Torah · MussarMussar140. Knowing What’s Really Right and WrongTzidkat HaTzadikPart 140Rabbi Uri Nahum · December 18, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0016:28Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat HaTzadik, אות קמ״ם, 140.0:04I’d just like to point out that today is the Sunday0:08after Parashat Vayeshev, where we just read about the dreams0:12of Yosef, and we’re going to read this Shabbat,0:16בעזרת השם, coming up, the dreams of0:20Paro. Why am I pointing this out? Because I believe it’s great that there’s a connection0:24over here, that we speak about dreams again in today’s piece.0:27He says, Kol zeman0:31she’adam bishlemut. As long as a person is not yet0:35in that stage of perfection, meaning throughout our whole life0:39we’re never perfect. If we’re perfect, we wouldn’t be here anymore. We’re here to0:43perfect ourselves, but we strive and we work and we work.0:46But then we reach a stage of perfecting ourselves. So as long0:51as we didn’t get to that stage yet, kol—he should know the following point, and that is,0:55Kol mah shemedameh lo yeda shehu hamashal hefech. Whatever he thinks,1:00he should just know that whatever he’s thinking is exactly the opposite1:03of the truth. Like it says in the pasuk,1:07like it says,1:11Ha’omrim lara tov v’latov ra. Like the pasuk says about certain people, they used to say about what’s evil is really good,1:15what’s good is really evil. And as Chazal tell us1:18these famous words,1:19Olam hafuch ra’iti, that he saw an opposite1:23world. I would like to just go back on that Gemara1:28in Masechet Pesachim and to just recap the story very quickly, because1:31it’s going to come up a little bit later on and we need to know some of the details.1:34The Gemara says about a certain rabbi that was very, very sick, and they came to visit him, and right as the1:39rabbis came to visit him, they saw that he passed away. But a little bit1:43later, all of a sudden he comes back.1:46They bring him back. I mean, he's back to life, and they start1:49talking to him and said, What did you see? He says,1:53Olam hafuch ra'iti. He says, Over there in the world of truth, I saw an opposite world.1:59Elyonim lematah, and the people that in this world,2:01like considered very chashuv, on top, are on the bottom,2:06and tachtonim lema'alah, and the ones on the bottom are really on top.2:09And then they ask him, What about us,2:12Talmidei Chachamim? And he answers them. He says,2:17Yeah, for you, Talmidei Chachamim, that, he says, the same way you are here,2:20you're also the way over there. That's what the Gemara says over there.2:22Now he says over here, when the Gemara says that point,2:26Olam hafuch ra'iti, you should know that, why is2:30it olam hafuch? Meaning to say that in this world, it's really upside-down world. What's the real world?2:34Is it the world over there or what we're seeing over here?2:36And the answer is, this world over here is not the real.2:40So what we see in this world as people that are making it2:44and are high up may not be necessarily what is going on over there2:48in that world. And that's what he's saying. And that means2:51even what we think in this world—even, look, we see in this world this guy is successful.2:55What we see is not necessarily successful. Why? Because3:00we live in this world and we don't understand what really is the good,3:04what really is not the good. So he says over here,3:10U'mah shenir'eh lo letov yuchal lihyot she'ein bo mamash, v'chen lehefech. And therefore, what we think is good3:13may not necessarily be good.3:15And the opposite, what we think is bad may not necessarily be bad; it's actually good.3:20Now this doesn't mean to say everything is exactly the opposite, because then I'll do the exact opposite of what I'm thinking.3:25But what I'm telling you is that there's no3:28for sure way of understanding.3:34ורק מי שאיר ה' יתברך עיניו בדברי תורה, דכתיב באמת. The only person3:35who is able to see things the way they really are3:38is a person who Hashem allowed him to enlighten him with the words of the Torah,3:43with what the Torah says about3:50emet. כמו שאמרו ז״ל, like Chazal taught us in Masechet Avodah Zarah, על ידי יכול לבוא על האמת. It's through Torah that a person can come to the point of truth.3:55Like it says in the same Gemara that we just quoted,3:57they asked the, the Anan, they asked this rabbi that4:02momentarily passed away, who got a glimpse4:05of the world to come, and they told4:10him, פירוש תלמידי חכמים היכי התם? How are we over there? How are we looked upon over there? And he says,4:15היכי דאיתו אנן הכא. That's how you are also over there, the same way you are in this world, it's also in that world.4:20Meaning, תלמידי חכמים, who have the Torah,4:22who study the Torah, and therefore are zocheh to the4:25truth, they see things the way they're supposed to be.4:33שהתורה מאירה בזה לאדם לעמוד על האמת, because it's the Torah4:36that enlightens a person4:38to be able to be a man of truth,4:41to see things the way they're really supposed to be.4:45ועל זה אמרו, and that's why the Gemara says, מסכת סנהדרין, עצה שיש בה דבר ה' היא תקום. It says in the4:52pasuk, עצת ה' היא תקום. What does it mean,4:54עצת ה' היא תקום? Obviously, whatever Hashem advises is going to stand.4:57And the answer is, no. Any advice that has5:00in it דבר ה', which means the Torah in it, that's what's going to really5:04be able to withstand. That's what's really going to be able to survive.5:15אבל בלאו הכי, מחשבה מועלת לבטל פירוש שיהיה הסוף ממש להפך ממה שחשב. But otherwise... Then we know that there's a machshavah, chas v'shalom, that a5:21machshavah can be mevatel. What does that mean? It means that at the end of what we think5:25and what we strive for and what we work for, what we think is really good5:29may not really be the way it really is. We don't perceive it5:33for the way it actually is.5:39וְהַסּוֹף הוּא גִּלּוּי הָאֱמֶת שֶׁיֵּשׁ בְּאוֹתוֹ דָּבָר. And it's only the end of5:41something, it's what we will discover, is when we will discover5:46if what we were doing till now was the truth or not.5:50כִּי בְּהוֹוֶה הַכֹּל אֶחָד. Because in the present,5:52everything looks the same.5:55רַק בַּסּוֹף נִכָּר. We will only be able to be recognized at the end.5:58Watch, the pasuk says,6:02שְׂפַת אֱמֶת תִּכּוֹן לָעַד. Lips of truth will become, will become correct forever.6:08And the Zohar brings a whole story about this, actually,6:11and here he quotes the Zohar in one line. He says,6:14קוֹנֵט לוֹ קְטִיב, לָא תִּכּוֹן. Where the Zohar brings over there a story6:16of one goy. He says,6:18you guys say, שְׂפַת אֱמֶת תִּכּוֹן לָעַד, right? You guys say that your truth is, which is6:23what you call the truth, the Torah is going to stand forever.6:26What we see in this world, Esav is powerful. Esav is the one who's6:31surviving. You guys are scattered amongst the earth.6:36You have no kingdom, you have no power, you have nothing. Where are you? Where are you guys?6:40What happened to שְׂפַת אֱמֶת? And the rabbi replies to him,6:45doesn't say שְׂפַת אֱמֶת תִּכּוֹן אֶת. It's not in the present, it's only תִּכּוֹן at the end.6:47All this is nothing. And really, the good understanding of this, Rav Tzadok, is6:51really to look at the entire Jewish history. For the majority of the6:55Jewish people's lives, we've been in exile, we've been tortured,6:59we've been chased away from countries, we've been persecuted,7:03we've been looked down upon. Even in the current times,7:07and you might think, hey, you know, we're living good. Maybe, yeah,7:11but don't think that our status as religious Jews is really something that people7:15look up to. The least, right? In the New York Times,7:19if you live in New York, you know that they are constantly bashing religious Jews7:23and their education. And the truth is7:27completely opposite, even in the ... that we see it, right? They claim that7:31the yeshiva education doesn't produce people that are going in society,7:35blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, and all these things. Meanwhile, right, the person7:39who's writing this is renting an apartment from the landlord7:43who owns the building, who happens to be a Chassidish graduate from those type of schools.7:47You follow what I'm saying? So it just doesn't make sense, the whole thing,7:51what they're talking about. These religious schools,7:55look at their graduates, look at their people. They have families7:58now. You know, money is not the bottom line.8:00And even that we could contend, but even with that, money is not the bottom line.8:05Money is not the most important thing. Family, having, you know,8:08kids and raising a good family that has8:12morals of the Torah, that's what's important for them in their lives.8:16And if they're yeshiva, that's what they provide them with. Why is that a bad thing?8:19So you see that religious Jews are not looked upon in a good light. And unfortunately, even by our8:24fellow Jews, we're not looked upon in a good light.8:28So the Sefat Emet, which is what?8:32The lips of truth, which is the Torah, it's—we don't see it in this world.8:36That's what the Zohar was being asked, and the answer8:40was given is that it doesn't say konen; it says tikon. It's only the end.8:43Look at Jewish history at the end, at the end. When the world comes to its completion,8:48and Mashiach will come, we'll see how throughout all these years,8:51throughout all these generations, throughout the centuries of Jewish history,8:55when they held on to the Torah, and even the current challenging times8:59where it seems to be they could be a Jew and be successful, but9:03if, you know, you have to kind of compromise on certain parts of the Torah,9:07and even then, right, we held9:11on to the Torah and its values the way they were given from Sinai,9:16those are the people that are really the emet, and that9:19will only be discovered at the end. Now he connects it to another Gemara, beautiful9:23idea. Says the Gemara, says,9:28מסכת ברכות: חלמא טבא חדוותיה מסתייה, בישא עציבותא מסתייה. The Gemara says a good dream, the happiness a9:35person feels about it when he wakes up—you know, when you have a good dream and you feel good about9:39it—that actually heals it. What does that mean? That actually takes it away.9:43And a bad dream, when a person9:47wakes up and he had a very scary dream, that bad feeling that he have9:51is the way that it heals the bad dream.9:55That's a simple meaning. פירוש says the Rav Tzadok on a deeper level.10:02It says, כל מעשה העולם הזה נקרא חלמא, כמו שנאמר בשוב ה' את שיבת ציון היינו כחולמים. We said this in previous letters, a few letters ago, and that is10:07everything in this world, all the actions of this world are called a dream,10:11as it says in the pasuk, when Hashem returns us from the galut,10:16it says, היינו כחולמים, we were like dreamers.10:18So dream is10:26עולם הזה. מקום מקום אמרו חזל, חלום אחד משישים בנבואה, וכן שבת. Yad HaChazal told us that dreams, although they're really just,10:30you know, a figure of the imagination or things, they do have some sort of prophecy10:34about it. They are one sixtieth. What's the idea of10:38one sixtieth? Like the way it says about Shabbat, it's also10:42one sixtieth of Olam Haba. Meaning to say,10:48אחד משישים בעולם הבא. There's a little bit of a10:50taste that you could taste also in11:00עולם הזה from it. כענין אחד משישים שהוא התחלת הגשמת הטעם היותר מוחש, כי אחד משישים, אחד אין טעם, ואתהו אחד משישים. As we know the halachot of ta'arovet, when you have a mixture of,11:05let's say, dairy and meat, you have a whole part of meat and a little bit of dairy11:09goes in. If there's one out of11:14sixty-one, we say that the milk is batel, the food is mutar.11:17When out of sixty, the food is asur. Why?11:20Because one out of sixty-one, you won't be able to taste the milk.11:25But one out of sixty, if you have only sixty times the amount of11:30meat to the milk, then the flavor of the milk will still be11:33tasted. So when Chazal tell us that a dream is one sixtieth of a11:37prophecy, and that Shabbat is one sixtieth of Olam Haba, it means you could still taste11:41a little bit of Olam Haba. You could taste a little bit11:45of a nevuah. So that means a dream is not totally off.11:49A dream has a little bit, 160, there's a little bit of truth11:53to it. Because the actions that we do,11:59which are hinted to or alluded to12:01in the word dreams, as we said, olam hazeh, the actions of this world are all12:05but a dream. Those dreams do have a little bit12:10of a touch of the truth that's hidden12:13deep, deep, deep down in the hearts of people.12:16And that's why Chazal said, very interesting, they said,12:22The way dreams come to reality is based on how you interpret them.12:27Chazal said these words in the following:12:29The dreams follow the mouth. Now, on a deeper level,12:32it explains, and in the theme of what we're talking about, it says,12:36Zot tzaddik, hainu bedivrei Torah, she'al yedei divrei Torah yachol levarer kol12:40ma'asim. What does it mean? The פה, the פה is the mouth that's used for12:45learning Torah. Through the learning of the Torah, a person can bring12:48the dreams out to fruition, meaning he can bring the12:52ma'asim ha'olam hazeh to see if they're actually good or not.12:57V'af al פי shehayu, איך שהיו, על ידי הפה הוא נעשה טוב. And even though what you did was done already, but how you13:00speak, by how you learn Torah now, you can actually turn them to good,13:05because Hashem illuminates him. When a person is learning Torah, Hashem13:08opens up his eyes to see what's good and what's not.13:13ואז נגבה החלום לאמת, כנל. And then, like we said beforehand,13:16the dream, which is the ma'asim that you did in this world, Hashem will make it13:20into something that's real, meaning to say you'll be doing the right thing.13:24Hashem will direct you to do the right actions.13:30דתורה היא אמת, ומי שדבוק בתורה דבוק בחיי עולם האמיתיים, because the Torah is called13:33Torat emet, and a person who attaches himself to the Torah is really attaching himself to the13:38world of truth. You're living the true, real life.13:43וממילא כל מעשיו שלא על כל הכן. Therefore, if you're living the world of life, because13:45your whole life is dictated by Torah, you're studying the Torah,13:49Hashem illuminates you that even your actions will be doing the right thing.13:54כי מקום שהוא אדם, שם הוא כולו, because wherever your head is, that's where your13:56entire being is. Where a person's thoughts are, that's where he really is.14:00And that's the same thing when a person is learning Torah. Where is your head? Is your head about14:04learning Torah? You know, people that go to Torah classes, people that hear14:08Torah lessons, those are good, but you should14:12just know, a person's head has to be Torah. His whole machshavot has to be about Torah.14:16If his machshavot is about making more money, about making a name for himself,14:20about being more popular, about having a name in the community and in the world14:24and whatever it is, then his head is there. Where is the person's head? His head is14:28in the Torah, then he lives the Torah, then what he learns and Hashem...14:32It implies to him that he'll make the right decision. And that's why, in tons14:36and tons of stories in the past and the current of gedolim,14:40that people went to them, and they were told to do things that make no sense,14:44but the gedolim told them, and they followed, and it was exactly as they said it. Why?14:48Because these gedolim's head is in the Torah. Their whole life is about Torah,14:52and therefore Hashem aligns them. Hashem allows them to see what's14:56correct and what's not correct, what will be good for the person and what will not be good for the person.15:00Even when the gedolim tell you to do something, and it may, quote unquote, fail in your eyes15:04or fail in the eyes of other people, that's because those people, they only15:08perceive olam hazeh as the good; everything else is not good. You follow the directions15:12of the gedolim, you'll end up in the right place. So I give you15:16a great proof for that. Listen to this. Parashat Vayeshev.15:20Yosef is living with his father. He's sitting with his father,15:24and he is sitting there in Be'er Sheva. Yaakov tells his15:28son Yosef, Your brothers are in Shechem. Go check them out.15:32He got a psak from the gadol hador: Go check them out. What happened?15:35Yosef gets sold. Yosef is turned into a slave.15:40Yosef eventually becomes a high-ranking person in Potiphar's house,15:43and then he's put back in jail again for another ten years.15:47But eventually Yosef emerges out of that jail and becomes the most powerful person15:51in the entire world, who is able to now sustain his entire family.15:55So when Yosef was told by Yaakov, Go check your brothers, Yaakov—16:00Set him up.16:01Yaakov, what are you talking? Yaakov made the wrong decision,16:03but Yaakov is emet, the emet of Yaakov, because Yaakov is whole Torah.16:07How can it be that the Gadol's advice could turn sour? And it says it didn't turn sour. It's16:13only now,16:15but in the future you'll see how the Gadol's advice, whose head is entire Torah,16:19was actually very good.16:20It was very good for Yosef, and it's very good eventually for an entire family of Yosef16:25and entire Jewish people throughout all of history.