Torah · MussarMussar134. Adjusting Your תשובה as You GrowTzidkat HaTzadikPart 134Rabbi Uri Nahum · December 2, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0018:30Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:02Sefat HaTzadik, ot kuf lamed dalet. In this piece, the Rav Tzadok discusses the depth of teshuvah, and he begins:0:15Pa'amim nidmeh la'adam shekevar shav ve'nimchalu chata'av. Sometimes a person feels that he fully reached the love of teshuvah, and his sins are forgiven.0:21He's a new man or person.0:23Ve'achar zman... and then after a while also, hu chozer mit'orer letmarmer al hachata'av. He comes back and he starts to feel terrible about his sins.0:33He starts to feel, Oh my gosh, I can't believe I did such a thing.0:36Now we know when a person does teshuvah, his sins are erased.0:40Like it says, he's forgiven. He's a new person.0:43It's, in the words of the Rambam, that a person who does teshuvah, it's like a shinui hashem. It's like he's not the same person anymore.0:51It's a different person. You look at him now, look at him before.0:54Let's take the prime example of a person, people who know this person as a baal teshuvah, Rabbi Uri Zohar,1:01alav hashalom, who just passed away.1:03He was a major, major movie—he was a major celebrity in Israel,1:10and, you know, in his own words, he could have gotten away with murder.1:13And now, all of a sudden, he became a1:17talmid chacham. You look at him, this is him? I can't believe it.1:21Doesn't look the same, doesn't act the same, doesn't think the same.1:24He's a totally different person.1:25Sometimes a person feels that he got to that level of what the Rambam calls shinui hashem.1:30He's a completely different person,1:31yet he seems to get feelings of contradiction.1:35What's going on? I'm still feeling bad about my sins.1:41U'margish sheshnei hamachshavot einam dimyon. And he feels that I'm not imagining things.1:44Now, that's an important line he just says over here.1:47Sometimes we imagine things, right?1:49Sometimes we have a fear of something, but it's not real.1:53Like walking down on Friday night in your basement when it's dark and you can't put on the lights,1:59you get this feeling that somebody's there.2:02Nobody's there. Relax.2:03It's a dimyon. It's an imagination.2:05It's in your head. You watch too many movies in your younger days, right?2:08Here he's saying, no, he realizes it doesn't feel—it's not, it's real.2:13I really felt that I reached a totally different level.2:17Now all of a sudden, I'm getting it again.2:19I'm getting that feeling of I'm feeling bad for my sins.2:22What's going on?2:23Says2:26Rav Tzaddok, U'be'emet shenehem emet. They're both true.2:28It is true, it is possible that a person does feel,2:32that could feel that he got into the level that he is forgiven,2:36and at the same time, a person could feel that he's also what?2:41He's also still regretting what he did in the past.2:44Why?2:44Because it says in2:51Yoma, עבירות דיום הכיפורים הזה חוזרין, ודיום הכיפורים הבא. Hazal tell us,2:53interesting2:54halacha. Even though you did vidui, you made confession on sins on Yom Kippur,2:59next Yom Kippur you should do it again.3:07Ah, ואפילו בעבירות שההלכה דלולא זז משם עד שמוחלין לו, והרי גם זה אמת. What's going on?3:09There is, I understand, if there's certain sins that a person needs to go through3:13tremendous suffering and he needs to go through death.3:16So you know what?3:17He hasn't really been forgiven for those kind of sins,3:21and that's why he has to come back every Yom Kippur3:27and—sorry—that's why he has to come back every Yom Kippur and confess3:30and do vidui again.3:32But3:34the עבירות, Hazal tell us that when you come on Yom Kippur3:37and you confess,3:38you are forgiven on the spot.3:41So why do I have to come back again next Yom Kippur and ask for forgiveness again?3:45So3:50he explains, רק כמו שאין שיעור למעלות האדם במדרגתו, כך אין שיעור למדרגות התשובה. The answer is, just like there's no levels,3:54there's no, you know, maximum that you can reach in levels,3:59a person always has the ability to climb higher and higher in levels, in4:04midot, so too in teshuva.4:05You know, there was a story.4:06I'm not sure if I've ever mentioned this in the past.4:09Here, I heard it from Rav Yehuda Ades.4:11Rav Yehuda Ades quotes4:13Rav Chatzkel Levenstein, who used to be the mashgiach in Mir in4:16Eretz Yisrael. Beforehand, he was in Europe also,4:19a major figure in the Mussar movement.4:21That's, I believe, in the '70s or late '60s.4:25In any case, Rav Chatzkel Levenstein said about himself4:28that he used to do teshuvah every single day.4:30Hard thing to hear so much, you know.4:32We're not talking about baal teshuvah here.4:34We're talking about a tzaddik,4:36yesod olam from his young days,4:38and he was one of the most disciplined people.4:40How did he do teshuvah every single day?4:42And now he's going to explain.4:44First of all, we already said that there are levels upon levels.4:48There's always levels on higher and higher. The higher of a level you attain, the higher5:05now you also have a different level now of doing teshuvah. Because all inyanei ha'adam al yachas echad, veha'adam eino omed b'makom echad. Because all things of a person5:07are based on where he's standing in life at that moment.5:11If he's standing in life at a certain place,5:13then his teshuvah, his midot, his anger,5:16his chesed is based on where he is at that level.5:20Let's give you a mashal5:22in something that could be measured.5:24Let's take, for example, learning,5:27okay? Take a person who is a newcomer to Torah,5:31and he's not a person who has the time to just take off from work5:36or from his life and enter yeshiva,5:39although that would be ideal.5:40He's a person who wants to come and5:42grow, and he wants to start keeping halachot.5:44Says, Rabbi, look, go easy on me,5:46you know what I'm saying?5:47So he says, okay, fine.5:49So what does he do?5:52The rabbi knows how to help this guy5:54out. He tells him, okay, step one.5:56Start putting on tefillin.5:58Lord, what is tefillin?5:59Let me show you how to put on tefillin.6:00He teaches him.6:01Now, what this person just did is he learned Torah.6:06He learned Torah of the halachot of how to put on tefillin,6:11not in the terminologies of the Shulchan Aruch,6:15you know, Shas and Poskim, but he learned Torah.6:17The rabbi took out tefillin and he gave him a lesson.6:20That lesson for this person was good enough for6:22him to be able to put on tefillin on a daily basis.6:25A month later, the person comes back and6:27says, Rabbi, I'm ready for the next step.6:29Okay, what is that?6:30Maybe I'll put on tallit now also.6:32Okay,6:33so the rabbi gives him another shiur,6:35reviews the first shiur,6:36and gives him another shiur on how to put on tallit.6:39This guy learned Torah now.6:41In two months, or a month and a little bit,6:44he learned about an hour of Torah.6:47As a person starts to become, or become more and more religious,6:51so now he actually starts to participate in a Torah class,6:55right?6:55Because now he's on a level6:58where he could actually read the7:02Aleph-Bet, understand what he's reading,7:03and he starts.7:04It could be7:05Chumash, it could be7:05Mishnayot, it could be7:06Musar, whatever it is,7:07he starts to learn.7:08And then eventually he starts to learn Gemara.7:11And eventually,7:12I'm talking about eventually,7:13a few years down the line,7:14this person starts to learn more and more.7:17He's learning on the train.7:18Now,7:18this person's Talmud Torah,7:21when he's already ten years into this,7:23is definitely not close to what he was on the first day.7:27In the beginning,7:28he was learning just once a month,7:31and I was already like,7:32wow, a major step,7:33and for him7:33that was great.7:34But now that he's already been religious,7:38or whatever it is,7:39he's keeping mitzvot to the best of his ability7:41for seven years.7:42It's a very different level of learning Torah.7:44He can't just say,7:45okay, I'm going to come פעם once a month.7:47You're on a different level now.7:48Your Talmud Torah has to be on a higher level.7:51It's the same thing also with chesed.7:53If a person is giving charity,7:56so we all start out,7:58you know, I don't know, we all,7:59you know, I guess.8:00Right, we start out, listen, it's a little tight, and we're on the receiving end, and people help us out,8:06but we still want to give a little bit of maaser. We give that 10%, or some people can't do 10%,8:11so they start 2%, 3%, whatever they're giving. The guy starts to make more and more money.8:16He's in a different position in life. He can't just keep on giving me 2% anymore.8:20He can't give the same, you know, quarter to the guy who comes around anymore. He has to up it up.8:26It has to match what he's making, no? He's on a different level.8:31Our math in first grade was not the same math that we were before we graduated high school,8:36or certainly not in college. And that's the same thing also in your8:39teshuvah. Your teshuvah, when you were a beginner, you did teshuvah. For your level, you're great.8:45Not everybody on his own level. But the higher of a level that you attain,8:49your teshuvah also now has to be adjusted to that level.8:53Oh, you're on a much higher level. You got to clean out a little bit more.9:01Again, to repeat the words of Rav Tzadok, everything that has to do with the person9:06is based where he's standing, and nobody stands in one place his whole life.9:09We're constantly moving. We're constantly going up and down, up and down.9:16This is exactly what Moshe Rabbeinu complained right before he passed away. He tells9:20him, look, klal Yisrael, ama... it was his last day on earth.9:26He says, I am 120 years old today.9:31I can't go out and I can't go in anymore. What is he talking about?9:37Chazal tell us that he's reached the maximum level,9:41but b'meitim chofshi, that's it. It's his final day. He's going to die,9:44and he can't attain levels. He can't go higher and lower, as it says in the pasuk,9:51b'meitim chofshi. Chofshi means free. Free, you don't have any responsibility.9:58Bametim, those who are dead are free of the mitzvot, says Chazal. V'nikan nach nafsheh. And even though he didn't die yet, but it's called that he's already passed.10:05His soul has rested.10:08Now, we said the word nach nafsheh to refer to a person who dies.10:13But nach nafsheh, the literal meaning is that his soul parked.10:17Parked means you don't move. That's when a person passes away.10:22But as long as you're in this world,10:26aval ba'olam hazeh, ein noach la'olam. There's no nach. There's no parking in this world.10:30Af al pi shehu margish, even though you don't feel it, you say, What do you mean? I am at the same level.10:34Baruch Hashem, what more else can I do? I'm keeping Shabbos. I'm keeping Beit Yosef,10:38and I am coming to learn my one hour a day.10:42But we move. We're constantly growing.10:44If you're constantly learning, you're constantly growing.10:47And now your teshuvah has to be different.10:48And constantly this is happening, constantly.10:50And if you're not learning, by the way,10:52and if you're not, you know, increasing your learning,10:56you're probably maybe going backwards.10:59You know, look at the world. Is the world standing still?11:03Are your phones standing still?11:05The moment that the new phone comes out,11:07you know, they're already working on the next model.11:11Why? It's good. It's working.11:13Work for maintenance.11:14No, they're already working on the next model.11:17Technology is the same way, right?11:19It's all there to teach us what should be happening by us.11:23And the companies, like BlackBerry,11:25that decide that I am not going to work on a new model of a phone,11:29they blink their eyes and all of a sudden they realize11:31that the whole world moved and they're still way back.11:35And they're out of style11:37and they're, you know, not updated,11:40and nobody wants to be with them anymore.11:41So you see, that's how it works.11:43That's how it works in the person's soul as well.11:46It works that way in the whole world, really.11:48And where it matters, people will know11:49you always got to improve and update your styles11:52and your prices and everything else.11:54Now he continues, he11:57said, I remember we learned this,12:00that if your source is good, then you cannot be bad.12:04Hu holech bema'alah lema'alah b'tovah, and you keep rising higher and higher in that good level.12:09V'chen lehefech, and unfortunately the people who are bad,12:11who have ruined their source,12:12they're also going higher, higher in evil, though.12:18Kemo she'amru, zakenet talmidei chachamim, ma she'maskinim chochmatam, right, becomes more.12:21Chazal tell us, the elders, the elder talmidei chachamim, the older they get, the wiser they get,12:26and ziknei am ha'aretz, the older they get, the more foolish they get.12:32V'kach keshemagia ha'ma'alah, the guy yoter gedolah. And that's why when a person reaches a higher and higher level,12:38az kefi madregato, lo hatchila shuv adayin. So based on that level, that's not called12:41teshuvah bichlal. Where you are 20 years down your teshuvah adventure,12:46your teshuvah life,12:47is not where you were when you first started.12:51So again, in terminology that we understand,12:54the five minutes that you learned12:56when you started your teshuvah journey12:58doesn't compare to where you are now13:00as a talmid chacham 20 years later13:02and you're learning so much more.13:04You can't learn five minutes a day anymore.13:06I still remember, you know, when I was in high school13:09and I started, you know, going to classes.13:11It was in high school?13:12No, yeah, it was like at the end of high school,13:13maybe post-high school a little bit,13:15I started going to classes.13:20And, yeah, my brother started joining us.13:22It was a men's class at the time, I remember.13:24And then I went to yeshiva the next year.13:26Yeshiva, it's a whole different level.13:28Baruch Hashem, you know, it's a different world.13:29You enter a world now,13:30it's not class once a week,13:33it's eight hours a day of learning.13:36So, TV by that time was out of the question for me.13:38No way, you shouldn't be watching TV.13:40And I remember going to one of the classes with my brother,13:43and the Rosh Yeshiva got up and he said,13:46Rabotai, you know,13:48you shouldn't be watching one, two hours.13:49So my brother tells me,13:50See, the rabbi said you should be watching two hours of TV.13:52That's normal, right?13:55It's all who you're talking to.13:57He's not talking to the yeshiva13:59bachur. Are you kidding?13:59A yeshiva bachur should be thinking TV.14:02He should be cutting down, maybe on his basketball14:04to put more learning,14:05I don't know, but he should be thinking TV.14:07It's all on the person's level.14:09Same thing in teshuva,14:11in everything.14:12Teshuva in every area.14:14Where you are, in the special area,14:16that's, you gotta, you know,14:17refine yourself more and more and more.14:20This is where it14:22really—he says14:24one more line, Vechatato negdi tamid. That's the meaning when14:28David HaMelech says, Vechatati negdi tamid. That person has to have his sin constantly in front of him.14:30What does that mean?14:31You shouldn't feel the pressure about your sins all the time.14:34No, that's not what it means.14:36It means that a person should realize14:38that he's constantly going higher and14:40higher, and therefore that sin that he once had14:42has to be now fixed14:45on his new level.14:47Now technically the piece stops here.14:49He puts in another idea,14:51a beautiful idea.14:52I don't want to read it inside;14:53it'll take too long.14:54But I want to first add one more thing.14:58Rav Chaim Vital in Shaar HaGilgulim,15:01which is really the sefer15:04HaArizal, he writes something amazing.15:05He says15:06that even a person, after he passes away,15:09he gets judged.15:10We all know that.15:12The judgment is only to see if you deserve15:14the good things that are coming to you.15:16But15:18after a person reaches that level,15:20don't think— In that world, he stops,15:23because if he has more zechuyot in this world,15:25for example,15:25he has kids,15:27not just saying Kaddish for him;15:29they're learning for him, and they're going in his ways15:30that he taught them.15:30If he has15:32sefarim, if he has talmidim,15:33if he has students or books that he wrote,15:34where he has basically made his mark,15:36he has an influence.15:37He's opened up institutions with his money,15:39where people are still, you know, sending him deposits15:44in his bank account up there in Shamayim.15:46So he goes on a higher and higher and higher level.15:48But every time before he goes onto a higher level,15:51they judge him for something more fine,15:54you know, it's more and more intricate.15:57That means, why isn't he, basically, if you think...16:00About the logic, why isn't he on that highest level yet?16:03You know why?16:04Because he doesn't deserve to be there.16:06Okay, why not?16:08Because must be something is stopping him.16:10There's some sort of sin.16:10So didn't you judge him already,16:13right, when he passed away? And it says, no. You get judged based on the16:16level that you're entering.16:17But now that you go on the higher level,16:19you get judged again.16:20He explains that's the meaning when Chazal tell us16:23in the end of16:25some masechtot, it16:25says, Tzadikim don't have rest,16:32lo ba'olam hazeh v'lo ba'olam haba. They don't have rest16:33not in this world,16:34not in the world to come.16:35Yelchu mechayil el chayil. They go from strength to strength.16:40What it means is16:41they're constantly moving.16:43Pashut pshat, you understand, in this world,16:44tzadikim in this world don't have rest.16:47But the Gemara says,16:49Ein lahem menuchah lo ba'olam hazeh v'lo ba'olam haba, not in this16:49world and the world to come.16:52Explains the Arizal,16:54because even in the world to come,16:56they keep rising higher and16:57higher because of their influence16:59that they made in this world,17:01where people are still giving them17:06zechuyot. And because they're rising,17:06so they have to get judged.17:08And Rav Chaim Vital brings a story there17:10about a certain tzaddik17:12that when he was getting higher and17:14higher, when he got to the world,17:15they judged him because one time17:18on Shabbat he was walking and dirt got into his shoe and he carried it.17:21Such a thing in17:24halacha, ask anybody who learns Hilchot Shabbat, they'll tell you, no, it's nothing to think about.17:26But still, you see,17:28that's for the average person.17:29When a person gets a higher, higher level,17:31it's more fine over there.17:33They judge him for more fine things.17:35And that's the same idea that Rav Tzadok is saying17:37over here with teshuvah.17:38He explains also that even in this world,17:41when the higher level that you reach,17:44you get to go deeper, deeper down17:46into your soul17:47and to bring out all that residue that's still there.17:50And sometimes when you confront17:52that residue, because you're more refined,17:54so that residue actually17:56could have more damage on you17:58than it did from beforehand.18:00And he explains that's what happened18:02to really18:04to Acher, that because he reached such a high level,18:06that small thing that he had deep in his heart18:08was able to make an impact on him.18:11Had he not reached such a high level,18:13then that little residue18:15wouldn't have such a18:16big—because his neshama was not so fragile.18:18The more refined you become,18:20the more fragile your neshama is18:22to any residue of sin.18:24It's a deep, deep concept.18:26Look it up in the thing to see further.