Torah · MussarMussar136. Temporary SuccessTzidkat HaTzadikPart 136Rabbi Uri Nahum · December 9, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0016:16Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot kuf lamed vav, 136.0:06It's a very deep piece, I'll tell you the truth,0:10and I hope I could say it right.0:13Really, really deep, what he's saying over here.0:15And I hope we don't misunderstand it.0:17When I say we, I'm talking about myself as well.0:21Also, we have to be careful how to, you know, apply the words.0:25He said something really, really deep in0:28concept, and like we know, you know, just when it's a deep concept, an application,0:33we should be hesitant in, you know, looking around.0:36Let's go through the piece and let's see what's going on.0:42כאשר האדם מצליח והשעה משחקת לו. You see, sometimes people are on a success streak.0:47They're going, everything's going good, everything's going smooth.0:50Whatever they touch, as they say in English, turns gold,0:53right?0:54When you see such a person is like that, or what they call0:58a little bit maybe in the secular world, the 15 minutes of fame,1:02but not necessarily fame, but, you know, everything.1:05Everything he's doing in business, anything.1:06It doesn't have to be fame necessarily.1:07Just whatever he's doing, he's touching, he's seeing success.1:11You know why that's so?1:17מפני שבעותה שעה מחזיקין אותו לצדיק בכל העולמות. Because at that moment, they hold of him as a righteous person in all the1:23worlds, everywhere.1:23I'm talking about all the worlds.1:24As we know, the Kabbalah brings down,1:26the Arizal says there are four worlds known as1:32ABYA: Atzilut, Beriah, Yetzirah, and Asiyah. Our world over here is that עין, that last one,1:35the world of Asiyah. There are three higher worlds,1:39not in physical space.1:42People make this mistake.1:43It's not like, you know, if you go up to the moon, you'll hit the next world.1:46It's not like that.1:47You're still in the world of asiyah there.1:49It's a deeper level in spirituality.1:51It's more refined.1:53That means less gashmiyut and more spiritual as you go up to the higher worlds.1:58In any case, if this person who you see is being successful,2:02is really right now, that moment, he's looked at as a righteous person.2:07He'll bring it.2:10The Gemara says over there, sometimes you have to avoid the reshaim on their height,2:15as they're succeeding, stay away from them.2:18The Gemara brings from Pesukim, and then it says also2:24not only that, he's zocheh bedin. What do we mean he's zocheh bedin? It doesn't mean that in this world, when you take him to court,2:27oh, he's going to win the court case, which probably might be true as well.2:33Zocheh bedin says, hainu shelema'alah. He's zocheh even in2:36Shamayim. If he's being tried, he's going to come out successful.2:42כמו שנאמר, מרום משפטיך. As it says, the mishpat of Hashem, the judgment of Hashem, comes from high above.2:46So how can it be that this person who's a rasha is2:50zocheh bedin? The Gemara says that clearly.2:51How can he be2:55zocheh bedin? אלא על ידי מצוות מעשים טובים. Over there, in the true world, in the world of spirituality,2:58the only way a person can succeed is only3:02if he has mitzvot ma'asim tovim. In this world, we all know,3:06the reshaim could take control of this world3:07either through bribery or people that3:12the judges themselves are crooked3:14and the, you know, hanufah, it's what we call in Hebrew.3:19The world is not coming to me in English,3:21but that's how it is in this world.3:23But in that world, there's no such a thing.3:25There's only one thing that is real in that world:3:29mitzvot ma'asim tovim. But it says he's3:32zocheh bedin, and that's the mishpat is in marom.3:35כמו שאמרו חזל, על כורחך. You have to say,3:37says Rav Tzadok, she's zocheh. What does it mean?3:39How is he successful in3:41din? How does he come out as a winner?3:44Because he has done mitzvot,3:47he has3:50ma'asim tovim. והשם יתברך מזמין לידו איזה מצווה שעבורה מגיע לו זה. For whatever reason, Hashem gives him this mitzvah.3:54And that's why he's zocheh with it3:56to get all this success.3:59In Shamayim, they're saying4:00this guy did tzar mitzvah, and he deserved this,4:02and that's why he's getting all that success.4:04He's zocheh b'din.4:05This is a guy who sha'ah mesacheket lo.4:08Now, it's a little funny.4:09I mean, the word mesacheket means funny, right?4:11Mesacheket lo means that it's not real.4:15Just at that moment, you know,4:17it looks like it's real,4:17and it is actually. At that moment,4:19he's seeing a tremendous amount of success.4:22But like we said, because at that moment, though,4:24if you freeze time right now,4:26he is right now getting in4:30Shamayim a green pass to go through everywhere,4:32through all the doors,4:33because of the mitzvot and ma'asim tovim that he's done.4:41וכאשר השם יתברך מסתיר אורו למעלה כרגע, נדמה בכל העולמות שזה... And when Hashem hides His light from shining4:45and revealing the true identity of the person,4:49then in all the4:50worlds everybody looks at this guy,4:51look, he's a tzaddik.4:52We see all his mitzvot,4:53we see all his4:54ma'asim tovim. It looks like he's really truly a tzaddik.4:59ולכן אמרו בית הלל. This is why5:00Tanai d'Bei Eliyahu speaks about Ashur and his descendants.5:03Let me just give you a little background.5:06The Torah in Parashat Noach at the end5:08lists all the descendants of5:10Noach, and it lists seventy descendants.5:12And from there is where, as the pasuk says,5:14that's how the world developed,5:17and they became known as the Shiv'im Umot HaOlam,5:22the seventy nations of the world.5:23Eventually all those seventy nations,5:25obviously with their kids and everybody,5:27they decided to team up and5:31to form one government,5:33one united power.5:36And they decided that we're going to build a tower5:39that's going to go up to5:40Shamayim and basically battle against God.5:44Everybody came, and the idea was started5:46by none other than Nimrod,5:48the arch-nemesis of Abraham5:50Avinu. However, one person decided to opt out.5:54Abraham never joined.5:56Ashur, who was part of the original5:59seventy, who was part of the, you know, the plan,6:01decided to opt out.6:02He says, This is not right,6:03and he pulled out.6:04He says, I'm not getting involved in this.6:06So he got rewarded.6:08He got rewarded in other ways throughout6:11Chazal. We see how Ashur got rewarded.6:14One of them, תנא דבי אליהו in the Midrash says,6:19שכרו של אשור שיצא ממנו סנחריב. The reward of Ashur is that6:21he eventually had a descendant6:23who was called6:26Sennacherib. For those who are not familiar with6:28Nach or Masechet Sanhedrin,6:29Sennacherib was the king of the country called Ashur,6:33which the Gemara says in6:35Masechet Megillah, he was one of the four kings6:36that had complete control of the entire world.6:40The whole earth was under his power.6:44Now, there's one exception,6:45because Sennacherib eventually came to6:47Yerushalayim to destroy6:49Yerushalayim, and that was his last stop, basically.6:54Literally. Figure, you know, that was his original plan,6:56mean to say. He already conquered the whole world,6:58and he just wanted to finish it off,7:00top it off with7:01Yerushalayim. But literally became his last stop7:03because all his great mighty army7:05died within one night.7:08In any case, look at what the Midrash says.7:11The reward of Ashur is that7:13he had a descendant who was7:15Sennacherib, who ruled the entire world.7:19What do you mean, the reward of Ashur?7:21The story of Ashur7:23not joining the building of7:28Migdal Bavel wasn't— The 1600s,7:31let's say, let's say early 1700s,7:33not in modern era.7:35Talking about from the creation of the world.7:36We're right now7:405,783. So this is in the year about 1600, 1700, right?7:44No, it had to be a little bit7:46later because it had to be when Abraham was born.7:48So we're talking about in the year7:522000-something. Now,7:53Sanherib, when he came to destroy7:55Yerushalayim, was way later.7:57It was like in around 3000-something.8:00And that's the time when he was at his height.8:02And what the Midrash says, that the reward of Ashur is Sancheiv came out of him.8:12What kind of reward is this for8:14Ashur when he's already in the world of emet?8:18And there, in the world of emet, everybody sees what life is all about,8:22and they see that having power and prestige in this world is nonsense.8:27It's a whole bunch of facade that the yetzer hara, you know, paints for us.8:33So how is that a reward for him?8:36Rak, he says,8:37Ki be'emet ka'asher hetzliach Sancheirib, haya az kach8:42bechol ha'olamot. You know what the pshat is?8:43Because when Sancheirib was successful, it's because he had a8:48zechut. And if he had a zechut, it wasn't only in this world.8:51It was actually zechut in all the worlds,8:54in all the abiya worlds,8:57in Atzilut, Beriah, Yetzirah, Asiyah, and even in the world of emet, where the soul of Ashur was.9:04And even to the place where Ashur himself was there9:09in Olam HaEmet, even there Ashur saw that Sancheirib, who was being successful,9:15it's because he had a9:20zechut, ki hu zakai b'shaish matot doreshaim. He was zakai,9:22and unfortunately the Jewish people of that generation were not9:25such big tzaddikim. This is right before Chizkiyahu HaMelech comes to power.9:30So, and we know that Ahaz, who was the father of Chizkiyah, was a big, big rasha9:34who did a tremendous amount of aveirot and avodah zarah in9:41Eretz Yisrael. So that's why in Shamayim over there, where Ashur, you know, was already,9:47he saw that his descendant Sancheirib is succeeding9:52not only in the physical world as we see it down here,9:55for those who were alive then or us that read the history books,9:59but even Ashur saw it in reality.10:02He had some sort of zechuyot, and that's why he's successful.10:05Vehem, and this is all under one big category10:09which is known as10:14b'kavshei deRachmana, ech midat mishpatav. This is one of those things.10:15Kavshei deRachmana is the terminology that's used in10:18Chazal about things that Hashem does that we don't understand.10:22From our point of view, it may be illogical.10:25Sanherib was a rasha.10:26What does that mean?10:26He was a tzaddik in all these worlds.10:28This is one of those things that we don't understand.10:31But you must say that this is what happened.10:34You understand or not, it doesn't make a difference.10:36This is clearly what was going on.10:41Because if it was not for the fact that10:43Sanherib, in the world of emet, in the spiritual worlds,10:49was looked at as a10:50tzaddik, he would not be able to be so successful in this world.10:54Powerful line, no?10:58And being that he had some sort of11:00zechut, because we see his success in this world,11:03so also Ashur himself, also that was his reward.11:08Remember the Midrash, it says that the reward of Ashur11:11is that Sanherib came out of him.11:13So Ashur also was elevated on a certain level.11:16Now, you might say, it's crazy.11:18We see a lot of people that are really11:21reshaim, very successful in this world.11:23You're telling me that they have now in Shamayim,11:26you're telling me they're11:28tzaddikim? Otherwise, how could they be this way?11:29And we have a big list,11:31rabotai. We know a lot of people that we see are succeeding.11:33You're telling me11:35they're—and I know clearly they're11:36reshaim. They're terrorists, right?11:38There's nothing to argue.11:39They're terrorists.11:40They're commanding the killing of thousands of people.11:44They're trying to go against the Torah.11:45They're trying to go against Hashem,11:48and they're so popular,11:50and their, you11:50know, all their da'at is against Hashem.11:52And you're telling me they're considered tzaddikim in those worlds?11:55And the answer is yes, but wait, wait, we're not done yet.11:58Now I can understand what the Gemara says:12:01Al tekana b'oseh avlah.12:05The pasuk says, But don't be jealous of those who do evil.12:09Lihyot kemohem, to be like them.12:12That doesn't make sense.12:14The Gemara is not talking to, you know,12:17wicked people who are, you know,12:19reshaim. The Gemara is talking about frum Jews.12:21Yeah, this is how it was most of our history.12:23And the pasuk says,12:25don't be jealous from people that do evil.12:28Says the Gemara, don't be jealous of them to be like them.12:31Where does that come from?12:34Why would I be jealous of a12:37rasha? And the answer is,12:41because if you knew what tzaddik told us till now,12:46then when you see success in this world,12:48it's because they're held as12:50tzaddikim. So must be this guy is a12:51tzaddik. If you see him successful,12:52it can't be that he's not a12:54tzaddik. Must be in Shamayim they hold he's a12:56tzaddik. And if he's a12:59tzaddik, then, ah, it's got to be that he's doing something right.13:02Comes the pasuk, says, no,13:04they're doing evil at the end of the day.13:06Why is he now successful?13:08Because he has some sort of13:09zechut. Don't be jealous of them.13:14And don't think the pasuk is telling you,13:16don't be jealous of the goyim.13:21Jewish people know that when we see the success of13:24reshaim and goyim,13:28the reshaim, that's only momentarily,13:30as the Midrash compares it to a wave13:32that tries to take over the world,13:33and so too the13:34reshaim, they think they can take over the world,13:36and we get a Hitler,13:37and then we get another13:41rasha, Paro and Nebuchadnezzar,13:42all these guys, they get power13:43and then they go back down.13:45The pasuk is not talking about that.13:47The pasuk doesn't have to warn the Jewish people13:50not to be jealous of the goyim13:53that are reshaim. No, rak shebisrael atzmam13:56yesh ken. Even amongst the Jewish people,13:58there are people like that,14:00kemo Doeg. For example, Doeg14:05HaEdomi, Chazal tell us in Masechet Sanhedrin, ein lo chelek l'olam haba. And Doeg was the head of the Sanhedrin.14:12Kemo Doeg, b'et hasa'ato haya mechuzak b'Yisrael l'tzadik gamur. Doeg, in his high time,14:15in his prime, as they say,14:17was considered14:18tzaddik gamur. Come on, think about it.14:19He is the head of the Jewish Supreme Court.14:23The one, you know,14:24one of the people that the king would advise with.14:29וגם בענייני עבודת השם. And even in his service of Hashem, Hashem14:33מצליח בידו. Hashem makes him succeed,14:37כדי שיהיה משפט להטיב לו, because that's the mishpat.14:38That's a judgment up there in14:40Shamayim that he should be successful.14:41That's the type of guy.14:43Now, we know אין לו חלק לעולם הבא today,14:45but back then, if you're living,14:46how dare you speak against Doeg?14:49He was such a tremendous14:52תלמיד חכם. Can you imagine that?14:54Can you imagine that?14:55We would never know.14:56It must be because15:01צריך לזה מבינות גדולה, איזה דבר הוא רק לפי שעה. But this is not easy to discern.15:04We can't go around15:05and look at people and say,15:07Ah, he's successful only15:09for שעה. We don't know.15:10You need a real15:11בינה to understand what's temporarily, what's not.15:17It's only at the end15:18that we discover that the whole time15:20this guy's success was really15:23not because he was truly a15:25צדיק, but like we said,15:28השעה משחקת לו, and very difficult to discern.15:31I'm going to skip the parentheses for a second.15:32Let me just read the last line15:33and come back to the parentheses.15:37ואפילו שמצליח גם בתורה ומצוות, לפי מראי עיני האדם. And even if you see the guy succeeding15:39in Torah and mitzvot,15:42the guy is succeeding literally in Torah.15:44He's a big15:45תלמיד חכם. He's writing15:46sefarim. He's giving15:47shiurim. Even you see the guy is, like, holding,15:50that's only to the eyes of people.15:52But we never know.15:54We will not know, actually.15:56Now, what do we do with this information15:57that we just learned?15:59Like I said.16:00In the beginning, this is a very deep concept. We are not that person that should be going around saying,16:07Ah, this guy's success is because... No, no, we don't know. We don't know. But to know16:14that there's such a concept that exists.