was actually imitating every little move.10:05They stopped, the monkey stops. They bend over, the monkey bends over.10:10Scratch their head, they check their phone, the monkey reaches into—he's just copying everything.10:15We have a saying in English called monkey see, monkey do,10:18right? They just copy. Now, if you look at the monkey separately, without looking at the human being, you would think the monkey's so smart.10:26The monkey might be smart for an animal, but you're not going to hire them as your CEO, even though they're copying your CEO.10:34So, shtut, when a person doesn't have emunah, because at that moment he thinks what he's doing is correct.10:40It's a shoteh, it's a fool. It's like a monkey. You think you're smart, but you're foolish10:47when you get to—it's like a teenager, you know. For those who understand, they have teenager children, and they think they know everything,10:52and they're convinced, and you talk to them, and they talk with such, you know, convincing voices and attitude, and that's the way it is.11:00You know, I might be a little bit older than a teenager, but I still remember my teenage foolish years, right?11:06And I would stand and I would defend certain types of people, and I would defend certain actions,11:11and that's all these idealists are, those young people are fools, because they don't know the reality of the world.11:17And yeah, you know, all these movements that have been created in the world always started by young people,11:23people that don't really have experience, and they want to make a change, and they may have good intentions.11:27Shtut that enters. It's not real chochmah. Real chochmah is something that's tested and tried.11:35So he says,11:41Rak keshiyotzei lepo'al b'ma'aseh uva'asiyah, sham hu makom shlitat ha'rav k'echad demyon. However, when the foolishness actually gets translated to action, now you've created a body and soul,11:48so now you actually brought it into the world. Right?11:52In idea, you know, once upon a time, I mean, if you read books from the olden days, you know, it's written, the book has value.12:02Anything that's been authored, anything that's been printed, it holds weight, it carries weight. It's something of significance.12:08We know today that's completely not true.12:11Anybody could text any time they want, they can write whatever they want, they can print whatever they want.12:16Means nothing if something is written down.12:18So he says,12:21b'tshuvah. Okay, so that's the same idea also over here. The foolishness, when it gets written, when it happens, it's like you brought it into the world now.12:32Uv'tshuvah shelokeach kol ha'machshavot u'mahaziran l'mekoran, and when the person does teshuvah, which is—what's teshuvah? Regret.12:36The main part of teshuvah is regret, because the action that you did, it can't be undone12:40unless, you know, the Torah gave you permission to undo it, like returning a lost item, actually returning a stolen item.12:46So regular teshuvah, though most of the time, is regret, and not taking back the action, but taking back the12:54machshavah. So how does teshuvah work? When you take those12:56machshavot u'mahaziran l'mekoran, you bring back to the original source, realizing, hey, I was a fool.13:00There's a ruach tumah that entered me. What was I thinking going to the restaurant on Yom Kippur?13:07So it comes out, when I did an action of real sin, I went on Yom Kippur and actually ate,13:12and then I come and I regret, I can't believe I ate on Yom Kippur, and it was horrible, what was I thinking?13:18You're bringing—you're taking away the machshavah, the soul of that action. What's left?13:22Only the action. The action without a soul is nothing, and therefore it's dead, and it dies,13:28and that's why it can disappear.13:30However, we do find, Chazal tell us, that not everything is mitkaper with just teshuvah.13:36You need to—certain aveirot actually needs a certain... Purification, certain yisurim, certain sufferings in order to cleanse it.13:50Neged haguf sheyechaleh me'aher, because why is that so? Because we need to burn that body of sin.13:55We can't talk about it much over here, but basically that's the idea of13:59yisurim. Hazal tell us that you need to go. A person who does teshuvah,14:03there's certain teshuvah, there's certain aveirot that teshuvah can be forgiven immediately.14:06There's certain aveirot that you need to go wait another Yom Kippur.14:09There's certain aveirot a person needs to go through suffering,14:13and there's certain ones that only once the person dies, then he's completely forgiven.14:17And he doesn't talk about it at length over here, and we're not going to do it either14:21because, as you're running, you know, the time is not letting us. But there's much to talk about over here why it has to be done.14:28He says,14:32The same thing that we said now by aveirot also works with the mitzvot.14:38A machshavah tovah, a good intention, when it's combined with a good deed, it's14:46mitztaref. It joins together in truth.14:50U'ma'aseh belo machshavah hu b'olam asiyah, and just doing an action without thinking about it. Let's say you're just giving charity,14:53not thinking, you're putting tzedakah, you're putting on14:56tefillin, not thinking, you're saying Birkat Hamazon without thinking, you're praying without thinking.14:59So it's an action, right?15:02It's in the world of15:14asiyah. אז הנה מה שאיש ירא ה' במצוותיו חפץ מאוד, רמוז על, וטוב לך לקטי כדואה אשרך בעולם הזה וטוב לך לעולם הבא, שהוא ביור העניין שם, מחשבה, כפי שהשיג על פסוק אז ישיר. He's stuck in a lot of15:16stuff. Basically, Chazal tell us,15:23Ashrecha v'tov lach. Ashrecha ba'olam hazeh v'tov lach l'olam haba. Chazal say on the pasuk,15:25You are fortunate and it's good for you.15:27You're fortunate in this world and it's good for you in the15:31olam haba. So you see that there is two types of rewards, in this world and in15:36olam haba. In this world, which is the world of asiyah, you're fortunate for doing a mitzvah15:41because that is your reward for the action that you've done.15:45So you get in this world, you're fortunate.15:48And tov lach l'olam haba, that's for the machshava that you had.15:52As we know that the letter yud represents15:55machshava, as we know when Chazal, when she says,15:57Az yashir Moshe, Hashem machshava, yud is always...16:00The lashon that's used when you want to talk about a third person doing something in the future,16:04which is basically an idea, a thought, and a plan to do something even though it hasn't been done yet.16:10And Chazal also tell us that the world to come, Olam Haba, is created with the letter yud.16:15It's all one and the same. You get the reward of Olam Haba based on the16:21machshava, which is the intention and the kavanah the person has.16:27V'yirei Hashem ha'oved b'maaseh rak asher chaval al zeh. A person who's God-fearing, who serves Hashem in Olam Hazeh, he does all the good deeds,16:33not with the machshava, he gets the ashrecha, he gets his reward that he's portion16:44in Olam Hazeh. But you should just know that don't think it's only Olam Hazeh, because at the end of the day16:48the body will receive its reward not only here, but also that will be resurrected16:52and will come back to life16:54in Techiyat HaMetim. So even the reward for a mitzvah which is Olam Hazeh, it has more than just17:00Olam Hazeh. It extends even to the world of17:14Techiyat HaMetim. לכך, דבר זה הוא שבח ושורש בכל העולמות מהשזה ושב עולם הזה. That's why therefore when we say ashrecha, when a person is a tzaddik and he does a mitzvah, it's actually not just good for him in the world of Asiyah, but it's good for him in all the worlds.17:26ואף על פי ששם אינו כן, מכל מקום כך מושרש שם במעלה זו, שבעולם הזה הוא צדיק. Even though in those higher worlds, which there, you know, the greatness of a person is based on his17:34machshava, and he's really not on the level of machshava because he wasn't thinking,17:37still the fact that he is in Olam Hazeh and he is doing a mitzvah,17:41it has a little bit of an effect for17:47Olam Haba. Of those other worlds, when they consider him a tzaddik.18:03אבל הנהנה מגיע כפיו, שהוא אינו מתעסק כנזכר לעיל, שכן הנהנה שההנאה הוא הרגשת המחשבה. It says in the pasuk, יגיע כפיך כי תאכל, אשריך וטוב לך. A person who earns from his own actions,18:08he earns his reward from his own18:12toil. It's a person that is not mitasek. That's not just doing a mitzvah without18:17machshava; he's doing it with18:19machshava. יגיע כפיך, it's his18:21toil. And that person who gets the hana'ah, because when you enjoy what you're doing,18:25when you think about what you're doing, you enjoy it.18:27And that enjoyment, like we said, even18:29mitasek by aveirah, it's considered something.18:31So kavachomer here by mitzvah, it's considered something as well.18:43ודווקא זה כדי שאמרו לאדם: טוב מעטים לו מפרי מעשיו, ובא אחרי היגיעה כפיים במעשה אחר, כך בין אם אותו מן העולם הבא, ואז זוכה לטוב לך גם עולם הבא. He says an amazing thing over here.18:48Chazal tell us that a good person, they give him a little bit of a taste from the fruits of his actions.18:53What does that mean?18:55How does a person get to that?18:57Sometimes a person zocheh, you know, like it says,19:01מגגלין זכות על ידי זכאי. It means the person has to be first19:04zocheh. When a person works19:07and toils, then sometimes even accidents come his way,19:09mitzvot are by accident come his way.19:12You know, there's a famous anecdote,19:16excuse me, that people always talk about,19:18that if you drop a coin and somebody picks it up19:21and he happens to be, he gets benefit from it,19:23you could get also rewarded that way.19:25And yeah, there's truth to that,19:27because why is a person19:29zocheh that his mistakes turn into mitzvot?19:32It says because of his יגיע כפיך and other places,19:34and Hashem allows him or sets him up in a way19:37that he could still earn mitzvot19:41through other ways, through other deeds.19:43That's what he's saying over here.19:45The יגיע כפיך is19:47mezakeh the person that afterwards19:49even things are done without19:51machshava, he gets it as well.